beatmap discussion
New Discussion
Please sign in to post or reply
Hype
Sign in and hype this beatmap to make it more visible for nomination and ranking!
PraiseSuggestionProblem
Discussions
Sort by
Regular soft whistles sounds better and clearer than the custom soft 1 is, can you use that instead? At least for majority of the parts where vocals are much more the focus like the starting section
Marked as resolved by [Kagamine Rin]
Marked as resolved by [Kagamine Rin]
For Taiko diffs (except SN707 & Rycy sets, because it's looking fine)
Make sure to "Resnap All Notes" before uploading. Some notes are not snapped properly. This can happen when you try to copy-paste many of the same pattern to different timings. (Also can't be detected by AiMod).
Edit: This can be resolve by the map owner, so the gd's no need to upload a new one. But make sure to always do it before uploading in the future.
Last edited by Rossi .
oh oops MV didnt show me will do it wait what diffs though MV doesnt show me?
Last edited by [Kagamine Rin] .
okay didnt read ur text fully oops uh ty for showing resnap thing on DC its fixed now through Futsuu oni inner oni Kantan didnt had it
Marked as resolved by [Kagamine Rin]
Marked as resolved by [Kagamine Rin]
Marked as resolved by [Kagamine Rin]
Marked as resolved by [Kagamine Rin]
So we remove it i just thought it be nice since Ady Digitalfear maps kinda old but sure i could revert it for some of the diffs, i will reopen rhis to get opinions from the other gders
Reopened by [Kagamine Rin]
Wait digitalfear gave me an idea will make an custom higurashi themed skin will leave this open once its done
Marked as resolved by [Kagamine Rin]
kantan:
00:06:223 - delete
00:14:205 - make don
00:24:939 - move note here 00:25:214 -
00:34:021 - add don
01:01:544 - add don
01:05:948 - add kat
01:14:205 - here to 01:15:306 - here add spinner too boring
01:19:709 - add kat
01:28:517 - ^
01:26:865 - this section is a 1/2 and should be mapped as d k d k d k k d (Map all sections similar to that in the chorus with that flow and itll feel better to the player <3)
01:32:370 - delete note and add stream from here to 01:33:196 -
Futsuu:
00:16:131 - add don
00:25:489 - add don
00:25:765 - make kat
00:30:168 - move note to 00:30:031 - and make kat
00:35:397 - add don
00:38:150 - here to 00:39:251 - add spinner too boring
00:40:076 - make don
00:42:003 - here to 00:43:104 - here make it like 00:39:801 - (it repeats perfectly here lol)
00:43:930 - delete note
00:43:379 - make don???
00:45:031 - move note to 00:44:755 - here and make a kat
00:46:407 - add don
00:46:957 - add kat
00:47:783 - move this note to 00:47:508 -
00:55:214 - add kat
00:55:489 - add don
00:56:040 - move this note to 00:55:764 -
00:56:315 - make don
00:57:416 - here add d k k before finisher at a 1/2 tick
01:04:021 - add don
01:05:122 - add kat
01:05:673 - spinner once again too boring
01:10:902 - delete
01:14:205 - add kat
01:14:755 - add kat
make the final section less boring by using more unique triple patterns
01:00:168 - I feel like a don should be added here for flow but a BN might give you shit for it D:
01:01:544 - delete
01:02:370 - add don
01:10:076 - add don
Muzuu:
00:06:223 - make don?
00:13:379 - you can barely hear this sound make it a don
00:16:682 - make don
00:16:957 - make kat
00:20:260 - make don
00:22:186 - make don
00:25:764 - make kat
00:26:040 - make don
00:29:893 - move this note to 00:30:031 - here
00:33:196 - make kat
00:33:746 - make don
00:35:673 - add kat
00:36:223 - delete you're mapping to vocals here
00:38:425 - here to 00:39:526 - here delete notes and make a slider
00:41:453 - make ddk
00:43:654 - make don
00:45:994 - add kat
00:47:783 - move this note to 00:47:508 -
00:48:058 - make kkd
00:51:361 - make kdk
00:53:012 - make don
00:53:563 - make kat
00:55:764 - here to 00:56:040 - here add slider
00:56:315 - add kat
00:56:865 - make don
00:57:278 - make kat
00:58:792 - make kat
01:00:994 - make don
01:01:269 - make kat
01:01:682 - make kat
01:02:370 - add don
01:02:508 - add don
01:02:645 - make kat
01:03:471 - make this kdd
01:05:122 - make this kkd k
01:06:086 - make don
01:07:875 - make don
01:10:076 - make this kkd
01:13:104 - map this section as dkd kdk dkd kkd
01:15:856 - ending patterns are too boring follow the previous changes as an example on how to map the ending <3
00:03:470 - add spinner from here to 00:04:846 -
00:55:764 - add kat
64 bit's oni:
00:07:049 - move this note to 00:07:324 -
00:15:856 - move this note to 00:16:131 -
00:20:535 - make don
00:24:664 - move this note to 00:24:939 -
00:25:489 - make don
00:27:553 - add don
00:49:709 - add don
00:54:113 - make dkd
00:54:939 - add don
00:55:076 - add kat
whoever mapped this I LOVE this diff it feels like a real taiko map after my changes <3
00:39:801 - add don
00:40:076 - add k
00:40:352 - make kkK
01:17:783 - make don?
01:22:186 - ^
01:30:994 - ^
Oni:
00:36:498 - add don
00:37:324 - delete
00:38:150 - add don
00:44:480 - make kkd
00:45:031 - make don
00:49:709 - add don
00:56:315 - make kat
01:04:297 - make this kdkkd
01:10:352 - make kat
01:15:031 - make kat
01:24:388 - make don
01:26:865 - make kat
I hope this helps <3
Try to give a reasoning behind each change you suggest (pitch changes aren't really valid, you can suggest different colours if it's a structure or flow issue). Right now you're giving the mapper a lot to read but it's essentially nothing as they won't know why you suggested anything and won't be able to decide and apply properly. You also have to keep in mind mapper's intentions, because you suggested so many changes that work well with your personal liking and interpretation of the song, but maybe they don't work well with what the mapper wants to do. I'm saying this because this mod is unfortunately not very useful, for the next mod you'll do you'll hopefully be able to give a reasoning and understand what the mapper wants to do, so I hope this message helps you with your modding improvement!
To summarise, you need a reasoning for what you say
EXAMPLE 1
00:37:324 - delete (bad mod)
00:37:324 - delete because there's no prominent sound here and it takes away emphasis from stronger sounds/ it makes the pattern flow in an uncomfortable way,which is unusual in this difficulty so it feels odd in the context of the map (good mod)
EXAMPLE 2
01:15:031 - make kat (bad mod)
01:15:031 - make kat because you mapped this sound every time as a kat but not here, which creates an inconsistency/the pattern is overly complex currently, changing this colour makes it easier and more suitable for the diff you're mapping (good mod)
random examples which should make you understand it properly :D
i forgot to say BUT muzu gets replaced nd some of the mods are really questionable so i wont apply, mainly curious why someone would add a stream in a kantan lol? i will let 64bit resolve this
Marked as resolved by [Kagamine Rin]
regarding the rhythm issues in the lower difficulty:
Easy&Normal
---------------
in the section from 00:05:398 - to 00:36:223 -, the easy difficulty feels quite similar to the normal difficulty. there are even parts like 00:09:526 (1,2,3,4) - and 00:16:131 (4,5,6) - where the rhythm intensity is exactly the same in both difficulties. in the easy difficulty, only a few parts, such as 00:30:168 (4) -, have fewer rhythms compared to the normal difficulty, but the rest are almost identical. i can see some places using repeat sliders, but it's not enough.
at 109bpm, even with relaxed restrictions for the easy difficulty, it's still important to consider difficulty allocation. the simplest solution is to reduce the 1/2 rhythms in the easy difficulty and continue to focus on 1/1 rhythms.
Hard
---------------
similar to the difficulty issue between easy and normal, the kiai part in hard does not distinguish well from normal, and the entire map has almost no spacing variation, maintaining a 1.0 distance throughout.
in hard difficulty, you can place a few large spacings at accent positions, without needing to use ds throughout.
secondly, the rhythm in the kiai part is almost the same as in normal. it feels like another slightly harder normal.
adding a few streams and more triples, not exceeding those in the insane diff, to the kiai section can increase the intensity.
i see what you mean for easy nd normal however i do think its kinda hard to have make them have diffrent rhythms given the song for the intro i feel like this is okay for easy/normal but i will wait it out for someone else their thoughts about this, i will let @digitalfear117 resolve this as there is something for Hard diff in here
Agree with most of your concerns. The diff has been reworked to create more spacing emphasis during the kiai and a few other spots with some smaller emphasis. The SV multipliers on the fast sliders was changed to 1.25x as I liked that a little bit more. I did not add any larger bursts, I do feel like it's a bit much for a hard. Thank you for the mods!
Marked as resolved by [Kagamine Rin]
ah top diff is already getting made by https://osu.ppy.sh/users/21664343 but if i decide to make this a 5diff i will probably shoot u a pm
I forgot to ask u im sorry but if u want my next map for taiko will be samsa if ur interested in gding that just write me on discord "cupnoodletext"