1. The menu selection is well made, the mascot in the back button fit well.
2. The result screen is well made.
3. For the HP bar... there is a white space between the left border and the jaudge. Maybe you should put your name in this space.
4. For the gameplay, why not the black border. The problem is your circles (except the colored part) don't have a @2x file... But also it's playable, it's no bad.

abraker wrote:

Skin in my signature. I know it's bad. I expect a well fleshed out critique. Do your worst.

abraker's skin: link

1. Litterally thre idke skin but playable.
2. The spinner isn't perfectly centered.
3. Good gameplay.
4. The digits of the input counter isn't readable (he's dark with a dark background).
5. You didn't edited the scorebar to remove/put your name...
6. I can't read the japanese of the menu selection...

abraker wrote:

Skin in my signature. I know it's bad. I expect a well fleshed out critique. Do your worst.

abraker's skin: link

1. The cursor is too small.
2. WTF THE HITCIRCLES ARE SMALLER THAN SLIDER CIRCLES!!!!! Also, the files are different if you play with @2x or not.
3. Approach circles too dark too be visible.
4. Input counter unreadable
5. Menu selection and result screen needs more work.
6. Default hitsounds >_<
7. You didn't skinned entierely the menu selection and the background. Also the result screen is ugly with your custom numbers.

abraker wrote:

I actually made that skin so I could read ez better

1. It's just a Cookiezi skin, no edited.
2. Too many anime girls.
3. Slider border are too dark and hard to read. This destroy a little the gameplay
4. Skin too huge? (112 MB)
5. Beautiful menu selection btw

Corne2Plum3 wrote:

Slider border are too dark and hard to read. This destroy a little the gameplay

Corne2Plum3 wrote:

Skin too huge? (112 MB)

nedd83 wrote:

Corne2Plum3 wrote:

Skin too huge? (112 MB)

i don't see this as a problem

1. Full mixed skin.
2. Song selection simple, but good.
3. We don't see Yugen skin a lot.
4. Long notes in Mania are buggy.
5. Simple skin, but good to play.

Corne2Plum3 wrote:

Long notes in Lania are buggy.

1. WTF these sounds of song selection...
2. Gameplay isn't bad at low diff, but with higher difficulty, becomes hard to read, especially stacks.
3. Mixed skin, I guess.
4. No @2x files, so look bad on large screens...
5. Miku?

1. Where are Random and Map Options in the song selection?
2. The border of your circles are too thin: that why they make glitches on slider heads.
3. No custom combo and score font. Also, you made combo numbers files, but they don't work.
4. Numbers in inputs count aren't visible...
5. There is not ranking panel by default. I found a ranking panel, he working, but he don't have a normal version (without @2x).
6. A lot of elements from other skins...

1. No skinned: menu background , ranking panel, mods icons, score and combo font...
2. Default hitcircles >_<. Also, no hidden slider end circle
3. Too huge miss, 50, 100, and 300(!) hits... Make the skin unreadable, especially with stacks...
4. Mixed skin. mania-hit300g from my -Night03- skin btw

Corne2Plum3 wrote:

There is not ranking panel by default. I found a ranking panel, he working, but he don't have a normal version (without @2x).

WitherMite wrote:

Corne2Plum3 wrote:

Long notes in Lania are buggy.

can you expand on that?
I don't notice anything wrong with mania LN's

1. Full mixed skin. A big mix
2. Simple but good menu selection and ranking panel
3. Good gameplay

Corne2Plum3 wrote:

color5(fixed) by z0z:

1. No skinned: menu background , ranking panel, mods icons, score and combo font...
2. Default hitcircles >_<. Also, no hidden slider end circle
3. Too huge miss, 50, 100, and 300(!) hits... Make the skin unreadable, especially with stacks...
4. Mixed skin. mania-hit300g from my -Night03- skin btw

Too high score font overlap...

Some elements no skinned, and with the hitcircle and hit images (50, 100, ...) this skin look like a 2008 skin... Unreadable for high difficulties...

Aesthetics 3/5 - Gameplay 1.5/5 - Personal touch 1/5 - Personal feeling 2.5/5
8/20

Hydreigon wrote:

do you rate ctb skins?

1. Some elements from other skins.
2. 221 MB !!!????? You should: reduce the size of applause song (it's too long and to high quality for a skin). You maybe should remove the psd files and put them in a other place.
3. NSFW fail background ? (need to be verified)
4. Circles numbers are a bit too small.
5. Approach circle is too thin, so it's sometime hard too read.
6. No bad gameplay.

1. Literally the MK version of the Flying Tuna skin...
2. Very good gameplay

Corne2Plum3 wrote:

KatouMegumi's skin: Burakku Shipu KM 2020

1. Some elements from other skins. (Yeah, using kamui as base. Also some elements are slightly remastered.)
2. 221 MB !!!????? You should: reduce the size of applause song (it's too long and to high quality for a skin). You maybe should remove the psd files and put them in a other place. (Eh. It's a player skin, doesn't bother me that much.)
3. NSFW fail background ? (need to be verified) (Maybe slightly ecchi, but not outright NSFW.)
4. Circles numbers are a bit too small. (Personally, this style of hit circles is the Chitanda one, numbers are an afterthought.)
5. Approach circle is too thin, so it's sometime hard too read. (Intentional design choice as to not rely on it too much during gameplay. It's a HD focused skin anyway, no biggie in that regard imho)
6. No bad gameplay.

Nice mixed skin, but the skin folder is too huge. I can see you made some elements too.

Aesthetics 4/5 - Gameplay 3.5/5 - Personal touch 3.5/5 - Personal feeling 4/5
15/20

1. Pause background NSFW brrrrr...? (need to be verified).
2. A lot of wolf furries... It's your style, I know.
3. The hitcircle are too opaque, it's hard to read with stacks.
4. Correct gameplay.

1. Mixed skin, except the hp bar
2. Nice gameplay, except spinner: it's just a dot in the center, and see the spinner take too many time... And I fail short spinners...
3. No @2x files for circles... (except for circles numbers).

Corne2Plum3 wrote:

Axl's Personal Skin v1

1. Mixed skin, except the hp bar
2. Nice gameplay, except spinner: it's just a dot in the center, and see the spinner take too many time... And I fail short spinners...
3. No @2x files for circles... (except for circles numbers).

This skin is simple, but nice to play, but there is a bug with spinner (I don't know why), the spinner is just a simple dot...

Aesthetics 4/5 - Gameplay 4/5 - Personal touch 1.5/5 - Personal feeling 4/5
13.5/20

ColdTooth wrote:

I could send mine, but I prefer it private. There's nothing nsfw about it, it's just that 1) it's not my skin, im still working on mine based off of it, and 2) it's gunna easily get under 5/20 with 0 points in gameplay.

Zelzatter Zero wrote:

ok here's my other skin. SFW ofc.

Corne2Plum3 wrote:

ColdTooth wrote:

I could send mine, but I prefer it private. There's nothing nsfw about it, it's just that 1) it's not my skin, im still working on mine based off of it, and 2) it's gunna easily get under 5/20 with 0 points in gameplay.

community/forums/posts/7754275 lol

I think your skin isn't finished

ColdTooth wrote:

Corne2Plum3 wrote:

ColdTooth wrote:

I could send mine, but I prefer it private. There's nothing nsfw about it, it's just that 1) it's not my skin, im still working on mine based off of it, and 2) it's gunna easily get under 5/20 with 0 points in gameplay.

community/forums/posts/7754275 lol

I think your skin isn't finished

I could give you videos of what it looks like.

https://streamable.com/skhqqa <--- the 1.0 release of my map lol but it's nomod

https://streamable.com/hwgo90 <--- with HD mod, and the hitsounds of the skin

if you really want the skin itself i'd have to upload it and send it privately for you to try

either way, let me finish my own skin first and THEN i'll come back, if this thread is still around

there is another skin i use, but it's CXu's unboomered skin, it's on his profile, at the very top of his me edit: the skin is rather anime, but it's pretty sfw

nedd83 wrote:

ColdTooth wrote:

Corne2Plum3 wrote:

ColdTooth wrote:

I could send mine, but I prefer it private. There's nothing nsfw about it, it's just that 1) it's not my skin, im still working on mine based off of it, and 2) it's gunna easily get under 5/20 with 0 points in gameplay.

community/forums/posts/7754275 lol

I think your skin isn't finished

I could give you videos of what it looks like.

https://streamable.com/skhqqa <--- the 1.0 release of my map lol but it's nomod

https://streamable.com/hwgo90 <--- with HD mod, and the hitsounds of the skin

if you really want the skin itself i'd have to upload it and send it privately for you to try

either way, let me finish my own skin first and THEN i'll come back, if this thread is still around

there is another skin i use, but it's CXu's unboomered skin, it's on his profile, at the very top of his me edit: the skin is rather anime, but it's pretty sfw

smh singletapping
yo where my alt bros at

Penguin wrote:

nedd83 wrote:

ColdTooth wrote:

Corne2Plum3 wrote:

ColdTooth wrote:

I could send mine, but I prefer it private. There's nothing nsfw about it, it's just that 1) it's not my skin, im still working on mine based off of it, and 2) it's gunna easily get under 5/20 with 0 points in gameplay.

community/forums/posts/7754275 lol

I think your skin isn't finished

I could give you videos of what it looks like.

https://streamable.com/skhqqa <--- the 1.0 release of my map lol but it's nomod

https://streamable.com/hwgo90 <--- with HD mod, and the hitsounds of the skin

if you really want the skin itself i'd have to upload it and send it privately for you to try

either way, let me finish my own skin first and THEN i'll come back, if this thread is still around

there is another skin i use, but it's CXu's unboomered skin, it's on his profile, at the very top of his me edit: the skin is rather anime, but it's pretty sfw

smh singletapping
yo where my alt bros at

alting is a new age thing. You can tell if someone is an older player if they primarily single tap. Such as me and ColdTooth.

Penguin wrote:

nedd83 wrote:

ColdTooth wrote:

Corne2Plum3 wrote:

ColdTooth wrote:

I could send mine, but I prefer it private. There's nothing nsfw about it, it's just that 1) it's not my skin, im still working on mine based off of it, and 2) it's gunna easily get under 5/20 with 0 points in gameplay.

community/forums/posts/7754275 lol

I think your skin isn't finished

I could give you videos of what it looks like.

https://streamable.com/skhqqa <--- the 1.0 release of my map lol but it's nomod

https://streamable.com/hwgo90 <--- with HD mod, and the hitsounds of the skin

if you really want the skin itself i'd have to upload it and send it privately for you to try

either way, let me finish my own skin first and THEN i'll come back, if this thread is still around

there is another skin i use, but it's CXu's unboomered skin, it's on his profile, at the very top of his me edit: the skin is rather anime, but it's pretty sfw

smh singletapping
yo where my alt bros at

alting is a new age thing. You can tell if someone is an older player if they primarily single tap. Such as me and ColdTooth.

axl2468 wrote:

although I'm slowly transitioning into a hybrid tapping style.

Penguin wrote:

there it is. they've got you

Penguin wrote:

nedd83 wrote:

ColdTooth wrote:

Corne2Plum3 wrote:

ColdTooth wrote:

I could send mine, but I prefer it private. There's nothing nsfw about it, it's just that 1) it's not my skin, im still working on mine based off of it, and 2) it's gunna easily get under 5/20 with 0 points in gameplay.

community/forums/posts/7754275 lol

I think your skin isn't finished

I could give you videos of what it looks like.

https://streamable.com/skhqqa <--- the 1.0 release of my map lol but it's nomod

https://streamable.com/hwgo90 <--- with HD mod, and the hitsounds of the skin

if you really want the skin itself i'd have to upload it and send it privately for you to try

either way, let me finish my own skin first and THEN i'll come back, if this thread is still around

there is another skin i use, but it's CXu's unboomered skin, it's on his profile, at the very top of his me edit: the skin is rather anime, but it's pretty sfw

smh singletapping
yo where my alt bros at

alting is a new age thing. You can tell if someone is an older player if they primarily single tap. Such as me and ColdTooth.

WitherMite wrote:

im an alternating hippie, I was alternating before I even knew what it was!

axl2468 wrote:

WitherMite wrote:

im an alternating hippie, I was alternating before I even knew what it was!

i think the correct term is alternating hipster

Penguin wrote:

nedd83 wrote:

ColdTooth wrote:

Corne2Plum3 wrote:

ColdTooth wrote:

I could send mine, but I prefer it private. There's nothing nsfw about it, it's just that 1) it's not my skin, im still working on mine based off of it, and 2) it's gunna easily get under 5/20 with 0 points in gameplay.

community/forums/posts/7754275 lol

I think your skin isn't finished

I could give you videos of what it looks like.

https://streamable.com/skhqqa <--- the 1.0 release of my map lol but it's nomod

https://streamable.com/hwgo90 <--- with HD mod, and the hitsounds of the skin

if you really want the skin itself i'd have to upload it and send it privately for you to try

either way, let me finish my own skin first and THEN i'll come back, if this thread is still around

there is another skin i use, but it's CXu's unboomered skin, it's on his profile, at the very top of his me edit: the skin is rather anime, but it's pretty sfw

smh singletapping
yo where my alt bros at

alting is a new age thing. You can tell if someone is an older player if they primarily single tap. Such as me and ColdTooth.

keremaru wrote:

Penguin wrote:

nedd83 wrote:

ColdTooth wrote:

Corne2Plum3 wrote:

ColdTooth wrote:

I could send mine, but I prefer it private. There's nothing nsfw about it, it's just that 1) it's not my skin, im still working on mine based off of it, and 2) it's gunna easily get under 5/20 with 0 points in gameplay.

community/forums/posts/7754275 lol

I think your skin isn't finished

I could give you videos of what it looks like.

https://streamable.com/skhqqa <--- the 1.0 release of my map lol but it's nomod

https://streamable.com/hwgo90 <--- with HD mod, and the hitsounds of the skin

if you really want the skin itself i'd have to upload it and send it privately for you to try

either way, let me finish my own skin first and THEN i'll come back, if this thread is still around

there is another skin i use, but it's CXu's unboomered skin, it's on his profile, at the very top of his me edit: the skin is rather anime, but it's pretty sfw

smh singletapping
yo where my alt bros at

alting is a new age thing. You can tell if someone is an older player if they primarily single tap. Such as me and ColdTooth.

real singletapping = hammerjacking at 200bpm to stream /s

keremaru wrote:

also, hi i finished my skin for the most part

various sources but i can't remember them all (so i just tagged it w/ "various artists" in the .ini)

and yes
i used vsauce clips for the sectionpass/fail audio

Foxi wrote:

keremaru wrote:

also, hi i finished my skin for the most part

various sources but i can't remember them all (so i just tagged it w/ "various artists" in the .ini)

and yes
i used vsauce clips for the sectionpass/fail audio

I don't think that link works. ;-;
You have to generate a link under the share option for Dropbox.

1. Some elements from other skins
2. Some cute elements UwU
3. Nice gameplay
4. The glow of your healthbar is a little strange.
5. Mods/Random/Options buttons in song selection aren't visible except if you pass your cursor on. Their positions aren't intuitive.
6. A lot of anime girl

sadave wrote:

https://www.youtube.com/redirect?q=https%3A%2F%2Fdrive.google.com%2Ffile%2Fd%2F1ZRCkM6dqu8LSlEEHAz9Tyb7gfnz2ZMvq%2Fview%3Fusp%3Ddrivesdk&redir_token=QUFFLUhqbDhvUGRUck9wUVFWQWlRcXQwTTdQemZ2cEU2Z3xBQ3Jtc0tuLS1SLWUtbkd3Q1l4dWVEa0tBUmJ0N2dSU3NRYVY1NE1rSlk2dnNUWXhhWGwzbUp2dS1mV3BIaWxEakI5V1owQmRoUW9UUEdnNkVRWmhYaVdZNDVMcUdTbjhfaC1IOXM1RnBsd2VRN0pLblg0NFJCcw%3D%3D&event=video_description&v=3eFcbYUDN44

1. Skin of a other player.
2. Unplayable, especially the cursor and his unconventionnal position (the pointer is at the top left corner, not at the center.
3. Score numbers burn my eyes.
4. Not the same font for hitcircles.
5. Bad result panel quality.
6. I know the multi-source is the style of that skin
7. WTF