forum

ITT: Odaril mods mod posts (open)

posted
Total Posts
46
Topic Starter
Shiro
READ BEFORE POSTING

With the increasing number of modders (subsequent to the increasing number of modders), I find the global mod quality to be awfully low. Some people (too few to my taste) care about improving their modding as well as their mapping. So I'm proposing to help them. This is like a generalized mentoring: instead of focusing on one person, I'd just help lots of people improve their mods. This is what this modding queue is for: I mod mod posts and not maps.

Any map posted will be ignored.

There's no rule for now. If people are people, I will add some in later.

Here's how it works: a modder posts in this thread a link to a mod post he made he thinks is either really good or really bad, and I will PM (forum) them quoting the mod post and commenting it.

Use your head. I won't check this thread every 10 minutes, so no need to spam me of mods to mod. Don't expect me to reply in an hour either: I have a life (yes I do), I have classes to attend, and other hobbies. Also, just because I am MAT doesn't mean I am the ultimate modder and that everything I say is true. Far from it. If you want to discuss something I've said, I will gladly talk with you about it.

Let's see how well it goes.

EDIT1: as expected, people were people. Made the thread title clearer.
EDIT2: You must wait 5 posts before posting again.
Ekaru
Okay, let's try this. Here's a mod post I made that I have no idea of the quality of:

viewtopic.php?p=991766#p991766

Advice, please! ^_^
Kawayi Rika
hi,odaril~

I hope you can MOD more MAP~ :)
KayeSara
OK, that's better for improve a modder than mapper, and that's what I think.
But, actually they have do good enough, except something like precisely clarify the title, tag etc for they just got no responsibility.
Anyway, have good luck~ ;)
Topic Starter
Shiro
Done. Next posts please.
Zelos
Raging Bull
I would love your mod of modding my mod right here

It was rather difficult to me since...well it's not what I'm used to modding.
Derekku
Deleted non-mod-post posts.
SapphireGhost
viewtopic.php?p=1030289#p1030289 One of my latest mods. Hope it's not too bad.
Mismagius
Topic Starter
Shiro

Derekku wrote:

Deleted non-mod-post posts.
Thanks Derek.

Done. Next posts please !
eldnl
viewtopic.php?p=1032662#p1032662

My last mod, and yes, that map is perfect :F
Thanks ~
Shadow
So, I'm still new to modding.

I think this was one of my better mods.

viewtopic.php?p=1026156#p1026156

Please check it out and tell me what I did right/wrong :)

Thanks ^-^
Makar
viewtopic.php?p=1020025#p1020025
This was my last mod post, It'd be nice to know an opinion on it
mochi
Louis Cyphre
I mod mod posts and not maps.
You seem so experienced wise man. May you can mod my User Page? Or my Achivements. Come here to Russia, i'll show what to mod else there.
Raging Bull
o.o He's just trying to help us out by telling us some suggestions when modding

In Russia, post mod y- /gets punched
mm201
Clearly there are people interested in Odaril's help, so I fail to see what's wrong with this concept. Helping the helpers is a very efficient way to help maps.

Louis Cyphre wrote:

May you can mod my User Page?
Too much italics. Spoilerboxes are unnecessary since it's a userpage you need to actively visit. That said, the text is stretching my page. The text on the picture is hard to read. May, the month, should be capitalized.

How much many pictures can be drawed drawn by using paint programm the Paint program on an image of 10 x 10 resolution?
Paint has 16,5 millions of various colors (16.581.375) (16,777,216) and a 10 x 10 image has 100 pixels.
So the answer is 16.581.375 16,777,216^100. Which is:
You're welcome.
whymeman
@ Louis Cyphre: If you plan to troll here, I suggest you stop while you're still able to post. Odaril is just trying to help people.
Sakura
There is nothing wrong with helping modders make better mods and give them feedback for them to improve. That way we will have better modders overall in the community which in turn means better understanding between modders and mappers, and in the end of the chain, probably better maps overall.

I think what Odaril is doing is a pretty good and unique idea and i support him and wish for him to continue doing it, if you dont think he can help you then you could simply not post here, and ignore the thread overall.
Topic Starter
Shiro

Louis Cyphre wrote:

I mod mod posts and not maps.
You seem so experienced wise man. May you can mod my User Page? Or my Achivements. Come here to Russia, i'll show what to mod else there.
Alright, I bet it's time to post something to defend myself (although I really didn't want to give you the attention you do not deserve).

I clearly am experienced. I have been modding for over 1.5 year, and just a year as a MAT. I have 450 kudosu (which means I modded at least 450 maps, taking double kudosu and mods that did not earn any into account), which is already a big number.
Wise ? I don't know - it is not for me to tell. But no matter how wise I am, I would gladly share that wisdom with people who need to be helped, or just want to be helped in general.
And, yes, clearly, the goal here is to share my experience, for new modders. But the way I mod is not THE RIGHT WAY (if there is a "right way to mod" at all). It is the way I do things personnally, and any modder is free to either decline the advice I give, or apply it.

EDIT: I'm done ! Queue is open again.
Raging Bull
I would love it if you mod my map post.

Mapper replied (all rejected T.T).
LaunchedthousandShip
Excuse me. I’m terribly sorry to bother you, Sir. But I’m wondering whether it’s possible that you could kindly mod my mod post for other mappers' maps, please, if it doesn’t cause too much trouble of course. Thank you very much. I really appreciate this help.
Raging Bull
Huh? Do you mean you want him to mod your mods? That's exactly what he's doing. Just give him a mod that you want some feedback.
kanpakyin
SapphireGhost
viewtopic.php?p=1038991#p1038991
Hopefully, I've improved. Thanks in advance.
shikyu
viewtopic.php?f=6&t=62003&p=1042701#p1042701
just a little mod :?. mod my mod, thanks :)
SYSEN
Gonzvlo
I'm always open for suggestions and I'm a bit curious...

Recent: viewtopic.php?p=1020564#p1020564
Old: viewtopic.php?p=978908#p978908

Thanks Odaril!
Topic Starter
Shiro
Done.
gyt
ok, viewtopic.php?f=6&t=46377&p=1039230#p1039230
tell me why I suck so much :D
Raging Bull
Bubble request please /np
http://osu.ppy.sh/forum/viewtopic.php?f=6&t=26297&p=1045945#p1045945

Modded a bubble map, I think it should be better since I've been using what you told me :s
HellDawn
Raging Bull
I'm just here to make your life harder really.

http://osu.ppy.sh/forum/viewtopic.php?f=6&t=61798&p=1047198#p1047198

Edit: Oh yeah also a bubble map \o/
Miya
viewtopic.php?f=6&t=48543&p=1047822#p1047822

Mod my mod please :D.. i want to improve my modding skill, so please.. :D
Sallad4ever
umm did Odaril still do this?
I want you to mod my mod post here
It was bubbled before but got self popped by the mapper
I personally think it's not ready for bubble yet
so I want your opinion =)
Topic Starter
Shiro
All done ! (I know, I'm late)
Jenny
My latest modding: viewtopic.php?p=1056953#p1056953

I don't have any idea of how you will mod a modding post, but I'm thankful for advice ;w;
KRZY
I didn't even know this existed until now :S

One can always do with more constructive criticism, so here viewtopic.php?p=1073694#p1073694

Thank you, and I look forward to talking with you about it!
merchat7
Maybe I should try posting here too. Want to see how I can improve my mods.

viewtopic.php?p=1049624#p1049624

Probably one of my best mod in the past 2 weeks as I wasn't too lazy in this mod and I like the song.
Raging Bull
YES! 6 posts! (or 5 if you don't count your "All done!" message) So err here

http://osu.ppy.sh/forum/viewtopic.php?p=1081146#p1081146

As always I'm here to make your life harder :D
S h i o n
Backstep
Mod my mod please >w<"

I'm newbie about nazi mod :3
[CSGA]Ar3sgice
Deif
I tried to mod a map, but it was so solid and neat that I could "only" do this:

http://osu.ppy.sh/forum/viewtopic.php?f=6&t=64141&p=1100933

Any ideas to improve my mod posts? :I
Topic Starter
Shiro
I'm done. For those who posted maps, I'll ask the posts deleted. This modding queue isn't for maps - that proves you didn't read the first post.
Please sign in to reply.

New reply