p/5093240 i think that pattern those and handsome mentioned is valid and i posted some additional things on that spring's diff o.o, and mapper hasn't replied to that
show more
Also, t/374793/start=225 this map is getting much discussion about EX EX diff, It's almost close to rank at this point, CTB mode is very fast for an S rank Disqualified by Kurokami, thx
https://osu.ppy.sh/b/972364
Potential metadata issues, regarding "Lamune War!" diff, not sure whether actually needs fixing
ok nevermind i needed to redownload im dumb
rigged at 2nd note exactly at 33.270 and if you try to hit the note on any manner it will fail you and it does this continuously through the map on the normal difficulty and other ones included https://osu.ppy.sh/b/159497&m=0
https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/p/5173191
Irrational difficulty name
01:20:381 (1) - wrong snap
https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/p/5173223
Accidentally 2 osbs on the mapset disqualified by p3n
p/5174068
I can't speak chinese but I get that maybe is a problem with the timing points?
https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/p/5201740
Incorrect metadata dq by kwan
https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/p/5223681
Inconsistent LN's end snap on diff EXH and GRV ...
Need a response ASAP because the map is going to the ranked section at this point...
my apologizes
https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/p/5327164
(maybe) some points in the map could be polished nope, are fine
show more
p/5096027
Spinner recovery in Normal is only 1 beat
Spinner recovery in Normal is only 1 beat
t/290713/start=330
Lots of discussing about patterning, flow, hitsounds and hitsounding. Mapper seems to decline everything to not get a dq.
Lots of discussing about patterning, flow, hitsounds and hitsounding. Mapper seems to decline everything to not get a dq.
p/5104968/
misplaced hitsounds according to the rest of the map, same with the thing that ive said he ignored
might be worth dqing
at least to get mapper's reply
misplaced hitsounds according to the rest of the map, same with the thing that ive said he ignored
might be worth dqing
at least to get mapper's reply
https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/p/5116341
Snapping issues, map is close to rank at this point so it should be DQ'ed ASAP
Snapping issues, map is close to rank at this point so it should be DQ'ed ASAP
t/374793/start=255
Like seriously. Not intuitional at all, only SV to emphasize anything in the EX EX diff.
Not even consistent spacing and if you use only SV to emphasize everything it should atleast have consistent spacing, not random...
This set could be ranked without the EX EX diff. That should stay unranked. It's fun, yeh. But not for a ranked map.
Like seriously. Not intuitional at all, only SV to emphasize anything in the EX EX diff.
Not even consistent spacing and if you use only SV to emphasize everything it should atleast have consistent spacing, not random...
This set could be ranked without the EX EX diff. That should stay unranked. It's fun, yeh. But not for a ranked map.
Snapping and both slider tick and slider slider are muted at same time
t/437678/start=60
t/437678/start=75
t/437678/start=60
t/437678/start=75
Maybe a little problem with the video?
p/5123361
p/5123361
Hey, i'm seeing quite a few reports going unnoticed, maybe because they appear to be minor/subjective stuff that don't absolutely require dq's. It would be nice to at least get a reply to them though... Whether the QAT agrees with the concerns or not. Right now it does look like some concerns have been ignored...
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/402016
missing video in hard diff
missing video in hard diff
MBomb
p/5136940#p5136940
Lots of issues with strong dash distances for a rain, as well as HDash misusage in rain difficulty.
Lots of issues with strong dash distances for a rain, as well as HDash misusage in rain difficulty.
Potential metadata issues, regarding "Lamune War!" diff, not sure whether actually needs fixing
ok nevermind i needed to redownload im dumb
The mapset which you gave is a 2012 ranked mapset and ranked mapsets cannot be disqualified.You have to report qualified maps only if you found serious issues,not ranked ones. Just saying to know more better in futureSLDplays wrote:
rigged at 2nd note exactly at 33.270 and if you try to hit the note on any manner it will fail you and it does this continuously through the map on the normal difficulty and other ones included https://osu.ppy.sh/b/159497&m=0
p/5165405/ because of snapping issues
p/5170184#p5170184
A lot of the issues brought by the mods weren't properly replied, conveyed by vague replies to issues that were poorly explained by some of the modders. Aditionally, some replies were also rude telling one of the modders that he/she "is delayed regarding mapping" and another one that some points brought by him/her "can't be regarded as a mod".
A lot of the issues brought by the mods weren't properly replied, conveyed by vague replies to issues that were poorly explained by some of the modders. Aditionally, some replies were also rude telling one of the modders that he/she "is delayed regarding mapping" and another one that some points brought by him/her "can't be regarded as a mod".
uhh can someone come and unqualify my map, got some really good suggestions I want to apply
p/5170568
p/5170568
Irrational difficulty name
01:20:381 (1) - wrong snap
Accidentally 2 osbs on the mapset
p/5174068
I can't speak chinese but I get that maybe is a problem with the timing points?
Kawawa
Incorrect metadata
p/5213864#p5213864
2ms unsnap on a sliderend
2ms unsnap on a sliderend
p/5223704 as requested by the creator himself http://puu.sh/ppR8e/b78dc3750d.png
EDIT: disqualified by blocko
EDIT: disqualified by blocko
Inconsistent LN's end snap on diff EXH and GRV ...
Need a response ASAP because the map is going to the ranked section at this point...
p/5228269/ huge gap from the normal to hard.
p/5231328
Lack of rest moments and use of high bpm 1/2 notes in Kantan; Misplaced pattern in Stein's Futsuu.
Lack of rest moments and use of high bpm 1/2 notes in Kantan; Misplaced pattern in Stein's Futsuu.
p/5247405
I have no idea what this answer to someone being legit concerned is supposed to be or supposed to say, I asked a few similar questions before and got answers like
"why not?"
"it's rest time lol"
"this is funny ikr"
and the likes, idk how this answers any of the questions asked or anything at all. If someone would mind doublechecking this and deciding where it's supposed to stay, that would be cool ("TEMPORARY QUALIFIED" on the description seems like he's expecting someone to take it down)
I have no idea what this answer to someone being legit concerned is supposed to be or supposed to say, I asked a few similar questions before and got answers like
"why not?"
"it's rest time lol"
"this is funny ikr"
and the likes, idk how this answers any of the questions asked or anything at all. If someone would mind doublechecking this and deciding where it's supposed to stay, that would be cool ("TEMPORARY QUALIFIED" on the description seems like he's expecting someone to take it down)
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/418097
popping a dq really quick for meta fixes and a quick hitsound volume fix (as well as an unsnapped note)
popping a dq really quick for meta fixes and a quick hitsound volume fix (as well as an unsnapped note)
Edit: (It's the same map as above) Oops, sorry for double, I opened the "reply" before Xexxar's post was here and noticed it appeared here after posting.
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/355573
There are still things to address and already many things were mentioned. That is, not mapping to music properly (overmapping and undermapping), most likely insensible background choice, but that's not big reason here, very repetetive and insensible patterning when it comes to kiai part, hitsounds are just meme sounds, which aren't even related to the song.
The answers given by Fort are either "fun" or "it's not overmapped, look at hitsounds" - By adding hitsounds, you are not getting a rid off the fact that you are mapping nothing. He mostly doesn't give any constructive arguments and doesn't explain why those issues aren't issues.
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/355573
There are still things to address and already many things were mentioned. That is, not mapping to music properly (overmapping and undermapping), most likely insensible background choice, but that's not big reason here, very repetetive and insensible patterning when it comes to kiai part, hitsounds are just meme sounds, which aren't even related to the song.
The answers given by Fort are either "fun" or "it's not overmapped, look at hitsounds" - By adding hitsounds, you are not getting a rid off the fact that you are mapping nothing. He mostly doesn't give any constructive arguments and doesn't explain why those issues aren't issues.
I've raised some issues in the CTB diffs that I feel should be addressed before ranked, including inconsistencies, flowbreaks, and other distance issues across the two ctb difficulties.
p/5258192
p/5258192
p/5263203
A couple of offscreen objects, and some possibly questionable rhythm/readability issues. The map was qualified as I was modding normally so I'd prefer if someone else could take a look at it before anything happens.
A couple of offscreen objects, and some possibly questionable rhythm/readability issues. The map was qualified as I was modding normally so I'd prefer if someone else could take a look at it before anything happens.
Edit: Ignore this, my bad
p/5276489
Not directly objetive-unrankable issues but the difficulty could get some improvement regarding playability
Not directly objetive-unrankable issues but the difficulty could get some improvement regarding playability
p/5281088#p5281088
The SB thingy I think needs to be fixed, just wanted to give my two cents about the rest.
The SB thingy I think needs to be fixed, just wanted to give my two cents about the rest.
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/452965
04:31:922 (2) - I don't think it's allowed to use absolutely silent samples. True, there are whistles on each tap but still afaik this isn't right.
04:53:865 (1) - You are not allowed to mute both sliderslide and sliderticks.
04:31:922 (2) - I don't think it's allowed to use absolutely silent samples. True, there are whistles on each tap but still afaik this isn't right.
04:53:865 (1) - You are not allowed to mute both sliderslide and sliderticks.
Priti wrote:
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/452965
04:31:922 (2) - I don't think it's allowed to use absolutely silent samples. True, there are whistles on each tap but still afaik this isn't right. It is actually possible because it makes sense in that part.
04:53:865 (1) - You are not allowed to mute both sliderslide and sliderticks. I didn't know there was such a rule like that but that can be really understandable since there's only one sound like that in the song → 04:53:865 - . It was either that or a spinner. DQ'ing a map for that reason would be nuts to be honest
my apologizes
A rule is still a rule. Both sliderslide and sliderticks cannot be muted at the same time.Secretpipe wrote:
Priti wrote:
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/452965
04:31:922 (2) - I don't think it's allowed to use absolutely silent samples. True, there are whistles on each tap but still afaik this isn't right. It is actually possible because it makes sense in that part.
04:53:865 (1) - You are not allowed to mute both sliderslide and sliderticks. I didn't know there was such a rule like that but that can be really understandable since there's only one sound like that in the song → 04:53:865 - . It was either that or a spinner. DQ'ing a map for that reason would be nuts to be honest
@priti, @Secretpipe, next time please post your concerns on the beatmap thread and discuss there, make sure only reports go here. Here isn't the place for you to discuss the map.
will clean the thread soon.
will clean the thread soon.
Ignore this post, my bad.
Requesting a dq on a map that should have been rebubbled due to some major pattern reworks in the highest diff, I've addressed the uncomfortable nature of the patterns in a small post here: p/5291322
The map is otherwise clean, and I have no other thoughts on it. Just, I feel like the map should have been rebubbled like I pointed out.
The map is otherwise clean, and I have no other thoughts on it. Just, I feel like the map should have been rebubbled like I pointed out.
p/5242755
mmmm I'm not sure how the QAT will handle this situation, since the mapping contribution from the set owner is less than the one from guest. There was some discussion in t/468358&start=0 and seems mostly everyone disagree, so I'm curious if mapping less is allowed now, since there was a case were a map got DQ because of this already, so I guess the same should apply to this map.
mmmm I'm not sure how the QAT will handle this situation, since the mapping contribution from the set owner is less than the one from guest. There was some discussion in t/468358&start=0 and seems mostly everyone disagree, so I'm curious if mapping less is allowed now, since there was a case were a map got DQ because of this already, so I guess the same should apply to this map.
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/245160
just saying, the genre should be Video Games, this song is the op of the game, and not be included in the TV anime.
just saying, the genre should be Video Games, this song is the op of the game, and not be included in the TV anime.
That's not a reason for disqualify, a QAT can change it via web.
Posting on behalf of Volta.
p/5313476
Inappropriate base slider velocity in Oni and suspect nsfw background.
p/5313476
Inappropriate base slider velocity in Oni and suspect nsfw background.
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/458993
except the im'otome diff, all diffs are mapped without combo colors.
which against the rule: Each map must use at least two different combo colors.
except the im'otome diff, all diffs are mapped without combo colors.
which against the rule: Each map must use at least two different combo colors.
^ That just means the mapper decided to use default colors. I don't think its possible to use less than 2 combo colors unless you use the same color more than once. The rule is there so you can't have 8 combo colors that are all the same xD.
^
my comprehension of that rule is that you have to set at least two combo colors, then these colors have to be different.
maybe there should be some misunderstanding but imo combo color have to be setted
i hate those do not set combo colors, i think they even dont care about their maps.
well, let's wait for qat's decision and reply.
my comprehension of that rule is that you have to set at least two combo colors, then these colors have to be different.
maybe there should be some misunderstanding but imo combo color have to be setted
i hate those do not set combo colors, i think they even dont care about their maps.
well, let's wait for qat's decision and reply.
MBomb
Multiple cases of HDash overusage in overdoses and rain, as well as a HDash against the wall in Koli's Overdose, as well as slider tick rate being lower on hardest difficulty for no apparent reason.
p/5323118#p5323118
p/5323118#p5323118
(maybe) some points in the map could be polished
because creator is busy now (not even online for 3 days), that's why we help him reply to the mapFeerum wrote:
https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/p/5320031
Mania.
After 3-4 Days still no reply of the Beatmap Creator.
I think there some Ghost Notes mapped. It would be cool when a QAT could check this.
A little concern on the sb, also any second opinion would great p/5328957/