SPOILER
http://puu.sh/1sDWNNewRulerNA wrote:
[xsrs's Normal]will give the rhythm issues a little more thought, thx for modding!
- 00:06:739 (2,3) - remove all claps. since he does not have clap on 00:05:739 (1), I seemed it should remove. ok, changed a bit
and 00:07:739 (3) - add whistle on slider end. added!- 00:15:072 (3,4,5) - use drum-whistle? I think it is better. I think it is fine
- 00:43:072 (1) - not follow vocal. vocal start is 00:42:905.
I suggest this rythem.
00:42:905 (1) - 3/2 slider
00:43:739 (2) -- 01:04:405 (1) - ^
- 02:03:072 (1) - ^ using 3/2 slider is better.
Konei wrote:
[xrrs's Normal] xsrs's B(
- Well, consider increasing HD/OD for the same reason as Easy. Normal in generall should have a higher setting Increased HD/OD by 1 each
- 00:02:405 (5) - Move a bit to the left to have a better allginment with 3 please This is intentional, I've made it a little more obvious now
- 00:23:739 (3) - Move a bit right to make it look better. Even flow is a bit better as cursor gets in a better position here Sure
- 00:26:405 (4) - I would remove whistle on end and set finish for it. The beat has more power on the end so I'd like to emphasize this by using a more rare finish then the more often whistle (This reply is for every whistle/finish suggestion that has no reply) while I understand the logic behind your suggestion, like finishes being rare and thus having emphasizing power (although I find the sound really weak when laid side by side with whistles), this change is avoided because of the way I put these whistles consistently. I've tried them and it sounds weird to me when there's a sudden scarcity of whistles.
- 00:27:405 (5) - And then I would remove whistle on this. This part is so sudden quiet so the hitsound doesn't fit this pretty well. Without hitsounds this note feels more likely the music
- 00:29:072 (2) - Would you mind removing whistle on Sliderbody? On this Slider is, not like on the one before, a holding voice, so imo the long whistle doesn't really fit with this at all
- 00:30:072 (3) - Same about this note as on 00:27:405
- 00:32:239 (3) - Start sounds really better without that whistle imo
- 00:35:072 (3) - I highly suggest to use finish for the start as this emphasizes downbeat and gives an extra emphasize to the vocal here Added
- 00:45:739 (5) - Remove whistle from this Sliderbody please, sounds noisy at this part
- 00:54:739 (2) - You could use whistle for the Sliderbody here, would fit the sliding vocal Yeah
- 01:09:572 (1) - This one sounds much better without whistle at start. The whistle is high and doesnt fit with this part at all. Addidionally it makes the finish a bit less powerful and takes the "power" out off it, if you understand what I'm trying to say
- 01:25:572 (1) - There is no point using finish for Sliderbody here. Set it for start instead to catch the sound of the heavy beat Fixed
- 01:46:405 (3) - Hm, current place looks a bit odd imo. The start off the Slider is somehow strange to me. Try something more good flowing like Current one is fine
- 01:46:905 (4) - Starting NC here makes much more sense to me. KIAI is starting and soundset is changing, so why not using NC here instead of using it on 01:47:739 ? Fixed
- 01:54:739 (5) - Going with the cursor back here doesn't fit the music well at all. I'd prefer a somehow more simple and just untricky pattern like Actually I'd say it fits pretty well so I'm keeping this
- 02:05:072 (5) - Consider shortning this to the red tick and add a repeat. That would follow melody in a better way then now if you listen I can't catch that melody
- 02:05:739 (1) - Remove clap from repeat please. Sounds odd and unfitting Okay, I went and remove the similar one in front too
- 02:10:905 (3) - Consider using a Finish for start, that helps to emphasize the strong beat here much better Added a few of them
- Well, I'm not liking the whole whistling on Sliderbody. Would be nice if you could reduce it to a better amount. Flow was really cool for whole map and Slidershapes regular and fitting. There were some combos I would have used in another way, but this is a question of mapping style in this place.
Thx for modding! By the way, you only need one [ list ] and [ /list ] for each category