I think I would give this advice to everyone who's playing, Nacho gave me this advice and I think this stands really true.
Trust people. If you scrutinize everything and especially with bias over one person, you're just screwing yourself over as well as town. Even if that trust is only for a bit, you can always go against it later. Trust is built and lost throughout the course of the game, town read more people than you scum cause it's better that way.
And most importantly DO NOT stick to your reads just because you've said them earlier and that going back on that word makes you look like you don't know what you're saying. Not evaluating your reads further and sticking with the one you had from D1 is definitely more of a sign that shows you don't know what you're doing.