Dark Fang wrote:

Hai~ - Hi~
from Fang Team's Queue
Let's go

[General]

offset +10 (652) - I will fix offset and similar things when I get another .mp3 and a video

[Easy]

I think that's good '^'d

[Normal]

nothing special

[Hard]

AR -1? - Ok, a lot of people have said this, so changing~
01:04:999 (2) - why don't you try make like this? - I just like this slider xD

[Insane]

AR -1 cuz that's awkward for 179 BPM - AR8 feels too slow for this map imo. And it's not because I can only read AR9 or anything like that, I just think it fits more xD
HP-1?
OD -1?
^Keeping these settings too.
01:23:267 (8,9,10,11,12) - why don't you try make like this? cuz that's too confusion for play. and NC - I like this pattern and how it plays, so I'm keeping it, and I'll also keep the combo as it it~

[Kinomi's Taiko]

00:43:547 ~ 00:44:552 - why don't you follow vocal?

good maps :3
good luck

Have a good time - Thanks

Netsukawa wrote:

Your source should be fix.

Sword Art Online SWORD ART ONLINE

Melophobia wrote:

A quick mod~ - Hi~

[General]
mp3quality is so poor imo, try to find better one - I got this from the episode though... I'll see if I can get a better one.
sliderslide is really noisy especially on the beginning of this song. consider adding muted one. - Sure.

[Easy]
00:09:859 (3) - i'd suggest to remove finish from the end of this slider, the drum sound is not as strong as 00:09:859 - - Yeah ok.
00:11:368 (1) - add finish here, i can hear it in the music - Sure.
00:35:502 (2) - ^ -
01:09:692 (2) - add finish at the end - Ok.
01:10:865 (3,4,5) - add finishes - Nah, that would be noisy imo.
01:23:770 (1) - this should start at 01:23:602 - - Heh, yes you're right.


[Normal]
00:03:658 (1) - start this at 00:03:491 - -
00:06:340 (1) - way too soon after a spinner, beginners need at least 2 beats recovery time - It's normal. You should be a bit more than a beginner at this point. Also, it's close to the center of the spinner, so I think it's fine.
00:09:859 (2) - same reason as Easy, remove finish from the end - Yes
00:35:502 (3) - add finish at the beginning - Yes
00:42:876 (1) - ^ at the end - ^
00:55:446 (2) - finish at the end? fits vocal/music better - I like the clap xD
01:06:172 (2) - ^ - ^
01:10:865 (2,3) - ^ - ^
01:23:770 (1) - same as Easy - K

[Hard]
00:21:591 (4) - this slider is too loud, try to reduce the volume by 20% - Added a gradual increase
00:56:452 (3) - ^ - ^
01:10:865 (3,5) - add finishes at the beginning of them - Too many finishes makes me go bleh.

[Insane]
00:21:591 (5,6,7,8,9,10) - same as Hard. reduce volume a bit~ -
00:40:195 (1) - adjust spacing to make triangle? - Haha yes!
http://puu.sh/IhvN
00:45:893 (3) - add newcombo to warn change of SV? - I think this should be okay to read.
00:56:452 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - same as Hard - Added a gradual increase.
01:10:865 (1,1) - add finishes at the beginning - Nah.
01:23:267 (8,9,10,11,12) - kinda hard for me to hit.. it'd be better to decrease spacing a bit - I can hit it just fine (the motion I mean xD) and I like it, so I'll keep it ^^

nice map, good luck! - Thanks!

Dark Fang wrote:

Hai~
from Fang Team's Queue
Let's go

[Kinomi's Taiko]

00:43:547 ~ 00:44:552 - why don't you follow vocal? I don't see why I should. Taiko is meant to follow the drums and beats, not vocals. So everything is currently okay in that part, so no changes, sorry.

good maps :3
good luck

Have a good time

Melophobia wrote:

mp3quality is so poor imo, try to find better one - I got this from the episode though... I'll see if I can get a better one.

Nidert wrote:

[General]
Since it's an opening, maybe video? (Derp, didn't read your first post. Well, w/e xD)
[Easy]
00:03:993 (1) - Maybe end it the spinner at 00:05:669 - and add a slider at 00:06:005 - like this

SPOILER

but maybe since it's an easy, it's better the way it is. - It's probably better, to have more time to react to the next note
00:45:893 (1) - I'd much rather have it placed at 00:45:558 - but as the thing above, since it's an easy it may be too early :l - Idk, I like it xD And yeah, Easy~

[Normal]
00:03:993 (1) - Well I won't go on about this, but I still think the spinner should end at 00:05:669 - and then have a note added at 00:06:005 - - xD Keeping for now.
00:45:633 - This one feels kind of forced, it would be better if you'd remove it. - You mean the triple? I think it should be alright.
00:45:558 (1,2,3) - This might be too difficult for a normal, maybe if you remove the second one it would be better. - It's one of those parts I want the feel of having to click a lot, because it's the end of the build-up to the chorus Well, I'll remove it if it poses a problem, but keeping it for now~
00:56:284 (1,2,3) - ^ - ^

[Hard]
00:03:155 (5) - This sounds very weird, maybe you should replace it with a triple or a note that goes from 00:03:155 - to 00:03:323 - - Trying to keep streams away from Hard as much as possible, so only 1 part of the map has a stream, really. Not quite sure how to fix this though. Tried reducing volume a bit, if that's better.
00:03:993 (1) - You know the drill. - :p
00:18:072 (1,2) - Sup with these funny looking sliders? - They are totemo kool.
00:21:591 (4) - Remove the last repeat. - Hah, yes why not xD
00:22:094 (1,2,3,4) - This part can be very confusing while playing, I'd recommend removing the repeat on the first slider and add a note on 00:22:429 - - I'll keep it in mind, but no changes for now.

SPOILER

00:24:776 (1,2,3) - I would say it for this one too, but it's easier to read since there is no fast repeat slider before it. - :p
00:56:452 (3) - Remove the last repeat. - Yesh.

[Insane]
I love this map as it is, so to find faults for it is really hard :3 -
00:04:329 (1) - Why not begin the spinner at 00:04:329 (1) - - You probably copied the time when you had the spinner selected xD But yeah, starting the spinner here because that's where I hear that sound starting (that sound being very descriptive)
00:26:452 (7,8) - Instead of ending the slider at 00:26:452 (7) - it plays better with ending it at 00:26:619 - - Nah, 1/4 <3

Well, hopefully this helped in someway xD - It was, Thanks

Mikarunoel131 wrote:

Hi =D - Hi~

Here I am from my modding queue ^^


General:

Nothing =)


Please remember I am only making suggestions but please try them out and when you like them than I mae a good job ^^


Easy:

Question : Is it allowed to use so many different spacings in an Easy ? Never saw that befor. - We'll see xD I just find that as long as the diffspacingchanges doesn't really feel forced, they should be allright.

00:27:457 suggestion http://puu.sh/Iqwx if you make it put a finish at the start o lideer 5 and a whistle at the end and at start and end of slider 6 whistle .
Sounds good and looks good ^^ - I like funnylooking sliders~
00:40:195 put first combo on middle line for same spacing and than like this ? http://puu.sh/IqDJ - I didn't quite understand this
00:49:245 put combo 3 until 5 like spacing is. It looks good either, dunno why u use spacing 1,06 - 1,07. - Well, to make the blanketting better xD
01:00:306 ^ - ^
01:09:524 why use spacing 1,09 ? http://puu.sh/IqHN the orignal spacing u used looks good there, too. - Eh, good question. Fixed.
01:19:748 put end of slider 2 exactly in end of first slider. - Sigh, I'll work on this more in a bit xD
01:21:088 put end of slider 3 exactly in end of slider 2. - ^
01:22:429 ^ same like befor - ^

That is it for Easy ^w^


Normal

00:15:055 ( combo 4 and 5 )Put them like this ? http://puu.sh/IqJN - They're slightly shifted because of stacking in-game.
00:22:429 make them like spacing is ? http://puu.sh/IqL0 looks almost like befor to me. - I think this is fine~
00:30:820 until 00:36:843 are jumps allowed in Normal and a spacing like that ? There are more changing spacing sometimes but i don`t know if that has to be changed. - I think patterned small jumps like these should be allright, as they're intuitive. Well, I'll keep them until people nudge me xD

That is it for Normal ^^


Hard

Only one thing to say =D
01:10:195 I like that pattern x3 http://puu.sh/IqP5 - haha, Thanks xD

Nothing more x3 It is a great ^^


Insane

00:21:591 new combo ?
00:32:150 ^
01:07:345 ^
01:23:267 ^
^Stream NC's, so I didn't change any, as I like it this way xD
That is it =D

I like the song and the beatmap x3 Good Luck ^^ - thanks

Aleks719 wrote:

General
Turn off letterboxes in all diffs. You don't have a breaks + you will add video - Done
things like this are forbidden: - Will fix when I need to re-adjust offset


Hard
00:20:083 (3,4,5) - 1,0x spacing seems strange here - Changed to 1,1x Should look better now~

Easy
00:45:893 (1) - i'd remove this note - Meh, I just like the feel of it for some reason xD So yeah, if possible, I'd like to keep it~

Philippines wrote:

I'm guessing a fast rank ~ On the other hand, please tell me a reason if you don't agree on my suggestions. - Hi~ Well, I do want this to be ranked soon, but well, if I need to, I'll use the time

General

1. Your source should be "Sword Art Online", not "SWORD ART ONLINE". - Isn't this fixed already?
   
   
2. Folder seems clean. Less worries ^^

Easy

1. This diff would look better with AR 3. Try it and see if it's better. - Ok.
   
   
2. 00:03:993 (1) - This spinner I believe is misplaced. I highly suggest that you should start your spinner on 00:03:658 so that this spinner will flow smoothly with the ascending volume effect on your song. - Well, that's the thing. I believe the ascending volume effect basically starts at 00:03:993 :p
   
   
3. 00:12:709 (3) - I'm not really sure if you're trying to make this slider a mini beat blanket for the previous note. If you are, it's not looking good. What about move the 3rd point 2 grids to the right? Looks better. - It is a mini-blanked. If you meant the 2nd point, thenn changed, if not, then nope, because the 3rd point would look weird xD
   
   
4. 00:24:440 (3) - The spacing is between the notes of this circle is not consistent. Please fix this little problem. This suggestion also applies to the note in 00:26:452 (2). - Moved 00:24:105 (2) closer, as well as 00:26:787 (3).
   
   
5. 00:46:228 (1) - If you will look closely, this slider is not symmetrical. Moreover, the slider doesn't even look great for my perspective. Try to make a perfect circle out of this one. I think it would be better. - Scaled it a bit. Should be a bit more symmetrical now. The shape will stay though.
   
   
6. 00:51:591 (1,1,1,1) - New combo abuse is not really appropriate for an Easy diff in my opinion. I suggest use (1,2,1,2) combo pattern instead, although (1,2,3,4,) would be better. - I want these to be consistent over all the difficulties, so I'm keeping this.
   
   
7. 00:56:954 (1) - The same opinion I told you about the slider in 00:46:228. Please fix this one and make sure they're symmetrical for better gameplay. - Did the same as earlier
   
   
8. 01:02:317 (1,1,1,1) - Another combo abuse >< Try (1,2,1,2) or (1,2,3,4,) instead. - Same as earlier.
   
   
9. 01:07:010 (1) - Fix the spacing here for better gameplay. They don't look good. - Herpderp fix xD
   
   
10. 01:09:692 (2) - Move the 2nd point one grid left and the 3rd point one grid up for better slider blanket. - Done

Normal

1. 00:01:982 (2) - Inconsistent spacing. Fix this one for better gameplay. - This is totally fine to read when you're playing.
   
   
2. 00:03:491 (1) - This spinner ended so late in my opinion. I highly suggest that you try to find a way to move the note on 00:06:340 near to the center so that the players can hit it easily even after they finish spinning. - 00:06:340 (1) is already near the center, and putting it closer would make a overlap from the hitburst from the spinner.
   
   
3. 00:14:049 (3,4,5) - This beat blanket needs more improvement. Try to make it look like this. - Click me
   
   
4. 00:18:072 (1) - I don't think a new combo for this note is not necessary. Please remove it. - Not necessary, but I like it and it wont hinder gameplay, so I'm keeping it.
   
   
5. 00:32:820 ~ 00:37:848 - The "slow down" on in this section is too slow. I think x.7~x.8 would fit this one. - Yes, 0.7x~0.8x would probably fit too, but same goes for 0.5x imo.
   
   
6. 00:51:591 (1,1,1,1) - Another one of your new combo things. Choose between these two combo patterns: (1,2,1,2) / (1,2,3,4). - Same reasoning as before.
   
   
7. 01:02:317 (1,1,1,1) - Another weird new combo pattern. ^ - ^
   
   
8. 01:23:435 (5) - Weird ending. I highly suggest you change this one with a 1/2 slider. It plays better. Don't forget to move your spinner 1/2 too if you followed this suggestion. - Heh, why not~

Hard

1. 00:48:910 (5) - The part of this slider is already off grid. Please try to move it away from the side. - Off grid, yeah, but it's not off screen, so it's fine
   
   
2. 00:59:133 (5) - Fix spacing by moving this note 1 grid down. I know it's nazi, but it doesn't look good on gameplay. - Moved (5) 2 grids down and (6) 1 grid down. Should be fine now.
   
   
3. To be honest, this diff is a bit perfect but let's try to look on the other side. I'm not really sure about your spacing. Don't try to think that this one is a huge problem. But the whole diff's spacing ranges from x1.0 to 1.25 (please tell me if I'm wrong). I hope you can try to make the spacing between the notes consistent. I know it will take some time but fixing this will make your map more readable and fun to play. (: - The map is already readable. It's not like different spacing like this, especially in a hard diff, would be unreadable.

Insane

1. 00:24:357 (4,5) - Move (4) 1 grid left and (5) 2 grids right. Nazi lol ^^ - This is supposed to be straight
   
   
2. 00:28:798 (1) - There is a great opportunity of turning this slider into a beat blanket. Do it for the sake of better gameplay ^^. - Already blankets previous slider.
   
   
3. 00:29:301 (2) - Weird structure of a slider. Also, the point part is off grid. Fix this one please. - Not offscreen, and the structure is just one of my preferences^^
   
   
4. 00:29:804 (3) - Fix this beat blanket effect. Doesn't look good. On the other hand, is this meant to be a blanket or not? lol - It's supposed to be in the middleground between blanketing both 00:28:798 (1) and 00:30:306 (4).
   
   
5. 00:34:161 (4) - Copy this one on 00:35:167 then press Ctrl+H and Ctrl+R. Trust me, It'll look better. - Lol, done.
   
   
6. 01:01:815 (4,5,6) - Please try to make the spacing consistent on this part. They're so hard to hit imo. - Really? I can do them just fine though x.x I'll keep this for now, since it's the same as 00:51:088 (4,5,6)
   
   
7. 01:22:429 (4) - Weird slider curve. Why not copy the slider 01:21:926 (2) instead and do a Ctrl+R? - It already is, the (4) is a copy of (2). I did a ctrl+R on the (2), then did it again to fix this. Probably okay now.
   
   
8. 01:23:267 (8,9,10,11,12) - What about this pattern instead? I think it's better to start the stream in the top part. - Nah, the pattern is going counter-clockwise ^^
   
   
9. Btw, your HP Drain for this diff is a pain >< Try to reduce it by 2. :O - Let them burn!! Well not really, but I don't think the HP-drain really is an issue here xP Also, reducing HP by even 1 tick would result in star ratings rating Insane easier than Hard xD

End of my Mod | PM me back after you fix my suggestions for a recheck (: - Ok, Thanks

MMzz wrote:

boink http://puu.sh/Iya3
taiko map for u

Aleks719 wrote:

General
Turn off letterboxes in all diffs. You don't have a breaks + you will add video
things like this are forbidden: