forum

[Queue] Taiko Nominator Association (disbanded)

posted
Total Posts
223
Topic Starter
Nardoxyribonucleic

Taiko Nominator Association Queue (日本語)

(Currently still on testphase)

Information
  1. This is not an average modding queue, so please read this announcement before requesting any mod.
  2. This queue opens every week on Thursday. You can post one Taiko set / difficulty after a TNA member opens a new round.
  3. The queue will reopen when maps are declined or successfully modded.
  4. The queue can open occasionally at an additional time, depending on how many additional workload we can take.
  5. 2 requests per round (may vary). New
  6. Mods for maps from the special list are only seen as valid when providing reasons. New
  7. Mapper with their requested map being ranked by TNA are not allowed to queue for 2 weeks.
  8. Disqualified maps which has been qualified by TNA will be rechecked.
Requirement

To make your map be accepted by the TNA, you have to fulfill one of the two requirements down below:

  1. Provide three recent mods (max. 3 weeks old) of yours on any Taiko map you want.
  2. Provide one mod on one of the maps which were not accepted by the TNA (max. 3 weeks old). We will list every declined map into a special list that can be used for this. (see below)
In any case, make sure to read the following guides to polish your map to the highest quality possible:
  1. [Guide] Appropriate Difficulties in Taiko
  2. [Guide] Mapping Taiko Difficulties
  3. [Help] Taiko Modding Academy
Ensuring top quality on your own maps before requesting a mod from us increases the chances highly to receive a nomination after our revision. Make sure to put most efforts into your maps to max out this chances as much as possible! If your maps are not even close to be considered for a nomination by us, we might even reject your request and roughly explain you why.
Special List
These maps requested to be modded here but were declined by us. To help them improve further before requesting a mod again, we list them here. Please mod these maps and help them getting ranked together with us!
  1. Duca - Zettai Darli'n (toara_fict)
  2. ROKINA - Icicle Stinger (EdamaMe411)
  3. Wakeshima Kanon - World's End, Girl's Rondo(Asterisk DnB Remix) (asuasu_yura)
  4. A-RISE - Shocking Party (TV Size) (Xinchii)
  5. Narae - Horang Pungryuga (Underflow)
  6. Chata - Remind (Chromoxx)
  7. BlackY vs. Yooh - XROSS INFECTION (-[ Dumpling ]-)
  8. Yoko Shimomura - Happy Holidays! (Hanjamon)
  9. nao.paradigm - Jingle Bell Mega Mix (Niko-nyan)
  10. Memme - Happy Solo Christmas (agu)
  11. SOUND HOLIC Vs. dj TAKA feat. YURiCa - TIEFSEE (extend ver.) (ll-oscar)
JUDYDANNY
1st round , TNA is open. We accept 2 requests for now!
Raiden
Hypeeeeee

POLE!

My 3 recent mods:
p/4434441
p/4437848
p/4448564

My map:
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/342966

Comment:
Please note however that Ozzy didn't apply the mods yet (well he actually did tell me that he didn't accept any, but still)
shionelove
https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/p/4450005/
https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/p/4449702/
https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/p/4444116/

map is https://osu.ppy.sh/s/322827

btw i want to join this after i finish my queue's reqs(then maybe i have better modding skill of taiko than now)
no i have own queue

Edit:if you add more slots plz make slots for American,Europian etc? to make equal chance(time zone rip)
for example 3slot open AM 0:00 in Japan and PM0:00 inJapan each
Topic Starter
Nardoxyribonucleic
Closed.
Yuzeyun
Freeing one slot. To request a mod, please ensure you meet the requirements given in the opening post.

Rejected (1):

  1. Sasaki Sayaka - Koi Saku Mirai
    1. Hitsound arrangement seems inconsistent with provided rhythm in harder difficulties
    2. Final difficulty name is "Cherry Blossom" - which could make players confused.
Charlotte
Yuzeyun
Closed.
Apl_old_1
Mistake.

<Deleted the image>
Raiden
Queue is closed, you cannot request mods until it opens.
Bara-
Nice
Good luck with the queue! :3
OzzyOzrock
The first official opening! 4 slots are open. To request a mod, please ensure you meet the requirements given in the opening post.
AnatOWJIya
With Skeuddy's permission that made GD for my map

Mods:
p/4447384
p/4453986
p/4455801

Map:
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/275841

Thanks in advance!
Blanc Kisaragi
EdamaMe411
Volta
OzzyOzrock
Closed!
KSHR
Probably you guys should add one more content that tells people to read your last post into Information like other modding queues do just in case imo.

Good luck, TNA!
Prophecy

KSHR wrote:

Probably you guys should add one more content that tells people to read your last post into Information like other modding queues do just in case imo.

Good luck, TNA!
yep. It should be better >w<

The time is bad for me lol
Topic Starter
Nardoxyribonucleic
Freeing 3 slots. To request a mod, please ensure you meet the requirements given in the opening post.

Rejected (3):

  1. Between August and December - Blow with the Fires
    1. Difficulties are mapped in a way too hard for their levels.
    2. Pattern arrangement in Futsuu seems random and the 1/3 notes in Oni are not supported by the song rhythm.
  1. Logan Mader and Jamie Christopherson - It Has To Be This Way (Platinum Mix)
    1. Quite a number of note sections cannot accompany the music well in lower difficulties.
    2. Kantan follows the main rhythm too much, which results in odd snappings. Futsuu follows rhythms in a way contrasting with Muzukashii too much while ignoring breaks.
  1. Walpis Carter - Asu no Yozora Shoukaihan
    1. The difficulty gap between Futsuu and Muzukashii is huge. Consider reducing it for a better spread.
    2. Patterns are a bit inconsistent in lower difficulties, especially during kiai time.
Raiden
Whoa, it really is strict. Okay let's give it a shot.

My mods:

p/4445928#p4445928
p/4439350#p4439350
p/4444493#p4444493

My map:

t/362138

Let's see if I can make it.

Keep up the good work guys!
newyams99
Dino99
Topic Starter
Nardoxyribonucleic
Closed.
Arzenvald
i should mod more taiko maps frequently starts from now hahah..

jk i had job to do so rip
anyway i love the concept on the flowchart and how they works.. keep the nice work up guys!
Surono

ExUsagi wrote:

i should mod more taiko maps frequently starts from now hahah..

jk i had job to do so rip
anyway i love the concept on the flowchart and how they works.. keep the nice work up guys!
dem system wuw =w= wuf, ew make mapper do modding.. and modding is make nice mapping =w= ah,.
OzzyOzrock
Freeing 1 slot. To request a mod, please ensure you meet the requirements given in the opening post.

Rejected (1):

  1. yuikonnu & ayaponzu* - Kunoichi demo Koi ga Shitai
    1. The difficulty gap between Futsuu and Muzukashii is too large.
    2. Pattern arrangement in Kantan and Futsuu can be made more interesting.
Lost The Lights
OzzyOzrock
Closed.
Nwolf
Freeing 4 slots. To request a mod, please ensure you meet the requirements given in the opening post.

Rejected (4):

  1. Within Temptation - Iron
    1. Pattern arrangement needs improvement.
    2. Final SV is too extreme.
  1. mimimemeMIMI - CANDY MAGIC
    1. The patterns do not follow the song well enough.
    2. Oni and Inner Oni are too similar to each other
  1. dj TAKA feat. Erika Mochizuki - MOON
    1. Overall the patterns in higher difficulties (mainly Inner Oni) are too random with unclear usage of 1/4 and finishers.
    2. There is a big spread hole around the Muzukashii diff.
  1. Renard - Bumblefuck
    1. Kantan - Muzukashii are too dense at some spots - for Kantan/Futsuu mainly before the first kiai and in the last kiai. Overall they are too hard for this BPM - Add a "Beginner" diff (might want to name it "Kantan" and rename Kantan to "Inner Kantan")
    2. 00:34:941 - This part has to be looked over in the higher diffs since the difficulty is too equal or even higher than surrounding parts (Focus on Muzukashii, Collab Inner)


A new rule has been added:

After requesting a mod you have to wait 2 rounds before being allowed to request a mod again.
tasuke912
SKSalt
Mod

https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/p/4446452
https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/p/4437577
https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/p/4412459

My map

https://osu.ppy.sh/s/324772

Comment :

Ranking Criteria wrote:

You must cut your mp3 if you're using less than 80% of it. This doesn't count intro time, and thus only applies if more than 20% of the outro is unmapped. If you only plan to map a portion of your song, then including the full mp3 is a waste of file space. Many mp3 editing tools like this exist which make fading and cutting a song simple. However, if you have a legitimate reason for keeping your full mp3 (e.g. a storyboard after the map ends), then that is fine.
This mapset may think that it conflicts with this. However, Because recent existing Ranked map has it, I do not have any problem. Link

Thanks in advance.
Renka
Aldwych
Gotta go fast!

Hi!

3mods (we can also take gezo's lel) :

p/4385604#p4385604
p/4357734#p4357734
p/4355067#p4355067

1 map :

https://osu.ppy.sh/s/165414

Thanks in advance!
JUDYDANNY
EDT1
Rejected Aldwych's request.

Requirement
  1. Provide three recent mods (max. 3 weeks old) of yours on any Taiko map you want.

Reopen freeing 1 slot.
Apl_old_1
JUDYDANNY
Closed.
Nwolf
Freeing 3 slots. To request a mod, please ensure you meet the requirements given in the opening post.

Rejected (3):

  1. xi - ANiMA
    1. Muzukashii and Oni are overall a little bit too hard compared to Kantan and Futsuu. At some spots, Oni and Muzukashii are either too similar or far too different (eg. 01:26:989 - to 01:36:798 - ).
    2. Kantan and Futsuu need more rest moments.
  1. Ayane - Perfect Quest (Short ver.)
    1. Hitsound usage in Futsuu and Muzukashii needs improvement.
    2. Spread between Futsuu and Oni is too big. Muzukashii needs to be harder in spots where the difference between Oni and Muzukashii is very big. In some spots, Futsuu needs to be a little bit harder as well. Simplifying some overdone parts in Oni like 01:44:108 (71,72,73,74,75,76,77,78,79) - might help as well.
  1. senya - Tsuki ni Murakumo Hana ni Kaze (PV ver.)
    1. Spread does not work out: Kantan needs to be harder, Futsuu and especially Muzukashii need to be easier (in some spots Muzukashii is very similar to Oni). Overall Futsuu's kiai should be reconsidered and some Muzukashii patterns refined to suit the spread to Oni better.
karterfreak
toara_fict
Surono
Topic Starter
Nardoxyribonucleic
Closed.
Topic Starter
Nardoxyribonucleic
The second official opening! 4 slots are open. To request a mod, please ensure you meet the requirements given in the opening post.
Maya Tendo
Map:
http://osu.ppy.sh/s/340040

my Mod:
p/4439301
p/4442048
p/4447512

Read this

・01:14:187~ kiai is just to the tune. If this makes this map unrankable, i will change this as soon as. So dont choose this in a Rejected reason. Teach me in TNA Modding.
・I think this maps make you so surprise, but i want you listening carefully to song and thinking carefully my maps.

sorry bad English...

to make sure I wrote in Japanese... so sry
・01:14:187からのkiaiは曲に合わせているだけで、できたらこちらの方がよいということです。もし、これがアンランクド要素に確実になるなら私はすぐ変えます。なのでこれをリジェクトの理由にしないでほしいです。譜面自体がよいのならTNAのModで教えていただきたいです。
・私が思うにこのマップセットはみなさまに怪訝に思われることだと思いますが、私はみなさんに注意深く曲を聴いてもらって注意深く譜面について考えてほしいです。

よろしくおねがいします。

thx
Raiden
Let's try again =_=

Mods:

p/4477158/
p/4475116/
p/4474224/


Map:

t/362138


let's hope everything is addressed uwu
Ploenar
I don't have any confidence. but let me try.

My mods:
p/4471960#p4471960
p/4467674#p4467674
p/4441775#p4441775

Map:
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/319462
Nishizumi
Topic Starter
Nardoxyribonucleic
Rejected Raiden's request. You need to wait another week (i.e. until the 3rd round opens) before posting again.

Opening Post wrote:

Mapper with their requested map being ranked by TNA are not allowed to queue for 2 weeks. New
One slot remaining.
DarkVortex
Heyho!

my mod: https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/p/4476266

my map: https://osu.ppy.sh/s/158141

Hope that works, thanks :3
Topic Starter
Nardoxyribonucleic
Closed.
qoot8123
Freeing 3 slots. To request a mod, please ensure you meet the requirements given in the opening post.

Rejected (3):

  1. Duca - Zettai Darli'n
    1. Spread needs much more adjustments. The gap between Muzu and Oni is to large, some parts (kiai time) on Futsuu are too close with Kantan
  1. Last Child - Diary Depresiku
    1. Some patterns don't reflect the song well (eg: oo oo), and doublet is not really needed for this song.
    2. Use to much notes on this kind of song(eg: 00:10:392 to 00:24:938 - ), it lead to the map a bit overmap ,needs more less dense part .
    3. SV change is not really needed to be honest,and there is some little overlap before early kiai (01:24:938 - ,03:06:756 - )
  1. EBICO & JIOYI - Slit
    1. Spread has serious problem, Muzu's difficulty is already out of the range that it should be, needs make it more easier (still needs focus more on spread when fix it)
    2. Oni is quite similar with Inner Oni. Should make Oni easier.
    3. Quite a number of 1/6 patterns used in Inner Oni and Cracked Taiko do not fit the song rhythm
Kurokotei
Hi!

My mod: p/4469872
My map: https://osu.ppy.sh/s/309772

The map has been previously modded when the diffs were uploaded on Fullerene's mapset

Thanks in advance!
Nofool
o/

my mod : p/4479886/
my map : https://osu.ppy.sh/s/351410

edit : im not 100% sure about my offset, JUDY suggested me another one but i would like more opinion if possible ;w;

thanks in advance'
pkhg
Topic Starter
Nardoxyribonucleic
Closed.
qoot8123
Freeing 2 slots. To request a mod, please ensure you meet the requirements given in the opening post.

Rejected (2):

  1. orangentle / Yu_Asahina - HAELEQUIN (Extended ver.)
    1. Questionable sv usage on -the kat of ex's truth- . It effect gameplay element very much.
    2. Some part has weird rhythm that also hard to play (eg : 01:43:238 ~ 02:02:773 - )
    3. Diff name is unacceptable for rank. Should be changed.
    4. 1/6 patterns need more carefully to use.
  1. Lia - Bravely You (TV Size)
    1. Muzu needs more breaks on calm part (eg: 00:48:665 - ~ 01:01:465 - ), and the spread is unbalanced with Oni that needs to be fixed.
    2. Some parts' note density on Oni are too close with Inner, and Oni's stream patterns are a bit hard (eg: 01:26:065 (422,423,424,425,426,427,428,429,430) - ). Should be fixed to easier one.
    3. Hitsound's volume could be less noisy.
Bara-
DakeDekaane
Mame ga nyaa
Raiden

Mame ga nyaa wrote:

><

mod
p/4436686
p/4487589
p/4487689

map
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/228647

thanks!
There were 2 slots, not 3. The 2 have been filled even tho the queue has not been closed.

Wait until next round or until a slot is freed in case any map is rejected.
Topic Starter
Nardoxyribonucleic
Rejected Mame ga nyaa's request as slots are full.

Closed.
Nwolf
3rd round opening! 5 slots!
Deep Sea
Hi TNA :3
with permission game rock, that made GD for my map

Mods:
t/357938
p/4476480/
t/364663

Map:
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/344082

Thanks in advance! ^^
Grimbow
Hello there o/

Three mods:
p/4443312#p4443312
p/4451449#p4451449
p/4488678#p4488678

My map:
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/324146

Thank you in advance if it is chosen! :oops:
Raiden
Sieg
Modding Queues forum is expanding?
shionelove
recent 3 mods

https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/p/4496351/
https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/p/4492983/
https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/p/4487743/

map

https://osu.ppy.sh/s/351520

plz delete my map from special queue,and plz don't add this map to special queue if you reject it.
Avena
Special map modded: p/4463501
My map: https://osu.ppy.sh/s/302535

edit: ahhh i linked the wrong map i meant to link this https://osu.ppy.sh/s/296017
Nwolf
Closed
Bara-
Uhm
What'll happen now that multiple Taiko BN are removed?
Nwolf and qoot
Raiden
Nothing but wait :/

I think this will be fixed soon enough... I don't think this has been done without noticing the consequences. I mean, Nwolf was on vacation on August, and qoot I think had work with University or something.

I guess that's all we can do for now, just wait ;w;
OnosakiHito
No worries for now. Nothing will happen. We will keep going as before. That's the good thing about TNA, since it is a group. And even so, it's not like they vanished. They are still experienced and trustworthy guys. It's indeed inconvinient, but we have to work with current situation.
For more information, click here.

Queue still closed. We will check those 5 maps.
qoot8123
Freeing 3 slots. To request a mod, please ensure you meet the requirements given in the opening post.

Rejected (3):

  1. DJ YOSHITAKA - CUSTOM DRIVE
    1. Improper diff spread among every diff:
      Compare with Muzukashii and Futsuu, the gap is very large. Itcontains too much 1/4 notes on muzu. And Oni has different difficulty jump.

    2. Lacks of quality:
      Ura Oni contains too many unnecessary 1/4 stream, it lose lots of emphasis of the song. The the pattern's flow also work not really well (eg :00:17:415 - ~ 00:20:536 - )
  1. Eluveitie - Helvetios
    1. Improper difficulty spread :
      Some parts between Futsuu and Kantan are too close , and Oni and Muzu has same condition. It make the gap with Futsuu and Muzu very large. For example 01:25:517 - to 01:36:427 - , muzu contains some 1/4 patterns which very close to oni, but futsuu only has 1/1 pattern which is close to kantan.
  1. Icon For Hire - Cynics & Critics
    1. Improper difficulty spread :
      Most of calm parts on Muzu is very close to Oni (eg : 00:00:509 - ~ 00:05:812 - ).However, the only climax part which has larger gap, it lead to the spread is very unbalance.

    2. Map's quality still has plenty room for improvement :
      The map contains too much 1/2 continuous pattern so that it didn't emphasize the song well, could use more 1/4 pattern in oni, and avoid using long/ continuous pattern too much, try to have some 1/1 gap between 1/2 patterns. And there is a example(00:45:591 - ~00:50:895 - ). Finally, highly suggest use kat to follow snare, it would be better.

And note that there are maps which removed from the special list as they have been modded 2 times or upon creator's request of removal :

1.Sasaki Sayaka - Koi Saku Mirai (shionelove)
2.Within Temptation - Iron (Raiden)
3.dj TAKA feat. Erika Mochizuki - MOON (Dino99)
Mame ga nyaa
Maya Tendo
Map:
http://osu.ppy.sh/s/340040

my Mod:
p/4490812
p/4447512 (I got kudosu 17 days ago... can I use this?)
p/4500486

thx
BeoMu
qoot8123
Closed.

Edit : refused Mrriichi's request, the mod was outdate.

Open one more slot.
tasuke912
lol

Hello. time to try again.

mod (from special list):
p/4479528#p4479528

map:
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/326029
qoot8123
okay.
Closed.
qoot8123
Because there are some requests which not cleared yet, so we decide not to open the queue this week. Sorry for inconvenient.
Bara-
Will it open this week?
Intelli

Baraatje123 wrote:

Will it open this week?
I bet it's going to open in 90 minutes when I'll be at marching band practice so I won't get in just because my luck rocks.
Volta
i once had a weekly queue. but then i abandoned it because i'm getting lazy and busy (gonna revive it soon though). so i know how hard to keep up with weekly request when you also have many other things to do. i hope this queue will last long. i also want to rank my map. Good luck TNA
qoot8123

Baraatje123 wrote:

Will it open this week?
Yea,for America time.this round will be handled by ozzy
Maya Tendo

qoot8123 wrote:

Baraatje123 wrote:

Will it open this week?
Yea,for America time
I hope you adding "in America (or some states) time" to Thursday.

Japan is now Friday 9 a.m.


sry Ono. I forgot it.
OnosakiHito
Please use this for chatting to keep the queue clean.
New information
OzzyOzrock
4TH ROUND OPENING! (Everyone posting around this time gives it away...)

5 Slots are open!! To request a mod, please ensure you meet the requirements given in the opening post.

Denied from before:


Hashimoto Miyuki - Eternal recurrence
  1. Futsuu and Muzukashii can use a bit more 1/2 and 1/4 notes respectively in kiai. The spread at 00:16:521 to 00:30:743 - can be improved.
Konomi Suzuki - This game(TV-Size)
  1. Muzukashii could use less 1/4.
  2. Some sections in lower difficulties change what is being mapped too quickly.
Maya Tendo
DarkDunskin
-Tenshi-
Hi!

Mod from the special list: p/4511569#p4511569

My map: https://osu.ppy.sh/s/326725

Thank you!
SKSalt
hi.

mods

https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/p/4520966
https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/p/4515824
https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/p/4511788

map

https://osu.ppy.sh/s/352682

Comment

Especially, 01:30:882 ~ 01:45:282 - This part is hard in all diffs. But this thinks that there is not to be helped for it in a characteristic of the music.

Thanks in advance :3
EdamaMe411
OzzyOzrock
Closed!
qoot8123
5th Round opening!

due to current TNA member are very busy so that the modding progress is slow down , so this time we will open 3 slot .
To request a mod, please ensure you meet the requirements given in the opening post.

note : the requests on last round doesn't be judged yet by all TNA members. we will give conclusions as soon as possible.
Lost The Lights
Charlotte
asuasu_yura
qoot8123
closed.
newyams99
Just a question. Is there an 'expiry date' to the usage of mods on the special list? Is it the same three weeks as the regular mods, or is there even a time limit?
xtrem3x
LOL ... for 10 minutes ._. ... waiting for other chance
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply