Guest
home
beatmaps
rankings
community
store
help
forum
  1. Forums
  2. Other
  3. Off-Topic

Moral Dilemmas: The Baby Problem

posted
Total Posts
45

Kill your baby?

Yes
17
80.95%
No
4
19.05%
Total votes: 21
Polling ended
Stomiks
9,038 posts
Joined March 2021
Topic Starter
Stomiks
Setting

November 10, 1943. It's been 2 years since you and your family's initial capture by the nazi officers who sent you to the Auschwitz Concentration Camp. Since then, you have been painfully making a plan to escape the camp, where allied forces are waiting for you. At night, you and your family went through the hole that you made leading to the main gate exit of the camp. The gate is locked and the only way for to open is for a vehicle to leave the premises.

Question

Thinking quickly, you and your family hopped inside the back of an empty van leaving Auschwitz and waited for incoming nazi officers to drive through the gate exit, until your baby starts crying. The nazi officers who are coming to drive the van out would definitely hear it. You try to shut the crying, but to no avail. If you can manage to stop the crying baby, you and your family would be free from the pain and suffering inside the horrific concentration camp. If not however, you and your family are to be caught by the nazi officers, and sent back to the camp, likely waiting for painful deaths. Now... the only way to stop your baby's crying is...

Would you be willing to kill your baby in order to save the rest of your family?
Polyspora
475 posts
Joined September 2019
Polyspora
I didnt read it, but it cant go wrong when you're talking about killing babies
WitherMite
1,610 posts
Joined August 2019
WitherMite
Thing is I'm pretty sure that auschwitz separated families and "disposed" of those who couldnt work so this wouldnt have happened. plus what's on the other end of this drive? Probably more nazis, so even if you got out they'd probably find you at the next stop.

to answer the question though, I don't think I could kill a baby, let alone my kid.
Last edited by WitherMite , edited 1 time in total.
B0ii
586 posts
Joined November 2021
B0ii
My Explanation
The thing is, by killing the baby, you're only killing one person.
The easiest way to do so is chocking them since they can't really defend themselves.

By letting the baby cry, you're just allowing more people (including yourself) to be killed (Assuming that both parents are present, and there is at least 1 other sibling). And chances are that you and your family member's deaths will be more painful.

Help I might of overthank this situation

also if the FBI is watching, this is a friendly reminder that this is just a hypothetical situation, on a random forum, of a random game
Last edited by B0ii , edited 1 time in total.
z0z
521 posts
Joined February 2018
z0z
Jonarwhal
1,227 posts
Joined November 2013
Jonarwhal
what the fuck
Stomiks
9,038 posts
Joined March 2021
Topic Starter
Stomiks

WitherMite wrote:

Thing is I'm pretty sure that auschwitz separated families and "disposed" of those who couldnt work so this wouldnt have happened. plus what's on the other end of this drive? Probably more nazis, so even if you got out they'd probably find you at the next stop.
Shh... Let's just imagine that this is an alternate world where it fits the story's narrative...
Patatitta
1,380 posts
Joined February 2020
Patatitta
ok these moral dilemmas are getting pretty ridiculous
Last edited by Patatitta , edited 1 time in total.
Manishh
2,095 posts
Joined October 2020
Manishh
Too long didn't read
Killing baby? Yes



Read it now.
Yes
Last edited by Manishh , edited 1 time in total.
Karmine
1,033 posts
Joined November 2015
Karmine

Polyspora wrote:

I didnt read it, but it cant go wrong when you're talking about killing babies

Manishh wrote:

Too long didn't read
Killing baby? Yes



Read it now.
Yes
Yeah
[[[[[[
908 posts
Joined August 2019
[[[[[[
literally saw a short play(?) that's super similar to this a few years ago except it's a bunch of vietnamese soldiers hiding from american soldiers, the female vietnamese soldier basically choke her baby to dead to make it stop crying
Cerno
169 posts
Joined November 2019
Cerno
Use the baby as a weapon. The nazis are dead, baby’s dead too. Two birds one stone
igorsprite
623 posts
Joined September 2015
igorsprite
i don't know, i have never been in such a situation
haha i rolypoly
367 posts
Joined January 2020
haha i rolypoly
I mean you can always just create another baby
Ymir
1,941 posts
Joined June 2020
Ymir
I didn't read the post I just voted to kill the baby
HoosierTransfer
279 posts
Joined October 2021
HoosierTransfer

-Remi wrote:

I didn't read the post I just voted to kill the baby
same
Stomiks
9,038 posts
Joined March 2021
Topic Starter
Stomiks
Christ guys. It's a baby.

But looking at the past moral dilemmas... OT really seems to hate children.
igorsprite
623 posts
Joined September 2015
igorsprite

Stomiks wrote:

Christ guys. It's a baby.

But looking at the past moral dilemmas... OT really seems to hate children.
but i like children :(
ClevelandsMyBro
883 posts
Joined April 2018
ClevelandsMyBro
Listen, if my kid starts crying whilst in the middle of a stealth mission then it's a stupid baby anyway.
[[[[[[
908 posts
Joined August 2019
[[[[[[

igorsprite wrote:

Stomiks wrote:

Christ guys. It's a baby.

But looking at the past moral dilemmas... OT really seems to hate children.
but i like children :(
L
Karmine
1,033 posts
Joined November 2015
Karmine

dPeace wrote:

igorsprite wrote:

Stomiks wrote:

Christ guys. It's a baby.

But looking at the past moral dilemmas... OT really seems to hate children.
but i like children :(
L
abraker
Global Moderator
8,356 posts
Joined July 2014
abraker
maternal instincts say the mother would rather die with the baby
DeletedUser_13957006
DeletedUser_13957006

Karmine wrote:

dPeace wrote:

igorsprite wrote:

Stomiks wrote:

Christ guys. It's a baby.

But looking at the past moral dilemmas... OT really seems to hate children.
but i like children :(
L
Manishh
2,095 posts
Joined October 2020
Manishh

aiq wrote:

Karmine wrote:

dPeace wrote:

igorsprite wrote:

Stomiks wrote:

Christ guys. It's a baby.

But looking at the past moral dilemmas... OT really seems to hate children.
but i like children :(
L


Think about it

First the both husband and wife will have terrible life there and the child also will have terrible life in the camp. So killing it will be the best option
Polyspora
475 posts
Joined September 2019
Polyspora

abraker wrote:

maternal instincts say the mother would rather die with the baby
I think that is one of the instincts we're leaving behind as we progress in evolution lol
TGGD
607 posts
Joined November 2021
TGGD
I voted no
igorsprite
623 posts
Joined September 2015
igorsprite

Manishh wrote:

aiq wrote:

Karmine wrote:

dPeace wrote:

igorsprite wrote:

Stomiks wrote:

Christ guys. It's a baby.

But looking at the past moral dilemmas... OT really seems to hate children.
but i like children :(
L


Think about it

First the both husband and wife will have terrible life there and the child also will have terrible life in the camp. So killing it will be the best option
i didn't say that was a bad idea. i don't even care about moral dilemmas
Manishh
2,095 posts
Joined October 2020
Manishh

Polyspora wrote:

abraker wrote:

maternal instincts say the mother would rather die with the baby
I think that is one of the instincts we're leaving behind as we progress in evolution lol
Last edited by Manishh , edited 1 time in total.
Karmine
1,033 posts
Joined November 2015
Karmine
How to handle the baby
Patatitta
1,380 posts
Joined February 2020
Patatitta

Stomiks wrote:

Christ guys. It's a baby.

But looking at the past moral dilemmas... OT really seems to hate children.
weird considering we're on osu
Scyla
71 posts
Joined February 2022
Scyla
If I become the Eminence in Shadow, I get magic including resurrection
Polyspora
475 posts
Joined September 2019
Polyspora

Patatitta wrote:

Stomiks wrote:

Christ guys. It's a baby.

But looking at the past moral dilemmas... OT really seems to hate children.
weird considering we're on osu
lol
z0z
521 posts
Joined February 2018
z0z

Manishh wrote:

Polyspora wrote:

abraker wrote:

maternal instincts say the mother would rather die with the baby
I think that is one of the instincts we're leaving behind as we progress in evolution lol
Corne2Plum3
Global Moderator
1,873 posts
Joined November 2019
Corne2Plum3

Manishh wrote:

Polyspora wrote:

abraker wrote:

maternal instincts say the mother would rather die with the baby
I think that is one of the instincts we're leaving behind as we progress in evolution lol
united
Stomiks
9,038 posts
Joined March 2021
Topic Starter
Stomiks
Almost forgot to update with the result.

Result

You put your hands on your baby's throat, gripping tightly, never letting go until the crying stops and no more breathing is felt. You killed your baby. To the family's horror, the act that they just witnessed is truly deplorable. But they understand. Such a situation will always put you under pressure, and you did it for them after all. They might never forgive you, but they are grateful for essentially saving their lives.

The nazi officers hop on the driver's seat and start the engine, leaving the place that you abhor and hopefully, will never go back to. During the ride, the van gets attacked and taken over by allied forces. They save you and the remaining people of your family. You're free from the grasps of the nazis, but the murder of your own child won't excuse you from the law.

You have been charged with infanticide and sentenced to 20 years in a US prison. During this time, your family has not visited you once. They cut off all their ties with you. Your crime has been spreading far throughout the prison. The prisoners treat you awfully. They assault you, verbally abuse you, and torture you. You have no safe zone from the misery. This is the same experience as that camp. Nothing changed at all. Maybe it would've been better if you had never escaped in the first place...
Kaaruumii
860 posts
Joined November 2021
Kaaruumii

Stomiks wrote:

Almost forgot to update with the result.

Result


You have been charged with infanticide and sentenced to 20 years in a US prison.
Worth it
Karmine
1,033 posts
Joined November 2015
Karmine
Moral of the story, never help others.
Thanks for the advice!
z0z
521 posts
Joined February 2018
z0z
sounds like a lose-lose situation based on the results
Karmine
1,033 posts
Joined November 2015
Karmine

z0z wrote:

sounds like a lose-lose situation based on the results
Yeah
Stomiks
9,038 posts
Joined March 2021
Topic Starter
Stomiks

z0z wrote:

sounds like a lose-lose situation based on the results
Who knows? Maybe you could've survived concentration camp oooooooooo

Also, I plan to have no more kids appearing in these moral dilemmas in the future since you guys just love to make children suffer.
z0z
521 posts
Joined February 2018
z0z

Stomiks wrote:

Who knows? Maybe you could've survived concentration camp oooooooooo

Also, I plan to have no more kids appearing in these moral dilemmas in the future since you guys just love to make children suffer.
we can only make decisions based on the information given and information that can be found

based on the date given, i would guess that the chance of survival would be very low
Last edited by z0z , edited 2 times in total.
keremaru
228 posts
Joined November 2017
keremaru

Stomiks wrote:

z0z wrote:

sounds like a lose-lose situation based on the results
Who knows? Maybe you could've survived concentration camp oooooooooo
Nah. Most likely, we would've been worked to death, frozen to death during the winter season, killed trying to escape, killed for conspiring with others to escape, or been sent to the chambers to make space for more healthy prisoners. Only in a very tight scenario of luck and circumstance would we be able to survive, let alone the rest of our family. In that regard, I don't think the baby would survive either way.

Next episode of Stomiks' Sinister Circumstances:
A college student versus a pregnant woman! Who would you run over?
Hopefully not.
Last edited by keremaru , edited 1 time in total.
Stomiks
9,038 posts
Joined March 2021
Topic Starter
Stomiks

keremaru wrote:

Stomiks wrote:

z0z wrote:

sounds like a lose-lose situation based on the results
Who knows? Maybe you could've survived concentration camp oooooooooo
Next episode of Stomiks' Sinister Circumstances:
A college student versus a pregnant woman! Who would you run over?
Hopefully not.
Great idea.
abraker
Global Moderator
8,356 posts
Joined July 2014
abraker
Bad Ending #3
MangaGrumpy
374 posts
Joined May 2022
MangaGrumpy
Pol Pot?
Please sign in to reply.

New reply

0
1 / 45