"EmoCosine - Black sour Ruby" should be renamed as "EmoCosine - Black sour Ruby (Extended Smelting)" with reason in below link:
beatmapsets/2040411/discussion/-/generalAll#/3874933

"EmoCosine - Black sour Ruby (short ver.)" should also be renamed as "EmoCosine - Black sour Ruby", see below official posts:
https://twitter.com/EmoCosine/status/1680495232704733185
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jXSWrmY3QMg

Here are a couple of templates with 128kbps mp3s bloated to 192kbps:

Sound Piercer - Ten, Sen, Men, Rittai: beatmaps/artists/334

AAAA Chazuke - Myosotis no Hanataba: beatmaps/artists/301
edit: My bad, the second one is actually 128 kbps. Sorry about that.

beatmaps/artists/377 Maple Trick appears to be timed about ~10ms too early, maybe a bit less

Reletr wrote:

beatmaps/artists/377 Maple Trick appears to be timed about ~10ms too early, maybe a bit less

To be clear - offset should be 1639, not 1631.

beatmaps/artists/51

Pretty confident Camellia's remix of rift.exe should be 210 bpm? the motifs of the original version are sped up here rather than slowed down

beatmaps/artists/16

Wisp X's Wander's audio file is bloated by embedded image in the MP3. Takes 4+ MB in size.

beatmaps/artists/240

No Time To Explain appears twice on listing

Boom Kitty (beatmaps/artists/233) - Power Trip samplerate is too high.

Mili (beatmaps/artists/331) - Bathtub Mermaid has inconsistent timings between deemo version and full version, should follow deemo version of 78 bpm, full version having bloated audio as well

Fleshgod Apocalypse - The Fool has audio bitrate of 256kbps. It is easy to fix it by downsizing it to 192kbps. But this adds an extra step that shouldn't be needed for mappers (especially new mappers) to use the blank map template

Dustvoxx - Disconnect Me has two issues.

1. Song title is incorrect, should be "Disconnect Me (from saturator)"
2. Timing fails to account for speedups and slowdowns

Fixed timings

Mili - Lemonade mp3 seems to be bloated from 128kbps.

Really huge issue - metadata for 19ZZ is incorrect.
Artist should be Frums (unknown "lambda") as according to official sources. This results in all maps of this song not having the Featured Artist tag on the site, as well as not showing up when searching for maps with a Frums song in the FA listing.
beatmapsets/1388112/discussion/-/generalAll#/4041444

beatmaps/artists/384
You & I appears as "You _ I" on the site

also, while looking through C-Shows page, i thought it would be cool to link where t+pazolites name is mentioned to his FA page, like how it's done for Camellia
beatmaps/artists/378

will see if more pages mention his name

- EDIT, Aquellex has t+pazolite mention too:
beatmaps/artists/380

- EDIT 2: 69 de 74 has an osu! profile, so i think it should be linked as well:
beatmaps/artists/268
users/28700783

- EDIT 3: Maybe link YUC'e's FA page when their name is mentioned in Aice room's FA page:
beatmaps/artists/360

(i'm sorry, next time i'll do big post instead of very small ones lol)

Sedna is missing a timing point and offset is 12ms early
beatmaps/artists/320

When Time Sleeps should be Drum & Bass, not Hardcore
beatmaps/artists/5

Inertia Split by beatmaps/artists/381 has three short sections with 120BPM and a 3/4 timing signature. They should be a 4/4 signature at 160BPM instead, since otherwise the smaller beat divisors are off.

more random stuff i noticed!

beatmaps/artists/32

onumi's links to her personal wesbite and youtube channel don't seem to work

new youtube link: https://youtube.com/@onumi

also, the songs PERSONALITY and ARROGANCE don't seem to be songs in the album Childhood Friend (according to both soundcloud and bandcamp), but please double check that

beatmaps/artists/394

2 songs in collaboration with KOAN Sound are not displayed, would be good to include them i think

beatmaps/artists/166

link to Monstercat FA page when Monstercat is mentioned

beatmaps/artists/62

Muzzy (MUZZ) and Feint could be linked now when they're mentioned

also, maybe include songs from MUZZ's and Feint's listings where she was featured in, as well as Maboroshi made with Hyper Potions and Synthion, Talk 2 Me from Tiny Waves and Spicy with 2ToneDisco and BLOOD CODE

beatmaps/artists/47

link the three bands mentioned to their FA pages: Alestorm, Necrogoblikon, Gloryhammer,

Yonkagor template issue (timing), issue addressed per box

beatmaps/artists/45 - wrong song title
UNDEAD CORPORATION - Bloodthirsty Lullaby Nightmare, in TOHO Complete Box - GOLD album, should be Bloodthirsty Nightmare Lullaby

http://undeadcorporation.com/tohocomplete/tohocomplete.html#5

beatmaps/artists/51 Akira Complex
Track "Infinity Stage Theme" should be "Infinity Stage 2019 Anthem"
https://soundcloud.com/akira-complex/akira-complex-infinity-stage-2019-anthem-trailer-song
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l85o_CLWjwo

beatmaps/artists/343 KASHIWA Daisuke

I assume the 1st half of "write once, run melos" is fine, but believe the 2nd half has multiple bpm changes that aren't taken into account. for example, the entire 17:37-22:23 part seems to be ~207 bpm instead of 176 bpm

I don't feel confident in providing exact fixes as the song has fractional bpms throughout e_e'

more linking!

ALEPH - beatmaps/artists/107



Lexurus - beatmaps/artists/208

- link Liquicity - beatmaps/artists/340

Inferi - beatmaps/artists/43

HUG AND KILL by Kobaryo here- beatmaps/artists/96
I believe the offsets off.
the offsets 188 when i think it should be closer to 218 or not idk.
I just know the offset is wrong.

and even more links and stuff, cuz links get outdated often xd

1. Æther Realm - beatmaps/artists/47
   - offical website link gives a 404 message, guessing this used to be a section where you could buy their merchandise, but it's gone
2. High Tea Music - beatmaps/artists/26
   - link T & Sugah's (beatmaps/artists/188) and Lexurus's (beatmaps/artists/208) FA pages where it's mentioned
   - also consider updating their icon as the lines above the tea cup are different now
3. T & Sugah - beatmaps/artists/188
   - link Liquicity's (beatmaps/artists/340) FA Page where it's mentioned
4. Zomboy - beatmaps/artists/224
   - no link to the osu! Beatmaps? i guess it's cuz of Never Say Die (beatmaps/artists/251) having the beatmap, but it makes Zomboy's FA Page feel unnecessary, so it would be good if the songs made by Zomboy can be found throught his FA link (beatmapsets?q=featured_artist%3D224)

that's it for now, cya again soon :p

MOtOLOiD:
- "Kimi ga Kimi ga -vocanico remix-" is inconsistent w/ other templates (creator is set to Ephemeral)
Mili:
- all of their mp3s are bloated to 192kbps seems like, cant check all but 2 got reported here and found one myself
Rohi:
- "Ichiru no Nozomi yo, Ano Tsuki e Hibike" seems to have low quality audio? theres a set w/ a 192kbps audio file herere and it sounds better so you might wanna check that
Yuyoyuppe:
- all of the templates in "Story of Hope" have cover art which is 3.6mb, wasting space
- also, "You and beautiful world" is encoded to 320kbps

*namirin:
-Please check the id fields (BeatmapID and BeatmapSetID) of "Ciel Etoile" because I always see them already filled in when I download it.

beatmaps/artists/294 Abuse
Album stream:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jQEY8ksNjrI
https://abu-se-ken.bandcamp.com/album/karma-a-darma

Track "Flowers, Mountains & Funerals" should not use an ampersand.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_B3ed2Z2qgs
https://www.nicovideo.jp/watch/sm37478800
Metadata sources that I was able to find refer to the song as "Flowers, Mountains and Funerals", using "and" instead of "&". I wasn't able to find an official metadata source that uses "&", as most use the japanese title.

Additionally, the song "Judah" is referred as "Judas" (Bandcamp & YouTube Title), with the only reference to "Judah" that I was able to find being in the YouTube English subtitles, which states that the translation was made by はるP, therefore I'm a bit skeptical.
I think "Judas" is what the artist prefers? I'm not sure...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MegN7P0Pfg8
https://www.nicovideo.jp/watch/sm36818941
https://soundcloud.com/abuse-406429347/judas
bandcamp link is the same in both.

beatmaps/artists/145 Empty Peperoncino
Tired Tired has drifting bpm and needs to be retimed

Kagaribi's background is unrankable

beatmapsets/2130665/discussion/-/generalAll#/4364469

beatmaps/artists/132 Yuyoyuppe / DJ'TEKINA//SOMETHING
Track Palette has a drifting timing at the beginning (Note: it does not happen in the Solitude Freak version)
I've done my best to retime it, and it also includes extra red lines to accomodate for osu's rounding errors and taiko's barlines.


edit june 17th, I forgot to omit barlines, I'm sorry

Melomanic wrote:

HUG AND KILL by Kobaryo here- beatmaps/artists/96
I believe the offsets off.
the offsets 188 when i think it should be closer to 218 or not idk.
I just know the offset is wrong.

they tried to fix the offset but now when im on osu lazer i can see the offset is still off a little. im not sure if its just osu lazer but the offset should be 250.

Hino Isuka - ULTRA MEGA HAPPY PARTY!!! has a 5/4 section missing

corrected .osz

Raimukun - Icyxis

mappable sounds before the timing point, new offset should be 289 (might be off by 1ms pls double check)

beatmaps/artists/207

"Chata - Papapapanda" is using a short/cut version, whereas the full song is roughly 4 minutes.
Not only that, but the audio file used is 128kbps, despite FLAC versions existing, as it was released in a couple of albums ( ちゃたのわ: https://www.lantis.jp/release-item/LACA-5776.html (Track 6) | lack of reason: http://www.solfa.asia/lackofreason/ (Track 6) )

I don't think this cut is technically official, as it was taken from beatmapsets/61046
Doing a SHA256 checksum comparison with certUtil, both files seem to be the exact same:

-FA Audio: 76f11de12dba986d6b9e03a7a841e4c2583ba221e63ec176f8a4ce3901a73cff
-Beatmap:  76f11de12dba986d6b9e03a7a841e4c2583ba221e63ec176f8a4ce3901a73cff

Was this intentional? Having a bad audio kinda breaks the purpose of a FA template.

Not only that, but the osz is labeled as "Chata - Papapapanda" in the website, but downloading it provides "solfa feat. Chata - Papapapanda". Is having different text also intentional?

any chance on a timing check for this one

https://assets.ppy.sh/artists/370/The%20Dreaming%20Tree/Ruby%20My%20Dear%20-%20The%20Dreaming%20Tree.osz

Kyutatsuki - SOUND ARCHITECT (Corsace) is missing unicode artist (九立つ気)

Blind Guardian - The Bard's Song (In The Forest) is mistimed.
I noticed, for example, that the sound that should be on the white tick at 01:35:355 is actually closer to 01:35:299. I think it should be reviewed.

https://assets.ppy.sh/artists/172/Songs/Akiri_x_II-L_-_QUADRANTIDS.osz (Akiri x II-L - QUANDRANTIDS) already has information filled in for difficulty name and beatmap creator which should be removed to match the rest of FA listing osz files

https://assets.ppy.sh/artists/31/osz/Camellia%20-%20%20Under%20Construxion.osz
Metadata is wrong on the song title and artist, it should be かめりあ as the artist and Camellia romanized
Title should be ⫻Under Construxion⫻ and romanized should be ///Under Construxion///
also idk if its halved for mapping reasons but the actual song bpm is 315

beatmaps/artists/96

Yggdrasil is incorrectly listed as just a Kobaryo song even though it's a collaboration with Gram under the name "Gram vs. Kobaryo". This only applies to the website, the osz file is correct.
SUPER MEMORIES is also listed as just Kobaryo instead of the correct artist "Kobaryo feat. HiTNEX-X", however, again this only applies to the website.

not sure how relevant this is but,

beatmaps/artists/372

YUC'e - Summer Lover!! should have offset shifted from 1416 to around 1424, as this was mentioned here (i mapped it as a tourney custom and asked for some more opinions on the server, and the general consensus seemed to be that 1424 plays better)

and bpm should be 95 as the entire song is in half time, and the ranked mania set uses 95 as well (might also be worth mentioning that it uses offset 1418)

i think Dead Rabbit and Witch's Blood it double its bpm. other wise its weird how some of its sounds are 1/16

https://assets.ppy.sh/artists/31/Songs/Camellia%20-%20Qyoh%20(Nine%20Stars).osz
i think the timing points 59608,286.806883365201,7,2,0,100,1,0
60755,344.43168771527,7,2,0,100,1,0
61329,272.727272727273,7,2,0,100,1,0
61874,346.820809248555,7,2,0,100,1,0
62459,247.933884297521,7,2,0,100,1,0
are unneccesary as there are 2 ranked versions of this in mania that dont have them (beatmapsets/1824429#mania/3743608 and beatmapsets/1833301#mania/3763646)

Kikuo - Kara Kara Kara no Kara (きくお - カラカラカラのカラ) seems to have noticably off timing starting at the speedup section. I'm by no means a timing wizard but this should be more accurate:

5004.65947155486,451.127819548872,4,2,0,100,1,0
176433,452.830188679245,4,2,0,100,1,0
178244,451.127819548872,4,2,0,100,1,0
180048,433.212996389892,4,2,0,100,1,0
181780,428.571428571429,4,2,0,100,1,0
183494,422.535211267606,4,2,0,100,1,0
185184,415.22491349481,4,2,0,100,1,0
186844,408.163265306122,4,2,0,100,1,0
188476,402.684563758389,4,2,0,100,1,0
190086,397.350993377483,4,2,0,100,1,0
191675,389.61038961039,4,2,0,100,1,0
193233,384.615384615385,4,2,0,100,1,0
194771,379.746835443038,4,2,0,100,1,0
196289,371.517027863777,4,2,0,100,1,0
197775,368.098159509202,4,2,0,100,1,0
199247,364.741641337387,4,2,0,100,1,0
200705,355.029585798817,4,2,0,100,1,0
202125,352.941176470589,4,2,0,100,1,0
203536,351.906158357772,4,2,0,100,1,0
204943,352.941176470589,4,2,0,100,1,0

beatmaps/artists/14

Rin - Eientewi set 06 ~ Plain Asia

The offset should be 1315. Otherwise the musical accents will go wrong if you listen to next sections.

the audio on Coffins (Pegboard Nerds x Mister Wives) is bloated and therefore violates the ranking criteria as can be seen here: beatmapsets/2199020/discussion/-/generalAll#/4681397

this discussion also includes a replacement audio file

touhou_metadata.gif

Rin / Function Phantom
Koumakan set 04 ~ Otenba Koi Musume
-> Koumakan set 04 ~ Otenba Koimusume
"koimusume" is considered a single word, see here

Koumakan set 13 ~ Mahou Shoujotachi no Hyaku Nensai
-> Koumakan set 13 ~ Mahou Shoujo-tachi no Hyakunensai

Koumakan set 15 ~ Beni yori Hakanai Eien
-> Koumakan set 15 ~ Aka yori Hakanai Eien

Daishibyo set 03 ~ Youkai Tera e Youkoso
-> Daishibyo set 03 ~ Youkaidera e Youkoso

Daishibyo set 09 ~ Yumedonodai Matsu Byou
-> Daishibyo set 09 ~ Yumedono Daishibyou

Daishibyo set 10 ~ Ougami Shinwaden
-> Daishibyo set 10 ~ Oomiwa Shinwaden

Daishibyo set 12 ~ Seitoku Densetsu
-> Daishibyo set 12 ~ Shoutoku Densetsu

Daishibyo set 13 ~ Youkai Ura Sandou
-> Daishibyo set 13 ~ Youkai Urasandou

Chireiden set 01 ~ Kurayami no Kazaana
-> Chireiden set 01 ~ Kurayami no Fuuketsu

Chireiden set 05 ~ Kyuu Jigoku Kaidou wo Iku
-> Chireiden set 05 ~ Kyuu Jigoku Kaidou o Yuku

Chireiden set 06 ~ Hana no Sakazuki Oueyama.
-> Chireiden set 06 ~ Hana no Sakazuki Ooeyama

"Rin - Chireiden set 08 ~ Shoujo Satori" is out of order due to the format

Chireiden set 10 - Lullaby and Chireiden set 10 ~ Shitai Ryokou is the same song, can you double check on this

Chireiden set 11 ~ Gouka Mantoru
-> Chireiden set 11 ~ Gouka Mantle

Koumakan set 04 Another ~ O Tenba Koi Musume no Bouken
-> Koumakan set 04 Another ~ Otenba Koimusume no Bouken

Muenzuka set 00 ~ Hana Utsu Tsuka
-> Muenzuka set 00 ~ Kaeizuka

Muenzuka set 01 ~ Shunshoku Shoukei
-> Muenzuka set 01 ~ Haruiro Komichi

Muenzuka set 06 ~ Roku Juunenme no Touhou Saiban
-> Muenzuka set 06 ~ Rokujuunenme no Touhou Saiban

Ayakashi set 03 ~ Touno Gensou Monogatari
-> Ayakashi set 03 ~ Toono Gensou Monogatari

Ayakashi set 07 ~ Tenkuu no Hana no To.
-> Ayakashi set 07 ~ Tenkuu no Hana no Miyako

Ayakashi set 09 ~ Touhou You Yume
-> Ayakashi set 09 ~ Touhou Youyoumu

Ayakashi set 10 ~ Hiro Yuui Kai Tori Ji
-> Ayakashi set 10 ~ Hiroari Kechou o Iru Koto

Ayakashi set 12 ~ Kasoke Miyabini Sakase, Sumizome no Sakura
-> Ayakashi set 12 ~ Yuuga ni Sakase, Sumizome no Sakura

Ayakashi set 13 A ~ You Bakko
-> Ayakashi set 13 A ~ Youyou Bakko

Ayakashi set 13 B ~ You Bakko
-> Ayakashi set 13 B ~ Youyou Bakko

Ayakashi set 14 A ~ Shoujo Maboroshi Sou
-> Ayakashi set 14 A ~ Shoujo Gensou

Ayakashi set 14 Another ~ Yoruga Furite Kuru
-> Ayakashi set 14 Another ~ Yoru ga Oritekuru

Moriya set 03 ReEdit ~ Wazawai Kamisama no Tourimichi
-> Moriya set 03 ReEdit ~ Yakujinsama no Toorimichi

Moriya set 05 ReEdit ~ Kamigami ga Koi Shita Gensou Sato - Original Mix
-> Moriya set 05 ReEdit ~ Kamigami ga Koi Shita Gensokyo - Original Mix

Moriya set 05 ReEdit ~ Kamigami ga Koi Shita Gensou Sato
-> Moriya set 05 ReEdit ~ Kamigami ga Koi Shita Gensokyo

Moriya set 09 ReEdit ~ Shoujo ga Mita Nippon no Gen Fuukei
-> Moriya set 09 ReEdit ~ Shoujo ga Mita Nippon no Genfuukei

Moriya set 12 ReEdit ~ Kami sa Hita Kosenjou
-> Moriya set 12 ReEdit ~ Kamisabita Kosenjou

I skimmed through first half of the touhou arrangements and checked, I might do the rest later

According to this post (beatmapsets/1916069/discussion/-/generalAll#/3513066), the notification of "Kegare Naki Bara Juuji" by Ariabl'Eyes is wrong and should be changed to "Kegarenaki Bara Juuji". If possible, the old maps which feature the wrong metadata should still also have the featured artist tag enabled after these changes.

Ariabl'Eyes listing: beatmaps/artists/93

beatmaps/artists/170 Fleshgod Apocalypse
"The Fool" has two issues:
- Tagged as Electronic, instead of Technical Metal.
- BPM is suspiciously precise on website, is this correct? I can't check until next week but, beatmapsets/1301878 uses 230

----------------------------------------------------------------------

beatmaps/artists/113 glass beach
"bathroom community" should be credited as one of the following in the website to give proper attribution to covering artists (Personal preference in bold):

1. glass beach & Pinkshift - bathroom community
2. glass beach - bathroom community (Pinkshift cover)
3. glass beach - bathroom community (Pinkshift)

Sources:
https://soundcloud.com/glassbeach/bathroom-community
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f9c4ysh7Gj4
https://glassbeach.bandcamp.com/track/bathroom-community-pinkshift

"Neon Glow" should also be credited as one of the following:

1. Dogleg - Neon Glow
2. glass beach - Neon Glow (Dogleg)

Sources:
https://glassbeach.bandcamp.com/track/neon-glow-dogleg
https://soundcloud.com/glassbeach/neon-glow-3
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SHAI4oYqTCk