mapped by -Hyde
submitted
last updated
Hype Train7 / 5
Nomination Status0 / 2
New Discussion
Please sign in to post or reply
Discussions
Sort by

00:01:382 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - I believe you're oversimplifying this section. The first group 00:01:382 (1,2,3,4) - with 1/1 rhythm works better because the second part 00:03:200 (5,6,7) - has synths sounds on the red ticks and needs proper distinction. If you check hard diff 00:03:200 (5,6,7) - and normal 00:01:382 (1,2,3,4,1) - both have that.

permalink

The rhythm on 00:05:018 (1,2,3,4) - works tho because the pattern drastically changed.

permalink

If it was intentionally undermapped I thought it was for the best at the time :/ I already buffed it a bit and remapped that part so that the patterns have more synergy

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Hyde

00:04:109 (1,3) - swap nc? nothing really changes aside from that little background instrument becoming higher pitch. Whereas a very noticeable bass kick starts on 00:05:018 (3)

permalink

done

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Hyde

since you're doing a symmetry map, it's very important to keep the visual distinctions for patterns that are mapping the same rhythm but covers different stuff in the song. Things like 00:06:836 (1,2,3,4) - and 00:20:245 (1,2,3,4) - using the same idea for drastically different sounds could be improved with some variation.

permalink

ok i changed it to two sliders

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Hyde

00:08:200 (3) - you could make this more comfortable if you remove a reverse and hit this note 00:08:654 with an active sound

permalink

I agree and I changed the end for a note, thanks C:

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Hyde

00:12:972 (5,6,7) - Since the map is overall very consistent and clear with its usage of visual spacing, it's kinda weird to have these 1/4 objects spaced as if they are 1/2 objects, especially when there's no increase in intensity to really back it up. This is the only part of the map that does this outside of the chorus/solo, so to me it just doesn't feel fitting.

permalink

Nice, done

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Hyde

00:14:563 (4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11) - tidy these up a little for better visuals, like this: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/17665017/f630

permalink

I'll leave it as it is

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Hyde

00:14:563 (4,5) - Broken stack, move it under the slider again

permalink
permalink
permalink
permalink

All done!

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Hyde

00:20:245 (1,2) - using circles here to mirror 00:06:836 (1,2,3,4) would be pretty cool

permalink

i changed the sliders for circles

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Hyde

00:23:200 (2,3) - You repeat this often but the vocals are actually doing this rhythm https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/17668492/be7b so you may wanna rework all these similar rhythms to this.

permalink

Also the same pattern is repeated frequently even where the music is different, such as 00:24:109 (5,6) - 00:25:927 (11,12) - 00:30:472 (2,3) - 00:34:109 (2,3) - It would be cool if you introduced more variations of this rhythm to represent different musical patterns more effectively.

permalink

I like it the way it is

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Hyde

00:23:200 - ~ 00:52:291 - during the entire verse you only ignored the vocals twice 00:45:472 (3,4) - and 00:48:654 (2,3) - . This variation comes very inconsistent within the section and its second iteration feels with both vocals lines passive is a massive let down. I'd recommend either making it consistent with 00:45:472 (3,4) - or change both to keep the vocal line on red tick active.

permalink

You're right I modified it so that it has synergy with the whole verse

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Hyde

Done, thanks c:

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Hyde

00:34:791 (4,5) - a higher, stronger vocal has quite low spacing here but right afterwards, a less powerful vocal has way bigger spacing 00:35:472 (6,7,8) - . i suggest swapping the spacings to make it follow the song better and stay consistent with the map

for comparison, you had large spacing for higher pitch at 00:30:927 (3,4,5) - , smaller spacing right after

permalink

You're right, I changed the space. Thanks!

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Hyde

00:35:927 (8) - missing hitsound on the start

permalink

you're right I added a hitsound

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Hyde

01:28:541 (11) - here as well? Different colour to cut across the previous streams

permalink

I applied both thank you

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Hyde

00:48:654 (2,3) - Personally I'd suggest you changing this rhythm to something that better represents the vocal line on the reverse and sliderend of this.

permalink

I modified it following the last advice

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Hyde

00:51:495 (4,5,6) - It's kinda weird if these sliderheads 00:51:950 (5,6) are on blue ticks.
I suggest place the sliderheads on white or red ticks... or maybe just make a burst of 4 notes instead these 00:51:950 (5,6).

permalink

I made a change to that part to make some of the loud sounds clickable

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Hyde

00:52:745 (1,2,3) - the heart slider is cute but the music doesn't follow this rhythm at all. This rhythm fits much better: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/17668504/7e94

permalink

For now I will leave it as it is. I will consider your advice for the future if it is absolutely necessary to make the change. Thanks!

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Hyde

00:55:927 (1) - as the Hard diff shows, try to make this slider 1/3 so to give consistency spread

permalink

Done

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Hyde

Thanks a lot, I'm glad you like it!

permalink

00:58:882 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - In this pattern it would make more sense to end it 01:02:291 (4) - where it started 00:58:882 (1,2,3) - somewhere in the first triangle and then you work around the square on 01:02:291 (4,1,2,3,4) -

permalink

It looks better thanks!

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Hyde

01:00:472 (4,3) - these are not stacked properly

permalink

I think I fixed it

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Hyde

01:01:382 (4,3) - broken stack

permalink
permalink

I adjust them

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Hyde

01:04:942 (11) - The drum here is not a sound snapped to anything, it's just a buzz roll. However it definetly sounds closer to have its first sound being snapped on the blue tick 01:04:904 - . I'd recommend making a slow slider instead of multiple reverse in this case, since the default drum slider-slide perfectly represents the song here.
If you still want to keep a fast reversed overmapped, you could, but using 1/6 is just unfitting since there's no subdivion change here.

permalink

I kept the slider overmapped but at 1/4

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Hyde

01:05:018 - maybe add a green line here to 35% hs volume or lower, sounds weird having 70% volume with constant 1/4 reverses when nothing is happening in the song.

permalink

Yeah I like it

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Hyde

01:09:563 (4) - The vocal rhythm is a really interesting double thing which is totally worth mapping.

permalink

You're right, that part sounded a bit slow to me. I fixed it.

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Hyde

01:10:472 (8,9) - 01:17:745 (2,3) - too distant 3/4 jump. this is surely a mistake during the playbase since it is very unexpected, these are also the unique super jump in the whole diff present in the kiai. you should remove the circle to make them 1/2 jump that would work better

permalink

I removed the 3/4 circles

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Hyde

01:21:382 (6,1) - I believe you're undermapping too much with this spinner. You did in a way that's supposed to follow the vocals at 01:21:382 - , but you're missing an important guitar sound in 01:22:063 - which is also what you follow afterwards in 01:23:200 (1,2,3,1,2,3,4) - .
You can go with slider into spinner if you want to keep the spinner and make sure it lasts long enough.

permalink

I removed the spinner and added a slider instead

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Hyde

01:21:722 - could map a 1/4 slider or a double here for the drums, currently rhythm feels empty considering since it's going into an intense guitar solo :p

permalink

I'll changed it

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Hyde

01:23:882 (1,3) - have these sliders symmetric, I would reccomend something like this but its up to you: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/17665023/5cc5

permalink

I like the idea, I will adapt it my way

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Hyde

01:25:586 (5,1) - I think this spacing is very high for a 1/4 pattern

permalink

I will take this into account in the future, although I don't see it as a very big problem.

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Hyde

01:25:586 (5,1) - This comes very off with the rest of the map. You didn't use any stream jump prior to this and overall the spacing of 1/4 wasn't this big anywhere else in the map. Even considering slider ends to streams spacing it's usually not that big 01:24:563 (4,1) - , 01:26:609 (3,1) - . So unless you have a very strong reason to use this, I'd say you should definetly re-work spacing here.

permalink

I remapped the spaces

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Hyde

01:27:745 (5,6,7,8,9) - this stream is a bit underwhelming spacing wise. In terms of comparision, 01:25:132 (1,2,3,4,5) - it's the same spacing even tho it's way less intense, 00:15:586 (8,9,10,11) - is even bigger spaced in the intro, same goes to 00:36:836 (1,2,3,4,5,6,1) - and 00:51:836 (1,2,3,4,5) - . I'd recommend buffing this so that it stands out like it should.
This applies as well to 01:28:427 (10,11) - which could use the same spacing for the doubles as 01:26:950 (1,2) - .

permalink

I modified the ending to have more synergy

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Hyde
/