Mr. Perfectly Fine (Taylor's Version) (From The Vault) mapped by JoshEco4‬ · beatmap discussion‬ | ‭osu!‬

beatmap discussion

0

mapped by JoshEco4

submitted 14 Mar 2023

last updated 26 Jan 2025

This beatmap wasn't updated since 26 January 2025 so it was graveyarded...

New Discussion

Please sign in to post or reply

Discussions

[Both Mr. BPChingu's Oni and Muzukashii]

i honestly have some gripes with the intro section

00:03:794 -> 00:17:911 - this works on the top diff because there's some improv alongside it but you should probably add SOME variation so it's not just kdd kdd kdd for the entire thing

00:17:029 -> 00:46:146 - from 00:46:146 onwards the improv gets alright but before that it feels very bland (and the 2 diffs even play a bit too similar imo because oni barely has any 3plets going on)
i think you should base it a bit like 01:28:499 onwards (preferably apply mods from that section beforehand though) because that section actually flows a lot more nicely compared to it

7 months ago

took a look into it and adjusted oni accordingly approximate to the 2nd verse (they are slightly different i guess)

7 months ago

that's what i did, only josh can resolve this post eyy

7 months agoLast edited by BPChingu 7 months ago.

eyy

7 months ago

Marked as resolved by JoshEco4

[All non-GD diffs, BPC's diffs optional]

04:28:941 - maybe add a spinner here? kinda a waste leaving the fadeout here unmapped imo

9 months ago

idk why i didnt add a spinner there before, added now

9 months ago

Marked as resolved by JoshEco4

(for the record) ending solid enough for me not to add a spinner imo.

7 months agoLast edited by BPChingu 7 months ago.

7 months ago

oh ok

8 months ago

[All non-GD diffs]

Kiai toggle inconsistency found at 04:14:327. Maybe make them more consistent? Unless you have your reasoning for doing so.

9 months ago

oops i forgot, will change to 1/2 gap between kiai toggles (more kiai coverage as it's the most epic kiai of the song with the key change and all) to match 04:00:043 - and similar parts

9 months ago

Marked as resolved by JoshEco4

wait im stupid its only in top diff

9 months ago

ok im just gonna make it the same as the other diffs

9 months ago

yea i post in all diffs in case you want to make kf the same as top, or vice versa

9 months ago

you did such a wonderful job at modding my map, thank you so much ^^

9 months ago

^^ gl with ranking

9 months ago

[All non-GD diffs]

04:00:209 - consider remove this greenline, as you have a greenline to toggle back kiai 1/8 later

this also creates some kiai flashes which might cause some reading difficulty.

9 months agoLast edited by Amasugi 9 months ago.

moved to 04:00:043 instead to be more consistent with other kiai toggles

9 months ago

Marked as resolved by JoshEco4

Spek:

9 months ago

Hello, Mr. Perfectly Fine. How's your heart after breaking mine?

10 months agoLast edited by Lexa14 10 months ago.

JOSHECO4 FULL SPREAD

2 years ago

yeah and i think i'm failing

2 years ago

(JoshEco4's Version) (From The Vault)

2 years agoLast edited by BPChingu 2 years ago.

/

›

›

›

›