Here's some metadata stuff:
http://littlewitchacademia.jp/tv1st/staffcast/
http://littlewitchacademia.jp/tv1st/music/ed.html
Can you add examination to tags?
Sorry if some stuff overlaps with FDF's or Bober's mods
Lower diffs still need some more work on them
Good luck with the set!
http://littlewitchacademia.jp/tv1st/staffcast/
http://littlewitchacademia.jp/tv1st/music/ed.html
Can you add examination to tags?
Sorry if some stuff overlaps with FDF's or Bober's mods
[ Cup ]
- For better spread, put CS2.4. I also feel 2 is just too big
- The SV here feels much too low, even for just a cup. Even the sliders that are perfectly horizontal require barely any movement. SOmething more like 1.30x base SV would make it much much better
- 00:08:488 (2) - Remove the note here, there's not really any sound on it that is distinct
- 00:41:923 (3,4) - Make this distance larger
- 00:58:641 (1,2) - Why is spacing so low here, should be around 1.10x ds like the others
- 01:13:526 (3) - Removing this slider and replacing it with a circle on 01:13:526 - would give a nice break to newer players, and the sounds the slider is covering don't really work being mapped with a slider imo
- 01:28:412 (1) - because this spinner is so short, I feel it would work better if you had one long slider starting on 01:27:954 -
- Last thing I'll mention for the cup is how the spacing emphasis in it is pretty inconsistent. You do use some, and when you do it works very well 00:25:664 (7,1) - but then for some really stronger sounds you don't use anything 00:40:320 (5,1) - 00:42:839 (5,6) - 00:56:580 (7,1) - and a lot more examples. Would be nice to have more variation in the spacing, even if this is just a cup
[ Salad ]
- Same issue as the Cup, SV is very low
- 00:07:458 (6,1) - Distance here is in an awkward middle between walk and dash. Adjust the distance to make it more like the one you wanted it to be
- 00:24:977 (4,5,6,7) - Not a huge fan of this pattern, something like a single curve made with the 4 notes would make it easier to play this coming out of a dash right before (see box below)
- 00:30:931 (3,1) - Spacing here is much too low
- 00:46:732 (3,4) - Dash here is pretty ambiguous, I'd distance it more. In general the dashes in the intro are a lot easier than the ones in the kiais, which is fine, but what happens is a lot of them are walkable and are readable as walk because of it. Any dashes that are around 2.70x ds I'd recommend increasing the spacing
- 00:56:580 (4,5) - Dash here is way stronger than anything else, I'd recommend making it a bit easier
- 00:49:252 (4,1,2) - Wouldn't put 2 dashes with different snaps right after the other in a salad, players will stop dashing after the first, and miss on the second
- 00:56:809 (5,1,2,3,4,5) - The low spacing on 00:56:809 (5,1) - mixed with the anti-flow on 00:57:267 (1,2,3,4,5) - makes this pattern really weird to play, especially for a salad player
- 01:13:526 (1,2) - Like in the cup, a single circle fits better here
- 01:26:122 (3,1) - Increase spacing here
- 01:27:954 (4,1) - Unrankable, you need at least 1/1 here between start of slider and last note. Because of this, I'd suggest the same thing as the cup here with a slider
[ Platter ]
- 00:26:580 (2,3) - Increase distance, this dash is walkable and pretty ambiguous
- 00:33:106 (8,1) - Dash would work very nicely
- 00:54:061 (2,3) - Rhythm here is unfitting imo, it doesn't really follow the song. Something like in the box below works much better for both vocals and drums
- 01:13:297 (4,1) - HDash here doesn't really fit, as the sound at the end is very weak
- 01:13:526 (1) - Like the other diffs, single circle here is better. If you want to keep it, at least end the slider here on 01:13:984 - and have a circle on 01:14:213 - because that's what you did in the salad
- 01:14:900 (2) - I'D remove this note, it's not really to anything in the song and that would make 01:15:129 (3,1) - stand out more
- Nice platter!
[ Magic ]
- 00:07:572 (1,2) - Movement here is weird due to the low spacing
- To differentiate this diff from the platter, you could use some more HDashes in the intro part 00:18:106 (6,1) - 00:20:168 (7,1) - 00:28:183 (2,3) -
- 00:35:969 (2,3) - Should at least be a dash imo
- 00:59:328 (2,3,1,2,3,4) - I really like this pattern!
- 01:00:244 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - Make the curve less strong here, the current stream here looks off
- 01:20:053 - There a 1/4 drum here that I think you should be mapping
Lower diffs still need some more work on them
Good luck with the set!