Uhm...this is my first time modding anything, so take my opinions with a grain of salt.
Mon français n'est pas très bon, donc je n'ai pas lu tout du fil. Is that even the right word to use?
General
I really like your mapping, I had a ton of fun test playing the difficulties I could, but..
Cup
This seems slightly too difficult for new players, as many things look like they must be dashed.
This was much too hard for a Salad, so I had a lot of fun playing it , but therein lies your problem. Not much for me to say, but I'd rather call this a Platter than a Salad.
really really fun though.
Platter
Too hard again, I'd call this a Rain instead of a Platter
Rain
Too difficult for me to test play . I'd call it Overdose. Otherwise, it seems fine.
Mon français n'est pas très bon, donc je n'ai pas lu tout du fil. Is that even the right word to use?
General
I really like your mapping, I had a ton of fun test playing the difficulties I could, but..
- Much, much too hard on the last three difficulties for what they're called. I'd move them all up one, and just make a new Salad
- The offset seems slightly off, by 5-10ms. I know you said that it makes almost no difference, and that someone else found the offset, but it makes quite a difference when listening with the effects turned up, it just feels off.
- You don't use quite enough hitsounds during non-kiai times.
I'd refer to this
Deif wrote:
- Cup: The easiest level of the mapset. It should be cleared without pressing the dash button, and use a quite simple rhythm.
- Salad: Dashes can be used in them, and the note density increases a bit.
- Platter: The perfect level for the average player. Easy HDashes and the introduction of 1/4 patterns shall fit here.
- Rain: HDashes and Dashes start to be challenging and the rhythm is already complex.
- Overdose: FCable for the top players. A challenge for the rest!
Cup
This seems slightly too difficult for new players, as many things look like they must be dashed.
- 00:06:090 (1,2) - Slightly too far apart, maybe just a tick or two closer?
- 00:19:290 (1,3) - Again, slightly too far apart.
- 01:20:790 (3) - Should be a beat here, it feels empty.
- 01:32:490 (1) - Maybe a beat here? It kind of works right now, the way it is.
- 02:00:090 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - The pattern here is too difficult
This was much too hard for a Salad, so I had a lot of fun playing it , but therein lies your problem. Not much for me to say, but I'd rather call this a Platter than a Salad.
really really fun though.
Platter
Too hard again, I'd call this a Rain instead of a Platter
- 00:27:540 (7,8) - Slightly too far, because the player is coming out of moving back and forth, and then they have to transition into a hdash immediately.
Rain
Too difficult for me to test play . I'd call it Overdose. Otherwise, it seems fine.