Playing well and easy to handle =/= being good. This should be widely known by now.Nofool wrote:
"this does not fit neither the atmosphere nor the song" ? even tho the snapping is not correct this is pretty close to what we can hear and above anything this is the the best way to map this part if you want to use 1/8, placing them "earlier" would make it extremely awkward to play and yu clearly made a playability choice there.
"interesting concept, not suitable for taiko" welp did you create taiko or something? this plays well and is easy to handle so not sure why this would not be suitable for literaly the entire gamemode lol. the "other things to represent" you are talking are barely hearable while playing, especialy compared to those fast piano notes so if anything the result would just be awkward in game.
As far as I know, the concept is mainly used for piano songs. And as far as I know as well, taiko is not a piano simulator. And the rest of the argument, if anything, would backfire against you? "Barely hearable" are the grace notes, so what you are saying is the part should be entirely 1/2, which is what majority of normal players are hearing in the song.
When am I suggesting to blindly follow something? I can't see anything like that in my post. And with intensity I meant that song does not increase it, the amount of notes played by instrument is stale, the pitch has not risen further, etc. Heck, if you compare it with the previous section 00:21:676 - you could even argue it's more allegro.Nofool wrote:
you are suggesting him to blindly follow the most accurate possible sound saying that the result will fit more the intensity or something? lol those 1/8 perfectly fit the intensity in my point of view so i hope you get some deeper explanations. as a supposedly experienced mapper you should know that following the exact timing of the song sometimes gives bad results in term of playabilty/flow etc and i would say that this is the case here.
It seems this is still widely a huge misconception. Vetoing something does not necessarily mean the map is unrankable, it is simply a right for nominators to use when they do not agree to see something ranked and needs therefore further discussion.Nofool wrote:
so about that veto i will just act as another opinion : i DISAGREE, this should absolutely not be an unrankable issue.
However, as far as I know RoR and FotS do not have grace notes, they have something called guitar tremolo which essentially is a "vibration".k3v227 wrote:
If you don't think grace notes are suitable for Taiko then why would you bubble Road of Resistance and Fury of the Storm? Seems strange :thinking:
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Now for yumuya: the section sounds much better now, even if I'm still reluctant about those 1/8s. I'll be happy to lift the veto if you can give me further explanation on why you are rejecting the other alternatives (1/2, 1/4 triples, etc.).