Your only post regarding redo's scum mines to my memory after the ISo was "redo's buddying has been noted" which I interpreted as " this is anti town but I still don't think he is scum" that is in effect a town read in my mind. You then, after implying you have a town read on him in a later post, state you do not have a town read on him but then did not state why or to what degree. I continue to think that there really wasn't much in any of your posts that would lead me to believe you thought of redo as scum until that point. I am glad that you agree that there are things to look into with regards to redo but think that my initial belief that you continued to think of him as town is justified. I'm not a mind reader
I asked him because he has not been contributing all that much on his own, and typically, asking questions of players who may not be making the most contributions on their own can offer at least some insight into what they think is going on and can raise activity. I can't really think of a reasonable explanation for why someone would refuse to answer that question. Outright refusal is different than stating "I don't know" or "I do not have a strong opinion on the matter" both of which, while I probably would press, are at least somewhat responsive
I asked him because he has not been contributing all that much on his own, and typically, asking questions of players who may not be making the most contributions on their own can offer at least some insight into what they think is going on and can raise activity. I can't really think of a reasonable explanation for why someone would refuse to answer that question. Outright refusal is different than stating "I don't know" or "I do not have a strong opinion on the matter" both of which, while I probably would press, are at least somewhat responsive