This is not in any way, shape or form sexual.
I just like keyboards very much and looking at my own keyboards isn't enough for me anymore.
My rating criteria would be based on:
- The overall aesthetic of the board. This includes, but is not limited to: The shape, material, keycaps, the cable and the layout of the keyboard.- Build quality. It's gonna be hard to judge a board's build quality through just photos alone, so additional info regarding your keyboard such as how it is constructed, the materials and features that you think would benefit this category would help me rank it more accurately.
- The switches. Again, it's gonna be hard to tell from photos so additional info is much appreciated.
- Typing sounds. Though this requires a typing demonstration so I'm gonna need a video of you typing on your board to judge it properly.
- Additional special features. Basically extra features that might be useful in a keyboard. This includes but is not limited to: Macros, media keys, displays etc. Although anti features that are masked as an extra feature would affect the rating negatively instead.
- Pricing. Some keyboards might be pretty decent, but have a low ranking. That is because pricing is also a criteria I'd like to judge. If a keyboard isn't great, but is very cheap then I won't judge it too harsh. But if a keyboard is very expensive, but doesn't really seem to be worth it, then I'll be harsher while judging it.
I'd like to judge on key feel as well, however obviously I cannot come and feel your keyboard switches so I will only base this judgement on the switches I've tried only.
For the ones that I haven't felt before, I'll refrain from passing judgement on them.
I try to be as fair and accurate as possible with my ratings. However, the criterias in which I use to rate them are very subjective. So at the end of the day, it's just my opinion and yours maybe different than mine regarding the matter and a keyboard which I thought is shit might be to you, a very good keyboard. So don't be too bummed out if your keyboard, which you think is an excellent keyboard, gets a low rating. What matters is that you like it and it's very much up to taste.
Also, I don't rate touchscreen and laptop keyboards since they're almost all the same and I don't know enough about them nor am I interested enough in them to find out about them and give out ratings for them.
But generally, I think most of them are shit.
Rankings
1. abraker, Penguin's 4th keyboard, kaffeine's white keyboard, Farfocele: 8/10
2. Penguin's 5th keyboard, gamer13254, Penguin's 6th keyboard, Lapizote's 2nd keyboard: 7/10
3. tyhjyys, Asian Warlord, ShinRun, Penguin's 6th keyboard, kaffeine's black keyboard: 6.7/10
4. Penguin's 2nd board: 6.5/10
5. Penguin, Dial: 6.3/10
6. Taikah, Suwumi, Nameless, Lapizote, -Flaky-, Vaniels: 6/10
7. zOz, _ralsei, abraker's 2nd board, abraker's 3rd board, Penguin's 3rd keyboard, NeigDoig, fat pear: 5.5/10
8. nedd83, Meguro's 2nd board, Ashton, Bambinex, moneusing, AccountWontWork's keyboard, Kaarumii's keyboard: 5/10
9. Hydreigon, Meguro, KatouMegumi, NoobDev, WinnyAce, eblf2013, Hydreigon's 2nd board, abraker's 4th board, ghoulybits: 3/10
10. axl2468: 2.8/10
11. Nikolai: 2.5/10
12. abraker's 5th keyboard: 2/10
13. pentaqola: 1.8/10