8 Dec 2021
Results - Monthly Beatmapping Contest 2021 Wrap-up
by pishifat, radar, Nokashi, Davvy

Results - Monthly Beatmapping Contest 2021 Wrap-up

by pishifat, radar, Nokashi, Davvy

At long last, winners from contests in every game mode have been crowned. See who sits on the throne in this Monthly Beatmapping Contest wrap-up!

There's a lot to cover here. Let's jump right into it.

The Monthly Beatmapping Contest (MBC) has four contests to conclude today. Navigate to whichever you're interesed in here:

Summary

User Mode Placement Badge prize Title prize MBC Points
Aistre osu! Winner + Screener's pick - 3 (⯅3)
phyr osu! Runner-up + Screener's pick - 2 (⯅2)
Jaltzu osu!taiko Overall winner - 2 (⯅2)
Ph0eNiiXZ osu!taiko Runner-up - - 3 (⯅1)
Jemzuu osu!catch Overall winner - 2 (⯅2)
Unlucky_w osu!catch Runner-up - - 1 (⯅1)
Kawawa osu!mania Overall winner - 2 (⯅2)
lemonguy osu!mania Runner-up - - 1 (⯅1)

While this summarizes the winners and their prizes, details on the rest of the participants (potentially including your entry) can be found below!

osu! results

This month's contest was themed around blankets!

During the screening process, experienced mappers narrowed down the contest's 20+ entries to 5 finalists. These 5 entries were thoroughly evaluated by a different team of judges, resulting in the... uh, results!

Rank Beatmap Judging Musical representation (50) Creativity (50) Gameplay (50) Theme (50) Total (standardized/raw)
#1 FORViDDEN ENERZY by Aistre see details 33 35 33 35 4.6 (136)
#2 Faith of Eastward by phyr see details 33 34 37 32 3.77 (136)
#3 Faith of Eastward by Mattay see details 29 26 27 24 -0.77 (106)
#4 Regeneraxion by too see details 24 25 25 25 -2.01 (99)
#5 Regeneraxion by zadknus see details 15 23 23 20 -5.59 (81)

See results for all submissions here.

Winners

In unprecedented MBC history, we have a tie between two entries in both screening and judging!

Sort of.

On the screening side, both entries received completely equal praise. On the judging side, both entries received the same raw scores, but standardized scores tell a different story.

We won't bore you with the math, but phyr's entry scored lower because it was less unanimously praised among the judges. More specifically one judge really liked the map, while support for Aistre's submission was closer to unanimous.

Regardless of how you put it, both Aistre and phyr had top tier performances with their beatmaps of FORViDDEN ENERZY and Faith of Eastward! Give each of them a quick round of applause and let's hope to their rise as Elite Mappers in next year's mapping contests!

osu!taiko results

This contest had a particularly difficult limitation: All patterns on snaps faster than 1/2 must have an even number of notes.

Unlike osu!, osu!taiko operates without screening. Instead, all entries undergo ordinary judging and are ranked accordingly!

Rank Beatmap Judging Structure (40) Creativity (40) Gameplay (40) Limitation (20) Total (standardized/raw)
#1 busy come, busy go by Jaltzu see details 35 29 34 19 3.76 (117)
#2 busy come, busy go by Ph0eNiiXZ see details 33 30 31 20 3.33 (114)
#3 busy come, busy go by uone see details 32 31 34 19 3.24 (116)
#4 Frostbite by HiroK see details 32 31 30 19 3.01 (112)
#5 busy come, busy go by Nifty see details 31 31 32 18 2.93 (112)

See results for all submissions here.

Winner

Ending Thailand's osu!taiko win streak and ultimately crossing the Finnish line is the one and only Jaltzu!

His incredibly well-structured entry of busy come, busy go resonated with judges in all categories, while also offering players an especially difficult challenge in the map's kiai section.

Runner-up

However, it's clear the Thai-ko mappers aren't done with us yet. Ph0eNiiXZ secures the runner-up spot and is the first osu!taiko mapper to win twice in the osu!taiko MBC!

His entry of busy come, busy go opted for relatively more slider velocity changes and slightly simpler patterns, but don't let simplicity disguise the expertise behind this entry.

osu!catch results

5 judges. 1 winner. And a runner-up, I suppose.

This contest focused on 1/1 rhythm gaps! For those of you who aren't mappers, a "1/1 rhythm gap" is essentially a 1 beat separation between two hit objects. Most Insane and Expert difficulties use these sparingly, so see how osu!catch mappers executed whole beatmaps around this concept:

Rank Beatmap Judging Musical representation (50) Creativity (50) Gameplay (50) Theme (50) Total (standardized/raw)
#1 REDOUT by Jemzuu see details 41 40 40 42 4.89 (163)
#2 REDOUT by Unlucky_w see details 39 40 40 40 4.4 (159)
#3 REDOUT by Secre see details 35 33 38 41 2.61 (147)
#4 Voice by rew0825 see details 38 31 35 40 2.19 (144)
#5 REDOUT by Dika312 see details 36 37 33 33 1.87 (139)

See results for all submissions here.

Winner

Winning with his entry of REDOUT is none other than osu!catch veteran Jemzuu!

An innovative mapper well known in the catch community, Jemzuu wasted no opportunity and promptly accepted this month's challenge — and boy did he deliver! Striking a clear balance between this month's theme and his usual technical style, he managed to create a harmonious experience that unquestionably impressed our judges!

Runner-up

And our osu!catch runner-up is Unlucky_w with their entry of REDOUT!

This may come as a surprise to a few mappers. Unlucky_w is a fairly new name to the osu!catch community, but they have been actively putting the work to get involved to advance their mapping, and as showcased by their spectacular performance, it is certainly paying off! Utilizing a rather unorthodox interpretation of our month's theme, they managed to capture the attention of our judges and achieve a considerably high score.

osu!mania results

Sticking to a simpler limitation than other game modes, osu!mania's contest disallowed long notes!

While this was restrictive, it still permitted a lot of different types of maps, as clearly seen by the contest's top submissions. Check them out for yourself:

Rank Beatmap Judging Musical representation (40) Creativity (40) Gameplay (40) Limitation (20) Total (standardized/raw)
#1 busy come, busy go by Kawawa see details 31 32 30 16 4.44 (109)
#2 Frostbite by lemonguy see details 33 29 31 18 4.08 (111)
#3 The Game Changer by EimitMaggi999 see details 30 28 28 17 3.39 (103)
#4 Frostbite by PianoLuigi see details 30 25 31 17 2.53 (103)
#5 The Game Changer by lenpai see details 29 28 26 16 2.48 (99)

See results for all submissions here.

Winner

Despite focusing on 7K rather than the mainstream 4K keymode, Kawawa is one of osu!mania's most competent and influential mappers, proven by their winning submission of busy come, busy go!

The beatmap takes full advantage of the contest's limitation while implementing spectatularly smooth patterning. Balancing every aspect of design, Kawawa's creation here sets a definite precedent on rice-only patterning for 7K.

Runner-up

Not far behind, lemonguy is another osu!mania legend who's proven themselves with their 4K entry of Frostbite!

Anyone who's participated in osu!mania tournaments knows the magic behind lemonguy. His beatmaps are tightly structured and utilize patterning that the judges found exceptional — especially demonstrated by his special variant of jumpstreams featured throughout the beatmap.


Wrap-up

We'd like to extend a huuuuuuuuuge congratulations to every winner in these contests! Mappers from certain game modes have been rioting outside osu! HQ demanding results for quite a while, so we're happy to finally publish the winners. Better late than never, right?

And of course, we'd be ashamed to forget about the countless helpers who've participated behind the scenes to make these Monthly Beatmapping Contests possible!

If you see your name below, it means you're an awesome person who will be receiving a personalized season's greetings card featuring my grandma. Or it means you contributed to the MBC in 2021. You'll have to wait to find out.

And with that, we'll be departing from official mapping contests until 2022!

We're hoping to launch a particularly special contest soon, but we'll leave details of that for when it's ready. In the meantime, look forward to the next year of Monthly Beatmapping Contests and have fun mapping!

—pishifat, radar, Nokashi, Davvy

Comments23

Sort by

i never hope to getting better MBC on taiko mode

it never ceases to amaze me that those weird ass bezier curvy slider maps always make it into the top 5

woah it's there thank you

let's gooooo

can't believe i waited 6 months to get a bunch of surface level comments that don't explain anything (minus that one judge who actually tried).

Liiraye Genjuro

Maybe unpopular opinion but judges aren't supposed to mod your maps, they're supposed to grade it. Getting further comments is nice but going deep in explaining themselves and pointing out what they liked and didn't like just ends up being a mod.

Genjuro Liiraye

It's both a matter of transparency as well as helping newer mappers out. Judges should be able to justify low scores by explaining WHY they gave them. This has nothing to do with modding the map, I think you're a bit confused about what modding is. I had judges comment "very solid entry!" only to give it low scores in most of the categories so I'm just left a bit confused. Out of all 4 judges there were only 3 specific points left about my map and I disagree with all of them because it's like they didn't even pay close attention to the map to try and understand my intentions so even that small attempt of giving feedback was scuffed..

Raiden Genjuro

It took someone 6 months to write "pretty basic nothing fancy" 😭😭

iceOC Genjuro

It is a wrong to demand peppy for quality of evaluation

The rule should be changed to not set BG.
BG should not affect the scoring. Setting BG may result in loss of anonymity.

choke enough iceOCdeleted
iceOC choke enough

There are judge mentioning bg so it is open to judges.
If I had been a judge, I would have been able to guess Nwolf's map.

Monthly?

Genjuro tasuke912

it was a long month

lemonguy tasuke912

*annually

"If you're brave enough to map anything other than a swing song with this limitation, we'll give them an honorary 0.01 MBC points for the attempt."
I want my 0.01 point back :(

Frostbite proved to be almost impossible for me to map under that taiko restriction without heavy overmapping, but hey, at least it was an interesting challenge!

Anyway, kudos to all staff who listened to our feedback and provided mappers actual comments and feedback this time. Maybe try not to delay the results by almost half a year next time though? ;)

2nd place is cool and all, but I see that you can still get screwed over from having a bad rating from one judge even if you get higher ratings than 1st place on 3 of the judges lol (edit: nvm it's 2 of the judges if the ordering is consistent)

poggers results out pog champ :D

whoa

too phyr

congratz

Still waiting for your grand-ma's peronalized season's greetings card @pishifat

/

Still waiting for your grand-ma's peronalized season's greetings card @pishifat