Guest
home
beatmaps
rankings
community
store
help
forum
  1. Forums
  2. Other
  3. General Discussion

General Discussion explained

posted
Total Posts
28
Lyawi
Global Moderator
3,612 posts
Joined February 2015
Topic Starter
Lyawi
osu! forums is the place besides casual chatting in the client - another way to communicate with osu! players from all over the world. Conversations were mostly on-topic and well thought through. Talking in forums used to be more compressed and carefully considered as this is still a very public place.

Keep posting! But make sure to follow the unwritten forum rules aswell. Stay on-topic. Make sure to post in the correct forum (yes, even if it doesn't add to your post counter, it's really not that important). You don't have to give a reaction to everything possible and above all, not spread over several posts.

As for General Discussion "quality content" really is subjective, though if there's places like Off-Topic or Surveys and your topic possibly could fit there better, you may just post there.

Good recent examples of suitable topics in General Discussion:
  1. Is AI making us less creative?
  2. Opinion on Gen Z?
  3. Pewdiepie is a dad now, Thougts?
  4. I just paid osu!support using cryptocurrencies
  5. What are your experiences with other forums?
A good topic is key in mutual interest. It doesn't have to be questions all the time, too. Being a bit silly is okay sometimes, but shitposting and filling threads with casual smalltalk doesn't belong to GD.

As for Surveys, I highly recommend reading "What is a survey?", says those.
If the topic you're thinking of doesn't fit in GD nor Surveys, it might just be Off-Topic?
If very osu-related, it goes to Gameplay & Rankings.

Remember folks, this isn't Discord. Even though for most of you, you might have encountered with Discord first, which might be the big difference to early forum users to cause the confusion in the first place. What was it like for you?
Ymir
1,755 posts
Joined June 2020
Ymir
The last two are good GD threads, but the first 3 aren't really all that, especially when you consider the nature of which it was posted.

If you look at the forum, we have way too many question threads, a stark contrast from a few months ago.
Lyawi
Global Moderator
3,612 posts
Joined February 2015
Topic Starter
Lyawi

-Remi wrote:

If you look at the forum, we have way too many question threads, a stark contrast from a few months ago.
yep indeed. Maybe I have to include a few old threads aswell?

generally said, people seem to try too hard to post something
Karmine
890 posts
Joined November 2015
Karmine
Make GD great again, can't happen as long as people farm post count though, most of the posts (and even entire threads) exist only for that now
Corne2Plum3
Global Moderator
1,766 posts
Joined November 2019
Corne2Plum3

Karmine wrote:

Make GD great again, can't happen as long as people farm post count though, most of the posts (and even entire threads) exist only for that now
imagine if post count is removed
Karmine
890 posts
Joined November 2015
Karmine

Corne2Plum3 wrote:

Karmine wrote:

Make GD great again, can't happen as long as people farm post count though, most of the posts (and even entire threads) exist only for that now
imagine if post count is removed
One can only dream
Reyalp51
961 posts
Joined April 2021
Reyalp51

Corne2Plum3 wrote:

Karmine wrote:

Make GD great again, can't happen as long as people farm post count though, most of the posts (and even entire threads) exist only for that now
imagine if post count is removed
World peace would be achieved
Ymir
1,755 posts
Joined June 2020
Ymir

Karmine wrote:

Make GD great again, can't happen as long as people farm post count though, most of the posts (and even entire threads) exist only for that now
Yeah, and chainposting is a big issue too. Got a neat project or high quality thread that you want people to engage in? Too bad, postfarmer3 will bump all threads made before it so that it falls to the bottom of the list. Somehow this happens on OT as well, where postfarming can't exist.

Seriously, chainposting and post farming are ruining the economy!
anaxii
15,000 posts
Joined December 2022
anaxii

Corne2Plum3 wrote:

Karmine wrote:

Make GD great again, can't happen as long as people farm post count though, most of the posts (and even entire threads) exist only for that now
imagine if post count is removed
Can't wait for that
Lyawi
Global Moderator
3,612 posts
Joined February 2015
Topic Starter
Lyawi
disabling counter is not gonna happen.

though getting silenced for chainposting/obvious post farming (spamming) is definitely possible. feel free to report aswell
Karmine
890 posts
Joined November 2015
Karmine

Lyawi wrote:

disabling counter is not gonna happen.

though getting silenced for chainposting/obvious post farming (spamming) is definitely possible. feel free to report aswell
Yeah but as remi said people do that even in OT where there's no post farming so it wouldn't even solve the issue

I never think of reporting :(
- Marco -
7,372 posts
Joined December 2011
- Marco -

Lyawi wrote:

though getting silenced for chainposting/obvious post farming (spamming) is definitely possible. feel free to report aswell
oh god i'm in danger
anaxii
15,000 posts
Joined December 2022
anaxii

- Marco - wrote:

Lyawi wrote:

though getting silenced for chainposting/obvious post farming (spamming) is definitely possible. feel free to report aswell
oh god i'm in danger
It's fine, you will survive compared to me
Aireunaeus
3,072 posts
Joined December 2021
Aireunaeus
I have an idea which will probably ruin post farming forever.
which is having required characters to post. For example, you must contain 15 characters to post. (quotes and empty spaces. won't count either). I obviously obtained this idea from MAL.

subforums like off-topic, introductions or any, that doesn't affect postcount, won't count, obviously.
Last edited by Aireunaeus , edited 3 times in total.
Karmine
890 posts
Joined November 2015
Karmine

Aireunaeus wrote:

I have an idea which will probably ruin post farming forever.
which is having required characters to post. For example, you must contain 15 characters to post. (quotes and empty spaces. won't count either). I obviously obtained this idea from MAL.

subforums like off-topic, introductions or any, that doesn't affect postcount, won't count, obviously.
That's a bad idea, you couldn't even reply to a question with "yes" or "no", or something short
It would just make some posts longer for no reason, also wouldn't prevent post farm at all since you could just spam longer posts
anaxii
15,000 posts
Joined December 2022
anaxii

Aireunaeus wrote:

I have an idea which will probably ruin post farming forever.
which is having required characters to post. For example, you must contain 15 characters to post. (quotes and empty spaces. won't count either). I obviously obtained this idea from MAL.

subforums like off-topic, introductions or any, that doesn't affect postcount, won't count, obviously.
Not a bad idea actually, but as Karmine said, you won't be able to say "yes" or "no" without having to fill the empty spaces
Patatitta
1,244 posts
Joined February 2020
Patatitta
I feel a lot of my threads could be considered GD stuff, but I just keep posting them to OT and otaku culture instead
anaxii
15,000 posts
Joined December 2022
anaxii

Patatitta wrote:

I feel a lot of my threads could be considered GD stuff, but I just keep posting them to OT and otaku culture instead
It's the opposite for me
Reyalp51
961 posts
Joined April 2021
Reyalp51

Patatitta wrote:

I feel a lot of my threads could be considered GD stuff, but I just keep posting them to OT and otaku culture instead
ot is a special case
Lyawi
Global Moderator
3,612 posts
Joined February 2015
Topic Starter
Lyawi
Praise from my side, it's definitely looking better :ok_hand:
Ymir
1,755 posts
Joined June 2020
Ymir
Felt like mentioning what I believe the difference is between an OT Post and a General Discussion post. I could have made a separate thread, but it fits here anyway.

Often GD and OT posts can be very similar (minus cultural differences).
There is a huge intention aspect to it, as in how you intend a thread to go.

If you post something on OT, you're pretty much agreeing to memejokes and derailing.
If you post something on GD, you'd likely want real discussions.

It doesn't help that the forum descriptions for both forums are vague, so this is how I'd treat the forums.
anaxii
15,000 posts
Joined December 2022
anaxii

Kitte wrote:

Felt like mentioning what I believe the difference is between an OT Post and a General Discussion post. I could have made a separate thread, but it fits here anyway.

Often GD and OT posts can be very similar (minus cultural differences).
There is a huge intention aspect to it, as in how you intend a thread to go.

If you post something on OT, you're pretty much agreeing to memejokes and derailing.
If you post something on GD, you'd likely want real discussions.

It doesn't help that the forum descriptions for both forums are vague, so this is how I'd treat the forums.
For me, OT is a place where we can talk about anything without any boundaries and GD is a place where we can talk more seriously on relatively general subjects
Ymir
1,755 posts
Joined June 2020
Ymir

Anaxii wrote:

Kitte wrote:

Felt like mentioning what I believe the difference is between an OT Post and a General Discussion post. I could have made a separate thread, but it fits here anyway.

Often GD and OT posts can be very similar (minus cultural differences).
There is a huge intention aspect to it, as in how you intend a thread to go.

If you post something on OT, you're pretty much agreeing to memejokes and derailing.
If you post something on GD, you'd likely want real discussions.

It doesn't help that the forum descriptions for both forums are vague, so this is how I'd treat the forums.
For me, OT is a place where we can talk about anything without any boundaries and GD is a place where we can talk more seriously on relatively general subjects
The issue is people do talk about general subjects on OT.
Karmine
890 posts
Joined November 2015
Karmine

Kitte wrote:

Anaxii wrote:

Kitte wrote:

Felt like mentioning what I believe the difference is between an OT Post and a General Discussion post. I could have made a separate thread, but it fits here anyway.

Often GD and OT posts can be very similar (minus cultural differences).
There is a huge intention aspect to it, as in how you intend a thread to go.

If you post something on OT, you're pretty much agreeing to memejokes and derailing.
If you post something on GD, you'd likely want real discussions.

It doesn't help that the forum descriptions for both forums are vague, so this is how I'd treat the forums.
For me, OT is a place where we can talk about anything without any boundaries and GD is a place where we can talk more seriously on relatively general subjects
The issue is people do talk about general subjects on OT.
With post farmers around though you're more likely to get serious and useful replies on OT than on GD
It seems to have calmed down a bit but at some point all forums were useless because of that
Lyawi
Global Moderator
3,612 posts
Joined February 2015
Topic Starter
Lyawi
Remember, if you see threads that belong somewhere else, you can also report them and state in the reason where it should get moved to (reporting isn't always negative, instead it helps us a lot to manage these things) :3
-kaify-
3 posts
Joined March 2024
-kaify-
Does anyone know the skin mrekk used on this video
https://youtu.be/bUtnfzHf2KY?si=-H500qBcUS7fJzTy
Lyawi
Global Moderator
3,612 posts
Joined February 2015
Topic Starter
Lyawi

sounstali wrote:

Does anyone know the skin mrekk used on this video
https://youtu.be/bUtnfzHf2KY?si=-H500qBcUS7fJzTy
Wrong forum. Please ask in the skinning forum here: community/forums/15
nizamgg001
5 posts
Joined February 2024
nizamgg001
i want eliminate skin
Please sign in to reply.

New reply

0
1 / 28