forum

Halozy - Genryuu Kaiko

posted
Total Posts
426
show more
xxdeathx

Lach wrote:

Weed wrote:

would never have guessed this map would ever become qualified... really an amazing map, its a shame those who can't play it will proceed to QQ
I think even people who can play it will complain, just like when people who can't play something offer compliments. It doesn't matter as long as they aren't acting like a dick and explain their reasoning.
hmm most of these complaints are coming from people that can't play it and i haven't yet seen one from someone who can
Garven
I love the slider art. You don't see that much anymore, so kudos for that.
Nathan
Yesssss been waiting for this day, lemme get my popcorn
Kogarou-
This map is actually funny with HT
ZZHBOY
怎么没一丝hw要quit的气氛
Darksonic
... this map is not made for humans.
isome

Darksonic wrote:

... this map is not made for humans.
Since when did HW made maps for humans.. tho?

lol congratz anyway
Slider arts are awesome, and the map itself is also an art. I don't really understand, but it is still great to look at
Colourful
hw大大请问下。。sb里面的毛笔字是用什么软件画出来的0 0,看上去很逼真。。
Trust
hot damn grats
Asahina Momoko
HW should put a supporter tag as a prize to player who FCed it lol
pkhg
I tried my best to avoid hating this map and after watching random ppl playing it, I feel like its good. If you can play it just put auto and enjoy it, feels great :3
The only thing that I dont like are those really spaced streams near the end, so hard

btw gratz :3
Topic Starter
Hollow Wings
thank u~ sco, yuki, lust and oracle, may have this as the best version.

guys, hate and love this map, thx for playing!
Mira-san
I liked it when it was pending tho. I don't know now.

Grats anyway. gna jinx ur qualify heh
meii18
WOW ! It's your first ranked marathon map ? If is , congrats HW !!! :)
FlobuFlobs

ByBy_ChAn wrote:

WOW ! It's your first ranked marathon map ? If is , congrats HW !!! :)
Huh? https://osu.ppy.sh/s/100348
Nyxa
YES
Kyubey
HW I love you.
pielak213
we are a few days early for the qualified -> first ranked map of 2015
Vuelo Eluko
i cant pass so its good map thank you for ranking
meii18

pielak wrote:

we are a few days early for the qualified -> first ranked map of 2015
It's not first ranked map of 2015. It will be ranked permantly still in 2014 :D

Yeah you're right . It was disqualified and ok . I agree with you pielak . First ranked map of 2015 baby ! :DD
TicClick
Sorry, but this map lacks a fair bit of something that is called quality and should have not been ranked in its current state. If you need more details, this is probably due to blatant abuse of patterns like 00:47:399 (1,2,3,1,2) - and the fact there are barely any distinct and audible sounds you mapped most, if not all streams to. Oh, and also a massive pile of overlapping copypaste that starts from 03:43:584, not speaking of the stream that follows the kiai part on 04:05:781 and ignores any features provided to you by music.

I am also going to refer to this post, as similar situation has already happened once in the past; you can read first two paragraphs of it, replacing "Platinum" with "Mysterious Hymn".

sweetod
打完发现被un了 :cry:
Kayano
HW的图总是要来个一次两次的

Since it has been DQ'd, I think i should point out the mistake of storyboard lyrics here

There are two places of your sb lyrics are wrong: (check http://en.touhouwiki.net/wiki/Lyrics:_%E6%BA%90%E6%B5%81%E6%87%90%E5%8F%A4)

  1. 13.png 风->風
  2. last-1.png (?)->崩


Well, good luck
InabaTewi
我飞机刚上了一半就坠机爆炸了
dqs01733

TicClick wrote:

Sorry, but this map lacks a fair bit of something that is called quality and should have not been ranked in its current state. If you need more details, this is probably due to blatant abuse of patterns like 00:47:399 (1,2,3,1,2) - and the fact there are barely any distinct and audible sounds you mapped most, if not all streams to. Oh, and also a massive pile of overlapping copypaste that starts from 03:43:584, not speaking of the stream that follows the kiai part on 04:05:781 and ignores any features provided to you by music.

I am also going to refer to this post, as similar situation has already happened once in the past; you can read first two paragraphs of it, replacing "Platinum" with "Mysterious Hymn".

Just wondering, when a QAT wants to unqualify a map, can they do it on their own accord or do they actually need get the approval of other QATs aswell? There are times when I see a map get unqualified, and the QAT post say something like, '' Hello there I've talked with this other QAT and this third QAT and we decide this doesnt work so rip your map'', and other times, like Otsukimi Recital and this, where it's just one QAT saying ''This map is bad and is now unqualified''
There's a reason why you need to get maps bubbled before ranking, you know...
- Suima -

给你一个kds,再接再厉人类进化计划
M o M i Z i
毀了一副好SB,唉。
FlobuFlobs

Kotonoha wrote:

TicClick wrote:

Sorry, but this map lacks a fair bit of something that is called quality and should have not been ranked in its current state. If you need more details, this is probably due to blatant abuse of patterns like 00:47:399 (1,2,3,1,2) - and the fact there are barely any distinct and audible sounds you mapped most, if not all streams to. Oh, and also a massive pile of overlapping copypaste that starts from 03:43:584, not speaking of the stream that follows the kiai part on 04:05:781 and ignores any features provided to you by music.

I am also going to refer to this post, as similar situation has already happened once in the past; you can read first two paragraphs of it, replacing "Platinum" with "Mysterious Hymn".

Just wondering, when a QAT wants to unqualify a map, can they do it on their own accord or do they actually need get the approval of other QATs aswell? There are times when I see a map get unqualified, and the QAT post say something like, '' Hello there I've talked with this other QAT and this third QAT and we decide this doesnt work so rip your map'', and other times, like Otsukimi Recital and this, where it's just one QAT saying ''This map is bad and is now unqualified''
There's a reason why you need to get maps bubbled before ranking, you know...
yea sure, but there's also a reason for the qualifie section/qat
Yauxo
Still waiting for approved section 2.0 to happen
dqs01733

FlobuFlobs wrote:

Kotonoha wrote:

Just wondering, when a QAT wants to unqualify a map, can they do it on their own accord or do they actually need get the approval of other QATs aswell? There are times when I see a map get unqualified, and the QAT post say something like, '' Hello there I've talked with this other QAT and this third QAT and we decide this doesnt work so rip your map'', and other times, like Otsukimi Recital and this, where it's just one QAT saying ''This map is bad and is now unqualified''
There's a reason why you need to get maps bubbled before ranking, you know...
yea sure, but there's also a reason for the qualifie section/qat
You're completely missing my point.
Rizia
plz rerank
star~
Kodora
Song have constant 1/4 beats during almost all drain time, and there is absolutely nothing wrong with mapping them, especially considering that they're provided by the song and hitsounded to fit the song perfectly.

And I can totally agree with Tess - dropping out just a broken heart icon without real issues to point out, without proper suggestions of how this may be fixed is so unprofessional.
E m i
I think you have gone too far, HW
but this is still a fun map 8-)
qq10054932
恭喜发财
Princess God
嗯,最后的星星感觉射在了应该射的地方
Nyxa

SnowflakeStreet wrote:

I'm cool with difficult maps, but the song is just not fitting.
What's not fitting about it, though? The song is really intense, as is the map. The sv flows quite well and the patterns match the intensity of the song really well too - I mentioned the last section being too hard earlier, but I still think it fits, despite its ridiculous difficulty. I think people are too used to easier maps. A map's difficulty isn't what makes it good or bad. It's how said difficulty is designed. I think we can all agree that Tenshi isn't a bad map and that map is miles harder than this one.

Except this map uses unique patterns, and that is what you have an issue with. Just like Miss You, which isn't really all that hard at all, but got the same amount of shit. Nobody really cares about a map's difficulty so long as it's mapped in a way preferred to them. That's what I've always seen, at least.

Maybe we need to start making it more clear what the difference is between objective and subjective quality in maps.
captin1
unfortunate that this is the reality of the QAT now, that they believe they can make subjective unranks for "map quality" without any attempt at improving the map because they believe their definition of "quality" is more important than the BATs involved in ranking the map

I personally don't have much of an opinion on the map one way or the other, but the simple fact that this was unqualified on such a weak concept just disappoints me
Natteke desu
hey guys, if you want to see this ranked again best way will be giving some mods
~passing by~
Arrival

captin1 wrote:

unfortunate that this is the reality of the QAT now, that they believe they can make subjective unranks for "map quality" without any attempt at improving the map because they believe their definition of "quality" is more important than the BATs involved in ranking the map

I personally don't have much of an opinion on the map one way or the other, but the simple fact that this was unqualified on such a weak concept just disappoints me
Truth has been spoken
Mismagius

captin1 wrote:

unfortunate that this is the reality of the QAT now, that they believe they can make subjective unranks for "map quality" without any attempt at improving the map because they believe their definition of "quality" is more important than the BATs involved in ranking the map

I personally don't have much of an opinion on the map one way or the other, but the simple fact that this was unqualified on such a weak concept just disappoints me
Yup. Make this my words.
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply