Yeah you summed that up pretty well, obviously every map can always be optimised, which is what handsomes mod is looking like, as opposed to "This is bad but I cant say why" I have no issues making changes just to tidy things up but redoing the entire base of it is just not an option for me.-Akuro wrote:
I agree with you. I have seen many people just saying something like "remap this" or "nobody can pass this anyways, it's too hard" etc... I too believe that the map is fine at it's core and what idea it is based off. Still, no map if perfect instantly from the beginning and thus optimisations have to be made, which isn't a problem of course. The main problem in my oppinion is that many people are too blinded by all the jumpy PP maps that are mostly roaming osu! at the moment. I am glad that there are more non-PP maps being ranked/qualified now (e.g. Axion) since we have new BNs (I am not saying that there were no ranked non-PP maps, but if I remember correctly, there were less of them getting ranked than now [statistically]). Coming back to your map though I have to say: Yes, optimisations have to be made at some point but in my oppinion a complete remap would be absolutely ridiculous because the best thing about mapping is the part where you can express yourself in your own style, basically like drawing, and if you'd be forced to paint something that isn't your style, your enjoyment for painting this will be gone in no time, and the same goes for mapping, at least for me. But according to what you wrote I think you feel the same.EphemeralFetish wrote:
Its mainly the whole "remap bloodthirsty" I have issues with, because I honestly believe its fine at its core. I dont want to be that guy but I really think people just cant understand it because the song is so complex and varied. If I was forced to remap it I wouldnt be able to do so, since Id be mapping based off ideas I myself dont understand so it would never turn out good. So its either I convince people and optimise it, or it graves.
Long story short: I believe if you stay determined enough for ranking this map, it will get ranked eventually if you keep working on it.
If anyone reading this may not have the same oppinion as I do it is completely fine. Feel free to discuss with me!
Again I said this last night but Im also looking to call a few people who might be able to shed some light with their opinions as well.