agreeing
notsure/nottotally/comments
notagreeing
notsure/nottotally/comments
notagreeing
Really thanks for modding boy! Don't worry about late, still really helpful and sorry if I've fixed somethings by myself, forgot to update :cSylphi wrote:
Sorry for being late. Hi! Don't worry
[Kantan][Futsuu]
- 00:36:069 (50) - Consider changing to k for consistency. comparing to other similar sound (or considering overall patterns), only this is started with kat.
Oh yeah I've fix it yesterday :p- 00:43:269 (63,64,65) - 00:48:069 (70,71,72) - I think It's not good idea to use different color patterns though these are similar pitch patterns. in these part, using same pattern would make beginners able to play more easier probably.
Applied- 00:51:069 (75,76,77) - It should be changed to d k d for consistency with 00:55:869. there is no reason that these similar things is diffrent.
I think holding current one is fine. The reason is I'm following main pitches at making third one don on both cases. So making just the middle note different shouldn't be that problem imo :p. Also dinamicity :3- 01:12:969 (103,104) - Swap these for consistency with 01:08:469 - 01:17:769 (108,109) -.
Fixed!- 01:21:669 (111) - Change to k for consistency.
I think using don to emphatise next kat is fine. Also isn't that different than before one- 01:32:469 (122,123) - Swap these. overall feeling (melody, drums, etc.) not changed. so there is no reason to start with k.
I think melody changes from 01:27:669 - . That kick sound (kat one) is fine imoalso next 4/1 does the same
- 02:08:169 (48) - Well, It may be asked whether It's necessary to map 5 stream with 1/1 divisor. consequently, it make continuous long patterns appear immediately. I think It would be nice to add note on 02:10:569 and make it 5 stream instead.
Yeah I've remapped almost whole kiais yesterday but forgot to update xD- 02:12:969 (59) - Similar reason as above. If you apply above mod, It should be removed for consistency.
^[Muzukashii]
- 00:06:219 (3) - 00:07:419 (6) - 01:27:819 (15) - 01:29:019 (18) - Yeah, there is definitely sound. but It's hard to catch the rhythm at this difficulty.
I think isn't that hard to be honest. They're simply a double with emphasis on second kick ^^- 00:23:469 (46) - Seeing other similar thing, that all are started with don note.
Changed!- 00:27:369 (60) - Change to k for consistency. Also, in the melody, It's little higher than previous thing.
Right! Also consistency with 00:22:569 (44) -- 00:35:469 (86,87,88,89,90,91,92,93) - Similar as 00:23:469. there is no specific reason (sound, pattern, etc.) to change the basic shape. It just make the flow break, make players feel weird consequently.
It's just about dinamicity. Isn't that hard to read considering there's only one note difference between them :p- 00:40:569 (103) - the pitch is higher than previous thing. how about changing this to kat?
Agree- 00:41:769 (106,107,108,109) - Considering the melody, k d d k would be more fit the music.
Sounds great- 00:46:569 (118,119,120,121) - Same as above.
Holding it to make it a little different, also third and fourth are more important than others imo- 01:00:969 (152,153) - Swap these for consistency with 01:05:769 (161,162)
Done- 01:34:269 (33) - Change to k for making pattern? ddd / kkk feels not bad for me.
First one is more descendant than second one so making this to emphatise third note on both cases is fine :p- 01:45:669 (10) - 01:43:269 (6) - Respectively k, d for consistency with after these patterns.
Same reason as above- 01:56:769 (2,3) - Most patterns in kiai time basically has the pattern like as o___o_o_o_... but only this thing starts with o_ooo_o_o_... shape. actually, itself doesn't matter. but if you consider consistency with 02:06:069, it should be removed.
Fixed- 02:03:369 (26) - k for consistency.
Fixed
- 00:08:619 (11) - It's a bit weird feeling and there is actually no sound to map.
I feel like there's sound, and it's clearly a kat so holding- 00:16:569 (41) - k for consistency.
Done- 00:21:669 (62) - How about moving this to 00:21:519 following the melody? as result, it would be more natural to play, I think...
Hmmm I feel like current one is more natural than that. New rhythm on Kiai starts on 00:21:669 - exactly so using kick here is fine ^^
- 00:24:069 (75) - 00:26:469 (87) - 00:28:869 (100) - Similar as above. but It's not forced.
- 00:30:669 (110,111,112,113,114) - It makes me feel awkward. I think, it's necessary to change to o_o_o_o___o pattern because the actual melody is like that. Same opinion about the follow things:
- 00:33:069 (123,124,125,126,127) - Same as above
- 00:35:469 (136,137,138,139,140) -
- 00:37:869 (149,150,151,152,153) -
I'm not totally sure if I'm changing second half of Kiai's right now tbh. I was thinking a lot about this but I feel a melody change between first half and second. For now I'm holding but if I'm requested... I'll change :p- 00:41:769 (167) - Should be k to follow melody. It's higher than previous thing.
Fixed- 00:45:669 (181) - k for consistency with 00:40:869 (164)
I think changing both for d d is better tho- 00:46:269 (183,184) - Swapping these would be more fit the music, in my opinion.
Hmmm holding current one for now, I think it's better- 00:52:269 (207) - Considering 00:56:469 part, It would be better to change to don for consistency.
You're rightchanged
- 00:58:869 - There is a big gap between Futsuu and Muzukashii even considering the feeling of this part. It probably can fix if you remove some 1/4 triplet... I think, It needs to reduce more the density on Muzukashii.
Totally right, fixed!
- Futsuu vs Muzukashii
- 01:34:569 (348) - 01:35:619 - Respectively, Change to kat, Add don. It probably make patterns look more balanced, in my opinion.
Uhh I like this section to be honest. Holding for now :p- 01:42:519 (372) - 01:43:719 (375) - Swap these for consistency.
Hmm I'm holding since I'm following the high pitch here so there's not the same through the whole section- 01:51:219 (402) - Remove for consistency.
Fixed- 01:57:369 - Same as 00:21:669
Same comment- 02:06:069 - Similar as 00:30:669. It seems to be intended to make more harder but I feel like that some rhythm placement is not fit the music.
Same ^^