Hey, kinda late Mod4Mod from my
queue.
General- Consider the use of custom combo colours for a better finish to your mapset.
- The start of your mp3 seems to have some sound where there shouldn't be some. Could you go about trying to get rid of this, either by editting it in an MP3 manipulator, or by sourcing the song from elsewhere?
Normal- 00:08:218 (3) - I would put a new combo here since the current combo spans over a lot of measures.
- 00:11:295 (5) - You could also put a new combo here, but it's not important whether you do or not for this note.
- 00:40:526 (2,1) - Try and avoid this overlap, it looks kind of unproffesional.
- 00:46:680 (2,1) - It would be nice if slider 1 was a blanket for 2.
- 00:52:834 (2) - This blanket could be improved [00:53:699]. If you look from that timestamp, you can see how the approach circle compares with the slider. Try to match the shape of the slider with the approach circle for neater blankets.
- 01:12:449 (3) - As above [01:12:930]. Try and make the blanket circular rather than parabolic.
- 01:18:026 (5,1) - This could also be a nice place for a blanket.
Hard- 00:05:718 (2) - The visual flow of this slider could be slightly improved. See how the slider goes upwards right at the start? Try and remove that so it flows straight down since you're using a linear flow.
- 00:08:795 (2) - As above.
- 00:09:757 (1,2) - Keep the spacing consistent with what was used in the previous combos. Changing the spacing in this way implies that the timing is different.
- 00:26:680 (1,2) - The distance here is larger than the combos used in the previous combos, yet the timing is shorter. Because of this, it is hard to read that these are infact shorter timings. Please keep to using the same distance snapping here as with the previous combos so that the timing is easier to read. This goes for the rets of the sliders upcoming too.
- 00:45:141 (1,2) - This could be a nice opportunity for a blanket.
- 00:55:911 (3,4,5) - These blankets could be improved [00:56:007].
- 00:57:449 (7) - Don't have a blanket so that the circle is touching the slider. It doesn't really look very nice this way. Also, put a new combo on this slider since you changed the slider velocity.
- 01:18:026 (7,1) - Try and avoid this overlap if possible.
Insane- 00:05:141 (1,2,3,4,5) - I'm not sure if this is intended or not, but this is not a perfect regular pentagon. You can make regular shapes using the Create Polygon Circles feature (Ctrl+Shift+D).
- 00:14:949 (2) - This blanket could be improved [00:15:622].
- 00:18:988 (4,5) - These aren't perfectly stacked. Use Ctrl+G on slider 4 to find its position by its tail.
- 00:22:065 (3,5) - These blankets could be improved [00:22:449].
- 00:24:180 (8,1) - This could be made into a nice blanket.
- 00:26:680 (1,2) - These blankets could be improved [00:27:161], [00:27:738].
- 00:30:911 (3,4) - These aren't perfectly stacked.
- 00:46:488 - It's not so important whether you do this or not, but you could add circles inbetween these sliders like here for example.
- 00:53:218 (6,7) - These aren't perfectly stacked.
- 00:55:911 (3,4) - Double-repeating sldiers of this length are generally frowned upon since they are hard to read and usually awkward to play. I would suggest mapping with something else.
- 01:01:680 (5) - Try make a circule blanket rather than parabolic [01:01:488].
- 01:02:641 (8) - This blanket could be improved [01:03:026].
ExtraI'm not so good with mapping difficulties that are designed to be Expert difficulties, but I'll mod this as best as I can anyway.
- 00:06:680 - It would be better if this was a stronger note like a circle or the start of a new slider rather than a slider tail since this is a downbeat, and has a new line of vocals.
- 00:07:449 (5,6,1) - These could be blanket'd.
- 00:10:141 (2) - Don't hide this note underneath 00:08:988 (5). It is difficult to read, and speaking as a Hidden player, is unecessarily cruel.
- 00:11:295 - This would be better off as a stronger note since it is the end of the into and uses a finish hitsound.
- 00:18:988 (1,2,3,4,5) - Try and arrange these as a perfect regular pentagon rather than placing them by hand.
- 00:20:526 - As with 00:06:680, try to use a stronger note here.
- 00:25:141 (5,6,7,8,9) - Try and arrange these as a perfect regular pentagon rather than placing them by hand.
- 00:31:103 (5,6,7,8,9) - As above.
- 00:34:565 (6) - This would look better as a circular blanket with 7.
- 00:37:257 (4,5) - Try and arrange these so that their shape can look relative to the triangle of 00:36:295 (1,2,3).
- 00:37:449 (5,6) - I wouldn't make this a jump if the slider ends on a blue tick, since this makes the length of the sliders difficult to read.
- 00:58:988 (1) - The slider velocity from this point onwards is way too excessive. If you look at any other Expert difficulty map, even they don't use velocities like this. You should lower the slider velocity and adjust the distance snapping for this timing section in accordance to this. I'll avoid modding the rest of this timing section due to it being obsolete when you change the slider velocity and spacing, which I highly recommend you do.
Good Luck