M4M from #modreqs.
Overall: good structure, some rhythm was weird but was playable, but the main issue is this is COMPLETELY overmapped. I can't hear sounds for half of the notes you've placed and removing some of the jumps and that 1/8 stream dropped the SR by nearly 0.4. It's unbelievable. If you want the difficulty higher then make it more consistent, you have massive difficulty spikes in areas.
That peak is the 1/8 notes. :/
That's it for this mod.
XFriend
Kinda Borderline Extra tbh
- 00:00:664 (2,3,4,5,6,7) – Wow, compared to the rest of the map this is probably the highest spaced stream. Please nerf this lol, it’s right in the beginning too.
- 00:06:878 (5) – NC? Up to you. You did it for each of 00:09:021 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) – so I suggest keeping it consistent.
- 00:15:771 (7) – Pretty big jump imo from this note to the next.
- 00:18:021 (2,3,4,5,6) – Space these further, you make the player wait with their cursor over this stream.
- 00:28:735 (4,5,6,7,8) - ? We talked about stack leniency in IRC but this seems unreadable tbh. How many circles are stacked under there? At first glance it’s hard to tell. Make this a moving stream like you did before? Would make it easier to read.
- 00:35:592 (4,5,6,7,1) - ^ Same.
- 00:56:378 (2,3,4,5) – Do you really need this in such a calm section? Same with 00:59:164 (2,3,4,5) - 01:04:414 (5,6,7) - 01:07:735 (2,3,4,5) -
- 01:08:592 (7) – Pretty strong note on this slider end. Wouldn’t recommend. ;w;
- 01:09:235 - 01:12:450 - Insert break? Or slow sliders?
- 01:13:092 - 01:15:878 - ^
- 01:16:521 - 01:19:307 - ^
- 01:19:950 - 01:22:735 - ^
- 01:33:878 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) – You’ve got to be kidding. 280 bpm streams on a 4*? If I removed this this star rating drops by 0.34. REMOVE THIS. Seriously.
- 01:42:771 (2) – Aaa, couldn’t you move this down? https://puu.sh/sjeig/3402f1cff4.png
- 01:45:450 (3,4,1) – Not a huge fan of these overlaps, but that’s personal.
- 01:49:307 (5) – NC?
- 01:53:164 (1,2) – Why not use the kicks you had before at 01:52:735 (1,2)? Would make more sense.
- 01:55:200 (2,1) – Massive jump, would nerf, seriously.
- 01:56:807 (4,1) – Again, not to big a fan of this overlap, but it’s personal.
- 02:38:164 - 02:41:592 – Insert break? Or slow sliders?
- 02:44:164 (3) - 02:44:164 – ^
- 03:00:128 (3,4) – This calm section would be better represented if these notes were removed. They’re mapped to very obscure sounds in the background and misrepresent the pacing of the song here.
- 03:01:628 (5) - triggered
- 03:01:735 (6) – Could make this a reverse to get that sound at 03:01:896 -
- 03:04:735 (1,2) – Filler note, no sound here.
- 03:06:342 (5) - ^
- 03:06:878 (7) – This doesn’t follow anything that I can hear clearly, would be better if it was removed imo.
- 03:07:521 (1) - ^
- 03:08:914 (7) – Filler note, no sound here.
- 03:10:200 (4) - ^
- 03:10:628 (6) - ^
- 03:10:735 (1) – Should probably end at 03:10:950 -
- 03:11:914 (6) – Filler note, no sound here.
- 03:13:307 (4,5) - ^
- 03:14:914 (2) - ^
- 03:15:771 (4) - ^
- 03:16:628 (4) - ^
- 03:16:735 (5) – Should probably end at 03:16:950 -
- 03:18:771 (4) – Filler note, no sound here.
- 03:19:200 (6) - ^
- 03:20:914 (2) - ^
- 03:22:735 (1) – I don’t know if a slider like this is rankable either. It seems to go back in on itself. I suggest changing this just to be safe.
- 03:24:021 (1) – No need for reverse here as the reverse tick doesn’t land on any sound.
- 03:24:342 (2) – Filler note, no sound here.
- 03:24:450 (1) – Should probably end at 03:24:664 -
- 03:25:628 (6) – Filler note, no sound here.
- 03:26:057 (8) - ^
- 03:29:485 (10) - ^
- 03:29:914 (2) - ^
- 03:32:485 (6) - ^
- 03:32:914 (8) - ^
- 03:35:485 (4) - ^
- 03:36:342 (4) - ^
- 03:37:200 (4) - ^
- 03:39:342 (6) - ^
- 03:56:485 (6) - ^ :/
- 03:59:914 (4) - ^
- 04:01:735 (6,7,8,9,1) – Uncomfortable to play probably, if that’s the intention then sure, but this part of the music doesn’t feel like it should have such a flow break.
- 04:20:700 (2,3) – Big jumps, would nerf for this star rating.
- 04:31:307 (1) – NC? Long hold that goes into the next section.
- 04:41:164 (5,6,7) – Timing is off, these are 1/3. NC because polarity change and use this rhythm; https://puu.sh/sjfmX/34ff608a74.png
- 04:45:771 (4,1) – Another huge jump for this star rating, would nerf.
- 04:46:735 (1,2) – These should also be 1/3. https://puu.sh/sjfr8/c09cc028af.png
- 04:54:878 (7) – Would nerf this streamjump for this star rating, also would NC this for consistency.
- 04:57:342 (2,4,6,8) - Again, filler notes, no sound here.
- 04:59:807 (4,5) – Space these out, would be difficult to read and hard to play
- 05:07:200 (2) – Filler note, no sound here.
- 05:14:914 (7,2) - ^
- 05:28:735 (6) – This not being vertical triggers me. :/
- 05:30:771 (4,6,2,4,2,2,4,6) - More filler notes… no sounds.
- 05:33:021 (1) – This also being not perfectly horizontal triggers me. :/
- 05:36:021 (4,5,6,7,1) – Massive jumps holy hell, this star rating is such bait. Please nerf.
- 05:41:807 (2) – Another filler note (I think.)
- 05:50:057 (2) - ^
- 05:53:057 (7) - ^
- 05:54:878 (5,6,7) – Why not use a quint stream like you did almost everywhere else with the same musical phrase?
Okay at this point I’m getting sick of finding filler notes literally EVERYWHERE in this map. This is horribly overmapped and does not represent the song well at all. I’m going to stop pointing them out now because I’m pretty sure you get the idea at this point. The problem now is if you remove them, your spacing gets screwed. In all honesty you may have to remap a large portion of this to get rid of those filler notes. - 06:13:092 (7,8) – Shift these back one tick. https://puu.sh/sjg0f/05c070d30f.png
- 06:19:735 - 06:27:878 – Insert break or slow slider?
- 06:27:878 - 06:31:307 - ^
- 06:31:307 - 06:34:735 - ^
- 06:34:735 - 06:37:307 - ^
- 06:40:950 (4,5,4,5) – These blankets. ;w;
- 06:51:878 - 06:55:307 - Break/slider.
- 06:55:307 -06:58:735 - ^
- 06:58:735 - 07:02:164 - ^
- 07:02:164 (1) – Silence this spinner end?
Overall: good structure, some rhythm was weird but was playable, but the main issue is this is COMPLETELY overmapped. I can't hear sounds for half of the notes you've placed and removing some of the jumps and that 1/8 stream dropped the SR by nearly 0.4. It's unbelievable. If you want the difficulty higher then make it more consistent, you have massive difficulty spikes in areas.
That peak is the 1/8 notes. :/
That's it for this mod.