1. Since some people may be confused as to which game this first appeared in, you may want to add "Beatmania IIDX" 15 to the tags.
2. You have a TaikoBG in your folder, but it isn't used on the Taiko difficulty.

1. 00:07:197 - I feel as if you should add a note here due to the fact that it's present in the music. It feels somewhat bland without it.
2. 00:08:577 - Same as above.
3. 00:26:852 (3) - You should make this slider into one that blankets the previous slider. It would look much neater.
4. 01:01:335 (1) - A whistle should be at the beginning and end of this slider.
5. 01:02:714 (2) - ^
6. 01:19:611 (1) - A clap should be on this in order to follow what you were doing at 01:16:852 (2,3,1,2).
7. 01:20:990 (1) - This one too.
8. 01:30:301 (1) - A clap on the end of this one to follow your 2 4 clap pattern.
9. 01:32:628 (1) - This spinner should really start 1 1/4th tick earlier.

1. 00:15:818 (1) - You may want to tilt this slider a bit to go along with the previous angled slider. Like this.

1. 00:03:059 (4) - This should be one grid to the right to from a symmetrical pattern.
2. 01:26:508 (1,2) - What's with the sudden whistles on these sliders? They don't fit with the previous hitsounds.
3. 01:30:990 (1) - The clap should be removed from this slider. It doesn't really sound right to me.

1. 01:09:611 (1) - Rather than a spinner, I believe this section of the song would be better if you mapped it out.

1. 00:47:542 (1,2,3,4,5) - Somewhere in this long series of streams, you really need to give the player a break. This isn't the hardest difficulty.

1. 00:22:714 (1,2,1,2) - =[
2. 00:25:473 (1,2,1,2) - =[
3. 00:32:714 (5) - A clap should be here.

Jacob wrote:

Let's get this back on track.

General

1. Since some people may be confused as to which game this first appeared in, you may want to add "Beatmania IIDX" 15 to the tags.
   Oh okay. ^^ Added Beatmania IIDX only because 15 would be a useless tag.
   
2. You have a TaikoBG in your folder, but it isn't used on the Taiko difficulty.
   Oh lol. fixed
   

Rust

1. 00:07:197 - I feel as if you should add a note here due to the fact that it's present in the music. It feels somewhat bland without it.
   sure
   
2. 00:08:577 - Same as above.
   sure
   
3. 00:26:852 (3) - You should make this slider into one that blankets the previous slider. It would look much neater.
   I tried. But it made me redo the whole map because of the spacing problem. Would love to follow this, but I hope you'll understand if i say no.
   
4. 01:01:335 (1) - A whistle should be at the beginning and end of this slider.
   sure
   
5. 01:02:714 (2) - ^
   sure
   
6. 01:19:611 (1) - A clap should be on this in order to follow what you were doing at 01:16:852 (2,3,1,2).
   k
   
7. 01:20:990 (1) - This one too.
   k
   
8. 01:30:301 (1) - A clap on the end of this one to follow your 2 4 clap pattern.
   k
   
9. 01:32:628 (1) - This spinner should really start 1 1/4th tick earlier.
   No change. This one was suggested by Derekku, so I guess I shall stick to his choice. Hope you understand. :O

Bronze

1. 00:15:818 (1) - You may want to tilt this slider a bit to go along with the previous angled slider. Like this.
   I don't really see any errors here. so I'm afraid I'm going to say no. Hope you understand.

Chrome

1. 01:09:611 (1) - Rather than a spinner, I believe this section of the song would be better if you mapped it out.
   Replace this one with slider stream. ^^

Gold

1. 00:47:542 (1,2,3,4,5) - Somewhere in this long series of streams, you really need to give the player a break. This isn't the hardest difficulty.
   This ain't the hardest, but it's an 'Insane Diff'. On the other hand, I guess a 1/2 break for every 5 notes is just enough for this difficulty.

Platinum

1. 00:22:714 (1,2,1,2) - =[
   i hope this would be the final suggestion i'll receive for this one. I change this one and moved all (2) as near as I can.
   
2. 00:25:473 (1,2,1,2) - =[
   same as above.
   
3. 00:32:714 (5) - A clap should be here.

Good luck!
Now this is what I call a good mod. Thank you so much for rechecking ^^

Jacob wrote:

Let's get this back on track.
Emdyion's Silver

1. 00:03:059 (4) - This should be one grid to the right to from a symmetrical pattern. I checked with CTRL+H, and it already seems symmetrical to 1
2. 01:26:508 (1,2) - What's with the sudden whistles on these sliders? They don't fit with the previous hitsounds. Fixed.
3. 01:30:990 (1) - The clap should be removed from this slider. It doesn't really sound right to me.

Fixed.


Good luck!

Jacob wrote:

Platinum

00:22:714 (1,2,1,2) - =[
00:25:473 (1,2,1,2) - =

1. inconsistency in source
2. stats in Gold
3. some spacing in Platinum

Quiz-chan wrote:

one more bubbleeee, come ooon.

Derekku wrote:

Quiz-chan wrote:

one more bubbleeee, come ooon.

It's not going for Approval, so it only needs one bubble and then a heart. :p

JappyBabes wrote:

That moment when people complain about Platinum being too hard yet people FCd the harder version within the first day of initial ranking.

JappyBabes wrote:

That moment when people complain about Platinum being too hard yet people FCd the harder version within the first day of initial ranking.

dkun wrote:

JappyBabes wrote:

That moment when people complain about Platinum being too hard yet people FCd the harder version within the first day of initial ranking.

That moment when someone walks in a thread and starts pointing fingers, yet said person has no idea with the background story, or for that fact; can't even read the thread properly and starts assuming things.

On a side note, great set now.

Ephemeral wrote:

it's not even difficult?

literally anyone with any proper streaming practice could ss that map in a few goes

JappyBabes wrote:

dkun wrote:

That moment when someone walks in a thread and starts pointing fingers, yet said person has no idea with the background story, or for that fact; can't even read the thread properly and starts assuming things.

On a side note, great set now.

Oh because you know whether I've been looking at this thread from the start.

dkun wrote:

you have no idea what a proper map is

JappyBabes wrote:

dkun wrote:

you have no idea what a proper map is

http://osu.ppy.sh/wiki/Ranking_Criteria#General What.

Ephemeral wrote:

nothing could possibly justify how one is to fill an entire difficulty with a majority of pointless 1/4 streams and unfounded jumps. this is not difficulty - this is pure, unabated laziness. to rank this map in this state would be an affront to all the other hardworking mappers which place obvious effort into making their maps both fun and suitably difficult without resorting to such ridiculous methods.

you would be better off completely removing Platinum difficulty, to be perfectly honest. a two-page modpost would be barely scratching the sheer quantity of problems with this map. you have effectively made a TAG difficulty, and they are not allowed anymore.

until platinum is appropriately addressed (ergo, is either deleted or significantly changed to actually reflect the music it is mapped to), this map is not suitable for ranking. all the other difficulties are well-measured and beautifully mapped, why sully the set with one ridiculous difficulty?

Ephemeral wrote:

you can fill an entire beatmap with 1/4s and claim it fits with the music as and as long as it does not violate the ranking criteria, you could effectively claim it is rankable. does that mean it is a good idea to rank the map? hardly

JappyBabes wrote:

Ephemeral wrote:

you can fill an entire beatmap with 1/4s and claim it fits with the music as and as long as it does not violate the ranking criteria, you could effectively claim it is rankable. does that mean it is a good idea to rank the map? hardly

So it comes down to whether a BAT/Admin likes it or not even though they probably won't play it. I love this ranking system.

dkun wrote:

If you don't like it, then simply leave. Is it that hard to comprehend?

dkun wrote:

If you don't like it, then simply leave. Is it that hard to comprehend?

dkun wrote:

If you don't like it, then simply leave. Is it that hard to comprehend?

JappyBabes wrote:

rankable

JappyBabes wrote:

dkun wrote:

If you don't like it, then simply leave. Is it that hard to comprehend?

It's completely rankable and some people like it. It follows the music. There is no moderation here, just "I don't like this map". The mapper also has a right to deny mods if they don't assist in what he wanted the map to be. A BAT shouldn't have full say over a map.

JappyBabes wrote:

Pointless and unjustified 1/4 streams? The whole song is just a piano with fast notes. Not much you can do there. Also, I find the map both enjoyable and difficult. Also, nice job on just completing deflecting my point that the difficulty is rankable.

Philippines wrote:

Why would I map make a 7 diff map if you think I'm lazy? I think you're the one who's lazy for having 2 diff mapsets ~

dkun wrote:

Philippines wrote:

Why would I map make a 7 diff map if you think I'm lazy? I think you're the one who's lazy for having 2 diff mapsets ~

I'm sorry? At least I don't put notes randomly all over the screen and call it a map.

quality > quantity

dkun wrote:

Philippines wrote:

Why would I map make a 7 diff map if you think I'm lazy? I think you're the one who's lazy for having 2 diff mapsets ~

I'm sorry? At least I don't put notes randomly all over the screen and call it a map.

quality > quantity

Philippines wrote:

Enough dkun, enough. You already won, Platinum is gone. WHAT MORE DO YOU WANT?

JappyBabes wrote:

http://osu.ppy.sh/s/7671 http://osu.ppy.sh/s/23058 You were saying?

dkun wrote:

JappyBabes wrote:

http://osu.ppy.sh/s/7671 http://osu.ppy.sh/s/23058 You were saying?

I feel like you didn't read a word of what I said.

nold_1702 wrote:

rank來的不是自己喜歡的
rank來幹什麼?

Philippines wrote:

Platinum is a Legend. No one will ever forget this diff.

thelewa wrote:

Philippines wrote:

Platinum is a Legend. No one will ever forget this diff.

what diff?

those wrote:

JappyBabes wrote:

rankable

We don't mod to rank "rankable" maps. We mod to rank maps that can hardly get better.

tony8128 wrote:

I'm sorry, but it seems that Chrome difficulty is glitched.
Osu keeps telling me to update to latest version even if I have already downloaded the latest .osu file.
Has someone else also experienced this problem?

tony8128 wrote:

I'm sorry, but it seems that Chrome difficulty is glitched.
Osu keeps telling me to update to latest version even if I have already downloaded the latest .osu file.
Has someone else also experienced this problem?

Makar wrote:

Secondly, I think people should stop complaining about the platinum diff being deleted, and please read what Mr Color said = = it's very true.

Mr Color wrote:

okay few things to point out here

platinum diff wasn't either fun or original, it was just streams. There's many ways to make a very challenging difficulty with this song without filling it with streams. It's rankable; but is it worth the rank? If I map something where I just repeat one pattern over and over just copypasting, flipping horizontally, vertically, rotating and whatnot, technically, it's rankable. Is it fun? Hell no. To the map's benefit, I thought the sped-up sliders, as much controversy as they caused, were, in essence, a nice idea. They just needed to be used better.

More about the Platinum difficulty; it's simply unreasonable. 85% of the map was streams, hands down. When I play a map, I don't expect it to just hand the SS to me, but I don't expect to get stuck on it for hours on end because there are too many streams - yes there is such a thing - and my arm simply starts to get tired. When I play a map, I expect it to go like this: "Okay, you're going to have to master a number of various techniques to beat me or FC me." Now, I might not get it on my first try, I might not get it on my tenth try, but at no point will I judge that I've been asked to do something that is unreasonable. This difficulty was unreasonable.

Just don't rank maps because they're rankable. Rank them because they're fun. maps that are original, readable, that flow well, that follow the music, and overall provide a great rhythm experience. You don't need over-the-top difficulty to have fun and enjoy the game.


Good luck to Philippines for this map, is it is now a reasonable mapset. Let us forget about that Platinum difficulty, it's not there anymore.

Philippines wrote:

Can soneone please unrank my map? I wanna bring. Back and FIX Platinum.

Ephemeral wrote:

i offered philippines the chance to fix the rest of platinum by making the bulk of the map more than just 1/4 streams, but he refused at the time.

osu!wiki wrote:

Even if you don't follow the modder's advice, did you not follow it because of your personal choice only, and not because the modding seemed pointless to you?

JappyBabes wrote:

Ephemeral wrote:

i offered philippines the chance to fix the rest of platinum by making the bulk of the map more than just 1/4 streams, but he refused at the time.

osu!wiki wrote:

Even if you don't follow the modder's advice, did you not follow it because of your personal choice only, and not because the modding seemed pointless to you?

It should be fine or am I missing something here?

Ephemeral wrote:

tony8128 wrote:

I'm sorry, but it seems that Chrome difficulty is glitched.
Osu keeps telling me to update to latest version even if I have already downloaded the latest .osu file.
Has someone else also experienced this problem?

a few others - try redownloading the map from scratch and if that fails, open a thread in help and support regarding the issue.

winber1 wrote:

i still get that vibe of those who can't stream/beat it rage and call it bad, and those who can say it's good. for the most part.
but actually.... meh

Mr Color wrote:

The map had a user rating of 6.3 back when it was first rank. This is REALLY LOW for a map with a IIDX/pop'n music song. You might say some people like it, but clearly the majority of the users don't. If we check its ratings now, it is at 8.8 and I wouldn't be surprised if it went up to >9.0 in the next few days.