Flake wrote:

Hello, I'll be doing a Normal Mod!
I'll be modding Hard for this diff

General

note: All objects mentioned below are from the Hard Difficulty

The timing seems pretty accurate, however, after listening through the track, I had a feeling the timing is slightly off. It seems to be apparent when I was listening to the track and encountered 00:43:900 (3) - 's clap hitsound. If you listen at Playback Rate of 25%, You can hear that the burst of sound is somewhat, earlier.

From my perspective, the offset would be more appropriate to be on 1,150-1,165 or somewhere near that. You can see if these ones (00:43:929 (3) - ) relate to the song in a more sensible way. Changed offset to 1184

Hard

- I've been wondering myself why are there many objects ending on blue ticks, because usually objects would end on white or red ticks. There could be a problem regarding timing, or regarding the offset of the song, as mentioned above.

- the sound on 00:01:737 (2,3) - and 00:03:237 (2) - are the same, but a slider is used on 00:03:237 - instead of a circle. I want to push this one through because 00:01:737 (2,3) - supports the music more than 00:03:237 (2) - does. I have decided to change the sounds to emphasize on the second combo
You could use a design similar to this


There seems to be a lot of things coming up in the start, such as 00:04:929 - and 00:06:429 - Though I don't encourage mapping these because consistency-wise, it's random. If you want to emphasize the sounds, you can emphasize them by adding new combos and other stuff. And 00:05:679 is a pretty long break. You've mapped that part on the Insane so, I think mapping that one on the Hard too is better. I wish to ignore all of this together, maybe I will wait and see.

I would do a pattern like this on 00:06:991 (1,1) - because the instrument changes a note on 00:07:929 - and 00:09:429 -


There are more things that are surrounding 00:09:991 (1) - , so I'd like to cover those. There's the whirring sound (or whatever you call it) on 00:09:991 - , though I don't think you need to do something extraordinary to make it stand out since it also fades after a few seconds, and if mapped could make the same thing that happens on 00:03:991, which seems to be following something else. I also want to point out that 00:10:929 - has a piano sound, and it's the piano sound is mapped on 00:11:491 (2) - , so as a matter of fact you could also map 00:10:929 - to help it compliment the song better.

For the slider on 00:09:991 - , you can try this design


00:15:429 - I don't think this should be left unmapped. 00:16:179 - onwards follow the guitar sound, so mapping the guitar sounds before 00:16:179 - should make it consistent. It's there as a short break for the player.

00:35:679 (3) - doesn't particularily follows the vocals. Suggest that you should place 00:35:304 (2) - 's sliderend on 00:35:679 - . if I put the reverse there it will also change the flow of the section, the circle is there to keep the 1/2 note gap flow

00:43:929 (3) - visually looks like it is sticking to 00:43:554 (2) -. 00:46:554 (2) - doesn't directly seems to be sticking to 00:46:929 (3) - , but it makes it a fact that the spacing is inconsistent with 00:43:554 (2,3) - and 00:46:554 (2,3) -. I also want to mention that 00:49:554 (2,3) - is similar to the two, but visually looks cleaner and same with 00:49:554 (2,3) - . Give 00:43:554 (2,3) - and 00:46:554 (2,3) - similar visual appeal/spacing like 00:49:554 (2,3) - and 00:50:866 (2,3) -

I can see that 00:53:866 (2,3,4,5,6) - is emphasized by the slider velocity, though I do think it's better emphasizing it through spacing. You can emphasize it with both, but I personally believe that people are more accustomed to lower sv short returning sliders. You could change the sv to 1 or 1.25.

not sure what happened but, 01:04:179 - seems no need for the change in sv. If anything, it should be receiving more emphasis than the previous parts since it's entering a kiai time, a part where many things would stand out. I would use 1 sv on 01:04:179 - since it makes it more enticing to the player and it create a visible entrance to the kiai. noticeably slower SV before kiai = more emphasis the on kiai

I don't have any complaints regarding the kiai times since it seems that it's entrance and exit are really consistent. Good job on those!

01:32:491 (3) - looks pretty odd, in my opinion. 01:31:179 (1,2) - are copy-pasted, and 01:32:491 (3) - seems like it's trying to imitate the copy-pasted ones. Maybe make it a red-anchored slider or something less-similar to 01:31:179 (1,2) - . Something like 01:28:179 (1) - would do.

01:39:616 (5,6,7) - overlaps 01:40:741 (2) - in an awkward way. Maybe having the slider end of 01:39:804 (7) - stack onto 01:40:741 (2) - 's slider end?

01:45:147 - you can add a spinner here because you're following the guitar and the guitar has a long sound on 01:45:054 - and if mapped with circles or sliders, would be awkward. Have it end on 01:46:179 - because after the guitars, you start following the vocals. There isn't any particular vocal sounds on 01:46:179 (1) - , so I think it's okay to. Something like this, i'd say: with your suggestion the spinner will end on the first circle of the next combo, which is a very unqiue sound. I prefer it to be circle. the distance on the timeline is too short to add a spinner according to the ranking guildeline.

z

02:08:866 (2,3,4,5,6) - I've mentioned about this part already, so I won't go in depth with it for this one. Lower sv, other way of emphasizing it.

02:19:179 - I've mentioned this too so, yeah. Higher sv

02:47:679 - to 02:48:804 - you can insert a slider here

I checked other parts and it didn't seem to have any huge issues, so I guess that'll wrap the Hard difficulty Normal Mod.

Good luck on the map!

thank you for modding no texts = fixed

IceKalt wrote:

Hey~
Coming from my Q

[Insane]
- 00:03:996 (1,2) - idk why you make the DS here bigger than 00:02:496 (1,2) - / 00:11:496 (1,2) -
- 00:09:621 - maybe consider making a triple here (and 00:11:121 - )
- 00:18:715 (5,6) - idk if a double is fitting here because there is only a sound at (6)
- 00:28:746 (2,3,1) - something went wrong with your stacking here~
- 00:31:934 (3,4) - /00:37:934 (3,4) - fix blanket
- 00:43:934 (1,2) - ^
- 00:51:434 (1) - blanket this with 00:51:996 (2) -
- 01:16:184 (1,2,3) - mybe use the same DS as above
- place 01:22:371 (2) - so the flollow lines overlap perfectly
- 01:28:184 (1,2,3,4) - blanket off
- 01:30:434 (2,3,4,5,6,7) - ^
- 01:40:746 (4,5,6) - stay consistent with theese pls~
- (so many blankets in this diff are like so slightly off hat they arent really worth mentioning but you should fix them nontheless (like this:01:56:684 (1,2) - ))
- 02:22:559 (3,4) - idk if this is a mistake but the DS is WAY to low - (i think you can compare 02:22:184 (1,2,3,4) - to 01:07:184 (1,2,3,4) - )
- 02:45:434 (2,3,4,5,6,7) - as above
- overlap 03:10:934 (1,1) - like you did the rest in this section
- 03:15:246 (3,4) - blanket (pls)
- 03:55:184 (3,4,5,6,7,8) - as above
- I would end spinner here 04:15:809 - because you map the e-guitar there and until this poind it is fading away with a huge sound after this the e-guitar isnt there anymore

That was it from me
Gl with you set and have a nice day

Bz EsKa wrote:

Hey I'm really new to modding (2nd only) so please don't mind me if I do huge mistake (and please tell me why, that way I can improve ).
Anyway the song is nice and the mapping too so I want it ranked asap *-* (also, excuse me for my bad english, I try to ba as understandable as possible)


Normal
I think the map is really cool but there's way too much of "waiting for a note" moment, and that break the map :'( When the vocal is inactive,
so is the map. I also use these silence to reset my mapping in case of applying mods so I don't have to remap the entire thing because it's glued together by DS snap. (still by the noob me)

I) 00:41:494 - Put a long slider here instead of the simple circle (maybe we can say the same about 00:29:494 ).That way players won't loose track of the timing imo (and to not stop the player too often)
00:57:057 - Add a circle to fit the song like you did earlier
01:04:182 - I think there is somthing cool to map, I find that sad to break here
II) 01:28:932 - I think the voice is more important than the simple drum song behind, even more for this difficulty, maybe make a slider last at the end of the syllable (01:30:057) and ignore the drum for this one ? :3
III) 01:30:432 + 01:30:807 - put 2 circle to start the map (and once again to not stop the player too long )
01:58:557 - Even if I understand your choice, in view of the difficulty, I would have continue the map here
02:16:744 - I would have add a circle here (dunno, its maybe too difficult for the level? )
02:18:244 - do the slider earlier (and that free 2x 1/2beat right before the break to do whatever you want) because the slider sound weird if we put it after the syllable
02:35:494 - 02:36:057 - same as the I), it'll be smoother that way imo
02:45:432 - 02:45:807 - fill them plz (a little caprice :p)
02:43:932 - same as the II)
02:45:432 + 02:45:807 - same as III)
02:47:494 - same as I)
03:55:182 + 03:55:557 - same as III)
03:57:994 - Start the slider here and end him at the same point he is right now (03:58:369)

After, for the other difficulties, can't point anything that disturb me even a little, except for that : (hard)
00:44:494 (4,5) - Something is odd with the timing of this part, but I can't say anything to help >< sorry seems fine to me

Regarding most of your suggestions on Normal, I would have done them too if not for Normal restrictions and if I did all of you suggested it wouldn't be Normal. There might be too much waiting in the map but it's not like Insane and Hard are any better, they are just masked with spinners. I cannot do that on Normal due to Normal spinner guideline lol

Thank you for modding!

And absolutly nothing to say about insane who feel insanely good to play by me
Sorry to give you such poor advice
Hope this get ranked fast, bye ♥

LimePixel wrote:

NM request from my queue.

[Normal]
General:
-New combos seem non-consistent.

-00:28:182 (3) - Curve (a small amount) clockwise so the curveline from 00:27:807 (2) leading into the slider is better. (10 degrees?) I don't understand what you mean lol
-00:57:244 (4) - Here the overlap with 00:58:932 (2) might be too confusing for a Normal diff. Suggestion: Ctrl+J this object and move above 00:58:182 (1)

Example of what it might look like

I will change this when another person points this out
-02:34:182 (1) - Consistency with slider shapes (02:33:057 (1) ) okay
-03:25:369 (3) - Replace with circle at the position of the slider head? (since these are 3 consecutive sliders with 1/2 gaps between each other. keep newer players in mind) 3 consecutive 1/2 rhythms are fine as long as they are not active
-03:27:432 (3) - Either make this a straight slider or make 03:25:932 (1,2) the same or a similar slider shape as 03:27:432 (3) k

[Insane]
-00:28:744 (2) - Imo this slider is unnecessary and should be a circle. The sound doesn't warrant the extended slider You're right why did I even put the slider there lmao
-00:54:619 (6,7) - Make closer together so they're actually touching. The spacing between them is too big even for an insane. If they're touching, you're removing the chance that the player might sliderbreak I can buffer the slider should the need arise
-01:03:807 (7,8,1) - While this spacing is valid, I'd space 01:03:807 (7,8) a lot less than 01:03:994 (8,1) to emphasize the strong sound at 01:04:182 (1), and the new combo.nerfed 7 a bit
-01:23:869 (2) - I see the intent in these object placements but I suggest Ctrl+G here It's intended and I prefer it this way
-02:18:807 (8,9,1) - Same emphasis thing here. Although you've made a slight difference here, it could be bigger nerf a bit
-02:35:494 (5,1) - Make spacing bigger since while playing it indicates that there's a 1/2 gap changed to stacking instead

Hope this helps Thank you for modding!

ulfanirahmi wrote:

Hello... From FunnyA's Moddin Queue

It's Conclusion what i got

General :
Do not use 1/8 beat snap divisor. I suggest you change to 1/4, because it is used for the experienced mapper (On Normal and Hard diff) The map is mapped with 1/4 divisor, it's just shown as 1/8 because one of the circle is snapped on the 1/8 divisor.

Normal.
02:34:182 (1) - Equate this Pattern with that one 02:33:057 (1) be like this mirror, imo alright
00:19:182 (6) - NC
00:21:432 (1) - Missing NC
00:22:182 (3) - NC
00:27:057 (1) - Missing NC
00:28:182 (3) - NC
02:56:494 (3) - Overlap.. you can change this position by click this object, then you press ctrl + J imo it's better I will consider changing this later.
03:13:932 (6) - NC
03:21:432 (1,1) - Missing NC
03:22:932 (2) - NC
03:24:057 (1) - Missing NC
03:34:557 (2,2) - Overlap It's fine

All NC mods applied, thanks.

Hard
00:43:182 - add one object here Yeah I forgot
03:13:182 (1) - Missing NC
03:13:932 (3) - NC
03:14:682 (1) - Missing NC
03:22:932 (5) - NC imo it's better
03:24:057 - Missing NC

All NC mods applied, thanks.

Overall difficulty should be 6 Reduced the OD a bit but it shouldn't be at 6 due to speed of the song
Approach rate between 6 and 7 IMO it's better you should change it! The song is too fast to have AR7 I will keep it like this

Metadata :
Please Add the Tag in your Song Set Up (eg name or nickname artist, album name, track release year, etc.)
Turn off or remove the checklist on Widescreen Support and Letterbox during Break (Advanced) in Normal and Insane diff. Because it is turned on your map that it has Storyboard. IIRC, you don't add stuff that already appears in other boxes in the tag (artist's names, title, etc) I will add album name later, though I think adding release year is unnecessary.

And don't forget to Try checking again on AiMod if you still repair them... Press (Ctrl + Shift + A)
Lastly.. I'm so sorry if I gave you a little advice (especially insane diff). But, if any of my suggestions that you do not change it, no problem. And it depends on you whether it's good for you or not.

Maybe ... that's all I can modding your map. Hopefully your map can be ranked.
So, Fighting ^^ Thank you for modding!

YashaPlay wrote:

Hello from my Modding Queue!

Normal

Normal really seems good!

Hard

00:28:744 (2,3,4) - Maybe some this https://puu.sh/wHXkS/01a56050f6.png ? I think it's the same thing lol
00:37:932 (3) - Some this need! okay
02:19:182 (1,1) - Need break time! oops I forgot
02:30:994 (7,1) - I don't like it maybe some it If I implemented that it would make inconsistent spacing and that's not good ?
Also looks good!

Insane

wow Insane so nice! thanks!

You need some Easy diff,and this set will be great! too much work xD
Thanks! Thank you for modding!

Naotoshi wrote:

[insane]
00:15:432 (1) - y not triple into 1/8th repeat lo ayy

00:21:057 (3) - if ur gonna switch off of the guitar to emphasize this then make it a jump at least rearranged and removed the triple

00:22:182 (1) - also skipping this now is weird cuz 00:21:432 (1,2,3) - is clearly following it rearranged and removed the triple

00:33:619 (6,1) - seems a bit drastic contrast wise, even though it has a piano buildup oo

01:10:744 (4,5) - ew diagonal sliders that r curved this much look ugly af rip and fixed

00:58:932 (2,3,4) - wrong snap btw this is 1/6th Dumbed down rhythms xd

01:04:744 - wuld b cool to map really minimalistic rhythm here for better contrast - i think a break sucks for that cuz it makes you zone out instead of noticing the lower density it shall be done on 01:04:182 (1) - and 02:19:182 - . I'm not mapping at 03:28:932 - because it's different

01:15:807 (1,2) - these 1s should be lined up with 01:15:057 (3,4) - cuz vocals right I don't understand what you mean, so Im waiting before actually tweaking anything on this lol

01:24:619 (4,5,6,1) - dont rly think 456 is distinguished enough frm the vocals, you could ctrl g it and make smaller spacing remapped

01:34:182 (1) - aaaa aaaa

01:57:057 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - rly big smaller now

02:30:807 (1,2) - same as before Not attempting to fix this yet

02:41:869 (2,3,4) - do u rly need this massive spacing here reduced

03:22:744 (5,6) - also kinda verspaced imo, ctrl g works better done

03:30:733 - same about mapping the break I mapped the other 2 breaks but I skipped this one because it's different and it's near unmappable due to extremely low density compared to other breaks

looks quite rankable ngl Thanks!! w

[hard]
00:20:869 (2) - make this 2 circles, it looks like a 1/2 spacing if everything is sliders I assume you mean the slider before as well? I have changed it to 2 1/1 circle ye

00:28:088 - triple plz done

pixel verlaps are aids raise the ds of this sectin a bit to avoid them plz fixed the overlapped 1/1

01:39:807 (5) - triple here at least plz k

01:39:807 (5,1) - this much undermapping is just tilt gotta sell the Insane somehow

01:42:994 (6,1) - same If I do this it would have 2 consecutive active 1/4 rhythms, that would be quite tough to play, so I'm still considering on this one.
looks like a normal lol

02:42:994 (3,1) - aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa FORGIVE ME

03:00:432 (2,3,1) - should b 3/4 snap imo I changed to 3/4 slider, that's what you meant right? If not RIP

03:13:932 (1,2) - its better t put a 1/1 repeat on this kinda thing cuz the vocal doesnt really change at all mmm that would leave a 1/1 gap after that

03:37:369 (4) - u make this important thing a repeat slider but then 03:40:369 (5,6) - is circles D= just make it all circles Here comes the Concept(tm): During the Kiai, vocal is the focus and mapped through different pairs of patterns. 03:40:369 (5,6,7) - the (5) is not vocal but I decide to make it clickable to keep the momentum and intensity of the Kiai. Your suggestion will also apply to every parts of the Kiais so me changing only on this timeline will only make inconsistency.

I went and tried your suggestion and applied it on every parts, the star rating just went Insane (almost literally). Due to the significant difficulty increase and what I discussed above, I have made the decision to revert it back to what it was.

04:11:494 (2,3,4) - will be misread fr sure Misread no more

[normal]

00:57:244 (4,2) - yea uh dont do this on normal lol ok then

01:34:182 - u should ue a bit more circles in this sectin, with 1/1 or occasional 1/2 gaps; constant sliders is not differentiaated from the rest f the map despite the song being ttally different I just couldn't find the place to put down circles tbh, This could easily be more dense in terms of rhythm density than the Kiai as well. I also try to limit the use of 1/2 rhythm outside of the Kiai. So yeah adding more circles will make some combos simply become
a bit too long and I cannot remove other objects without it affecting the overall quality of the map, I believe.

02:33:057 (1) - remove nc woops

map the guitar more closely in the top diffs in the parts i highlighted, get 1 or 2 mods from decent modders, and call me back Thank you so much for modding!! I will make sure to improve the mapset as best as I can.

JeirYagtama wrote:

boi u can just straight out pm me ingame for a mod~
i Like ur song choices sooo yea XD

Normal

01:27:244 (6) - hmmm this slider kinda ends a bit too early since theres still a vocal sound in the next white tick 01:27:807 -
either extend the slider or add a note whatever suit's your taste XD Too many consecutive 1/2 gap, can't
03:39:994 (6) - ^ This is actually not intended
03:51:994 (6) - ^ Too many consecutive 1/2 gap, can't
02:18:432 (5) - would suggest to move the slider to the last red tick since theres vocal sound that can be mapped and also extend the slider to the white tick if ur going in this route xd limited by 1/2 gap
03:07:275 (1) - would suggest to end this spinner to the last red tick since it the sound ur mapping ends there instead of the blue tick I'm pretty sure it ends on a blue tick

Hard

00:39:619 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - kind of a nazi mod but can you atleast space the pattern out a littlleee bit more? sure
00:41:682 (6) - hmm also I kinda think you can just remove this since there isnt any sound to supoort it if its for filler rhythm then ok but if its not welllppp theres my suggestion I think it is fine
01:31:557 (2,1) - kind of an ugly overlapI hope no one points any readability issue
03:36:994 (3,1) - nazi mod again srry but fix thy stack thx thanks
boi I like your mapping on this diff gj~

Insane

01:33:432 (5) - NC perhaps? why not I guess the combo is getting long
02:22:932 (3) - ^ seems unnecessary
03:58:182 (5) - ^ why not I guess the combo is getting long
02:26:494 (1,2,3) - kinda would suggest to ctrl g them seperately since 02:26:119 (5,1) - kinda doesnt flow well imo It's a bit harsh but I will leave there
02:53:307 (7,8) - why is the spacing so low all of a sudden? I hope it is better now.
03:00:057 (1) - would suggest to delete this and add 2 circles instead since 03:00:182 - the guitar sound starts here I dumbed down the rhythm
03:16:932 (1) - slider kinds of ends with a clickable note you know what to do when ur goin to accept this mod xd It happens on a low intensity section, making everything completely clickable is not a good idea here

Mutual pls thx sure
gl~ Thank you for modding!

yShadowXOP_ wrote:

Loli's Mod Queue

NM

yShadowXOP_ wrote:

Insane:

1. 00:58:182 (1) - stack the reverse at the end of the slider 00:59:869 (2) - sure
2. 01:09:244 - could be a stream here in my opinion I prioritize vocal
3. 01:15:432 (1) - i think NC here is unnecessary It's a different pattern of sound
4. 01:18:994 - circle ? no vocal
5. 01:30:338 - i think there should be a circle here, because there is sound in the blue tick there is a sound there but I don't want to emphasize it
6. 01:39:525 - circle ? emphasis reasons
7. 02:05:869 (6) - NC? Nope as this section follows 2 downbeat 1 NC rule
8. 02:30:432 (1) - i think NC here is unnecessary same as I stated above it's from a different pattern of sound
9. 02:53:682 (1) - i think this slider should start here 02:53:493 (8) - Then it will extend past the downbeat
10. 03:00:057 (1) - should be a slider here not a reverse because it starts on the 1/3 tick 03:00:182 - I simplified the rhythms as it's actually not 1/3 the guitar is off
11. 03:11:307 (2) - NC
12. 03:12:432 (2) - ^
13. 03:18:432 (5) - ^ I see no need for these
14. 03:20:682 - triple ? Low Intensity in song is reflected with Low Density in mapping
15. 03:54:994 - circle Emphasis reason
16. 03:55:088 - ^ same

I hope my mod has helped you in some way

Good Luck~

Thank you for modding!

1. AR5.4 is a bit too high considering the density and the bpm. a simple 5 will do
2. 00:18:807 (5) - 00:24:807 (5) - delete these and extend 00:18:244 (4) - 00:24:244 (4) - by half a beat. Mapping to the guitar is cool but imo since the rhythm is slightly complex it's better to single-layer map the guitar for better readability
3. 01:36:244 (4,5) - 01:42:244 (4,5) - ^
4. 00:43:182 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,1,2,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3) - this part is the only part that is mapped to the instruments (except for pure instrumental sections ofc). Ideally this should be mapped to the vocals instead for the sake of consistency and stuff but with the music change and stuff this is borderline okayish. However, this tiny part 00:49:932 (2,3,4,5) - being mapped to the vocals is weird af. Map this whole part to the vocals or map the small one to the instruments.
5. 01:12:619 (6) - end this on the white tick instead. The vocal stops there and there's snare on the white tick as well
6. 01:24:619 (6) - ^
7. 01:18:057 (1) - 2 circles. compare this with 01:11:494 (3,4,5) - 01:13:744 (2,3) -
8. 03:42:807 (1) - 02:33:057 (1) - ^
9. 01:25:182 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - 01:13:182 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - why is the rhythm choice inconsistent lmao. just stick with the 01:13:182 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - ; it's better
10. 02:40:182 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - 02:28:182 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - ^
11. 03:49:932 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - ^
12. 01:19:182 (1) - 02:34:182 (1) - remove nc. reason: 03:42:807 (1,2,3,4,5) -
13. 02:49:182 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - when did you start putting nc every 3 measures? just stick with the 2 measures 1 nc thing for consistency and that combo length is a bit too long
14. 03:21:432 (1) - remove nc. Combos on 03:19:932 (1,1,2) - are too short lmao there's no need to nc here
15. 04:00:994 (4,5) - 04:06:994 (6,7) - same

CrystilonZ wrote:

This is gonna be in english so nao can read it

03:10:932 - Add a redline here to reset the measure. not really necessary but eeh idk
Alright

BG height is over limit. The height limit right now is 1080 pixels. Though the RC says this but it's someone being lazy(hi loctav). The actual limit is 1080p


[Normal]

1. AR5.4 is a bit too high considering the density and the bpm. a simple 5 will do alright
2. 00:18:807 (5) - 00:24:807 (5) - delete these and extend 00:18:244 (4) - 00:24:244 (4) - by half a beat. Mapping to the guitar is cool but imo since the rhythm is slightly complex it's better to single-layer map the guitar for better readability mm
3. 01:36:244 (4,5) - 01:42:244 (4,5) - ^
4. 00:43:182 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,1,2,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3) - this part is the only part that is mapped to the instruments (except for pure instrumental sections ofc). Ideally this should be mapped to the vocals instead for the sake of consistency and stuff but with the music change and stuff this is borderline okayish. However, this tiny part 00:49:932 (2,3,4,5) - being mapped to the vocals is weird af. Map this whole part to the vocals or map the small one to the instruments. made it all instrumental
5. 01:12:619 (6) - end this on the white tick instead. The vocal stops there and there's snare on the white tick as well I switch back to the instrument
6. 01:24:619 (6) - ^
7. 01:18:057 (1) - 2 circles. compare this with 01:11:494 (3,4,5) - 01:13:744 (2,3) - This is slightly different, so you can't really compare them
8. 03:42:807 (1) - 02:33:057 (1) - ^
9. 01:25:182 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - 01:13:182 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - why is the rhythm choice inconsistent lmao. just stick with the 01:13:182 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - ; it's better well that rhythm choice already repeats itself 3 times if I do that again it will b e 6 times, I think a little bit of variety is nice as well, plus I also map these differently on all diffs
10. 02:40:182 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - 02:28:182 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - ^
11. 03:49:932 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - ^
12. 01:19:182 (1) - 02:34:182 (1) - remove nc. reason: 03:42:807 (1,2,3,4,5) - k
13. 02:49:182 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - when did you start putting nc every 3 measures? just stick with the 2 measures 1 nc thing for consistency and that combo length is a bit too long switched back
14. 03:21:432 (1) - remove nc. Combos on 03:19:932 (1,1,2) - are too short lmao there's no need to nc here ok
15. 04:00:994 (4,5) - 04:06:994 (6,7) - same

It's late so this is all
gl~ Thank you for modding!

SrSkyPlayer wrote:

General
can you resize your bg? I mean 1702x1200 isn't a standard aspect ratio, you should have it at least 1280x720 (16:9 ratio)
k it's fine!

Normal
02:55:182 (4,6) - I don't have a good feeling about this because you're just overlapping two distinct sliders and that's what makes this section very messy, maybe consider try another pattern there I don't really understand what you meant here

Hard
02:30:807 (6,7) - maybe ctrl+g? that will cause it to overlap with the 3 circle a bit too fast which will readability issue
02:33:432 (2) - it's touching the hit error, try moving it on a bit k
04:10:182 - I don't feel like ignoring this sound is a good idea because it's a downbeat and very clickable, you should just pull the reverse of this one beat 04:09:807 (1) - and put a circle there 04:10:182 - stacking it with 04:10:369 (2) - done

Insane
00:52:932 (2) - this spacing here is a bit confusing because there's a 1/2 interval between (2) and 00:52:182 (1) - and like before you did a similar spacing 00:50:869 (1,2) - but there's a difference in rhythm. Consider increasing spacing of (2) to make it clear why not I guess
01:07:932 (3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,1) - maybe replacing 01:08:494 (9,10,1) - with 1/4 slider + circle should be better because it will bring more emphasis to the vocal I prefer with the increasing intensity through clickable objects
01:33:057 (2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - I don't feel like these drums are covering something properly. Anyways, that's just me but I think you can use your soft-whistle here as well mm that's a good idea for soft whistle, I will wait and see first
01:40:182 (1) - any reason to ignore the guitar here? or even here 01:43:182 (1) - ? I mean if you are able to follow it, I think you should do that until the end, so replacing 01:40:182 (1) - with a 1/2 slider + 2 1/4 notes and 01:43:182 (1) - making it a 1/2 reverse slider would be better in my opinion. It enters the other section which I consistently map for the entire map
02:07:932 (2) - maybe replacing it with a 1/8 reverse slider should be better I prefer vocal

good luck Thank you for modding!

Asagi wrote:

M4M stuff thingy

Okay lets go!

General stuff

1. I know the BG is has a pink-ish theme feeling but 2 pink combo colour is kinda repetitive to see, I guess removing/changing it to something might be a good idea changed to a new color
2. Ask someone about the metadata, im not good with it but I think there's something wrong, just in case Best I could try http://vgmdb.net/album/63471 it's unofficial site and official (Japanese ayyy) http://nanosizemir.com/cds02/

Insane

1. HP 6 is quite low, which is not "that hard" of a diff, try to make it around HP 7 at least HP drain is not truly dependant of the numberic value, it's calculated by rhythm intesity and NC usage. With how long the final spinner is and how terrifying the map would be with HR. HP 6 is a must
2. I dont get the idea of AR 8.8, I know the bpm is quite low (160) but judging on how it plays, it looks like your "typical Insane kind of diff with AR9" feeling AR 9 normie
3. As for the OD, its relatively high for 4.63 star map, ill change it around 7.5 or something, since this doesnt need to be a hard to accuracy difficulty for a quite chilly song like this The standard for OD has quite raised a bit I still lowered it to 8.2. And this would be considered low tbh I see slower songs for 8.5 OD
4. 00:17:494 (1) - this overlap doesnt really look appealing, you might want to stack that on (2) at least alright
5. 00:21:057 - i get your idea that you mostly follow the guitar but skipping the beat here is a must click, put a note there or whatever slider you want that will hurt the emphasis on the circle imo it's ok to skip the snare a bit
6. 00:26:494 (5) - finish hitsound
7. 00:28:744 (2,3,4) - try to spread this out and make a jump out of it to emphasize the cymbal sound better, also add finish hitsound
8. 00:29:494 (4) - add NC here to indicate the start of the spinner
9. 00:36:619 (7) - again with the awkward not appealing overlap, you might want to make a blanket out of this, or put the previous slider tail on its middle better like you did here 00:32:494 (3,4) - The angle wouldn't allow it without directly tempering the distance emphasis. this looks fine without sliderend.png so yeah it will look like shit on Default skin
10. 00:40:182 (5) - though its not as bad as the previous one i mentioned, but you might want to polish this
11. 00:53:869 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - not sure about the hitsounding here, not REALLY sure, I mean it kinda hurt my ears but it somewhat following the music It sounds perfectly fine with my skin but on Default it's ear bleed which for some reason the default puts drum hitsounds so ridiculously
    loud, I can just add more custom hitsounds I guess.
12. 00:59:213 (3,4) - i think 1/8 slider fits here better but dunno, seems 1/4 is fine too i guess :thinking: Dumbed down the rhythms and it's actually 1/6 I believe
13. 00:59:494 (1) - you probably want to put more spacing and make this a jump to emphasize that cymbal better, thought its at the corner, gonna be hard task to change if thats the case The reverse flow already does plenty
14. 01:01:932 (3,4) - pretty sure you attempting some kind of blanketing here, try to make it better Well I did update after this mod so it's changed now and it's not intended to be blanketed
15. 01:09:432 (1,2) - following the vocals here is kinda...anti-climatic, I dont feel the impact before entering the good part of the song which is kinda boring, you might wanna follow the instrument instead to make it more intensive. Same applies on the similar part, not gonna mention it I prefer vocal
16. 01:30:244 (3) - the stream starts here actually, just put a note after that note It's quiet though but I guess 1/4 slider would do
17. 01:40:182 (1) - if you are actually following the guitar here, there is a stream guitar sound thingy on the middle of slider (red tick) till (2), but dunno, thatll make the part inconsistent but its fine to reconsider I just map the guitar because nothing is active but the moment it enters the section the guitar is overshadowed by the cymbals imo
18. 01:45:057 (8) - NC to indicated the start of slider
19. 02:08:869 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - yea, same as the first one i mentioned that is similar to this, im not REALLY sure
20. 02:58:182 (1) - well, this is awkward, the guitar scratch starts on the red tick. If you feel conflicted, you can try something like this Changed with my solution
21. 03:22:182 (1) - i heard some 1/8 sound thingy around here, but not sure myself I tend to avoid unclear 1/8
22. 03:22:744 (5) - no sound actually exist here actually, you better remove it then make this 03:22:557 (4) - a 3/4 slider instead Filler rhythm xd
23. 03:54:807 (1,2) - you better follow the instrument here instead, for better closing call on that part good call and I went back to change the other parts to make it purely Instrumental, the previous parts are both instrumental and vocal which make it look a bit bad
24. 04:12:338 (1) - its better to map this that a long-ass spinner, though it might get complicated since its like theres a new timing point there, try to ask for timing check Too much work and it would be incredibly boring as well

Hard

1. I think the OD for Hard is kinda high, its like Insane-level of OD, try to decrease it to 6 instead lowered to 6.5

1. 00:21:057 - same as insane, you missed the beat here Intended
2. 00:27:994 (3,4,1) - i think this slider is quite high, its slider body will overlap on hp bar of some skins
3. 00:29:494 (4) - again, same as insane, NC to indicated the start of the spinner
4. 00:29:682 (1) - i think its fine to put this on the blue tick instead Noob might panic and spin a bit early lol
5. 00:36:619 (6) - its better if make this identical to 00:35:869 (4) -
6. 00:38:494 (4) - i dont know whats up with the sudden increase of spacing
7. 00:41:682 (6) - NC cuz you know
8. 00:45:432 (5) - yea, unappealing overlap, you probably know what im going to say It will mess up with spacing emphasis so no
9. 01:09:432 (1,2) - you might wonder why i didnt complain here compare to insane, i guess its fine like this on hard diff :thonking:
10. 01:31:932 (3,4,1) - it really feels crowded here, you probably force them to put there specially at the top part of the grid, which is kinda hard feel more suffocating, try to make something else This will require a remap as it is locked by the objects after it as well which is going to require a lot more effort for little gains. I mean if it's really a problem I can indeed remap this later but for now. It's pretty ok to me
11. 02:15:244 (2,3) - i wonder if doubles are suitable for Hard diff, a bit confusing to play for some new advanced player doubles are fine if the final object is a slider imo
12. 02:16:932 (3) - this can be improve better, like blankething its tail to (1) while (2) is still blanketed with (3) idk how to do this but I changed it a bit I guess
13. 02:57:244 (4) - you missed the downbeat here, in the middle of white tick of the slider, though you mostly follow guitar here but try to consider Nope I prefer it this way
14. 02:58:182 (1) - and speaking of guitar, same as insane, the guitar scratch starts from the red tick, you must change it I wont change this on the Hard as I think it is cool to have a draggy sound on the long slider.
15. 02:58:744 (2,3,4,5) - this looks so bad, I mean they are like squished sardines in a can right there, you might wanna spread it out It is Hard I can't really spread it out as im more or less stuck with DS snap but I try to make it a little bit better
16. 03:25:369 (5) - slider too high, might touch some hp bar of some skin again
17. 03:54:244 (1) - kinda same about the squished sardines, but you might want to move this on the upper side that force stack it switch to partial overlap
18. 04:12:338 (1) - same as insane same

Im not really good at modding lower diffs, so Ill skip Normal for now, sorry
I guess thats that, 1st mod after being inactive for a long time

Good luck Thank you for modding!

Lince Cosmico wrote:

modding metadata and insane diff xd

Insane

General:
Regarding your metadata:
- Put this as title "ナノサイズミール" (NanosizeMir's name in japanese) it's actually the original name of the artist so it have to be like that
- add "the best" on tags, since it's the name of the album
- Put "/ゲーム ~TV animation ver.~" as name of the song
Put "Philosophyz ~TV animation ver.~" as romanised name of the song
Put "リライト" as Source and add "Rewrite" on tags (since its the original name of the anime)
Add "水谷瑠奈" and "塚越雄一朗" on tags, These are the original name of NanosizeMir members (as i can see you did only put their romanised names)
Add "Shinji Orito" and "折戸伸治" (romanised name and name) since he's the composer of the song
Source
Source 2
- 03:34:932 - Seems that you forgot to enable kiai on the bpm line (enable it on all diffs)
Objects:
00:18:057 (2,3) - It would be good if you stack this to 00:16:182 (1,2) - sliderends
• 00:21:432 (1) - I'd suggest you to move it a bit to avoid unnecesary weird overlaps, you could just space it more or move it to somewhere like x:287 y:151
• 00:22:088 - Hey! Seems like we're missing a loud and notable sound here!! You shouldn't do that in the top diff
• 00:24:244 (3,4,5) - Same than before, stacking it with 00:23:307 (4) - wouldn't we a bad idea
• 00:41:682 (1) - This circle is clearly overmapped, you dont really need it you can just start the spin there
• 01:20:494 (5,1,2,3,4,5) - I would move this a bit up so 01:21:057 (2) - is not that close to 01:20:307 (4) -
• 01:21:432 (5,2) - Fix this stack
• 01:24:618 (4,5,6) - This pattern is lack of spacing, the current one is just too low so it could be a problem while playing. I recommend you to raise up the spacing of this jumps in order to satisfy player's desire
• 01:34:182 (1) - The rhythm here seems that you're undermapping... It feels more like this way
• 01:37:182 (1) - Exactly the same thing here, and this is such more noticeable than the one from before, you MUST change this one
• 01:42:057 (2,3) - As i said when i started, stacking this would look better
• 01:43:182 (1) - Same rhythm thing
• 01:44:494 (5) - I'd suggest you to move this a bit to the left to avoid the overlap with 01:43:182 (1) -
• 01:55:932 (2,1) - This pattern would look better if it was stacked
• 01:57:432 (3) - NC for emphasis?
• 01:58:182 (1,2) - I'd rather suggest this rhythm. It would represent the voice in such a better way
• 02:05:869 (6) - Add NC
• 02:31:744 (2,3,1) - I'd move all of this just a bit up in order to make 02:32:119 (1) - stack with 02:30:619 (2) -
• 02:36:807 (6) - You should add more spacing to this one since it could be confused with an 1/2 rhythm jump and that wouldn't be good
• 03:10:088 (8) - What about adding a kickslider here? (ending it on 03:10:182 - ) so it would fit the fall of volume between these two tics instead of ending the stream in a weird blue tick
• 03:19:182 (7) - Add NC
• 03:39:244 (1) - It feels like the hitsound here is a bit off out context tho
• 03:48:994 (3) - Shouldn't this be a bit to the left so it fit with 03:48:244 (1,2) - ? It feels off actually, It should be like this imo
• 03:58:932 (1) - Same rhythm thing from before, the long slider just doesn't fit
• 04:00:244 (1,2,3,4,5) - The stack fucked up here
• 04:01:932 (1) - Same rhythm thing
• 04:03:244 (5,6) - As i said before, i'd suggest you to move this a bit to the left to avoid overlap with 04:01:932 (1) - since it feels kinda weird right now
• 04:03:619 (6,1) - It feels like it would fit better if the circle 1 starts in the same position than circle 6
• 04:04:838 - Missing a sound again huh?
• 04:12:244 (3) - I recommend you to move this to x:167 x:86 so it would be exactly between 04:10:932 (1,2) - this two avoiding a weird overlap

That's all i have, i hope it helped you

RevengeZ wrote:

DO NOT GIVE KUDOSU TO THIS POST

Lince Cosmico wrote:

modding metadata and insane diff xd

Insane

General:
Regarding your metadata:
- Put this as title "ナノサイズミール" (NanosizeMir's name in japanese) it's actually the original name of the artist so it have to be like that
- add "the best" on tags, since it's the name of the album
- Put "/ゲーム ~TV animation ver.~" as name of the song
Put "Philosophyz ~TV animation ver.~" as romanised name of the song
Put "リライト" as Source and add "Rewrite" on tags (since its the original name of the anime)
Add "水谷瑠奈" and "塚越雄一朗" on tags, These are the original name of NanosizeMir members (as i can see you did only put their romanised names)
Add "Shinji Orito" and "折戸伸治" (romanised name and name) since he's the composer of the song
Source
Source 2
- 03:34:932 - Seems that you forgot to enable kiai on the bpm line (enable it on all diffs)
Objects:
00:18:057 (2,3) - It would be good if you stack this to 00:16:182 (1,2) - sliderends hmm so it looks off with stacking turned off
• 00:21:432 (1) - I'd suggest you to move it a bit to avoid unnecesary weird overlaps, you could just space it more or move it to somewhere like x:287 y:151 sure
• 00:22:088 - Hey! Seems like we're missing a loud and notable sound here!! You shouldn't do that in the top diff I wanted to emphasize the guitar more
• 00:24:244 (3,4,5) - Same than before, stacking it with 00:23:307 (4) - wouldn't we a bad idea right
• 00:41:682 (1) - This circle is clearly overmapped, you dont really need it you can just start the spin there there is a lil bit of sound and I like double clicking
• 01:20:494 (5,1,2,3,4,5) - I would move this a bit up so 01:21:057 (2) - is not that close to 01:20:307 (4) - sure why not
• 01:21:432 (5,2) - Fix this stack k
• 01:24:618 (4,5,6) - This pattern is lack of spacing, the current one is just too low so it could be a problem while playing. I recommend you to raise up the spacing of this jumps in order to satisfy player's desire scaled up the spacing
• 01:34:182 (1) - The rhythm here seems that you're undermapping... It feels more like this way This is on a conceptual level, doesn't mean your suggestion is bad. But this beatmap is designed around 1/1 sliders in these sections
• 01:37:182 (1) - Exactly the same thing here, and this is such more noticeable than the one from before, you MUST change this one ^
• 01:42:057 (2,3) - As i said when i started, stacking this would look better done
• 01:43:182 (1) - Same rhythm thing same
• 01:44:494 (5) - I'd suggest you to move this a bit to the left to avoid the overlap with 01:43:182 (1) - done
• 01:55:932 (2,1) - This pattern would look better if it was stacked kk
• 01:57:432 (3) - NC for emphasis? that will be inconsistent
• 01:58:182 (1,2) - I'd rather suggest this rhythm. It would represent the voice in such a better way the strong vocal will end on the slider end tho
• 02:05:869 (6) - Add NC nope
• 02:31:744 (2,3,1) - I'd move all of this just a bit up in order to make 02:32:119 (1) - stack with 02:30:619 (2) - I think it's fine as the circle already faded away
• 02:36:807 (6) - You should add more spacing to this one since it could be confused with an 1/2 rhythm jump and that wouldn't be good sure
• 03:10:088 (8) - What about adding a kickslider here? (ending it on 03:10:182 - ) so it would fit the fall of volume between these two tics instead of ending the stream in a weird blue tick sure
• 03:19:182 (7) - Add NC there is no need
• 03:39:244 (1) - It feels like the hitsound here is a bit off out context tho added whistle
• 03:48:994 (3) - Shouldn't this be a bit to the left so it fit with 03:48:244 (1,2) - ? It feels off actually, It should be like this imo Yes it is off because if I did that the sliderend would be out of the playfield
• 03:58:932 (1) - Same rhythm thing from before, the long slider just doesn't fit same
• 04:00:244 (1,2,3,4,5) - The stack fucked up here thanks
• 04:01:932 (1) - Same rhythm thing ye
• 04:03:244 (5,6) - As i said before, i'd suggest you to move this a bit to the left to avoid overlap with 04:01:932 (1) - since it feels kinda weird right now k
• 04:03:619 (6,1) - It feels like it would fit better if the circle 1 starts in the same position than circle 6
• 04:04:838 - Missing a sound again huh? ye
• 04:12:244 (3) - I recommend you to move this to x:167 x:86 so it would be exactly between 04:10:932 (1,2) - this two avoiding a weird overlap sure

That's all i have, i hope it helped you Thank you for modding!

Cerulean Veyron wrote:

Queue

[- - Normal - -]

1. 00:25:744 (2) - The first curve of this slider isn't really that much of appealing. I would say, you could give a try to redo the curve to display another curve of the slider more clearly by doing something similar to this, but you can actually choose not to add an anchor if it doesn't feel comfortable with you. At least aesthetics wouldn't be much of a big deal, but probably makes structures prettier. After that, it's all up to you. Reverted to just curve lo
2. 00:57:244 (4,1,2) - That's quite a big overlap there to be honest, covering most of the slider head of (2) after the reverse. Might wanna move it above for a clear visibility of the approach (in terms of normal being the easiest difficulty around the set). Like, if you want to keep the overlap for other cases like flow, difficulty rating, or whatever it is... you can move it up slightly and not way too much high up, which probably would represent structures much like a Normal difficulty. moved up
3. 01:20:869 - 02:35:869 - I'd rather not ignore a few good beats around here, even if it's just a background music or one minor snare. Would recommend to follow them instead of skipping for a tiny break. Right now, it kinda sounds a bit empty while the song track is still intensifying itself so that means, there's literally no emphasis either. You could at least add a reversed 1/2 slider or a casual 1/1 slider if possible for filling up the rhythm composition. It's there as a short break for the player and me actually. As if I mapped everything there would be no place for me to adjust my diff without
   basically causing a domino effect for too long.
4. 01:27:244 (6,7) - 02:42:244 (6,7) - Not absolutely sure about the rhythm composition. Like there's a beat on that white tick which is stronger than the red, it ended up leaving the circle for the vocal lines. But hey, there's also a vocal landing with the snare at the same time on white tick, so I do really think making that tick clickable would stress the potential beat as desired. I'm not sure of which rhythm choice you can use around this, but I would say this one for altering rhythm composition. sure, but Im still worried about consecutive 1/2 gap
5. 03:07:275 (1) - As for the spinner, I don't really think the guitar, or the last piano note, or the ride sound lands on 03:10:088 - to be honest. Hearing this part a little deeper and a few more times is pretty much a good thing to try out. So, I might recommend ending the spinner on the red tick 03:09:994 - to end it along with the instruments in the song track. right

[- - Hard - -]

1. - I might recommend using Approach rate of 7 minus the 0.5 buff. It's kind of a slight gap in-between this difficulty and the previous than the next, so maybe reducing a little bit might give a few consistency of the approach rate setting by two. kk
2. 00:18:244 (3,4,5) - 00:24:244 (1,2) - Well, the triples here aren't really quite usual though. Like, there's another part that's really sounds similar to the next part but has it's triple rhythm somewhere else. So you may have some rhythm inconsistency here, either by balancing them equally or try following the hi-hats instead. It's more or less a technical limit more than anything I would love to map all the triplets
3. 01:09:432 (1,2,1) - 01:15:619 (5,6) - I do kinda feel these notes were placed fine based on distance spacing. But visually looking at the distance in-between these notes (and probably others similar to these two prats further on), are not quite spaced properly in my point of view in spite of slider velocity manipulation. Like you could look at the notes a bit closer to see how well or not they're spaced, which is likely to be misleading jumps or structures. I've seen many of them further on, so you may need to reconsider placing it a bit further or closer in order to balance out the spacing through this difficulty. Don't really quite get it, but that seems like a big change lo
4. 02:00:244 (5,6) - 02:03:244 (6,7) - You've spaced out with no casual jumps until the second part, which is kinda inconsistent through intensity and the emphasis. So there are two options to redo this issue alternatively; either create a jump on the first part for the vocal pitch, or Ctrl + G / space out the slider on 02:03:244 (6) - to consist the intensity of both parts. fixed
5. 03:07:275 (1) - The same thing about ending a spinner as well. ye

[- - Insane - -]

1. 00:22:088 - The landing of the hi-hat here sounds quite promising. Might you need to mind adding a circle here for creating a triple in order to follow that. it was triplet before but the BN suggested that I sticked all the way with the guitar
2. 00:40:182 (5) - You probably have a few questionable new combos around these parts. Like seeing you adding one combo each two tracks, then started to add in each every white long tick or downbeat. It's quite pretty odd. So about mentioning this part, you may probably need to add a new combo here to correlate the second part on 00:52:182 (1) - . kk
3. 01:34:369 - 01:37:369 - 01:40:650 - 01:43:369 - You've missed pretty much a lot of great beats around this whole section. Skipping them just makes it feel pretty empty in terms of rhythm composition. I'd probably recommend either having the slider's end/head land on the ticks mentioned, or add a circle for filling up emphasis much equal. It's not likely to increase note density too much, or create spikes and buff the star rating. So there's a chance it would really be called an Insane difficulty. there are no 1/2 sliders in these sections at all, and I focus purely on the cymbal flow reverse concept not really mapping the guitar
4. 02:33:057 (1,2,3) - 03:42:807 (1,2,3) - I find these two a near duplicate of patterning and structure. I'd rather say, you could've probably done something different to represent more effort into making more good patterns. Similar structure, but different patterning in variations. Maybe redo the third part onto something a bit... overwhelming? You can also try altering the jumps for the song track intensity if you want, it may still be fine. For short, try out something else cool here. rearranged one of them
5. 02:49:557 (2,3) - The stack here kinda feels a bit delaying of active cursor movements around the objects. Like, the density sounds pretty much the same, yet the movement of cursor suddenly stops in a second or less which is quite odd in my opinion. Would rather unstack and move it somewhere to make a jump, or just use distance spacing to space things out as usual. sure
6. 03:08:307 (4) - For only this slider (4), how about flipping the sliding position vertically by Ctrl + J to create a better structural flow? Just after going through the two sliders on 03:07:557 (2,3) -, and would represent a smoother pattern for sure. mmm

Not bad, good luck! Thank you so much for modding!

timemon wrote:

RevengeZ wrote:

DO NOT GIVE KUDOSU TO THIS POST

modding metadata and insane diff xd

Insane

General:
Regarding your metadata:
- Put this as title "ナノサイズミール" (NanosizeMir's name in japanese) it's actually the original name of the artist so it have to be like that
- add "the best" on tags, since it's the name of the album
- Put "/ゲーム ~TV animation ver.~" as name of the song
Put "Philosophyz ~TV animation ver.~" as romanised name of the song
Put "リライト" as Source and add "Rewrite" on tags (since its the original name of the anime)
Add "水谷瑠奈" and "塚越雄一朗" on tags, These are the original name of NanosizeMir members (as i can see you did only put their romanised names)
Add "Shinji Orito" and "折戸伸治" (romanised name and name) since he's the composer of the song
Source
Source 2
- 03:34:932 - Seems that you forgot to enable kiai on the bpm line (enable it on all diffs)

- Frontier - wrote:

sorry, i was busy w/ school and mapping contest
m4m

[General]

1. The difficulty spread between beatmap is inconsistent. The difficulty spread between Normal and Hard is bigger than difficulty spread between Hard and Insane. So consider lower the star rating in Hard. I mapped with Hard Guideline
2. 01:46:182 - I think you can mapped after this. No need to add a break, as you did on 00:31:182. too tiring for new players and me,
   mostly me
3. 04:17:635 (1) - I think you could add a spinner after this note since there is a continuously crescendo sound after this note. The Hard would have 10 spinners lol

[Normal]

1. 00:46:557 (2) - I don't hear any sound to make this an 1/2-beat slider yet. So consider changing to a circle or whatever. mmm shouldn't be diffferent tbh
2. 01:34:744 (2,3) - Kinda bad overlap imo zzz I like it
3. 02:08:869 (1,2) - These notes overlapping 02:08:494 (3) looks messy imo same
4. 02:11:494 (3) - The note touches the hp-bar. Touching hp-bar can make players having difficulty in reading notes. So consider moving it down a little bit to make it not touching the hp-bar.
5. 02:55:182 (1,3) - Avoid having notes overlapping each other. It could make players confused and be complex for reading notes. What about changing (1)'s slider structure. It might be good for you if you wanna keep the curve slider on 02:56:494 (3) since it continues with 02:57:244 (4).
6. 03:34:557 (2,2) - Overlap zzz

[Hard]

1. The kiai parts are too dense rhythmically, which is really different from the other parts. Since non-kiai parts mapped really calm and mostly use distance snap in mapping, while the kiai parts use lots of jumps and rarely use distance snap which cause inconsistency between map. (like light insane actually xP) So consider restructure the notes or whatnot. aren't Kiais supposed to be harder than the rest?
2. I think you could nerf circle size a little bit bigger in Hard. Like 3.7 or something for more variety and not as same as Insane diff. I'm afraid it might mess something up tbh, as I mapped with CS4 in mind
3. 00:51:244 (7) - This kinda breaks the flow. Since the previous notes are meant to go to go right side. This note is forcing the players to move back to the left side again which makes the map flows unnaturally. it is quite a strong sound so a sudden change in flow should be fine and it looks dope
4. 01:12:244 (3,1) - Overlapping notes :v Why don't you try something like this to avoid having notes overlapping each other too.
5. 02:00:244 (5) - ctrl+g this looks more appropriate and gives better flow.
6. 02:04:557 (2,3,4,1,2,3) - Compared with this part 00:49:557 (2,3,4,5,6,7). They're almost the same both in rhythm and vocal, but you mapped differently. Consider making these as same as in previous part that I mentioned it. (Also inconsistency in nc) It's different lol the 00:49:557 (2,3,4,5,6,7) feel slower due to the bass and really loud snare. while the former is faster
7. 02:15:244 (2,3) - Just my opinion, you may avoid using notes like this since it's pretty complex and you rarely use this pattern. (mostly you use triplets) So whatever. Complex, yes. but it should still be doable for new player
8. 02:25:182 - So, this kiai part doesn't have lots of jumps. Compared with the others, this is totally different in terms of spacing. Add more jumps or consistency between kiais.
9. 02:52:463 - Consider adding a note here since there is triplets here.
10. 03:16:744 (7) - This kinda breaks the flow. I suggested you to move it to the right side. downbeat xd
11. 03:36:244 (1,2,3,4) - These quite messy zzz They can make players losing ability to identify the notes.

Sorry for not modding Insane.
Good luck~ Thank you for modding! no texts = fixed

Naotoshi wrote:

alright lets see

metadata?

リライト and 改写 in tags maybe? (rewrite aliases)
and visual novel or something (but not eroge, that's silenceable!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!)
also yuuichiro has 2 us lol I just copy pasted the japanese name and removed english one lo

[insane]
i think u should map the start.. no real reason not to imo. lo I tried and imo the song should start right away not spending 15 seconds to play the boring intro, I mapped it before I remapped and it tiled me to oblivion when retrying because getting stuck in the intro is rip

00:16:182 - literally can u put circle 1/2 slider here 00:22:182 (1) - same etc
that guitar note on the red tick is soOO strong, ignoring it entirely is like ?_? 1/2 slider with reverse seems like a good compromise between the two

00:40:744 (2,3) - having this big of a jump in the calm part is pretty out of place, considering you''ve been following vocals and this one is on a piano. i think you should ctrl h the 2-3 pattern so it is a small jump kkk

00:52:182 (1) - wub 1/3s where... not so much of a wub but it's 1/3!

00:58:932 (2,3,4) - its the top diff just map the 1/6th zz It's unexpected imo and 1/6 is really fast

01:15:432 (1,2) - what i mean is that since these arent vocals they should be separate from the ones with vocals. like the vocals are up down, the non vocals are side to side. something like that lets you distinguish them in the map. Changed again but imo this one is quite hard to implement. The Kiais are supposed to be movement heavy and flowy (is that even a word idk) so yeah angle and flow are going to be on consideration. Hard to pin certain sounds to a certain place when you have to get a good angle on objects. PLUS I LOVE the other 2 jumps I made on the other 2 kiais they're dank imo

01:27:432 (1,2) - spacing is tiny af switched 2 with 3 and now it's big!

01:34:182 (1) - wat why ignore the super obviou guitar bendy thing? put kickslider+1/2 slider plz 1/2 slider + reverse because I believe kickslider doesn't really work great with cymbal

01:40:182 (1,2) - yea no this level of rhythm simplification is just borderline ignoring the song... rip

just go and look for other guitar tuff that you ignored, and map it. it's super boring to hear really distinct notes and just not click on them for no reason (like monstrata maps, he does this a lot.) I'm pretty sure I caught them all

01:51:807 (9,10,1) - spacing is weirdly big. the angle change is already sufficient to distinguish it, no need for such big jumps in the calm part reduced xd

02:16:932 - plz randomly switch to this sound it sounds so funny lmao idk how to slider art and make wub pls teach

03:52:557 (2,3) - 2 is very underspaced =( underspaced no more

will do other diffs tomorrow, but please go through the map looking for stuff i said earliier. dnt feel like pointing out every instance of the same thing. Yeeee, should be all that I saw unless I slipped up. Thanks mr nao

1. 04:12:338 (1) - Why not end the spinner at 04:15:619 - and add a circle at where the spinner currently ends? Because after that point, there's a small pause, and I feel like a spinner after that pause would feel really off.
   
   [Normal]
   
   
   1. 00:57:244 (4) - I personally think that (4) should be split into two sliders. I understand that you're following the vocal on the reverse, but there's also a strong vocal/beat on 00:57:807 - where the slider currently ends (the red tick which is after the white tick I mentioned) is a fading vocal. How about you try this?
   2. 01:03:807 - I see that you mainly follow vocals here, and it's quite odd that you skipped the vocal here and it sounds strong.
   3. 01:15:244 (6) - I see that you extended this slider to emphasise the vocal on the white tick which on the end of the slider, but, isn't this slider to emphasise the vocal before it? I suggest shoterning the slider to 01:15:432 - and a circle at 01:15:807 - to emphasise vocals better, same goes for the rest of the parts like this in kiai.
   4. 01:20:494 (5) - Would be better if you emphasised the high note here with a slider, don't you think? This also goes for the rest of the kiais with the same part.
   5. 01:34:744 (2,3) - This overlap seems unexpected, since the rest of the map don't have overlaps like these.
   6. 02:55:932 (2,3) - These too, try something like this?
   7. 04:12:338 (1,1) - The gap between these two is too short, and considering the fact that there's no easier diff than this, you should shorten this spinner.
   [Hard]
   
   
   1. The guitar sounds have close spacing.. I personally think that they should at least have a bit of spacing since guitars sound intense, them having close spacing doesn't really emphasise the sound well in my opinion.
   2. 03:36:619 (2,4) - This overlap seems to random personally, since the entire diff doesn't really have such overlap, and it could be hard to read.
   [Insane]
   
   
   1. 01:48:244 (4,5,6,7,8) - I wonder why (6) is spaced out from the (4) and (5) and has a whistle like (7) and (8) do.. it could be my ears, but (6) doesn't need a whistle or spaced from (4) (5) since it doesn't have the same sound as (7) and (8) do.
   2. 03:09:432 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - I personally think that (8) should be spaced out a bit because it looks like two circles instead of slider. It could cause confusion, so I feel like it'd be better to space it out a bit.

Xiaolin wrote:

NM from Q

[General]

1. 04:12:338 (1) - Why not end the spinner at 04:15:619 - and add a circle at where the spinner currently ends? Because after that point, there's a small pause, and I feel like a spinner after that pause would feel really off. Did on Normal and Hard
   
   [Normal]
   
   
   1. 00:57:244 (4) - I personally think that (4) should be split into two sliders. I understand that you're following the vocal on the reverse, but there's also a strong vocal/beat on 00:57:807 - where the slider currently ends (the red tick which is after the white tick I mentioned) is a fading vocal. How about you try this? I don't care much about other layer when mapping xd
   2. 01:03:807 - I see that you mainly follow vocals here, and it's quite odd that you skipped the vocal here and it sounds strong. mapped
   3. 01:15:244 (6) - I see that you extended this slider to emphasise the vocal on the white tick which on the end of the slider, but, isn't this slider to emphasise the vocal before it? I suggest shoterning the slider to 01:15:432 - and a circle at 01:15:807 - to emphasise vocals better, same goes for the rest of the parts like this in kiai. I prefer the current way
   4. 01:20:494 (5) - Would be better if you emphasised the high note here with a slider, don't you think? This also goes for the rest of the kiais with the same part. I need a short break
   5. 01:34:744 (2,3) - This overlap seems unexpected, since the rest of the map don't have overlaps like these. I like them tbh
   6. 02:55:932 (2,3) - These too, try something like this? kkk
   7. 04:12:338 (1,1) - The gap between these two is too short, and considering the fact that there's no easier diff than this, you should shorten this spinner.
      shortened
   [Hard]
   
   
   1. The guitar sounds have close spacing.. I personally think that they should at least have a bit of spacing since guitars sound intense, them having close spacing doesn't really emphasise the sound well in my opinion. They're not in the Kiai, and I use consistent Distance Snap across the diff
   2. 03:36:619 (2,4) - This overlap seems to random personally, since the entire diff doesn't really have such overlap, and it could be hard to read. yeeee
   [Insane]
   
   
   1. 01:48:244 (4,5,6,7,8) - I wonder why (6) is spaced out from the (4) and (5) and has a whistle like (7) and (8) do.. it could be my ears, but (6) doesn't need a whistle or spaced from (4) (5) since it doesn't have the same sound as (7) and (8) do. It needs one!
   2. 03:09:432 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - I personally think that (8) should be spaced out a bit because it looks like two circles instead of slider. It could cause confusion, so I feel like it'd be better to space it out a bit. I bend it and add NC

Good luck! Thank you so much for modding!

pishifat wrote:

https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/751 ... itclap.wav
https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/751 ... finish.wav
normalized hitsounds pls use i cant hear switched to your hitsounds

insane
01:12:619 (4,6) - 01:24:618 (4,6) -etc bassy hitnormal is so unsupported here lol. should go with additions for the whistles and soft sampleset applied on all kiais and difficulties
01:44:494 (6) - finish applied on all difficulties
thjese actually apply to all diffs lol

normal
01:24:244 (5,6) - spacing mistake fixed
04:17:447 (1) - um
well even if it was snapped properly, i would suggest using a slider since more hit leniency http://puu.sh/wUSlF/aeea46980c.jpg switched to slider and snapped properly

get a rebub then call me back!!! thank you so much for modding, pishifat!

pishifat wrote:

if anything about artist/title/source was changed, yes. if not, i can qualify