This beatmap was submitted using in-game submission on 2018年4月25日 at 下午 08:15:59

Artist: Yuki Yumeno
Title: Minority
Source: 少女マイノリティ-慰めの愛-
Tags: DMM hentai eroge game visual novel opening pure more assassincread
BPM: 130
Filesize: 4061kb
Play Time: 01:57
Difficulties Available:

1. Easy (1.4 stars, 148 notes)
2. Hard (2.8 stars, 255 notes)
3. Insane (3.96 stars, 376 notes)
4. Light Insane (3.4 stars, 285 notes)
5. Minority (4.29 stars, 371 notes)
6. Normal (1.76 stars, 190 notes)

Download: Yuki Yumeno - Minority
Information: Scores/Beatmap Listing
---------------
osu! needs more Yuki Yumeno

I'm sorry for who liked my CTB difficulties I made about a year ago for this song. lol I remembered your support and I really appreciated it !

metadata here 1 2 3

我尽量跟着你的作图想法去Mod，因此没有什么大改

最高难度的话我打不动，没法mod。对我来说有点难

GL~

irc mod

Vanillas wrote:

我尽量跟着你的作图想法去Mod，因此没有什么大改

Mod

General

1. Mp3的码率高于192kbps，用软件降低一下码率 現在不方便，晚點改
2. tags不一样
3. 图片的大小目前是1024*575, 建议用16：9的比例 （1024*576）差一个像素 這真的沒轍，我生不出這1像素..
4. 建议看一下rank准则或者说guide: https://osu.ppy.sh/wiki/Catch_the_Beat_Ranking_Criteria 我下边会有提到
5. widescreen support关掉，没有storyboard的话不需要开这个的

Cup

1. 00:22:652 (2,3) - 这两个的间距建议近一些，对于新人来说可能看到下一个circle再加上反应的时间可能会来不及导致miss。这里00:17:344 (2,3) - 的间距就很好。 Cup這難度我都按照DS做的，我先看一下別人怎麼說
2. 01:51:267 (2,3) - ^ 同
3. 01:12:036 (1,1) - 这个转盘和circle的距离要2拍，目前是1拍根据rank准则：Adequate time must be left between objects and the start and end of spinners to ensure readability.
   120 < BPM < 240 - 1 beat
4. 检查一下combo：这里的combo超了：00:12:959 (1,2,3,4,5) - 00:24:036 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - 00:46:190 (1,2,3,4,5) - 00:49:883 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - （后边应该还有）Combos should not exceed 8 objects including slider tails and repeats. Spinners are an exception. rank准则规定的
5. 说一下建议，因为问题都是类似的：目前这个难度单个的circle比较多，这样的话建议将他们的间距弄得小一点，毕竟这个难度不允许有dash，我在test play的时候有一些circle之间虽然没用到dash不过也仅仅是刚接到，这样对于新人可能比较难。然后01:23:113 (1,2) - 这样的节奏在easy模式的话也不是很推荐：这里一段：Note density should follow a mostly 1/1 pattern - 1/2 and/or 1/3 patterns can be used sparingly keep一下，我想想

Salad

1. 01:19:421 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14) - 好长的combo。Normal最多允许10 objects，一个果子算一个，一个滑条有两个。我的建议是每遇到一个长白线就放个NC好了。然后可以试着变化一下，slider和circle间隔这放，比如这样 https://puu.sh/uzEn0/d52d79d5aa.png
2. 01:12:036 (1,1) - 依旧是转盘和物件之间的间距。Salad的要求和Cup一样。

Platter

1. 00:52:421 (5) - 同一个时间点放了两个物件，忘了删？
2. platter允许的是12个水果combo
3. 01:45:267 (1) - 这个转盘感觉不合适，中间挺多音的不map可惜了 我的話會把這邊複製貼上，我覺得那不如轉盤好了..
4. 00:06:959 (4,5) - 不建议果子完全贴边放置，不是红果子的话虽然可以，不过这种撞墙的感觉挺难受的
5. 00:34:883 (4,1) - 这个有点Edge dashes的感觉，platter难度不允许用，要么改成红果子，要么就距离近一些
6. 01:36:959 (5,6) - ^ 這個我就不同意了，因為我玩起來沒有E-DASH的感覺

Rain

1. 00:20:344 (1) - 红果子不建议靠近边缘，具体离边几个像素我记不住了，不过红果子撞墙的话就失去效果了，建议往中间放一点 這看起來沒貼啊
2. 00:55:306 (14,1,2,3) - 这个有点难了，从1到2容易Miss
3. 01:00:036 (1,2,3) - 这个距离稍微调整一下，建议一个红果子一个距离近一些，两个都类似e dash的话后一个容易Miss
5. 01:37:652 (6) - 红果子不要贴边
6. 多放点物件，rain难度的话可以改变一下采音，目前的采音还是基于easy和normal来做的，仅仅是通过增加物件之间的距离来提升了难度。可以多塞一点东西没关系的，要不节奏太单一了。其實這難度原本是Platter的，但是我發現過難了所以才改成Rain，原本這難度就是想表達分散音弄出的各種梗，所以才不連貫的。連貫性將會從Minority表達出來，但不是這難度

最高难度的话我打不动，没法mod。对我来说有点难

GL~

其餘都改了，大感謝 !

473147315371 wrote:

irc mod

SPOILER

21:40 473147315371: 00:14:575 (3,1,2) -
21:40 473147315371: 這裡有點討厭 ;w;
21:41 assassincread: Rain?
21:41 473147315371: minority
21:42 assassincread: 喔喔 我下載葉面那裏有說要重做最後的難度哦 前面4個都好了:)
21:42 assassincread: 那裡的確很討厭XD
21:42 473147315371: D:
21:43 473147315371: 原來
21:43 assassincread: 我大概這幾天會完成 有做過功課了
21:43 assassincread: 不過可能不會做到很難
21:44 473147315371: 我就是看到不會很難才玩得
21:45 473147315371: 現在大部分玩家都被PP沖昏了腦袋
21:45 assassincread: 恩恩 我盡量做好玩點:)
21:46 473147315371: 你的RAIN可以改成AR8.5
21:46 473147315371: 勁量不要跟PLATTER重複
21:47 assassincread: 哦哦
21:47 assassincread: 我可能不會調那麼高 可能8.2
21:47 assassincread: 因為Rain的密集度不高 怕打起來分散
21:47 assassincread: 謝謝你的提醒啦 我下回上船就改
21:48 473147315371: 可以
22:02 assassincread: 哇 可惜了
22:02 473147315371: 有幾個地方
22:03 473147315371: 00:27:729 (1,2) -
22:03 473147315371: 這地方有點極限
22:03 473147315371: 不知道是不是故意的
22:04 473147315371: 我覺得差紅果或擺進益點比較好
22:04 473147315371: 插
22:05 assassincread: 好 改紅果
22:06 473147315371: 00:59:113 (1,2,3,1,2,3) -
22:07 473147315371: 這裡通一點感覺比較好
22:07 473147315371: 看要是都紅果還是都不要
22:07 473147315371: 比較整齊
22:07 assassincread: 我喬一下
22:08 473147315371: 我只是說我的意見啦 你不一定要改
22:09 assassincread: 這裡我有被modder點到 我也覺得照你們說得不錯:)
22:12 473147315371: 00:26:806 (3) -
22:12 473147315371: 我覺得這6連音有點怪
22:13 assassincread: 節奏是沒問題 問題是間距吧?
22:13 assassincread: 太開?
22:15 473147315371: 不知道改成值得2聯姻3個
22:15 473147315371: 會不會比較好
22:15 473147315371: 或帶點外八
22:16 473147315371: 你原本的有點給人 那理想動卻只能乖乖站在原地的感覺
22:17 assassincread: 恩 我想想怎麼改
22:17 473147315371: 你之前有放小內八
22:17 assassincread: 待會結束你把我們聊天紀錄存起來 PO我的討論串 我給你KD
22:17 473147315371: 我覺得可以再多可小外八
22:18 473147315371: D:
22:18 assassincread: 那個其實我不太喜歡XD 不過我會想想怎麼取代原本的
22:18 473147315371: 不是很懂你們MODDER屆的術語
22:19 473147315371: 不然就改成和之前一樣的4聯姻也可以
22:19 473147315371: 不一定要2 2

謝謝你啦~

Hello from PM request //sorry about late TwT


Hope it can help you. Good luck

requested a long time ago not too long though

i'll mod rain for now to point which part has the highest issues


sorry for the short mod

apply mods dude.

-Nicotine wrote:

apply mods dude.

You mean all of them? No, I want to get more experience to build my basic judgement via getting more mods, then I'll know if they are worth to "keep them in my mind" but not just apply them all. So give me some time please

ye, but what I meant to say is reply to mods. once you've replied to those mods ill start modding.

take your time lol its ur map.

Hello. You asked for that so I'll mod your map.

Good luck!

Will check mods and update the map once I'm home. Sorry for late reply !

Well. I might looking the changes and giving mod whenever you are ready tho. I am looking forward for the best results and good luck..
Waiting is leisure...

Yeah here!
　　
[ General]
　

1. Disable Widescreen Support since u didn't use Storyboard in this map
2. I don't think the source is NIKO , at least I found the song is from a eroge game "少女マイノリティ-慰めの愛-" , put metadata in the thread please! The link I found 1 2 3
3. Probably add "pure more" in tags? and Remove NIKO from source

　
[ Easy]
　

1. Unrankable stuff
   ( You must fix all of these , if I write something is not unrankable , please tell me in the reply )
   
   1. Nope
   　
2. Beatmap design/Suggestion
   ( Most of them are my suggestion , you can disagree if you want )
   
   1. 00:24:056 (1,2) - These two are really different compare with 00:16:672 (1,2,3,4) - try to make them in the same way?
   2. 00:27:749 (4,1) - Switch NCs to make the stanza consistent?
   3. 00:48:056 (4,5) - You can blanket it perfectly or let them to be symmetrical visually
      
      Examples

      or
   4. 01:02:826 - Probably add a note here to stress background music and piano sound as well? because u map here 01:06:518 - too , if u do so then add some thing here 01:10:210 -
   5. 01:20:364 (4) - Hmm... It is okay to use reverse slider here though , but it feel the whole map is easy and playable , U may probably simplified the slider here by a 1/2 slider or something else xD , same as 01:35:133 (4) - 01:55:903 (1) -
   6. 01:43:441 (3) - Slider is good here , I think you can change the shape of the slider and let him follow the music
      
      Simple way to follow the music with a slider dot!

      

　
[ Normal]
　

1. Unrankable stuff
   ( You must fix all of these , if I write something is not unrankable , please tell me in the reply )
   
   1. Nope!
   　
2. Beatmap design/Suggestion
   ( Most of them are my suggestion , you can disagree if you want )
   
   1. 00:48:749 (4,5) - I would like to change this to a 3/2 slider instead of current one , 00:49:441 - I know this is clickable but there is really nothing 00:49:210 - imo >< , Same as 00:56:133 (4,5) -
   2. 00:59:133 (3,4,1) - Looks not good for me , U can make them prettier imo , like this one
      
      Screenshot

      

[ Hard]
　

1. Unrankable stuff
   ( You must fix all of these , if I write something is not unrankable , please tell me in the reply )
   
   1. Nothing I think xD
   　
2. Beatmap design/Suggestion
   ( Most of them are my suggestion , you can disagree if you want )
   
   1. 00:12:979 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - Don't u think this part is a bit long here~? I would like to NC on all the Long white tick like 00:16:672 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) -
   2. 00:27:749 (7,1) - Switch NCs here to make them like 00:24:056 (1,2) -
   3. 00:55:903 (2) - Stack this note with 00:54:979 (4) - ? U make the pattern like 00:47:595 (4,1,2) - 00:51:287 (4,1,2) - , so I think it is better to stack them xD
   4. 01:01:903 (1) - This small spacing change doesn't need a NC to emphasize imo , maybe just remove it ? also here 01:03:749 (1) -
   5. 01:04:672 (1,2,1,2) - These looks so random for me , use a circle + reverse slider is better instead of two sliders for this part imo
   6. 01:43:441 (1) - (Highly Recommend) why a spinner here~? U map here on easy and normal difficulties , so I would like u to map here like other difficulties !

　　--------------------------------------------------------
The hitsounds are fine for me
There are no big issues in this map
But I would like to say the NC pattern is different in each difficulties ;w;
Try to make the whole mapset to same pattern!
Star here!!

bossandy wrote:

Yeah here!
　　
　
[ Easy]
　

1. Unrankable stuff
   ( You must fix all of these , if I write something is not unrankable , please tell me in the reply )
   
   1. Nope
   　
2. Beatmap design/Suggestion
   ( Most of them are my suggestion , you can disagree if you want )
   
   1. 00:24:056 (1,2) - These two are really different compare with 00:16:672 (1,2,3,4) - try to make them in the same way? I made the difference because the music part is different. Also 00:27:287 (3) - is different from previous part. I think I am allowed to make a change here.
   2. 00:27:749 (4,1) - Switch NCs to make the stanza consistent? I wanna use this NC to distinct the rhythm change and make the part ez to read.
   3. 01:02:826 - Probably add a note here to stress background music and piano sound as well? because u map here 01:06:518 - too , if u do so then add some thing here 01:10:210 - I follow both drums and vocals here. I think the rhythm here match the music enough ~

　
[ Normal]
　

1. Unrankable stuff
   ( You must fix all of these , if I write something is not unrankable , please tell me in the reply )
   
   1. Nope!
   　
2. Beatmap design/Suggestion
   ( Most of them are my suggestion , you can disagree if you want )
   
   1. 00:48:749 (4,5) - I would like to change this to a 3/2 slider instead of current one , 00:49:441 - I know this is clickable but there is really nothing 00:49:210 - imo >< , Same as 00:56:133 (4,5) - I think it is fine to keep it because there are full of beats in the music. I wanna make it clickable to play better as well.
   2. 00:59:133 (3,4,1) - Looks not good for me , U can make them prettier imo , like this one but it looks good to me xD
      
      Screenshot

      

[ Hard]
　

1. Unrankable stuff
   ( You must fix all of these , if I write something is not unrankable , please tell me in the reply )
   
   1. Nothing I think xD
   　
2. Beatmap design/Suggestion
   ( Most of them are my suggestion , you can disagree if you want )
   
   • 00:12:979 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - Don't u think this part is a bit long here~? I would like to NC on all the Long white tick like 00:16:672 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - I added NCs every 2 white lines because the soft part here was less beats. I will keep the same NC pattern as Hard, Light Insane
   1. 00:55:903 (2) - Stack this note with 00:54:979 (4) - ? U make the pattern like 00:47:595 (4,1,2) - 00:51:287 (4,1,2) - , so I think it is better to stack them xD I think it's fine to me to keep it. I'm not a big fan of always making the same things
   2. 01:01:903 (1) - This small spacing change doesn't need a NC to emphasize imo , maybe just remove it ? also here 01:03:749 (1) - the NCs for this part are for the jumps, the rhythms and the patterns. Every NCs are combined as a pattern.
   3. 01:43:441 (1) - (Highly Recommend) why a spinner here~? U map here on easy and normal difficulties , so I would like u to map here like other difficulties ! It's because I couldn't make 1/1 beat stop after a spinner in Normal and Easy, I only did it for this Hard.

　　--------------------------------------------------------
The hitsounds are fine for me
There are no big issues in this map
But I would like to say the NC pattern is different in each difficulties ;w;
Try to make the whole mapset to same pattern!
Star here!!

the things I don't quote have been fixed ~ Thank you bossandy !


For who modded my CTB difficulties : I am sorry to say I will push the mapset as STD ones. Thank you for the mod !

mme的曲子都好中毒啊 <33

Garden wrote:

mme的曲子都好中毒啊 <33

隊。謝謝射星xD

btw whole sets completed. Moved to Pending

好老的譜xD
先佔個位明天再來摸 lol

Easy

1. 感覺沒問題(看了兩遍
   比較想建議改的只有4個circle那不過好像也還好 lol

Normal

1. 00:38:364 (5) - 移到248|332? 感覺移動會比較順
2. 00:59:133 (3,4) - 感覺把迴轉的部分再分開點比較好看

Hard

1. 00:48:749 (3,4) - blanket?
2. 01:25:672 (3) - 移到208|208? 原本的位置轉起來我覺得有點硬
3. 01:01:903 ~ 01:11:595 這段的物件好像全都在右測, 考慮稍微移動一下嗎 lol

Light Insane

1. 00:01:903 (1,2,1) - 不太懂為何你的hard在這段放得比這難度還要細 xD
2. 00:29:364 (5) - 感覺可以移到248|32, 比較美觀而且應該也比較順我覺得w
3. 01:28:672 (1,2,3,4) - 我覺得在副歌間的這小段可以用小一點的間距做個對比(考慮到接下來又是下一段的副歌
4. 01:39:287 (4,5) - ctrl+g位置? flow應該會順很多

Insane

1. 00:33:979 (5,6) - 我覺得跟人聲的擺放模式好像好一點xD 刪掉5然後6應該開始在5的位置, 然後00:34:672也許可以放滑條帶入下一段
2. 01:01:441 (3,4) - 3跟4中間再放一個circle好像不錯
3. 01:26:595 (5,1) - 01:26:595 (5) - ctrl+g然後移到原本的位置, 然後把01:26:826 (1) - 往右移一點, 這樣01:26:595 (5,1,2) - 的flow好像比較好(?)

Minority

1. 01:43:903 (5,6,7,8) - 可以做一個圓弧的形狀好像比較好看(?) https://imgur.com/a/oQZj8

給不出什麼好建議xD
好歌好圖GL~☆

00:01:903 (1,2) - increase distance for better flow
00:03:749 (1,2) - increase distance for better flow

bigfrog wrote:

好老的譜xD
先佔個位明天再來摸 lol

Easy

1. 感覺沒問題(看了兩遍
   比較想建議改的只有4個circle那不過好像也還好 lol

Normal

1. 00:38:364 (5) - 移到248|332? 感覺移動會比較順這個位置DS不對lol 而且我覺得這裡不會不順，就keep了
2. 00:59:133 (3,4) - 感覺把迴轉的部分再分開點比較好看 好啊

Hard

1. 00:48:749 (3,4) - blanket? 我直線沒有想blanket的打算xD
2. 01:25:672 (3) - 移到208|208? 原本的位置轉起來我覺得有點硬試了下，覺得原本的就好。改動的話又要動到spacing和pattern有些麻煩
3. 01:01:903 ~ 01:11:595 這段的物件好像全都在右測, 考慮稍微移動一下嗎 lol 移了

Light Insane

1. 00:01:903 (1,2,1) - 不太懂為何你的hard在這段放得比這難度還要細 xD 想在這個難度玩滑條梗，滑條速度快而且形狀崎嶇看起來比較多變；這段節奏也和最後一段呼應，最後一段的anti-jumps要是用在Hard就會被噴，所以就在這難度展現:D
2. 00:29:364 (5) - 感覺可以移到248|32, 比較美觀而且應該也比較順我覺得w 移動了下其他位置~
3. 01:28:672 (1,2,3,4) - 我覺得在副歌間的這小段可以用小一點的間距做個對比(考慮到接下來又是下一段的副歌我比較偏向用大間距強調vocals做過度xD
4. 01:39:287 (4,5) - ctrl+g位置? flow應該會順很多好，連同下個slider也改了下

Insane

1. 00:33:979 (5,6) - 我覺得跟人聲的擺放模式好像好一點xD 刪掉5然後6應該開始在5的位置, 然後00:34:672也許可以放滑條帶入下一段OK
2. 01:01:441 (3,4) - 3跟4中間再放一個circle好像不錯 這邊我偏向跟人聲並且多做點跳，感覺比較有趣；一方面也是為了跟top diff作區別
3. 01:26:595 (5,1) - 01:26:595 (5) - ctrl+g然後移到原本的位置, 然後把01:26:826 (1) - 往右移一點, 這樣01:26:595 (5,1,2) - 的flow好像比較好(?) 試過了但是還是偏向原本的flow~

Minority

1. 01:43:903 (5,6,7,8) - 可以做一個圓弧的形狀好像比較好看(?) https://imgur.com/a/oQZj8 之前就打算重擺了只是沒空lol 感謝建議~

給不出什麼好建議xD
好歌好圖GL~☆

謝謝mod和star ! 青蛙妹!

Leoncio01 wrote:

00:01:903 (1,2) - increase distance for better flow
00:03:749 (1,2) - increase distance for better flow

I didn't really get this since you didn't mention what difficulty you were going to mod, and how much spacing should I increase. But still appreciate you to take a look at my map.

這首我好像在哪聽過xd

Easy

00:16:672 (1) - 尾巴好像沒對準
00:25:903 (2) - 怎麼突然變形了xd
00:32:364 - 人聲都出來了，覺得可以map這個drum sound，也可以避免2/1,1/1,1/2 gap在同一個combo都出現的情況。加個圓或者將(1)改成reverse
00:35:133 (1) - ^
01:01:903 - 加個圓?
01:02:826 - 加個圓?
01:23:133 (1,2) - 覺得之前的pattern比較好e.g. 01:17:595 (4,5)，不用強行轉。01:23:133 (1)這裏的held sound用圓不是很妥
01:43:441 (3) - 很多sound在裏面...要不轉成兩條1/1
01:55:903 (1) - 以為你是在Easy故意避免1/2 reverse的 怎麼最後又出來了?

Normal
呃有空再補

都打過了一輪試試看之後，總體上沒什麼問題感XD

[Insane]

01:27:287 (2,3) - 除了這邊以外其他類似的節奏都是順手的排列，要不要修一下。雖然短滑條按一下就好XD

[Minority]

00:16:210 (1) - 背景有明顯的單音在這，像 Insane 那樣放單點會比較符合節奏

00:51:633 (4,1) - 這邊如果是刻意做的話就ok XD 不過第一次打到這的時候遲疑了一下


ps.

看了profile原來也是大前輩等級的玩家 (8 years)

謝謝你們的mod，我週末的時候看:)

hi~ from q
Insane

1. 00:01:903 - 开场部分连续折返是不是有点简单了，比三个低难度还要简单
2. 00:13:326 (2,3) - 可以修改堆叠值4→5，效果如下
   
   
3. 01:27:287 (2,3) - 在最高难度里此处是单点，虽然难度上差不多但是稍微平衡一下怎样
4. 01:55:209 (2) - 请挪一下，没对齐

Minority

1. 00:55:672 (2,3,4) - 建议这里调整为向上，延续连续1/4滑条的逆时针flow，像前面两处类似部分所做的一样
2. 01:19:441 (1,2,3,4) - 首先这里没有问题，只是一点个人的想法看看就好。在我的角度看不太推荐使用单点来表达歌曲这一部分的内容，一方面voice得不到恰当的表现，01:34:441 - 01:36:749 - 有种无处施力的感觉，另一方面kiai部分整体也有强调voice的考量，像这些01:15:749 (1,2,1,2) - 。所以大概可以有另一种选择比如

祝早飞

Tomoka Rin wrote:

都打過了一輪試試看之後，總體上沒什麼問題感XD

[Insane]

01:27:287 (2,3) - 除了這邊以外其他類似的節奏都是順手的排列，要不要修一下。雖然短滑條按一下就好XD 好啊，改單點

[Minority]

00:16:210 (1) - 背景有明顯的單音在這，像 Insane 那樣放單點會比較符合節奏 這邊我想要用變速滑條針對背景音樂中特別的聲音做強調，這樣的不同變化也能比較好區別Insane和top diff之間的難度

00:51:633 (4,1) - 這邊如果是刻意做的話就ok XD 不過第一次打到這的時候遲疑了一下 是故意的沒錯，不過我間距改近一點，應該就還好了:D


ps.

看了profile原來也是大前輩等級的玩家 (8 years)

AFK很大段時間的，不是大前輩xD (不過我老圖玩比較多)。你才是真正大前輩啊 !

ACOMG wrote:

這首我好像在哪聽過xd

Easy

00:16:672 (1) - 尾巴好像沒對準 故意的~
00:25:903 (2) - 怎麼突然變形了xd 這個其實沒關係lol但是我討厭別人之後又吐槽這個，就改圓弧吧
00:32:364 - 人聲都出來了，覺得可以map這個drum sound，也可以避免2/1,1/1,1/2 gap在同一個combo都出現的情況。加個圓或者將(1)改成reverse
00:35:133 (1) - ^ 故意空出來的。因為這段是soft part，只跟鼓聲效果會很好
01:01:903 - 加個圓?
01:02:826 - 加個圓? 同上
01:23:133 (1,2) - 覺得之前的pattern比較好e.g. 01:17:595 (4,5)，不用強行轉。01:23:133 (1)這裏的held sound用圓不是很妥 並不是一定要held，也能空出來。我想空出來讓節奏有更多變化~
01:43:441 (3) - 很多sound在裏面...要不轉成兩條1/1 這個滑條是因為這段的整體音樂有一塊突然消失了，用長滑條帶過連續音而且也讓soft part難度大幅下降，我覺得這樣最合音樂，也最合Easy
01:55:903 (1) - 以為你是在Easy故意避免1/2 reverse的 怎麼最後又出來了? 因為這裡的節奏很特別，我不覺得這裡的三連音用其他擺放方式會更簡單，又更合音樂

Normal
呃有空再補

AIR wrote:

hi~ from q
Insane

1. 00:01:903 - 开场部分连续折返是不是有点简单了，比三个低难度还要简单 你是指Light Insane ? 我覺得間距、滑條速度和滑條形狀比較特別，應該說的過去xD
2. 00:13:326 (2,3) - 可以修改堆叠值4→5，效果如下 好啊
   
   
3. 01:27:287 (2,3) - 在最高难度里此处是单点，虽然难度上差不多但是稍微平衡一下怎样 恩
4. 01:55:209 (2) - 请挪一下，没对齐 看不出是哪裡沒對齊，對齊哪裡lol

Minority

1. 00:55:672 (2,3,4) - 建议这里调整为向上，延续连续1/4滑条的逆时针flow，像前面两处类似部分所做的一样 還是偏向轉換flow。而且其他類似的地方也有逆時針轉順時針flow的~
2. 01:19:441 (1,2,3,4) - 首先这里没有问题，只是一点个人的想法看看就好。在我的角度看不太推荐使用单点来表达歌曲这一部分的内容，一方面voice得不到恰当的表现，01:34:441 - 01:36:749 - 有种无处施力的感觉，另一方面kiai部分整体也有强调voice的考量，像这些01:15:749 (1,2,1,2) - 。所以大概可以有另一种选择比如
   還是偏向原來的節奏。空拍部分是為了很好的跟人聲，而且我很喜歡這樣有「節奏遊戲」的感覺。kiai的部分我也想沿用「人聲為主，聲音為輔」的方式做，想盡量以人聲clickable為優先。謝謝你闡述的想法:)

祝早飞

謝謝你們的mod ! 也謝謝ACOMG和AIR的星

~
top
00:20:133 (5,1) - could space this further, 00:18:287 (5,1) - compared to this its a bit small
00:21:749 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - i think you should seperate each NC out a bit more so its a jump, doesnt have to be a big jump but something more noticeable would be better. i think in comparison to 00:29:133 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,1) - its very underwhelming.
00:33:633 (2) -00:37:325 (2) - etc i think skipping over the drum beat is a bit unnecessary? maybe http://puu.sh/A8Bye/870ccc030b.png
00:44:364 (1,2) - i think taking this into consideration 00:42:518 (1,2) - maybe this rhythm is better,since 1 vocal beat per slider http://puu.sh/A8BJX/a316d6737a.png
00:47:133 (1,2) - maybe can keep same pattern as 00:46:672 (1,2) - so when vocal starts here 00:47:595 (1) - its different
00:48:749 (4) - 00:52:441 (4) - etc i think it would be cool if you made this into a reverse slider, atm i feel like 00:49:210 (5,6,7) - this bit is very off since its a sudden change in the instrumental layer that you are following.like this --> http://puu.sh/A8BWW/d326dfbb89.png
00:51:633 (4,1) - maybe increase spacing a bit more?
01:28:210 (4) - maybe a reverse slider here instead since 01:28:672 - no vocals here so circle feels a bit out of place imo
01:42:056 - map circle here instead? i think better to keep all vocals clickable, and its different to 01:42:287 (2) -

Insane
00:33:287 (1) - 00:36:518 (4) - 00:36:979 (1) - wish you emphasized these vocals in some way...
00:48:749 (3,4,5,6) - same suggestion as top diff with the reverse slider
01:03:979 (2,3,4,5) - 01:11:364 (2,3,4,5) - these jumps are bigger than top diff
01:20:595 (5,6) - 01:35:364 (5,6) - 1 slider instead? 01:20:826 (6) - feels out of place with no vocal support
01:43:556 (2,3,4) - i think this transition into following the background sound would work better if it started from 01:42:979 (3) - instead. though personally i would just not map it at all and do like http://puu.sh/A8CD3/74289f6152.png

light
00:15:749 (1,2) - maybe stack these? since first note is different sound
00:33:287 (1,2) - dont really understand why you follow the vocals here but not like at 00:35:364 - ? i think it fits the entire section a lot better if just map this as a 1/1 slider imo or fill in 00:35:364 -
01:07:441 (1,2) - follow vocals instead is better imo http://puu.sh/A8CVj/8854a7f4a5.png
01:24:287 - really should be clickable imo since its different vocal pattern to 01:23:133 (1) - maybe something like http://puu.sh/A8CXT/26b3815c9e.png

hard
ok

normal
ok

easy
01:23:133 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - 01:37:903 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - i think rhythm like this is simpler while following vocals a bit better http://puu.sh/A8Des/931a60387f.png


~
probably wont need me w

kwk wrote:

~
top
00:20:133 (5,1) - could space this further, 00:18:287 (5,1) - compared to this its a bit small because of the music, it is sometimes strong, sometimes weak. That's what I try to follow xD
00:21:749 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - i think you should seperate each NC out a bit more so its a jump, doesnt have to be a big jump but something more noticeable would be better. i think in comparison to 00:29:133 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,1) - its very underwhelming.
because of intro again, the music in 00:29:133 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2) - is stronger than 00:21:749 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3) -
00:33:633 (2) -00:37:325 (2) - etc i think skipping over the drum beat is a bit unnecessary? maybe http://puu.sh/A8Bye/870ccc030b.png
I made the kind rhythm choice because the parts in 00:31:441 (1,2,3,4,5) - and 00:46:210 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - shows they are mainly intro basic ; The parts in 00:36:518 (4,5,1,2,3) - and 00:48:056 (1,2,3,4) - the vocals are obviously stronger here. Then see 00:48:979 - 00:52:672 - there is only intro can be mapped. So that's how I mapped for these parts though.
00:44:364 (1,2) - i think taking this into consideration 00:42:518 (1,2) - maybe this rhythm is better,since 1 vocal beat per slider http://puu.sh/A8BJX/a316d6737a.png I prefer to use 1 circle to make the stop rhythm here
00:47:133 (1,2) - maybe can keep same pattern as 00:46:672 (1,2) - so when vocal starts here 00:47:595 (1) - its different I prefer what it works now
00:48:749 (4) - 00:52:441 (4) - etc i think it would be cool if you made this into a reverse slider, atm i feel like 00:49:210 (5,6,7) - this bit is very off since its a sudden change in the instrumental layer that you are following.like this --> http://puu.sh/A8BWW/d326dfbb89.png I'll keep considering it but I still think the rhythm now matches the intro way better
00:51:633 (4,1) - maybe increase spacing a bit more? well I did it further before but players tell me it looked kinda confusing so I'll reduce the spacing like this
01:28:210 (4) - maybe a reverse slider here instead since 01:28:672 - no vocals here so circle feels a bit out of place imo I know the beat here is weak so I reduced its spacing. I am still fine with it and I don't really wanna do the reverse slider here
01:42:056 - map circle here instead? i think better to keep all vocals clickable, and its different to 01:42:287 (2) - I am going to keep consistency for the long slider in the kiai time, also I think the long slider fits the vocal well

Insane
00:33:287 (1) - 00:36:518 (4) - 00:36:979 (1) - wish you emphasized these vocals in some way... I think it is enough since this is a calm part. Or do you have any suggestion ?
00:48:749 (3,4,5,6) - same suggestion as top diff with the reverse slider so same as top diff I wrote
01:03:979 (2,3,4,5) - 01:11:364 (2,3,4,5) - these jumps are bigger than top diff it's because the doubles in top diff need movement so it needs to carefully handle (when play it). So I don't intend to make too large jump for it ; since we can easily play the doubles which are overlaps, I think I can make the spacing more larger. Also I can highlight it by this way
01:20:595 (5,6) - 01:35:364 (5,6) - 1 slider instead? 01:20:826 (6) - feels out of place with no vocal support I think I can put a circle to follow that drum right ? xD
01:43:556 (2,3,4) - i think this transition into following the background sound would work better if it started from 01:42:979 (3) - instead. though personally i would just not map it at all and do like http://puu.sh/A8CD3/74289f6152.png the background music here 01:43:441 - is only one sound repeated so the stream should be properly followed to me. The rhythm you made has a sudden stop and the single circle followed just one sound, then randomly you followed the whole sounds by using 01:43:903 (5) - . I think it is not really make sense.

light
00:15:749 (1,2) - maybe stack these? since first note is different sound but I wanna make a jump between 00:15:749 (1,2) - since the sound at 00:15:979 (2) - should be highlighted to me
00:33:287 (1,2) - dont really understand why you follow the vocals here but not like at 00:35:364 - ? i think it fits the entire section a lot better if just map this as a 1/1 slider imo or fill in 00:35:364 - same as what I explain above. And I think following every beat would lose the mainly rhythm I wanna make. That would become a kind of overmapped.
01:07:441 (1,2) - follow vocals instead is better imo http://puu.sh/A8CVj/8854a7f4a5.png ok I did it to Hard too
01:24:287 - really should be clickable imo since its different vocal pattern to 01:23:133 (1) - maybe something like http://puu.sh/A8CXT/26b3815c9e.png
I think it is fine. I am not making every vocals clickable in this difficulty.

hard
ok

normal
ok

easy
01:23:133 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - 01:37:903 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - i think rhythm like this is simpler while following vocals a bit better http://puu.sh/A8Des/931a60387f.png
I prefer mine and I think 2 short sliders are harder though lol


~
probably wont need me w why w

Thank you for mod !