abraker wrote:

Ok got the reaction I wanted
Penguin is a safe town read

Penguin wrote:

You didn't even explain how you were scum testing until GuyInFreezer and Westo asked you.

Penguin wrote:

I believe that you were just trying to do damage control because you realized that your arguments made no sense and that you were looking very scummy

Penguin wrote:

By saying that you think I'm a safe town read, you were trying to get me to dismiss my suspicions about you. Trying to make me feel safe with you or something

Penguin wrote:

Plus, when you did tell us how you scum tested, it wasn't even a solid scum test.

Penguin wrote:

You brought up that you've been "drinking" to us twice now too. Seems like you're subtly trying to make excuses.

abraker wrote:

Penguin wrote:

You didn't even explain how you were scum testing until GuyInFreezer and Westo asked you.

Normally you wouldn't do that until time is almost up. You don't want to lay all your cards on the table from the beginning, otherwise mafia scum will just adapt to everything.

abraker wrote:

Penguin wrote:

I believe that you were just trying to do damage control because you realized that your arguments made no sense and that you were looking very scummy

Trust me, that's not even close to damage control. I can't even consider that as damage control. Real damage control comes when you are one vote away from lynch and you got a possible mafia who can vote you for game victory, so you need to get one of the townies off your back asap. I speak from experience: https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/p/5855775

abraker wrote:

Penguin wrote:

You brought up that you've been "drinking" to us twice now too. Seems like you're subtly trying to make excuses.

The second time was not an excuse, but a recap of what happened. I have no need to push an excuse that doesn't benefit me whatsoever

abraker wrote:

At this point I want to hear more from Death, cravenfiner, and Husa

abraker wrote:

everyone, please subscribe to this thread so you dont forget it exists

abraker wrote:

GuyInFreezer wrote:

abraker wrote:

It's prob my 5th or 6th. It's been several months since my last one

Darn.
Here I thought I could get an easy read.

Go ahead and go through my previous games if you'd like

https://forums.tuuba.moe/viewtopic.php?id=3
https://forums.tuuba.moe/viewtopic.php?id=137
https://forums.tuuba.moe/viewtopic.php?id=161
https://forums.tuuba.moe/viewtopic.php?id=264
https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/t/625397
https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/t/552912

cravenfiner wrote:

i havent said much since im new at this and not great at investigations

abraker wrote:

the ones who talk the most always seem to talk themselves to the grave the fastest

funny how that happens

abraker wrote:

the ones who talk the most always seem to talk themselves to the grave the fastest

funny how that happens

abraker wrote:

That's how the mafia works

abraker wrote:

the ones who talk the most always seem to talk themselves to the grave the fastest

funny how that happens

Penguin wrote:

In my experience, the ones who talk themselves into the grave are, for the most part, actually scum.

Husa wrote:

need more information qwq

keremal wrote:

anything can be sus on first two days tbf

sakura wrote:

i will randomize roles for every player in the game until there's at least 50% town players and at least 1 anti town player, i will continue to randomize until at least something's balanced and/or fun

• 
  Voting: abraker, Death, keremal, Penguin
  Not voting: cravenfinder, Westonini, GuyInFreezer, Husa

abraker wrote:

it's high probability we will end up lynching town day 1
If it's a townie power role that ends up lynched, that is a whole lot of bad
If we don't, day 2 it will be 5 vs 2 instead of 4 vs 2

I'm ok with no-lynch for now

abraker wrote:

Well it's not so simple. Even if someone can investigate, only they will know the person's role.

abraker wrote:

Also how sure are you are you there is a third party on this game?

cravenfiner wrote:

hope death notices so keremal doesnt get lynched

Westonini wrote:

cravenfiner wrote:

hope death notices so keremal doesnt get lynched

Isn't Death the one getting voted on by keremal? Death voted to lynch Penguin. Either way we'd need a majority vote for a lynch anyways.

Death wrote:

Vote: No Lynch

"Votes in play" includes no lynch votes, right? Otherwise, I'm dead lol

abraker wrote:

ok I think now is the best time as any to make up a secret code that only town people will understand
that way the cop can tell town what's up

keremal wrote:

abraker wrote:

ok I think now is the best time as any to make up a secret code that only town people will understand
that way the cop can tell town what's up

the only issue is telling which players are townies and how to get the information to them, since we can't exactly say "hey townies, the code word we're using is 'fubbernugget'." it'd either have to be a system of trusting and half-assed luck, since we can't expose our roles either since then the mafioso would be able to kill everyone.

Sakura wrote:

They still have time to post in game or msg me during the Night phase before a replacement is found.

abraker wrote:

Sakura wrote:

They still have time to post in game or msg me during the Night phase before a replacement is found.

And if Husa never responds during the night phase?

abraker wrote:

1702 1782 1670 1766 1750 1622 1606 1686 1766 1555 915 915 57

Sakura wrote:

abraker Town Lover has died Night 1

Death wrote:

Sakura wrote:

abraker Town Lover has died Night 1

Should have voted for Penguin.

Westonini wrote:

I'm trying to google those roles.

"Lovers are players who are linked to each other. If one Lover dies, the Lover(s) linked to it dies simultaneously."

"Alien One-Shot Psychomagnet (all night actions are redirected to the target)"

I'm assuming these are correct.

Westonini wrote:

So if one lover dies, the other also dies.

So since abraker was a town lover and he died, that means GuyInFreezer was his lover? In that case "Town Lover" means that the person was a Townie but could still love someone of a different role.

So the mafia killed either abraker or GIF, causing the other to die as well?

Westonini wrote:

Hmm, ok. So it was a one-way thing meaning abraker was the only lover?

cravenfiner wrote:

maybe lover role doesnt have to have another to exist, its just a random chance for someone else to get it

Penguin wrote:

I think I'm wrong about the cross party lovers, but still, GIF's role would have said that he was a lover.

Westonini wrote:

Penguin wrote:

I think I'm wrong about the cross party lovers, but still, GIF's role would have said that he was a lover.

Yeah, "However, sometimes, one lover is otherwise a vanilla townie, while the other is a mafia goon."

And I do agree that GIF's role most likely would have said lover. But it would seem odd for there to be only one lover in a game. Maybe that's just because of my lack of experience though.

Penguin wrote:

"If there are other Lovers in the game, you will form a Lover bond with them. All Lovers will die at the same time."

Keyword is "IF"

Westonini wrote:

So GIF's Psychomagnet ability allows him to direct all actions at a single person. But seeing as he died, he probably didn't use the ability and just regularly killed abraker, then the mafia killed GIF.

Westonini wrote:

So if it was originally 5vs1vs2, it's now 4vs2. Or at least that's what seems most likely. But I suppose it's also still possible for there to be another neutral or mafia.