1. Easy (1,38 stars, 91 notes)
2. Hard (2,86 stars, 226 notes)
3. Insane (3,89 stars, 275 notes)
4. Normal (1,87 stars, 145 notes)

liangv587 wrote:

hello, from your m4m queue

[General]

1. hitsound not unsed: normal-hticlap51.wav Oh wow, how did that ended up here.

[Easy]

1. 00:00:807 (1,1) - it's too short for the Easy, delete spinner I deleted two circles in the beginning instead.
2. 01:23:782 (2,1) - spacing

[Normal]

1. fine

[Hard]

1. ar8 is too fast for the Hard. ar7 would be better AR 7.4 instead.
2. 00:07:263 (5) - before and after the equal spacing http://puu.sh/eA7uR.jpg The jump is intended.
3. or just make 00:07:263 (5) - curved I like it straight more. Might think about this.
4. 01:07:073 (1) - a little dangerous, probably ovlerp the scoreboard I'm sure this is just a guideline to follow, should be fine.
5. 01:26:440 (3) - overlap But it's a neat one :3

[Insane]

1. 00:02:991 - spinner ends here I even think it ends at 00:03:038 - first, but it makes more sense to me to leave it at the red tick just for a more regular rhythm. This might be critical, I'm gonna ask a BAT later about it.
2. 00:56:060 (5) - move to 88,136? Was my first intention, but the jump isn't justified by the music for me, so i spaced normally.
3. 00:58:529 (2,3) - stack
4. 01:01:756 (1,2,3,4) - how about five-pointed star http://puu.sh/eA5pl.jpg I like to have the highest jump between 3-4, so no change.
5. 01:18:086 (2) - ctrl+g to get better flow I like the sharp flow-break here. But I'm gonna see what other people say about this.

good map. good luck

Pho wrote:

I really want to have exactly this picture as the BG, but the only one I found was at http://www.deviantart.com/morelikethis/466108239 , which has a somewhat low resolution.

bg

handsome wrote:

yolo m4m

General

1. those tags lol, slain is spelt 'slaine' jeez :^) Dammit.
2. check audioleadin thingy, idk if spinners are counted as leadin tho lol Gonna add 1500 I guess.
3. asdf i dont understand some of your NCs

Insane

1. 00:03:086 - unnecessary greenline Spinner wrong snapped, sry.
2. 00:10:681 (1) - skipped the white tick in the middle, just pointing it out. i would use a reverse if i were you. Switched with slider + circle.
3. 00:21:124 (4,1) - consider doing something about the spacing for this, it is too close imo. keeping 00:21:124 (4) - at 1.6DS without moving 1 is fine. I tried.
4. 00:51:883 (1,2,3,4) - suddenly unnecessary jump with nothing in music, imo I increased the DS for the incoming vocal. I will hear what other people think about this.

Hard

1. you probably want to do something about your NCs, they seem quite inconsistent. parts like 00:47:136 (5) - 00:56:440 - 01:08:592 (5) - could use a NC. while you can remove 01:01:756 (1) - . either that or i don't quite understand your NCs lol. I seem to have forgotten to set some orz. Fixed all.
2. 00:26:820 (3) - strongly disagree with close to half SV change in a relatively easy hard. Let me hear another opinion about it, it should be still handable, but I'm willing to change if it's really bothersome.
3. 01:14:858 (4,5,6,7,8,9) - this was quite uncomfortable to play, i suggest possibly changing the rhythm here a bit to be less dense, like 5 to a 1/2 slider. also you can NC 01:14:858 (4) - Ah but I like the growing tension here with the 1/1 beat taps, as it makes for a good transition to the next combo imo. Gonna keep for now, I don't think NC is necessary here either..

Normal

1. 00:39:351 (1) - u sure u wanna skip dat beat in the middle, circle+slider works I was unsure about this either lol. I think I'll put it back in.
2. 01:16:187 (1,2) - weird rhythm due to a 2, it started on something not as audible as surrounding beats, maybe http://i.imgur.com/RddwckP.png Neat. Occasionally fixed it on some other sliders where i had the same issue.

Easy

1. 00:00:807 (1) - just delete this spinner, it makes your beginning rhythm hard to follow since it starts on some random beat that was there due to that spinner recovery time nonsense I solved the issue from previous mod already by deleting the two circles following.
2. 00:24:541 (1) - dunno what to feel about this, cuz i heard before that repeats more than once aren't allowed in easier diffs I think it's good to have variation here, and it's long enough so that even new players see that it repeats twice. It's not unrankable.
3. 00:15:427 - to 00:24:541 - everything here, in my opinion, is slightly harder than everything after here up to chorus. its probably due to the rhythm density, consider simplifying with reference to 00:27:579 - 01:02:326 - . for example, 00:18:465 (4) - can be extended to a 1/1 slider :-) Good point! I'll change it.

no other glaring errors, very nice mapset, i remember when you were still paseli

Pho wrote:

@Ringating: orz... Sorry for the inconvenience lol.

Fatfan Kolek wrote:

[Easy]

1. Check mal den AiMod, da gibts 4 Issues mit dem Spacing! http://puu.sh/eAIbN/73b54135c5.png Bei zwei Anmerkungen spinnt es wieder rum, Rest ist gefix'd (und noch ein paar andere Stellen).
2. 00:39:731 (1,2) - Ich find den Flow ein bisschen komisch hier. Ich würde an deiner Stelle den Tail von (1) mehr auf (2) navigieren, damit es die Newbies leichter haben. Es wirkt recht forced find ich. Hmm, okay.
3. 01:07:073 (1,2) - Mmh, (2) sieht im Verhältnis hart zu aimen aus an dieser Position. Ich würde es auf 01:05:554 - placen, damit es leichter wird. Wenn du dies fixst, musste natürlich auch 01:09:351 (3) - neu placen. Ich glaube das sollte auch für neue Spieler händelbar sein, soweit sind die Objekte auch nicht voneinander entfernt.

[Normal]

1. 00:04:605 - Ich find den Beat hier so stark, dass du da eine Note placen solltest. Fühlt sich zu leer und für mich verwirrend an momentan. Hab mal den Rhythmus hier etwas umgeändert.
2. 01:02:136 (4) - Der Winkel scheint mir ein bisschen zu spitz von (3) und (4). 45° oder ein leicht gecurvter Slider fühlt sich für mich besser an. http://puu.sh/eAJAf/dba4224c7c.jpg Ich mag ihn so wie es ist :> Ändere es vielleicht um, wenn es nochmal jemand erwähnt.
3. 01:26:440 (3,4) - Ich mag das Pattern, just saying. xD :>

[Hard]

• Hier würde ich den Spinner wie in der Insane Difficulty an 00:03:086 - enden lassen und die erste Note dann auf den weißen Tick setzen. Es wirkt einfach ein bisschen overextendet, finde ich. :O Das würd ich auch gerne mache, aber nach der neuesten Spinner-Leniency Regel muss bei Hard diffs zwischen Spinner und nächsten objekt mindestens 1/1 beat abstand gehalten werden =.= Doofe Regel, aber muss mich dran halten.

1. 00:14:288 (2) - Den Overlap kannste bestimmt verbessern. http://puu.sh/eAK9h/aa76525867.jpg Uhh, okay
2. 01:27:959 (5) - Um die beiden letzten Noten besser zu betonen, würde ich einfach 2 gespacete Circles placen. Slider ist in Ordnung, die Note auf dem der Slider ended hat ziemlich schwache Präsenz, da braucht es keinen starken klickbaren Beat hier.

[Insane]

1. 00:26:060 (4) - Sieht ziemlich weit gespaced aus, wenn du mich fragst. Symmetry jump <3 Ich warte mal, was andere dazu sagen, ich lass es erstmal, so wie es ist.
2. 01:27:959 (5) - ^ Siehe Hard ^

Ziemlich kurzer Mod, hoffe es hilft dir aber trotzdem! ;w;

Regraz wrote:

Hi! There is Regraz's mod!
There is a few points of my mod:

1. Thank you for requesting a mod from me! Mod is just a kind of suggestion, so feel free if you dont want to make change.
2. I am still learning modding skills so I am sorry if I cannot provide much help.
3. Same issues won’t be repeated unless they are in a GD.

General

1. OK

Easy

• 
  Rhythm:

1. 00:30:238 Add a note here to follow the vocal?
2. 00:32:896 (4) – 1/1 slider for the same reason above? Set a circle in here instead.
   Structure:
3. OK, solid.
   Hitsounds
4. 00:21:503 (2) – Add whistle to the slider end.
5. 01:16:946 (2,3) – Add clap to the end of slider 2 instead of 3? The clap is for the drum in the track, which lies on 3.
6. 01:27:959 (5) –Add clap to the end? Same as other diffs. The note has too weak presence in the music for me, so no addition here.
   Others:
7. Maybe AR 3.5 is better, for a linear rise-up between each diff. Would be yeah, but AR 3.5 feels a bit too fast for a pretty beginner-friendly easy for me. Keep it.

Normal

• 
  Rhythm:

1. OK
   Structure:
2. 01:01:756 (3,4) – The flow is not that nice in Normal, yea. I’d suggest this: http://puu.sh/eCGqj/88138702ae.jpg for there won’t be a large angle between 3 and 4.
   Hitsounds
3. 01:20:554 (3) –whistle on head. No need to, there isn't a kick in the track at this point.
4. 01:11:630 (2) – Clap instead of whistle on head. There's no drum clap in the music at this part.
   Others:

Hard

• 
  Rhythm:

1. 00:09:921 (2,3) – Try this? http://puu.sh/eCH5h/c9ca7836a1.jpg http://puu.sh/eCH77/b1a49972a9.jpg I'd rather keep the current rhythm. This is a relatively easy hard, and I don't want to have such a high note density at this section.
   Structure:
2. 00:36:503 (4) – Guess it is better to make DS the same.
3. 00:52:263 (1,2) –Ctrl+G them. For it’s better to make the DS between 00:51:503 (4,1) – larger, to indicate this is a 1/1 rhythm. Same here: 00:55:301 (2,3) – Rearranged a bit here, the flow wasn't that well anyway.
4. 00:58:529 (2) – If it is intended to make such DS, make the same points in this part DS consistent.
5. 01:05:934 (2) – Here the DS is quite different from 01:06:693 (4,5) - , consider making them consistent. Ah, this is intended as the music in the latter is more intense.
   Hitsounds
6. OK
   Others:
7. OK

Insane

• 
  Rhythm:

1. OK
   Structure:
2. 00:49:415 (4) – Better to lower the DS. Such large DS now indicates it’s a 1/1 space instead of 1/2. I'm sure at this level of gameplay, people can sightread that this is 1/2 tap.
   Hitsounds
3. 01:27:579 (1,2,3,4) – Add Claps, just like 01:15:617 (5,6,7,8,9) - It is yeah, but I don't like spamming in here for the sole fact that it's not that representative in the track for me like 01:15:617 (5,6,7,8,9,10) -
   Others:
4. Nice diff! No custom diff name? No need to, I wish this to be more like a traditional mapset

Good Luck! :3

Yauxo wrote:

Hi there, coming from your request in our/my Modding Queue. Be so kind to take some minutes (or seconds, lets be honest) to answer to my mods. Dont be a dick and just "lol didnt changed stuffs hurr durr" without an explanation. If I told you something that was against your map, tell me why. This way mapper and modder both gain something.

Unrankable
Suggestion
Rather important change
Not so important change/small note or opinion

(copy paste end)

Heya o/ Hatte gestern noch privates zu tun, sorry D: Jo, kein Ding lol

[General]
■ OD 5.5 on Hard and OD 7.5ish on Insane should be enough. I dont think that you'll need OD8 on a 4 star Insane

[Insane]
■ 00:04:984 (2) - While Iam (in general) not a fan of stacks, I think that 2 sounds more stack-y with 00:04:794 (1) - as opposed to 00:05:174 (3) - Ahh, i feel more comfortable with the current stack since i like how it plays this way.
■ 00:05:744 (5) - Something like this maybe? 5 would catch 4's movement better and the flow into 1 would be improved as well I think the current shape of 5 catches the motion from 4 pretty fine as well and i like the 'edgy' flow to the next combo for a better emphasis. I feel that keeping the flow going at this point is kind of plain to play.

■ 00:13:529 (5) - same as the first one Same argumentation.
■ 00:22:832 (6,1) - I think this should be unstacked. While the other ones made ... well, some sense, this one doesnt. 00:22:643 (5,6) - is pretty much the same beat as 6-7 and they arent stacked. (In general, unstacked would be more fun to play)
Actually, you seem to use this alot, so I'll count it as pattern. Yup, I like to have stops at these points. :3
■ 00:29:478 (2) - 216/244 for better spacing? 3 currently has 1.33 into 1.56, where 2 has a greater spacing to the Slider before it. A constant 1.5 wouldnt hurt I think
■ 00:32:896 (3,4,5) - I think this would be pretty cool (and it'd improve the flow imo)

■ 00:36:313 (5,1) - I think it'd be cool if they act like 00:42:389 (4,1) - and similar I like the spacing here as it is.
■ 00:52:073 (2,3,4,5) - I kinda disagree with this pattern, but I guess Iam actually too nazi about it. So, what buggs me here is that they act like extended singletaps and not jumps. They have a clear (straight/slightly curved) path with no real jumpyness (zigzag, back and forth, starpattern etc), which makes it really difficult to play as you cant really snap these. To add to that, the music doesnt really ... well, "speed up" or climax out of the basic rhythm so that they'd fit or make sense (to me). I think it'd be better if you made these more zigzaggish or, in general, more jumpy so that the player can snap these.
(If ^ is kinda unclear, pm me ingame) I see people got issues with this pattern, but I believe it works well for the tension it brings for the vocal. If pointed out again in the future again, I guess I'll rework this section a bit.
■ 01:05:364 (5) - 40/156? Don't like the jump between 5-1. so I keep the current pattern.
■ 01:06:503 (3) - <- you might want to adjust that to ~1.5 DS if you did ^ (for consistency and kiai reasons (strong music, suddenly 1.0 DS into high DS again)) I don't like having higher spacing here, having a jump between 01:05:554 (1,2) - already created high enough tension.
■ 01:21:124 (2,3,4) - flows rather weird imo, but neither can I suggest a fix Should be fine... I guess. Let me see if I can find a better solution here.

[Hard]
■ 00:00:807 (1) - Why does this Spinner end so late? It supports the ... windup (? D:) sound and should end when the windup ends, not when the first beat hits. Can't really fix this, although i'd really want to :c The problem is with the new spinner leniency rule that hard diffs must have at least 1/1 beat distance between the end of the spinner and the next upcoming object. For Insane it was doable as there's no limit to this rule, but the time frame between Spinner end and next object is just 1/2 beat.
■ 00:15:427 (1,2,3,4,5) - There is one problem I could see here. As the first three stacked Circles are 1/1, the player might misread the second stack (which is 1/2) as a 1/1 as well. Oh, you might be right. I think it's actually readable and the 1/2 backslider might infer that this is a 1/2 tap as well, but I'll wait for other people's opinion on this.
■ 00:57:769 (3) - 256/163? I think the spacing to the next object should be prioritized as opposed to the pattern with the (not visible at this time) Slider before. I need to stop doing stupid spacing changes lol.
■ 01:03:275 (2) - I'd NC these (They are also NCd in Normal)
■ 01:25:111 (4) - 56/100 for consistent spacing reasons

[Normal]
■ 00:00:806 (1) - See Hard That'd clearly miss out the strong beat at where the spinner currently ends. No change.
■ 00:39:351 (1) - replace with two Circles so that the downbeat/strong beat is clickable? Sliderends are always so ... "meh" :v I know what you mean, but circletapping 1/1 all the way feels awkward to me and the slider actually follows vocal pretty well.

Looks good

[General]
■ 00:00:806 (1) - blah. I think it'd probably be better if you just removed this and mapped the part from the first beat after that on. That break feels really weird and .. well, empty. QQ I will keep it for consistenc with the other maps in this set.

Looks good aswell

Meow :3

LixRei wrote:

Hi there. Modding from my queue.

[Overview]

1. Those tags... lol. If you really want to relase your rage against Slaine, you should put that on the creator's words, not in the tags. LOL At least, this rage-relasing is better than xxdeathx's one. lol I feel like i got to delete them soon anyway ;-; But I'll wait for a BAT to decide on that.

[Insane]

1. 00:04:794 (1) - This one should be more centered between 00:04:225 (4,5,6) - . Try to use the approach circle as guide to center it.
2. 00:11:630 (4,5,6,7) - This is pretty much nazi stuff, but I think those would actually play better if shaped like a square. I like to have variation in here, since i do these triangle/square stuff pretty often already.
3. 00:26:630 - I think the SV change here actually comes as quite sudden. Yeah, I know previous SV is like 0.75x, but I think changing SV here just for the vocal doesn't fit it that well. You should keep SV constant here. Length of vocal is the main reason I disagree with the SV change (more info in the thing below). Oh, but this SV change is not done for the vocal, but the e-guitar in the background. It makes for a pretty interesting momentum imo, so I'll keep it.
4. 00:26:820 (3,4) - End of (3) is kinda off-beat, and judging by (4)'s position on the timeline, I think you're actually using it as a "extended" slider, through it doesn't work quite well since end of vocal is actually on 00:27:389 - . My suggestion here is to simply extend (3) to 00:27:200 and erase (4). That way, when you readd the finish hitsound, it will do the work fo giving the "finishing" impact (or something like that) just like Hard does. It's a difference between actually hitting a beat and or just following it with sliderend (just like in Hard). I want more emphasis on this note by playing it for the sole fact that there's a strong cymbal there. The extended slider actually works fine imo since there's also a beat in the track at 00:27:105 - .
5. 00:33:275 (5) - This slider should actually end on 00:33:465 - . Extending slider like this makes this part sound really weird, since end is off-beat. You should only extend sliders like this when there isn't a beat that should be mapped before (a 1/2 beat). If a sound in the red beat exists, you should map it to keep a nice rhythm. This one actually goes pretty well with the e-guitar in the background. And considering there's no noteworthy beat on the previous red tick (there's sound, yeah, but not a reason for me to put a note in there), i'd rather keep my current pattern.
6. 00:34:035 (2) - You shouldn't skip the beat at 00:34:225 - . Reason's practically the same as above. So are my reasons. Keep.
7. 00:36:313 (5) - This circle should be fully centered between 00:35:174 (2,3,4) - to create proper blankets in every slider (and for aesthetics), but maybe I'm just too nitpicky about it.
8. 00:37:832 (1) - You should make the downbeat a clickeable element (you said so once ). Also, you're skipping the beat on 00:38:022 - . I know here you're extending slider to follow vocal, but it's just a bit too ankward to play. Did I? xD Yeah, probably, but I like to lower the pressure again after the previous sliderjump-section here, so extending it to follow the vocal better is fine - I don't really see a problem gameplay-wise. Also, 00:38:022 - has no noteworthy beat - if you mean the e-guitar, it plays 1/2 regularly, but it's less dominant than other elements in the track for me that I'd follow it that much.
9. 00:42:389 (4,3) - Same as above (downbeat thingy). Since there isn't any 1/2 beat to follow, you can just place two circles to replace it. It's a bit less ankward to play that way. Circles feel too choppy to play. Considering this section is rather calm and i want smoother flow and play in general, sliders are a better choice and they follow the vocal really well.
10. 00:45:048 (2,1) - If you intended a blanket here, you should recheck it. Seems a bit off in my end. I don't think it's really notable to fix, they are too far away on the timeline to notice in gameplay anyway.
11. 00:57:959 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2) - This is pretty~ Symmetry figures best <3
12. 01:12:769 (5) - Just a friendly comment for you to be careful with this circle since it's almost outside the grid. No change needed now, through. Repositioned.
13. That's it for this diff. It's quite fun to play, actually. Good job!

[Hard]

1. 00:09:921 (2,3,1) - #naziblanketmod. This seems a bit off. It looks fine to me oO
2. 00:11:630 (3,1) - Most likely a needless worry of mine, but overlap here isn't that pretty. You could move (1) a bit above to avoid it. It doesn't hinder gameplay that much and i don't want to do a big jump here, so it's fine.
3. 00:13:719 (1,2) - Those ones overlap a bit, too. Yeah, that's intended. Makes for interesting gameplay.
4. 00:15:807 (2,3,4,5) - You should check the blanket here; seems a bit off for me. If you move the sliders, remember to move the notes you're stacking, too. I'm not good with blankets lol.
5. 00:26:630 - Same as Insane. It's like you've wanted in Insane tho. oO
6. 00:29:668 (3,4) - Blanket seems sightly off (just a tiny bit). Fixed...uhh, kind of?
7. 00:41:250 (1) - Just saying this thing is almost touching the HP bar, so you should be careful with it. Should be fine, touching the HP bar is also just a guideline to follow, not unrankable.
8. 00:43:149 (4,1) - Those sliders overlap a bit (but judging by distance, it might not be that visible during gameplay, so maybe this is just minor). It's intended. I like this overlap :3
9. 00:43:908 (1) - Same as Insane (00:42:389 (4,3) - on Insane case). Same reason.
10. 00:47:896 - Playability is a bit weird if you don't map this beat (since a "beep"-ish sound is played here). It is, but it's not very remarkable in the track, so I left this out on purpose.
11. 00:51:503 (4) - Downbeat's at the end of this slider, but playing it isn't quite ankward (maybe because melody changed?). This one's fine, it follows the piano well.
12. 01:01:756 (1,2,3,1) - Shouldn't this be a perfect square? It's a bit ankward IMO if you start a square with constant DS, but you alter it at the end. Intended DS change, yep. 01:02:326 (1) - is a really strong beat, so i set emphasis by increasing spacing by just a little bit (just like in Insane)
13. 01:25:870 (2,3) - Those sliders overlap a bit... Yeah, that's intended as well.
14. Hm... rhythm on this diff is pretty good. Most of this mod is "nazi" stuff ( ), so apply it if you see fit.

[Normal]

1. 00:15:427 (1,2) - Practically "nazi" stuff, but I think those look good when blanketed (2's head with 1). It would hurt the flow too much though, so no change.
2. 00:18:465 (1,2) - This blanket is just a tiny bit off. How do you find this stuff xD
3. 00:45:427 (1,2,3) - You should recheck the blanket of those two (it's just a bit off).
4. 01:00:997 (1,2) - I think flow improves here a bit if you Ctrl + J those circles. If you do, remember to check spacing of 01:01:756 (3,4) - I like the flow here, so no change.
5. 01:20:554 (3,5) - I don't know if a blanket was intended, but you should check it. It really wasn't intended lol. But i don't want to make that slider more curvy, it hurts flow too much for me.
6. This diff plays and flows quite nicely. Great!

[Easy]

1. The only concern I have with this diff is with the usage of 1/2 notes (that are usually avoided on Easy since they seem to be too fast), so I'll try to check those. Change things if you see fit. 1/2 here are fine, I used them only between sliders so it's much more handable. No change from below
2. 00:10:681 (3) - I suggest moving this to 00:10:870 - and make it a 2/1 slider to avoid the 1/2 click here.
3. 00:13:719 (3) - You could move this to 00:13:908 - and make it a 1/1 slider...
4. 01:17:516 (3) - Maybe moving this to 01:17:706 - and making it a 1/1 slider works?
5. That is practically the mod for Easy. I personally think 1/2 notes should be avoided in Easy unless the BPM is actually low enough for them to work (and I don't think 158 BPM is low). Yeah, about that, I'm not even sure if it's 158 or 79 BPM, people still seem to be unsure about it.

Well, I think this is it. The mapset is actually quite great (and Aldnoah.Zero is good). Have a star! Aye, thanks a lot for the star and mod! I didn't fix much, but I hope my points are clear. No comment = fixed.
Good luck!

1. http://puu.sh/eHLE1/19d0383582.png lol, just fix spacing between 00:06:313 (1,2) -
2. 00:18:465 (4) - i think some like it looks better (is curved like 00:16:946 (2) - and do blanket with 00:19:984 (1) - )
   
   
3. 00:23:782 (5) - i think, curved is better fo consistency with 00:21:503 (2,3) -
4. 00:57:959 (1) - may be... it will look more consistent
   
   

1. 00:49:605 - missing note? like 00:50:743 (4) - (pls, for consistency).
2. 01:10:111 (1) - pls, make a bit more curved, like 01:11:630 (2) -
3. 01:11:630 (2,2) - pls!, improve the stack (disable grid snap)
   
4. 01:17:326 (2) - whistle??
5. 01:18:845 (5) - ^, in head?

1. mm... mm... really, the start was not intutive, imo...
   if you move spinner end to 00:02:896 - and make some like:
   
   (remove hitsounds to spinner) feels better
2. 00:11:630 (3,1) - ugly overlap :'(
3. 00:28:908 (4) - i think you move it a bit, looks better:
   
   
4. 00:37:263 (3) - why a stack??!, this broken the flow, i really think it is a bad idea...
5. 00:43:149 (4,1) - overlap :'(
6. 01:16:946 (3) - mm... idk xD, imo, curved will looks better
   
   

1. 00:20:744 (3) - two circles feels better with vocals.
2. 00:25:301 (3) - no ignore drums pls ._.
3. 00:27:200 (4) - mm.. overmap??, why xD
4. 01:15:617 (5,6,7,8,9,10) - orz... for me.. this stack is bored D:, the music is very intence here, with a stack this lost emotion ._. My suggestion is it:
   
   Pandoras Box(?)

   1. move 01:15:238 (3,4,5) - like (1.6x spacing):
      
   2. make a 1/2 slider:
      
   3. .. and make the magic:
      
   ... or something (?) hehehe
5. 01:20:364 (5,2) - stack is not perfect

ErunamoJAZZ wrote:

hi o/


[Easy]

1. http://puu.sh/eHLE1/19d0383582.png lol, just fix spacing between 00:06:313 (1,2) - How could I miss that?
2. 00:18:465 (4) - i think some like it looks better (is curved like 00:16:946 (2) - and do blanket with 00:19:984 (1) - ) I like the current motion more, keep for now.
   
   
3. 00:23:782 (5) - i think, curved is better fo consistency with 00:21:503 (2,3) - I don't think slider-shape consistency is needed here, the current one feels fine too.
4. 00:57:959 (1) - may be... it will look more consistent Like the flatter shape, it works so well with the vocal here
   
   

[Normal]

1. 00:49:605 - missing note? like 00:50:743 (4) - (pls, for consistency). Not needed, if you listen closer to the background instruments, this actually follows them pretty well.
2. 01:10:111 (1) - pls, make a bit more curved, like 01:11:630 (2) - But I like flat curved sliders too ;~;
3. 01:11:630 (2,2) - pls!, improve the stack (disable grid snap)
   
4. 01:17:326 (2) - whistle??
5. 01:18:845 (5) - ^, in head? It's the same as in every diff, no change.

[hard]

1. mm... mm... really, the start was not intutive, imo...
   if you move spinner end to 00:02:896 - and make some like: Oh, that's neat, I'll try it out.
   
   (remove hitsounds to spinner) feels better
2. 00:11:630 (3,1) - ugly overlap :'( Ugh, fine... increased the jump.
3. 00:28:908 (4) - i think you move it a bit, looks better:
   
   
4. 00:37:263 (3) - why a stack??!, this broken the flow, i really think it is a bad idea...
5. 00:43:149 (4,1) - overlap :'( Keep, I like this one. :3
6. 01:16:946 (3) - mm... idk xD, imo, curved will looks better Flow > aesthetics for me, i feel pretty fine withthe straight slider here
   
   

[Insane]

1. 00:20:744 (3) - two circles feels better with vocals. Feels not smooth enough to play imo.
2. 00:25:301 (3) - no ignore drums pls ._. Ikr, but it follows the vocal so well too. Let me hear another opinion about this.
3. 00:27:200 (4) - mm.. overmap??, why xD It's not overmap :c Listen closely to the music, there's also a beat on the blue tick.
4. 01:15:617 (5,6,7,8,9,10) - orz... for me.. this stack is bored D:, the music is very intence here, with a stack this lost emotion ._. My suggestion is it:
   
   Pandoras Box(?)

   1. move 01:15:238 (3,4,5) - like (1.6x spacing):
      
   2. make a 1/2 slider:
      
   3. .. and make the magic:
      
   ... or something (?) hehehe I really like to keep it clean here (as it is for the whole map). It's the only stream session in the song, and spacing it kind of works against the style i'm going for in this map. No change.
5. 01:20:364 (5,2) - stack is not perfect

Good song and mapset

Good luck

Xelasto wrote:

From my modding queue!

Easy

00:38:212 (2,3,1) - Improve triangle
00:41:250 (2,3,1) - ^
00:53:402 (3,1) - Same shape But they are oO
01:07:073 (1,2) - Blanket Not intended, and it'd break up from the windmill pattern.

I don't know if parts like 00:13:149 (2,3) are good for beginners, IDK. But anyway, nice job on this

Normal

00:05:554 (4) - Try and make this a repeat slider but still amount to the same length I don't see a reason for this to happen.
00:15:427 (1) - Improve blanket Not supposed to be one.
00:24:541 (1) - Ctrl H this to copy 3 I don't really know what you want me to do here, but doing this would kill the spacing.
00:28:339 (2,3,4) - This may be too confusing for beginners It's a normal diff, players should be able to comprehend it at this level.
00:31:377 (2,3,4) - ^ ^
00:39:351 (1) - Try and make it so 00:39:731 is the beginning of a note or slider, as it is a strong beat. Will think about this, but the slider follows vocal pretty well too.
01:16:187 (1) - Try and make this curve more to improve 3's blanket.
01:23:592 (4,5) - Try and improve blankets It looks fine as it is already.
01:25:870 (2,3,4) - IMO this doesn't look good nor flow well, but that might just be me. People like it :c It's fine, really.
Approach rate 5 Like current AR more to handle these 1/2 taps better.

Pretty good difficulty. Not much wrong here.

Hard

00:03:655 (2,3) - Blanket? Not intended.
00:11:250 (2) - Put this more inbetween 3 and 1 https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/2604135 Idk, but I like the current pattern more.
00:12:769 (1,2) - Please don't touch, really noticeable.That's intended.
00:16:187 (3) - Improve blanket
00:20:744 (6,7) - Make same slider Curved 7 instead.
00:28:339 (3) - Move middle point up by 1
00:43:149 (4,1) - Don't touch Again, intended.
00:57:959 (1,3) - Make same slider Why, the current pattern works fine too.
01:01:756 (1) - No New combo I think this is fine, wait for other people commenting on it.
01:07:073 (1) - Improve blanket
01:14:858 (1,2,3,4,5) - Improve this star formation Looks fine to me.
01:14:288 (3,6) - and at the same time stack these There's no need to stack at this point.
Approach rate 7 Like the current AR more.

Great difficulty. Just a few slight problems that don't look good. Also, a lot of the combos seem to short for hard mode.

Insane

00:05:554 (4) - This dip doesn't flow well I feel it's fine here.
00:10:111 (5,6) - Reverse the position on the timeline to flow better and mirror 1,2, and 3.
00:16:946 (2,3,4,5) - Make the same shape. Can't see a reason for that to happen, as the current pattern is fine already.
00:24:921 (2) - Center this more in the middle of 3
00:34:794 (1) - Make this sort of like 3, except upside down like this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/2603665
00:35:174 (5,6,7) - Make all the same slider (Copy and paste) They are actually. I just rotated them by 120/240°.
00:37:832 (1) - No new combo This one's fine.
00:39:351 (6) - Instead make this a copy of 5, then Ctrl H, G, then place it the left of 5 Again, it's only a bit rotated, still the same.
00:43:149 (1) - No new combo Needed to make the play more intuitively here.
00:48:845 (3) - New combo here instead of 1 NC'd here to make the jump more intuitively.
00:57:959 (1,3) - Same shape. I don't really know how you came up with the shape issues, but this one's perfectly symmetrical to the y-axis. >.<
01:01:756 (1) - No NC Needed for big jumps.
01:26:440 (1) - ^ But it fits well to the pattern :c.

Good job on this difficulty. It flows well, etc. Looks a little messy though. A few short combos

Good job on this map. It flows well and the hitsounds are beautiful. Some of the combos could be improved, and the map doesn't feel as clean as it could be in all difficulties though. (especially insane.) However, these aren't small problems and could be easily fixed. Keep mapping. I hope this gets ranked.

Easy and Normal look fine.

Hard

SPOILER

00:21:503(1) Overlap? Could snap it onto the 5 circle or move it somewhere else
00:49:415(2,3) Switch for a better sound beat?
01:02:326(1) I wouldn't have a NC there
01:04:605(2) Overlap
01:08:022(3)^
01:08:782(1,2) Switch the slider and circle for readability since the slider is on a red tick in a more clicky section
01:12:389(3,4) ^
01:27:877(5) Maybe align slider with the 4th back and forth slider

Insane

SPOILER

00:07:643(1,2) Align the slider end with the beginning of 2nd circle for polish
00:08:212(2) Place around x:352 y:342 to prevent overlap
00:25:372(3) Messed up slider from slider speed changes I guess. It also doesn't look well blanketed
00:27:200(4) Bit hard to read, or give it more emphasis, doesn't feel like the beat is there
00:54:179(3) Curve it the over way and blanket it with that 5th circle. Also makes a nice pair with the 4th slider
01:15:617(5,6,7,8,9) Make it into a moving stream for difficulty
01:16:946(3,4,5) Put another circle pattern in there, the square feels like it breaks flow and overlaps with 01:17:516(1)

Outside of the mapset
lmao

Zoom in on that pic. Add a space between 'isa'. Whatever

lol

Mikii wrote:

Hey from #modreq

Easy and Normal look fine.

Hard

SPOILER

00:21:503(1) Overlap? Could snap it onto the 5 circle or move it somewhere else Would break up the spacing. THis should be fine, both objects are far away in the timeline.
00:49:415(2,3) Switch for a better sound beat? It follows the instruments well in the background.
01:02:326(1) I wouldn't have a NC there It's there for the spacing change.
01:04:605(2) Overlap This should be fine. Will think about it.
01:08:022(3)^^
01:08:782(1,2) Switch the slider and circle for readability since the slider is on a red tick in a more clicky section It's there as there is a strong beat to follow at the red tick.
01:12:389(3,4) ^ Oh, I forgot I wanted to change this, thanks!
01:27:877(5) Maybe align slider with the 4th back and forth slider I like it more this way.

Insane

SPOILER

00:07:643(1,2) Align the slider end with the beginning of 2nd circle for polish This should flow well already.
00:08:212(2) Place around x:352 y:342 to prevent overlap The previous circle faded away in time already, so it's fine.
00:25:372(3) Messed up slider from slider speed changes I guess. It also doesn't look well blanketed I don't really see a problem here. oO
00:27:200(4) Bit hard to read, or give it more emphasis, doesn't feel like the beat is there It is there, just delete and listen closer.
00:54:179(3) Curve it the over way and blanket it with that 5th circle. Also makes a nice pair with the 4th slider Hmm, guess I can try this out.
01:15:617(5,6,7,8,9) Make it into a moving stream for difficulty Not needed, I feel comfortably with this stacked stream.
01:16:946(3,4,5) Put another circle pattern in there, the square feels like it breaks flow and overlaps with 01:17:516(1) I rearranged a slider only.

Outside of the mapset
lmao

Zoom in on that pic. Add a space between 'isa'. Whatever Not needed :3

lol hue

Good luck!

Mikii wrote:

No kudosu???
But yeah most of what I said was just personal preferences and nitpicks. The map is good enough as it is. I'm still learning so kudosu or not, at least you got some use out of the mod.

I guess I should read that it was a BAT req before I started

Mao wrote:

Everyone tries the speedrank *runs*

jonathanlfj wrote:

woot woot

[General]
offset needs about -8ms
also better fix the title xD

[Easy]
00:09:351 (1) - maybe a finish on the start here (applies to all diffs)
00:45:427 (3) - missing a NC here i think
01:08:782 - since there is a clap here, consider swapping 01:08:592 (2) for a 1/2 slider I prefer it the way it is currently, 1/2 slider here feels a bit strange to me.
01:23:782 (2) - there is actually no clap on the end here, similar to 01:18:845 (5)

[Normal]
00:16:187 (2) - use a repeat slider here like 00:19:225 (2) would fit better imo
00:34:415 (2) - same thing here, since there is a vocal you can follow at 00:34:605
01:03:845 - another sound that can be covered for build up, try making 01:03:655 (2) a 1/2 slider
01:18:465 (4) - this note flows a bit weird, I would have done something like this:

SPOILER

[Hard]
00:00:806 (1) - i would decrease the volume more at the end for the fade effect to be stronger
00:57:769 (3) - i was thinking maybe you could center this note to carry forward the symmetry from 00:56:440 (1,2)
01:01:756 (1) - i dont really find this NC necessary, since it belongs to the same musical section and pattern as 01:00:997 (1,2). I seem to have set the NC unconsciously here orz
01:02:326 (1) - this is fine since it contains a spacing change and a transition of the music
01:09:351 (4,5) - i can't really tell what these short kick sliders are following in the music, you are better off using some sort of jump pattern here to make the emphasis
01:22:168 (5) - this would be an insane-style gimmick, do not recommend overmaps like this on a hard diff
01:25:301 (1,2,3) - oh god my OCD, please fix the blanket spacing with 01:25:301 (1,3) lol allright

[Insane]
00:00:807 (1) - same as Hard, maybe a lower volume for the spinner end
00:25:301 (3) - there is a pretty significant beat at 00:25:491, i would try not to skip it Thought nobody would notice it, allright~
01:01:946 (2) - maybe you could center this note to preserve the symmetry a bit
01:20:364 (5,1) - this sudden direction change is a little hard to play, you could try ctrl+g on 01:19:984 (3,4) to make a zig-zag flow out of this I don't really want to jump here since I'm already jumping in the next combo. I moved the slider a bit to the left to redeem this.

thats about all, let me know after you are done

HabiHolic wrote:

yo pho!

i will check your map!

trammiexo wrote:

Hi from my modding queue! bạn có khỏe không? :> Bạn khỏe :>

"Whoa vietnamese modder/mapper, that's a rare sight. I need to learn vietnamese again...."
Lol ikr.. I never met a Vietnamese player on osu personally... maybe from some multiroom but definitely do not know them personally. But here's a viet mapper right here xD

Easy

00:13:711 (2,3,4) - Flow feels a bit weird. At 00:12:381 (1,2) these are parallel to each other then combo 3 comes and --- to me it seem visually wrong. I know DS is also a pain to deal with too (when you move one, must move other to have consistent ds) but I'd move combo 3 to the left in a way, and then adjust the follow objects' DS. you dont have to agree with my opinion though, just my thought I might fix the flow at that section a bit when the next BN is coming for a recheck. Your solution is not really viable since it causes inconsistent spacing in the combo which really want to avoid in general in easy diffs.

Normal:

00:13:141 (2) - You can make this stack with 00:11:622 (5,6) just turn of DS, adjust, then adjust 00:13:711 (3) to maintain consistent DS Stack is not what I really intended to do here since I do that 1/2 slider spacing consistently at the beginning. Keep
01:02:128 (4) - I think pointing the slider outward would look more appealing I like the sharp angle for emphasis :p

sry if its not as much help but, im still learning in modding and mapping ;w; best of luck though, its a nice map set ;DD No prob, you got a point tho. Thanks for mod anyway

DakeDekaane wrote:

Didn't see people were already crowding on this map *cries*

1. 00:03:267 - Whistle is redundant with no kick, just placing clap is enough. Same goes for 00:04:597 (6) - 00:10:103 - 00:10:673 - 00:11:242 - 00:11:622 (4) - 00:20:736 - 01:00:230 - 01:03:267 - 01:06:685 (4) - 01:11:242 (4) - You need to be fair to all snares, please.
2. 00:06:875 - Missing whistle. Same for 00:08:774 - 00:11:052 (2) - 00:11:432 - 00:11:812 (5) - 00:14:090 - 00:14:470 - 00:27:192 - 01:09:913 (6) - 01:16:179 - 01:17:888 - 01:27:856 (4) - You also need to be fair to all kicks, please.
3. 00:12:002 (6) - You can remove whistle here.
4. 00:13:141 - Missing clap.
5. 00:45:040 (2) - CTRL+G makes the flow more comfortable.
6. 00:46:938 (5,1) - Also a CTRL+G for vocal on 00:46:938 - and kick on 00:47:318 - , since you didn't put any hitsounds on 00:47:128 - which makes it hollow even the music has a tiny synthesizer sound.
7. 00:51:495 - Default soft whistle. Same applies on 00:51:495 - & 00:54:913 - .
8. 00:51:495 (5,1,2) - The usage of distance snapping here is really poor, even most people have listened to this song so many times, not everyone who listen to this song for the first time can clearly read the gap in between.
9. 00:57:761 (3) - Delete this for the sake of distance snap, the music doesn't provide potentials for such a big jump to be honest. 00:57:951 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3) - are different because of solid vocals.
10. 01:10:008 (7) - Overmapping doesn't fit with the whole diff.
11. 01:11:622 - This should be a clap instead.
12. 01:12:381 (4) - Swap the hitsound, kick is on slider tail instead of head.
13. 01:15:040 - Remove the whistle and put it on 01:15:230 - where kick is found.
14. 01:15:609 - Lower the volume a bit on streams please, it's too much like a machine gun shooting now.
15. 01:19:217 - Why not finish? Whistle is of too low pitch.
16. 01:27:666 (2,3) - Claps missing.
    Copied hitsounds again to other diffs

1. 00:00:799 - Redundant green line.
2. 00:43:141 (4,1) - This placement can be polished by ignoring distance snap: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/2765657
3. 00:46:938 (4,1) - Your mapping style is to alter the spacing suddenly sometimes with no grounds on the music which makes it really untidy from my point of view. 00:48:078 (3,4,1) - Also this is really confusing, it can be a 1/1 halt if I am just looking at the spacing. And these: 00:53:014 (4,1,2) - 01:04:976 (3,4,1) - 01:18:837 (5,1) - 01:20:356 (4) - Maybe recessive jumps look more tidier and neat.
4. 00:50:736 (1,4) - Intentional no-blanket?
5. 01:18:078 (2) - This flow is quite uncomfortable, I suggest doing something like this: http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/2765699
6. 01:25:293 (1,2,3) - Avoid the unaesthetic overlapping: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/2765711

1. AR5 is fine enough for such BPM, 5.5 is too exaggerated.
2. 00:49:597 - Add a circle here for the sake of avoiding polarity and the kick.
3. 01:04:027 (1) - May curve it facing another orientation: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/2765745

IamKwaN wrote:

I love maps with no GDs :3
Pop for now, I hope you don't mind as you have so many BN-deep darkfriends above who are glad to help qualify. Uhm okay. I don't know how they pop up in this thread either
[I]

1. 00:03:267 - Whistle is redundant with no kick, just placing clap is enough. Same goes for 00:04:597 (6) - 00:10:103 - 00:10:673 - 00:11:242 - 00:11:622 (4) - 00:20:736 - 01:00:230 - 01:03:267 - 01:06:685 (4) - 01:11:242 (4) - You need to be fair to all snares, please. #BlameMyEars
2. 00:06:875 - Missing whistle. Same for 00:08:774 - 00:11:052 (2) - 00:11:432 - 00:11:812 (5) - 00:14:090 - 00:14:470 - 00:27:192 - 01:09:913 (6) - 01:16:179 - 01:17:888 - 01:27:856 (4) - You also need to be fair to all kicks, please. #BlameMyEars
3. 00:12:002 (6) - You can remove whistle here.
4. 00:13:141 - Missing clap.
5. 00:45:040 (2) - CTRL+G makes the flow more comfortable.
6. 00:46:938 (5,1) - Also a CTRL+G for vocal on 00:46:938 - and kick on 00:47:318 - , since you didn't put any hitsounds on 00:47:128 - which makes it hollow even the music has a tiny synthesizer sound.
7. 00:51:495 - Default soft whistle. Same applies on 00:51:495 - & 00:54:913 - . I'd rather leave these out, I don't think the piano notes need more emphasis.
8. 00:51:495 (5,1,2) - The usage of distance snapping here is really poor, even most people have listened to this song so many times, not everyone who listen to this song for the first time can clearly read the gap in between. Lowered.
9. 00:57:761 (3) - Delete this for the sake of distance snap, the music doesn't provide potentials for such a big jump to be honest. 00:57:951 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3) - are different because of solid vocals. Kept that note as it is pretty dominant in the track. Lowered the spacing though.
10. 01:10:008 (7) - Overmapping doesn't fit with the whole diff.
11. 01:11:622 - This should be a clap instead.
12. 01:12:381 (4) - Swap the hitsound, kick is on slider tail instead of head.
13. 01:15:040 - Remove the whistle and put it on 01:15:230 - where kick is found.
14. 01:15:609 - Lower the volume a bit on streams please, it's too much like a machine gun shooting now.
15. 01:19:217 - Why not finish? Whistle is of too low pitch.Finish feels over the top here, there isn't a cymbal here either and the snare isn't really strong either.
16. 01:27:666 (2,3) - Claps missing.
    Copied hitsounds again to other diffs

[H]

1. 00:00:799 - Redundant green line.
2. 00:43:141 (4,1) - This placement can be polished by ignoring distance snap: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/2765657 Why evryone hates this orz.
3. 00:46:938 (4,1) - Your mapping style is to alter the spacing suddenly sometimes with no grounds on the music which makes it really untidy from my point of view. Equally spaced now. Yeah, I got that quirk to sometimes space strangely in hard maps, not sure where that comes from.
   00:48:078 (3,4,1) - Also this is really confusing, it can be a 1/1 halt if I am just looking at the spacing. I liked the halt at this point though.
   And these: 00:53:014 (4,1,2) - 01:04:976 (3,4,1) - 01:18:837 (5,1) - 01:20:356 (4) - Maybe recessive jumps look more tidier and neat. I do that sometimes in the map already, at the sections you pointed out I don't think it is necessary.
4. 00:50:736 (1,4) - Intentional no-blanket? yes
5. 01:18:078 (2) - This flow is quite uncomfortable, I suggest doing something like this: http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/2765699
6. 01:25:293 (1,2,3) - Avoid the unaesthetic overlapping: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/2765711 I don't feel this looks so bad. :/

[N]

1. AR5 is fine enough for such BPM, 5.5 is too exaggerated.
2. 00:49:597 - Add a circle here for the sake of avoiding polarity and the kick.
3. 01:04:027 (1) - May curve it facing another orientation: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/2765745 Like the current pattern more though.

1. 00:18:457 (4,1) - change NC batter.
2. 01:23:394 - clap
3. 01:23:774 - whistle
4. 01:24:913 - clap

1. 01:20:546 (1) - Ctrl+G is flow batter

HabiHolic wrote:

ok~

[Easy]

1. 00:18:457 (4,1) - change NC batter.
2. 01:23:394 - clap
3. 01:23:774 - whistle
4. 01:24:913 - clap

[Insane]

1. 01:20:546 (1) - Ctrl+G is flow batter

nice map and hitsound~

call me back

Mao wrote:

Herzlichen Glückwunsch!