forum

[ELECTIONS RESULTS!!!!!] OT!Elections 2025

posted
Total Posts
394
show more
Polyspora
I mean we as abraker and all the past presidents and parliaments who maintained the OFFICIAL hall and did not enforce their own bootleg version of it

Tell me, how many of your voters are active now in OT to see the shit you guys came up with?
Karmine

Polyspora wrote:

I mean we as abraker and all the past presidents and parliaments who maintained the OFFICIAL hall and did not enforce their own bootleg version of it

Tell me, how many of your voters are active now in OT to see the shit you guys came up with?
Bait used to be believable.
chromb
give it to me, I won't do anything 👍
Asian Warlord

chromb wrote:

give it to me, I won't do anything 👍
Karmine

chromb wrote:

give it to me, I won't do anything 👍
Nvm I support GMT participating now.
z0z
came back to see scyla and igorsprite throw their hats into the ring

they're probably not winning
igorsprite

z0z wrote:

came back to see scyla and igorsprite throw their hats into the ring

they're probably not winning
i think we both should join forces
Puck_

igorsprite wrote:

z0z wrote:

came back to see scyla and igorsprite throw their hats into the ring

they're probably not winning
i think we both should join forces
Polyspora

Puck_ wrote:

igorsprite wrote:

z0z wrote:

came back to see scyla and igorsprite throw their hats into the ring

they're probably not winning
i think we both should join forces
Corne2Plum3

Polyspora wrote:

Puck_ wrote:

igorsprite wrote:

z0z wrote:

came back to see scyla and igorsprite throw their hats into the ring

they're probably not winning
i think we both should join forces
z0z

igorsprite wrote:

z0z wrote:

came back to see scyla and igorsprite throw their hats into the ring

they're probably not winning
i think we both should join forces
you and scyla? i think that would make you and scyla even more of a toxic waste barrel
sametdze
fuck it bros im running for president
sametdze
actually i dont even want president i just want to answer the questions with minimal effort
Karmine
Yo sametdze for president, he won't do shit.
Scyla

z0z wrote:

igorsprite wrote:

z0z wrote:

came back to see scyla and igorsprite throw their hats into the ring

they're probably not winning
i think we both should join forces
you and scyla? i think that would make you and scyla even more of a toxic waste barrel
we'd be nuclear
sametdze

Karmine wrote:

Yo sametdze for president, he won't do shit.
ok i am now running for president again because of this post, thank you for your motivation carmen sandeago
Karmine

sametdze wrote:

Karmine wrote:

Yo sametdze for president, he won't do shit.
ok i am now running for president again because of this post, thank you for your motivation carmen sandeago
a
sametdze
pata can i run for president mann why am i not a confirmed thingy
Tad Fibonacci
A GMT being president is the most pointless thing ever lmfao
Karmine

Tad Fibonacci wrote:

A GMT being president is the most pointless thing ever lmfao
He gets it.
Topic Starter
Patatitta

sametdze wrote:

actually i dont even want president i just want to answer the questions with minimal effort
you're allowed to answer the questions even if you're not a presidential candidate


sametdze wrote:

pata can i run for president mann why am i not a confirmed thingy
I was sleeping, you can run for president, but do you want to?, like you just said you didn't so i'm confused
sametdze

Patatitta wrote:

sametdze wrote:

actually i dont even want president i just want to answer the questions with minimal effort
you're allowed to answer the questions even if you're not a presidential candidate


sametdze wrote:

pata can i run for president mann why am i not a confirmed thingy
I was sleeping, you can run for president, but do you want to?, like you just said you didn't so i'm confused
yes i want to run for president, im not confident i'd win but it's fun to participate in these threads so yeah
Topic Starter
Patatitta
okay added
Asian Warlord

Patatitta wrote:

okay added
yo you forgot about me im in the ot!era but you just forgot to put me in
Polyspora
uuuuh is it here where I say it? I dont wanna run anymore, this is not what I imagined it would be, and even if all of this will be forgotten midterm, I just feel queasy participating.
Topic Starter
Patatitta

Polyspora wrote:

uuuuh is it here where I say it? I dont wanna run anymore, this is not what I imagined it would be, and even if all of this will be forgotten midterm, I just feel queasy participating.
rip, accepted
ShinRun
Just realized that there are little to no new users participating in this election, everyone here is like 3 years+ at this point
Ymir
Scyla, Igor, Samet or Acroba getting presidency is nail-in-the-coffin for OT, billions must leave.
DeletedUser_32597938

Ymir wrote:

Scyla, Igor, Samet or Acroba getting presidency is nail-in-the-coffin for OT, billions must leave.
Damn
Karmine

Ymir wrote:

Scyla, Igor, Samet or Acroba getting presidency is nail-in-the-coffin for OT, billions must leave.
Acroba and sametdze probably wouldn't do anything, wouldn't be as bad as whatever the other 2 would do.
igorsprite
only patatitta is running for president 😭
Ashton
Damn
Wimpy Cursed
hi

let me run so I do absolutely nothing
Topic Starter
Patatitta

Wimpy Cursed wrote:

hi

let me run so I do absolutely nothing
sure
Achromalia
+ pata v poly, and a mixture of gmt moderation woes and mild-but-significant cults of personality centered on current-day internal off-topic politics! threads stirring with awkwardly serious telanovela antagonism between major modern political figures, and their distinct opposing philosophies of governance...

+ a history of gradual institutional reforms to balance the scales of power between moderators and governed denizens while qualifying denizenship further and preserving/updating off-topic customs...

+ a mostly disorganized culture of ambivalent users with variably contrasting niches of interest, perhaps bound together only by collective boredom and entertainment shared with specific acquaintanceships and friendships...

+ roleplay seems to be stuffed in with the antiques, appreciated in the memories and dreams of some but comfortably obsolete to many. i doubt these denizens and dwellers would force the issue at this point

+ third-way candidates soon arise on a whim or by pointed opposition, some are just bored, maybe particularly by presidency or government as institutions in themselves, and run partly to halfheartedly make a point

+ times have changed, denizens and dwellers have changed, politics have changed. so, may the willing live well in the present :)

i intend to run for president!

i don't intend on getting too deep into the weeds for any reason other my own curiosity and interest and i don't intend to force roleplay or government politics into much of any public all-encompassing user-facing service/practice beyond what is largely customary for the people who value it (presidency, denizenship, archived libraries), and while i do believe there is a role to be had in serving as more of an event host for whatever y'all think would be fun, it will probably be more of an optional free sample of things to do or participate in with each other in a social space while you each make your own threads about your interests and your awful awful kinks x')

but for those worried about moderation and user behavior, i also don't intend to be oblivious to extremes in interpersonal abuse or moral bankruptcy or in exercises of power, nor do i intend to allow the neglect of general user experience. for a variety of reasons exemplified through our messy communal history, there ought to be some form of self-preservation in anticipation of distinct threats to the health of our community's users and activities

to this end, i would be responsive to more specific negotiation with moderator teams to root out what the hell went wrong and whether it's more personal or interpersonal rather than systemic, in order to keep these tensions out of the way of any users who may be exhausted by this. if y'like to spectate user or government or moderator drama, there may be correspondence-based events of varied regularity which could be supervised by myself and/or a rotating balance of notable community members depending on the need and circumstance. these would be hosted for the express purpose of hashing out conflict in specific matters, whether in governance or in interpersonal conflicts that involved parties may informally consent to publicizing

rough ideas, really, but i imagine the sentiment of "serve a mixture of spaces/events according to a balance of general community interests and faction-based interests" has been illustrated by now. many suggestions i could make are not-so-much a kind of promise when the community is ever-changing and sometimes self-contradictory. but i largely seek to be some mixture of adaptively open-minded and generally concerned. i would work with whatever parliament i get but i am not interested in letting public decisions be made in a bubble

we are ultimately wandering a corner of a website populated by all sorts of fellow weirdo netizens that variably give any extent of care or concern from "all-in" to "fuck-all" (for some, quite literally), whether they prefer to be on their own or get cliquey, looking on at interesting threads and sating their boredom and curiosity. it would be nice to give them a little bit of something they want to eat

oh yes and im the "arts and culture" candidate in this because i like those things lol <3

i would rather like to avoid fucking up a place where a good variety of people dwell, whether they intend to leave or not. if they do, i hope whatever nearby future spent here would provide both parts peace and entertainment :)

...and if presidency and governance doesn't suit that end, then... we will see what becomes of it, i suppose. let go of what we don't need, right? i'd like to think that kind of thing would be up to you, since you all end up seeing it everywhere across your threads

i was the first president, and maybe i would be the last. but i'm getting ahead of myself. point to what you think you will enjoy or benefit from, pick it out, and have fun~
sametdze
ladies and gents we have our winner
Wimpy Cursed
due to recent events, I announce my resignation
igorsprite

sametdze wrote:

ladies and gents we have our winner
congrats patatitta 👏👏
sametdze
nobody is voting for ts potato we're all voting for the skeleton lady
Karmine
Everyone just coming in and out of the race, kinda crazy.

Now pata got a real challenger.
Corne2Plum3

Karmine wrote:

Everyone just coming in and out of the race, kinda crazy.

Now pata got a real challenger.
Cinema
igorsprite

sametdze wrote:

nobody is voting for ts potato we're all voting for the skeleton lady
you're wrong + insult + sexism
sametdze

igorsprite wrote:

sametdze wrote:

nobody is voting for ts potato we're all voting for the skeleton lady
you're wrong + insult + sexism
sybau
Wimpy Cursed

Karmine wrote:

Everyone just coming in and out of the race, kinda crazy.

Now pata got a real challenger.
yeah, pull out game is crazy
Ashton
I mean achro has this in the bag let's be honest.

Edut: wait, achro wahmen?
sametdze
achro, will you drop an end of term class party?
Karmine

Ashton wrote:

I mean achro has this in the bag let's be honest.

Edut: wait, achro wahmen?
I think achro keeps it ambiguous on purpose, which is funny imo.

Pata can still win, but it's not guaranteed anymore.
ShinRun

Karmine wrote:

Ashton wrote:

I mean achro has this in the bag let's be honest.

Edut: wait, achro wahmen?
I think achro keeps it ambiguous on purpose, which is funny imo.

Pata can still win, but it's not guaranteed anymore.
I personally think Pata have a higher chance of winning than Achro
Ymir
Absolute Cinema
DeletedUser_32597938
yeah, honestly, even then

i *want* chroma to be president tbh

history, presentation, she has it all
Ashton
I'll vote achromalia probably. They have the most level headed takes in OT most often
Behrauder

ShinRun wrote:

I personally think Pata have a higher chance of winning than Achro
ShinRun
Wait if achro is a female then wouldn’t ghouly most notable achievement which is being OT’s first female president be nullified?

Mf ghouly ain’t have nothing to her name 😭
Ymir
I forgot Ghouly even existed lol xd
Achromalia

sametdze wrote:

achro, will you drop an end of term class party?
literally i could do that and more while making all the festive decor x') and class is probably getting weekly opt-in choices for field trips and diversions as well as mix-and-match lectures for subjects of interest

Karmine wrote:

Ashton wrote:

Edut: wait, achro wahmen?
I think achro keeps it ambiguous on purpose, which is funny imo.
hey??? this is Serious Politics Business???

mm but youre kinda right though

ShinRun wrote:

Karmine wrote:

Ashton wrote:

I mean achro has this in the bag let's be honest.
Pata can still win, but it's not guaranteed anymore.
I personally think Pata have a higher chance of winning than Achro
im almost kinda surprised i had the effect i did... but i did suspect it while letting my intentions be known

im interested more in the awkward moment i'll definitely have immediately after this, because i think that will largely describe the interests of this community more and i am particularly invested in seeing the outcome of what i think that subject is and what its consequences will be

in the meantime im busy urgh but ill write more later
Asian Warlord

ShinRun wrote:

Karmine wrote:

Ashton wrote:

I mean achro has this in the bag let's be honest.

Edut: wait, achro wahmen?
I think achro keeps it ambiguous on purpose, which is funny imo.

Pata can still win, but it's not guaranteed anymore.
I personally think Pata have a higher chance of winning than Achro
Not unless I come in

z0z
looks like the field is being cleared
ShinRun
If Achro does win then there will be quite a shift since Achro seems to be leaning towards a more laissez faire system while Pata was a lot more hands on
Tad Fibonacci

ShinRun wrote:

If Achro does win then there will be quite a shift since Achro seems to be leaning towards a more laissez faire system while Pata was a lot more hands on
Democratic capitalism vs Nationalist Socialism
Ashton

Tad Fibonacci wrote:

ShinRun wrote:

If Achro does win then there will be quite a shift since Achro seems to be leaning towards a more laissez faire system while Pata was a lot more hands on
Democratic capitalism vs Nationalist Socialism
You two truly are the political theorists of all time
abraker
Achro is pretty much a sealed deal honestly
DeletedUser_32597938
It’s gonna be a fun couple of weeks ladies and gentlemen.
Ymir

IAMACROBA wrote:

It’s gonna be a fun couple of weeks ladies and gentlemen.
Most of the "fun" has already happened. I think I'm right in believing this to be the most eventful election.
Topic Starter
Patatitta
yeah no I lost gg everyone, I don't mind achromalia being president tho
Corne2Plum3

Patatitta wrote:

yeah no I lost gg everyone, I don't mind achromalia being president tho
You know what? same.
Achromalia
ah the questions sheet was finally updated, it seemed so empty at first x') in fairness, i really did not know whether i would have any interest in adding questions when i could ask them at literally any time as the need arises. anyway i like them a lot, i anticipate some more ^^

this reads to me like the sight of a murder of crows perching and scavenging at the corpses of carnage at a very convenient time, i had this belief that it would defuse tension by way of not being immediately relevant and not really forming significant grudges but,, it kind of already resolved itself?? which, while it was eventful, i think i appreciate the peace of easily enjoying the election event alongside other threads

...that being said, this probably could have been redirected without confusing and provoking nearly as many people, i don't know how many people enjoy it but i find it a bit useless/disappointing to have users angered in their isolated spaces and unable to enjoy anything here either by scrutiny/ridicule or their own frustration with other obstinate or contentious figures. perhaps it could be prevented and resolved entirely, if future paricipants in arguments want it. lessons learned, i trust
Corne2Plum3
I added quite a few questions.

For what I intent to do as president I'll still wait a couple of days, analysing how OT is going and find the best solutions.
ghoulybits

Ymir wrote:

I forgot Ghouly even existed lol xd
:(
DeletedUser_32597938
we answer the questions publicly in the next phase, no?
Topic Starter
Patatitta

IAMACROBA wrote:

we answer the questions publicly in the next phase, no?
yes
DeletedUser_32597938
and to be 100% clear

just because i personally want out next president to be achro, does not mean i rescind my candidacy.

i still fully intend to run i’m just being transparent with the community.
Karmine
Even candidates are gonna vote achro instead of themselves. :cry:
Topic Starter
Patatitta

IAMACROBA wrote:

and to be 100% clear

just because i personally want out next president to be achro, does not mean i rescind my candidacy.

i still fully intend to run i’m just being transparent with the community.
i'm not removing anyone unless they explicitely tell me to
z0z
if you did a poll now, there would be no contest
abraker

ghoulybits wrote:

Ymir wrote:

I forgot Ghouly even existed lol xd
:(
a ghost merely doing ghosty things 👻
ghoulybits

abraker wrote:

ghoulybits wrote:

Ymir wrote:

I forgot Ghouly even existed lol xd
:(
a ghost merely doing ghosty things 👻
Excuse you, I'm clearly a ghoul.
DeletedUser_32597938
you can’t even call yourself that

you’re just bits and pieces of one
Tad Fibonacci
Ghouly be like:

abraker

ghoulybits wrote:

abraker wrote:

ghoulybits wrote:

Ymir wrote:

I forgot Ghouly even existed lol xd
:(
a ghost merely doing ghosty things 👻
Excuse you, I'm clearly a ghoul.
That's not what I see in this historic photo circa 2021

keremaru

ghoulybits wrote:

abraker wrote:

ghoulybits wrote:

Ymir wrote:

I forgot Ghouly even existed lol xd
:(
a ghost merely doing ghosty things 👻
Excuse you, I'm clearly a ghoul.
she is...
the america ghoul
Reyalp51
lets all vote scyla it would be funny
Karmine

Reyalp51 wrote:

lets all vote scyla it would be funny
No.
- Marco -

Reyalp51 wrote:

lets all vote abraker it would be funny
aight
abraker

- Marco - wrote:

Reyalp51 wrote:

lets all vote abraker it would be funny
aight
Wait I don't remember becoming a candidate
Not that I'm complaining, but it would be odd
- Marco -

abraker wrote:

- Marco - wrote:

Reyalp51 wrote:

lets all vote abraker it would be funny
aight
Wait I don't remember becoming a candidate
Not that I'm complaining, but it would be odd
too late the deep state already decided
Achromalia

- Marco - wrote:

abraker wrote:

- Marco - wrote:

Reyalp51 wrote:

lets all vote abraker it would be funny
aight
Wait I don't remember becoming a candidate
Not that I'm complaining, but it would be odd
too late the deep state already decided
mad scientists never leave the lab they were born in <3
reffty_gag
aight, im running for president
reffty_gag
cuz im getting bored at OT, so participating would be fun
Topic Starter
Patatitta

reffty_gag wrote:

aight, im running for president
with only a few hours left to go, accepted
Achromalia
conveniently updated while re-reading whitelisted questions...
Topic Starter
Patatitta

Achromalia wrote:

conveniently updated while re-reading whitelisted questions...
the questions listed are NOT whitelisted, they're just ALL that were submited, the whitelisting process beings now, tho I will say only "how can i see without eye ope?" is going to be removed
Topic Starter
Patatitta
Phase 2 starting now, decided just to update this thread since I think it's going to be more clear, last year I did the same with parliament and I personally like this format.

Anyways, phase 2, every contestant must answer every single question, 6 questions will be asked daily, that rhythm may be incraesed depending on how many new questiosn are asked. The cutoff date for all questions will be friday. No new batch will be released on saturday, to give every contestant at least 24 hours to answer each questions. You don't need to have every questions answered at the end of each day, just have everything answered by the end of the week.

To answer the question, just quote the question, or say which are you refeering to in a way that is clear for everyone that you're answering the question. Non candidates may also answer the question. You may also ask questions in here, but don't expect them to get whitelisted, to do that, please use the form, it's just to keep things more organized.

There is no word limit or requirement for your answers.

Also, technically phase 1 isn't over for another hour so yeah, if you want to register, now it's the last chance!, if you've backed down in the past, you may still join now.
z0z
damn 9 candidates
Topic Starter
Patatitta
- Why are you running for president?

I am the former president, I like the changes I did, and I would like them for those changes to stay another year, and the best way to do that is to run myself again

- anything new you have in mind for OT?

Not really no, I think ot is in a good state. If I wanted to do more chages, I would have done it by now, i've also not really seen many people during my term saying "Ohhhhhhh the government should do x and y", sure, you had people saying to revert the changes I did, but not to do extra, so I think this is the right choice

- will you exile users who keeps making threads in less than 24 hours?

Exiling someone is more complicated than you are led to believe, gmt really DONT like exiling people, even someone like jangsodloor, the gov pushed for them to be banned months before their inevitable osu ban and it was unsuccessful, they only became exiled after a force external to OT pushed for it to be exiled. Aditionally, abraker shadow removed jangsodloor from exieled hours before they actually got banned, which was pretty comical. But yeah, even if I wanted to push this change, I don't think it's possible.


- Do you believe formal rules or guidelines should be put in place for, among other things: Thread quality, respect between OT members, preventing bad influences on minors? Why or why not?

Let's divide this questions in parts

Thread quality

Absolutely not, mainly because there is no way to objectively define the thread quality. You may say "ohhhhhh scyla threads are clearly awful we should go scorched earth on them" but even for that, there are people engaging with scyla threads. At the end of the day you just need someone who works as a judge for thread quality, and from all the years OT have been in the hand of a single overlord, it isn't the best system, it's heavily biased, it feels bad whenever you get a thread locked that you thought it was good, and I don't think it's even going to help anyone, because as we have seen, getting your thread locked has had 0 effect on people to stop producing said threads. People were getting their threads locked every single time yet they would still post them.

The other option would be having a system like my thread "Rate your OT thread", where threads under a certain threshold are locked, but how do we guarantee transparency on that?, if the rating system is public, people will just try to farm it, like it happened with rate your OT thread, and if it's private, how do you guys know we're not lying?. It also requires a certain ammount of people to be rating every single thread for the system to work, and I don't think we cant expect people to go to every ot thread and rate them if they should be locked or not forever and ever.

It's a mess, and I think how OT operates right now with few locks + appeal for locks is ideal.

- respect between OT members

This already exists, it's in the OT rules, I assume the person asking this question assumes it's not enough, probably because of the drama that happened when I didn't let GMT participate. And for that I say that's not really a example that you can extrapolate to the whole of OT, because in that person, the people arguing where gmts, they were above the law.

Now, excluding that specific scenario, do I think there is not enough enforcement of this in OT?, not really, last year has probably the chillest i've seen OT in a while. However I will say, remember that the report button exists, if you see someone annoying you and you feel they should face consequences, report it.

- Preventing bad influences on minors

By default, osu does not have a age requirement, however, the specific countries do have laws on how old do you need to be before you start using social media and stuff, and the most common of those requirements, and the one I agree the most is 13yo+, I do think we should enforce OT for all the content to be 13+

Now, I know why you're asking the question, I know you're probably not happy with my 13+ answer, mainly arguing that there are people in OT who are less than 13 even if they dont publicly admit it. This is not something I can enforce, mainly because I know everyone would be against it, but I would personally simply not let these people into OT, I would exile them, I would do whatever to make sure they dont get in

why?, because OT is the wild west, yes, we may have very strong enforcement but unless that enforcement is lighting quick, someone under that age may still be exposed to that content, not only that, but it's quite literally a crime. I don't think it's realistic for everyone in OT, a forum where most people are over that age of 13, to adapt their speech to be suitable to someone who is 8yo who should not by law be admitted on there.



- Why do you believe you should be the president over the other candidates?

I disagree with the premise of this question. I don't think i'm morally entitled or an bojectively better choice than anyone else, however, I don't think it's narcicistic to say the person I trust the most is myself, and I if want to see the changes I want to see, it is I who should run in the race. So in short, I don't think anyone is a better candidate than anyone else morally, but I still enjoy my own policies the most.

- If you couldn't vote for youself, who would you vote for?

Achromalia, I like them as a person, I think they're one of the less erratic ot users and most level headed ones, and in adition they always write their whoooole thought process before typing anything, and honestly, even if they do changes I dislike, I don't think I can even be mad at them, so yeah, it's achromalia.
sametdze
why are you running for president?
because i want to

anything new you have in mind for OT?
not really

will you exile users who keeps making threads in less than 24 hours?
is an exile really necessary? just lock and move on and if the problem persists just silence them

Do you believe formal rules or guidelines should be put in place for, among other things: Thread quality, respect between OT members, preventing bad influences on minors? Why or why not?

-thread quality; absolutely not. the whole reason to why i liked OT compared to other places was because i could post whatever and people would interact with it no matter the effort. also, aren't low quality threads what makes OT.. OT?

-respect; yes, i believe there should be some bar of respect. some fun silly banter is fine, but overall we should generally keep away from getting on each others nerves. just how inviting would OT be if we were all dunking on each other?

-the minor issue; if a child is getting influenced by horny linux users on an anime rhythm game forum, just think about the whereabouts and teachings of the parents.. personally for me i dont mind the questionable stuff on here, i'm smart enough to not get influenced.
i misread the questuion. in some situations wes should definitely have a few rules put in place but overall i dont think we need a new set, maybe just one or two

Why do you believe you should be the president over the other candidates?
i DON'T think i should be president lol, im just here for fun

If you couldn't vote for youself, who would you vote for?
achro because i find that they're the best at expressing themselves, and a president which is capable of expressing their true thoughts and emotions while maintaining positive traits is better than a president that doesn't even know where to begin (cough cough me)
Topic Starter
Patatitta
accepted sametdze, OP updated
sametdze
Karmine
ohhhhhh scyla threads are clearly awful we should go scorched earth on them
Scyla
Why are you running for president?
"I Am Running", that time it was raining and I was running

anything new you have in mind for OT?
no, stay natural

will you exile users who keeps making threads in less than 24 hours?
no, this place needs new threads until page 5 per day

Do you believe formal rules or guidelines should be put in place for, among other things: Thread quality, respect between OT members, preventing bad influences on minors? Why or why not?
no, you have common sense for that and forum rules

Why do you believe you should be the president over the other candidates?
refty, save the best for last

If you couldn't vote for youself, who would you vote for?
my other self
Scyla

Karmine wrote:

ohhhhhh scyla threads are clearly awful we should go scorched earth on them
my threads are masterpieces, it has a 90% chance of me getting banned or silenced yet i am still alive

100% calculated
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply