Crimmi wrote:

Saten-san wrote:

2 sec seems too long imo..

I say that because from the beginning till the first note is a bit short especially for the ones who use Double Time.

but like i say it's a suggestion

FireballFlame wrote:

These three-part difficulty names are quite bulky, maybe you should remove one of the parts. nooooo, I've done it for this http://osu.ppy.sh/s/24135 and this http://osu.ppy.sh/s/27523 and there were no problems!
On every diff: 2 seconds lead-in is too long imo. 1 is enough. Nope
Also, what are taiko.png and taikobg.png there for? They do not seem to be used by anything. Been fixed before this mod

[Ami-Hard]
00:04:771 (2,3,4) - Make them symmetric to the y-axis.
00:07:128 (1,2,3) - The music doesn't really justify a triple here. I'd remove that (2). Nope
00:10:128 (1) - Again, symmetry.
00:41:628 (1,1) - This looks kinda weird, as the slider appears almost at the same time as the spinner. Maybe remove it, put the whistle on the spinner and make that 1 beat longer? Nope
01:16:771 (1,2,3,4) - Symmetry.
01:23:628 (1,2,3,4) - ^
01:26:843 (1,2,3,4) - I don't think this is a very good idea. I'd remove that combo altogether, as it comes quite unexpected, but if you want to keep it: Move it 1 beat earlier in time. It becomes more readable (can be observed while still spinning), less confusing (every note of the melody ist mapped instead of the 1st one skipped) and closer to the music (the current (4) sounds like it's just an echo) that way. Oh, and 1 grid up to match the axis. I'm keeping it the way it is. it's not confusing, this is a hard!

[Ryuji-Easy]
00:41:628 (1,2) - 1 and 2 grids right respectively to match the axis. Nope
00:51:486 (2) - 3 grids down, 2 right, so it doesnt overlap with (1). Then adjust (3,4) to restore spacing. Soemthing different
00:54:914 (2) - A bit too far from (1). No it isn't >_>
01:26:843 (1,2) - Remove them. Not fitting for the Easy diff imo. Yes it does

Star!

Colin Hou wrote:

[Insane]:

1. 01:13:986 (1) - not a fan about this slow slider, spinner with a starting note is better imo. or at least make a better shape for them? there are only 3 way point and seems randomly placed.
2. 01:17:414 (1) - ^
3. 01:20:843 (1) - ^

FireballFlame wrote:

[Saten's Taiga-Insane]
Nice map! But tick rate 0,5? At least raise it to 1. It even sounds better.

akrolsmir wrote:

Saten's Taiga-Insane:
I think a slider tick rate of 1 or even 2 would be good; it's a bit disconcerting to see long sliders with no ticks in them.
Other than that, I thought the patterns were really well done in this difficulty!

Weezy wrote:

@ I'm keeping it the way it is. it's not confusing, this is a hard! Well, Hard =/= confusing. I don't like to have at 100% and then get misses on the last 4 notes (which I did)
@ No it isn't >_> Yes it is. Try distance snapping it and you'll see.
@ every Nope Why not?

FireballFlame wrote:

Weezy wrote:

@ I'm keeping it the way it is. it's not confusing, this is a hard! Well, Hard =/= confusing. I don't like to have at 100% and then get misses on the last 4 notes (which I did) To simply put it, you missed. I don't find anything wrong with it and find it simply to get it.
@ No it isn't >_> Yes it is. Try distance snapping it and you'll see. how is this far http://puu.sh/2ckR -.-
@ every Nope Why not?found them to be nazi mods :/

00:41:628 (1,1) - This looks kinda weird,

jericho2442 wrote:

00:41:628 (1,1) - This looks kinda weird,

i advise you to do this from FireballFlame's mod, just fast checked it myself and this does play horrid, extend the first spinner to 00:42:700 and add a note at 00:42:914

also please remember a modder is not modding to agitate you, even if they do a nazi mod they spent time to do it so they could help you with your map, do not take it offensive and please always atleast try the changes before you reject them I always do D:

also FireballFlame's mod was not purely nazi, was also a lot of good suggestions even if you yourself did not apply them

Leorda wrote:

Hiiiiii, sorry for taking so long

General
* Since the title is "Orange", how about the combo color change into an Orange color? lol The first combo colour is orange :S

-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Ryuji-Easy
00:12:486 (1,2,3,4) - I think these stack is kinda confusing for noobs, but I'm not sure about this one....
00:23:200 (3) - ^ (maybe?)
00:58:771 (1) - Move 1 grid up, to make a same distance as 00:57:057 (1,2) (Nazi)
01:04:986 (2,3) - Can you move down a bit? It's kinda odd to see that this is overlapped by slider in gameplay (Nazi)

-------------------------------------------------------------------------

net's Kitamura-Normal
00:14:628 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - I'm pretty sure that 8 combos are too high for normal diff
00:22:128 (4) - Not stack perfectly with tail slider
00:25:557 (4) - ^
00:35:200 (3) - I don't like if this overlapped by previous object
00:45:485 (1) - Too far from spinner, you should make it close to spinner. Otherwise, noobs can't reach this object while gameplay Nope :/
00:47:843 (5,6) - I am pretty not sure about this. It has weird stack during gameplay, but in editor it's just fine
01:00:485 (1) - Too far from spinner, you should make it close to spinner. Otherwise, noobs can't reach this object while gameplay Nope :/
01:06:914 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - 10 combos at normal diff are too high
01:10:771 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - I'm pretty sure that 8 combos are too high for normal diff

-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Ami's Hard
00:01:771 (4) - New combo?
00:34:343 (2) - Ugly slider (Nazi)
00:37:986 (2) - Not stack perfectly with 00:37:771 (1)


-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Don't hate me ok? Why would I hate you D:

1. 00:22:541 (6) - Delete note?
2. 00:22:755 (1) - slider beginning finish?
3. 00:24:470 (1) - ^
4. 00:39:255 - Add note
5. 00:39:470 - ^
6. 01:06:255 - http://puu.sh/2f3YSuggestion
7. 01:24:469 (1) - Spinner end Silent?

1. OD,AR+1?
2. 00:24:486 (5) - Finish?

• Normal must not change spacing...

1. 00:03:700 (3) - Spacing
2. 00:15:271 (4) - ^
3. 00:18:271 (4) - ^
4. 00:18:700 (6) - ^
5. 00:27:914 (5) - soft finish?
   many Spacing miss Please check

1. 00:17:200 (3) - end Add finish
2. 00:37:771 - http://puu.sh/2f4PSuggestion

1. HP Drain Rate 2

1. 00:37:771 (1) Start the spinner here ?
2. 00:41:200 (x) Add a note here

1. 01:09:271 (1,2,3,4) Stacked notes? looks bad.
2. 01:13:343 (1,2,3,4) ^. Would look much better without those notes and with more imagination
3. 01:26:843 (x) Add notes, as that easy.

1. HP Drain Rate 6

1. 00:34:343 (2) loosk bad
2. 00:41:200 (1) Move this note to the centre and remove new combo.
3. 00:53:628 (1,2,3,4) Stacked notes? looks bad.
4. 01:09:271 (4) New combo
5. 01:16:343 (1) Remove new combo
6. 01:19:771 (1) ^
7. 01:20:200 (1,2,3,4) Stacked notes? looks bad. Please improve. creativitie (?)
8. 01:23:200 (1) Remove new combo.

1. 00:49:343 (1) Remove new combo ?
2. 01:26:843 (x) Add notes, as that hard.

eldnl wrote:

[Easy]

1. HP Drain Rate 2

Nope :/

1. 00:37:771 (1) Start the spinner here ?
2. 00:41:200 (x) Add a note here

Nope, too close to the spinner



[Hard]

1. HP Drain Rate 6 Nope

1. 00:34:343 (2) loosk bad no it doesn't
2. 00:41:200 (1) Move this note to the centre and remove new combo. Not removing the new combo
3. 00:53:628 (1,2,3,4) Stacked notes? looks bad.
4. 01:09:271 (4) New combo
5. 01:16:343 (1) Remove new combo
6. 01:19:771 (1) ^
7. 01:20:200 (1,2,3,4) Stacked notes? looks bad. Please improve. creativitie (?) Nope I got a little pattern going :3
8. 01:23:200 (1) Remove new combo.

Saten-san wrote:

;w;
why u add finish here (00:07:343 - ) on mine? ;w;

if you say it fits, then I need to add finishes here as well:
00:53:628 -
01:07:343 -

updated, added finishes and change some new combos..

SapphireGhost wrote:

Hi, I'm here from #modreqs, non-MAT/BATness included.

[General]
- Kiai time is inconsistent and unrankable. Make kiai time for all difficulties the same.

[Normal With A Long Name]
01:06:914 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - Put a new combo here somewhere.
01:17:521 (1) - Move the spinner back one blue tick.
01:20:950 (1) - ^

[Ami-Hard]
00:39:700 (4,1) - *nazi* This could blanket better. Right now it looks like this:

1

It would be better like this:

2

Map is okay.
[/color]

Weezy wrote:

Yomeiro wrote:

Random mod~

Ami-Hard

00:21:486 (1,2,3,4) - I kinda expected a "AaAa" pattern here for the whistles as well.... it's AAaa instead o.o (special reason for this? ><)
00:24:914 (1,2,3,4) - ^
00:52:557 (7) - Is there a whistle missing at the end of this one? o.o (I guess there is, since you used one at the end of 01:06:271 (7) as well ><)


I guess I'm pretty much fine with all other diff's ~
Hitsounds on Easy felt a bit weird though, probably since I checked the other diffs first~
Oh well.... guess I just leave this here~

1. 00:26:200 (2)- Maybe new combo?

1. 00:09:271 (5)- Whistle?
2. 00:15:057 (3)- ^
3. 00:15:914 (5)- ^
4. 00:18:486 (5)- ^

1. 00:00:914 (3)- Whistle at the end?
2. 00:03:914 (1)- ^
3. 00:27:914 (1)- Whistle in the beginning?

1. 01:06:271 - May use this slider velocity in 0,50?

vivere wrote:

[Saten's Taiga-Insane]:

1. 01:06:271 - May use this slider velocity in 0,50?

p3n wrote:

[Insane]