Mystica
Bobo
Ty for star Mystica and ty for mods both!
SPOILER
Mystica wrote:
here comes my mod.
[Easy]
00:05:444 (2,4) - cancen the whistle Hm, this is consistent with my whistle pattern on all of my diffs, I follow the guitar and I think whistle sound really nice with it.
01:11:230 (4) - nazi mod.make it symmetrical Hm, guess I made it better
01:27:730 (2) - cancen the whistle Same reason as before
01:30:944 (1) - make this spinner end at white line (all diff Listen to piano, I'm sure that there is nothing on the white tick, but 1/8 earlier on the yellow tick.
[Insane]
00:10:372 (1,2,3) - I listen many times..feel that it's not 1/6...at least not very fit The piano is very prominent here, I think it's weird just continuing the same rhythm I did and also for variety in rhythm as I reuse the rhythm I think 5 times.
other seems fine
star
Bobo
SPOILER
Bobo wrote:
Hey there :3
[General]
Kiai isn't consistant on every diff, if you look closely at Normal and Easy you can see a slight difference. There is no note where I end the kiai time on the other diffs in Easy, so I just end it on the closest next note instead. Thinking about this, it can't really hurt to move Easy kiai time back, but I'm looking for a reason except for consistency reason on why to do this.
01:37:801 - All the audio from here is unused, I suggest cutting this out. I did a quick test of how much file size it would save and it just 0.18mb, around 8%, I don't think this is a very significant difference and I think you should only really do this for longer song as 8% become much larger when mp3 file is at 10mb for example and when more of the mp3 is unused.
[Easy]
00:28:372 - This is where the background effects start to kick in, new players would assume the slider starts here and click too early. I suggest placing a hitobject here. I did this just to not get complaint about not leaving enough recovery time for beginner to recover after a spinner, if there is no problem with this, I would extend the spinner by 1/1. Since it's a slider, I don't think this play really bad due to how forgiving a slider is on timing window.
00:57:944 (3) - Sliders with this sort of shape look out of place when you don't use hitobjects to compliment them, I suggest reshaping. I don't understand what you mean here, how can I compliment this slider shape? I chose this slider shape to emphasize "te nai" at the end to compensate for using a long slider. Just something I like to do when mapping easier diffs, just to follow the song a little better. I really see no problems here.
01:01:372 (3) - ^ ^
[Normal]
00:22:801 (4,5) - How about moving these lower below (3) so that they aren't so far to the left? Well look at where (3) is pointing, I want to line (4) up with end of (3) so if I had more space, I would probably move (4) a bit more down. Tried adjusting, but can't do much while keeping to this idea as the note are almost off grid.
00:25:587 (3) - It fits better if you finish this on the white tick, don't forget to move the spinner a tad forward. I don't see a problem with this, listening to vocal, I think of 2 long sliders and not 1 long and 1 short.
00:39:301 (2) - ^ ^
01:14:658 (3) - This slider looks a bit crumpled and doesn't fit well without other hitobjects to fit with it, like I said with the sliders in [Easy]. I suggest reshaping, and I wouldn't use red anchors. Same as in Easy, regarding red anchors, I use it here to slow down the slider and emphasize this note, using the same slider shape as everything else doesn't accent this note well at all imo.
[Insane]
00:40:801 (3,4,5,6) - This would make a very nice diamond shape ;3 Adjust this
And well that's about all I can find for Insane, I'm not too fond of the spacing. Hm, what do you dislike in particular about the spacing (except lot of inconsistency XD), does it play bad? Did some part become confusing to play due to the spacing? Did some spacing change seem really random? I didn't really check the spacing much so maybe some stuff were not intentional.
---------------------------------------------------
Very nice mapset, good luck getting ranked ~ ty, only one change, but I think I explained everything. The only thing I'm confuse about is regarding slider shape and maybe tell me what you dislike in particular about the spacing in Insane.
Ty for star Mystica and ty for mods both!