LMAOOOOOestellia- wrote:
so many shit arguments in this thread
its 0502 in the morning
have this beauty of a remap
LMAOOOOOestellia- wrote:
so many shit arguments in this thread
its 0502 in the morning
have this beauty of a remap
L O L o l l ol o o l lo lestellia- wrote:
so many shit arguments in this thread
its 0502 in the morning
have this beauty of a remap
10/10estellia- wrote:
so many shit arguments in this thread
its 0502 in the morning
have this beauty of a remap
no respect for nold ok :VFort wrote:
i don't care for your single meme :>
you're not mazzerin who map crazy deathstreams in every maps he made
you're not Ekoro who mapped Time Freeze with extra effort
you're not lesjuh who made a good map in 2009
you're not val0108 who made a really stylish sliders map
you're not hanzer who made a stream with a jump
you're not me who map a crazy fullscreen jumps
im waiting for epic qualified posts in here (and waiting people who can pass this map without NF or HT)
nice ending btw
yea wots upYunomi wrote:
hey nathan lol
you really think he would make two difficulties for this song? he put a 15 second spinner over nothing at the end of the song just so he could go for marathonisopaharuntikka wrote:
i think it would be beautiful if the map had an ugly difficulty and a beautiful difficulty
what do u mean nothing the audio was fading out loldeathmarc4 wrote:
you really think he would make two difficulties for this song? he put a 15 second spinner over nothing at the end of the song just so he could go for marathonisopaharuntikka wrote:
i think it would be beautiful if the map had an ugly difficulty and a beautiful difficulty
he could let someone else do a guest difficultydeathmarc4 wrote:
you really think he would make two difficulties for this song? he put a 15 second spinner over nothing at the end of the song just so he could go for marathonisopaharuntikka wrote:
i think it would be beautiful if the map had an ugly difficulty and a beautiful difficulty
rude as mecaptin1 wrote:
i love when people who don't understand anything that they're talking about try and criticize a map for doing what the creator intended. the messy sliders absolutely fit the style of the song, so stop being a bunch of r/osugame shitlords and take a hike. there's no reason to say that sliders done erratically mean that the "map quality" is low, if you think that you're completely shallow.
gl monstrata hope these people leave you alone soon
Fort wrote:
you're not Ekoro who mapped Time Freeze with extra effort
don't give that emoticon for nold it's really insulting himGiralda wrote:
no respect for nold ok :VFort wrote:
i don't care for your single meme :>
you're not mazzerin who map crazy deathstreams in every maps he made
you're not Ekoro who mapped Time Freeze with extra effort
you're not lesjuh who made a good map in 2009
you're not val0108 who made a really stylish sliders map
you're not hanzer who made a stream with a jump
you're not me who map a crazy fullscreen jumps
im waiting for epic qualified posts in here (and waiting people who can pass this map without NF or HT)
nice ending btw
well tbh i'm sure monstrata knows himself he can map it better/more appealing/more comfortable to play? he doesn't need anyone's input to remap this. He has way more than enough experience to remap this to his original style.Fezu wrote:
News flash: Telling a person to map it better without providing any mods won't make a map better.
Timing maybe, but other than that it's pretty effortless. Don't mind having it ranked though if some timing and rhythm issues mentioned before are fixed, spacing seems to be good for the pace of the song. I don't really like random 280bpm streamjump and some crosscreens that are just too much on this sometimes but whatever, God bless.Haruto wrote:
i feel so sad to monstra who had taken all of his effort for this map.
i still dont understand why this shouldnt be ranked/qualified, there is no unrankable stuff on the map anyway. it is didnt play well like i expect but please respect the mapper ;;
gl monstra, i hope those guys will realize themself and can leave you alone soon
fixed <3Fort wrote:
i don't care for your single meme :>
you're not mazzerin who map crazy deathstreams in every maps he made
you're not Ekoro who mapped Time Freeze with extra effort
you're not lesjuh who made a good map in 2009
you're not val0108 who made a really stylish sliders map
you're not hanzer who made a stream with a jump
you're not me who map a crazy fullscreen jumps
you're not irreversible who makes cs7 maps
im waiting for epic qualified posts in here (and waiting people who can pass this map without NF or HT)
nice ending btw
fixed <3Fort wrote:
i don't care for your single meme :>
you're not mazzerin who map crazy deathstreams in every maps he made
you're not Ekoro who mapped Time Freeze with extra effort
you're not lesjuh who made a good map in 2009
you're not val0108 who made a really stylish sliders map
you're not hanzer who made a stream with a jump
you're not me who map a crazy fullscreen jumps
you're not irreversible who makes cs7 maps
you're not cherry blossom who makes symmetrical maps
im waiting for epic qualified posts in here (and waiting people who can pass this map without NF or HT)
nice ending btw
fixed <3Fort wrote:
i don't care for your single meme :>
you're not mazzerin who map crazy deathstreams in every maps he made
you're not Ekoro who mapped Time Freeze with extra effort
you're not lesjuh who made a good map in 2009
you're not val0108 who made a really stylish sliders map
you're not hanzer who made a stream with a jump
you're not me who map a crazy fullscreen jumps
you're not irreversible who makes cs7 maps
you're not cherry blossom who makes symmetrical maps
you're not failureatosu who maps stale memes
im waiting for epic qualified posts in here (and waiting people who can pass this map without NF or HT)
nice ending btw
The map got bubbled since Monstrata thought it was fine and ready to ship. Setting the precedent that the mapper knows best on how to improve their map means that the entire ranking system is a complete waste of time.Yunomi wrote:
well tbh i'm sure monstrata knows himself he can map it better/more appealing/more comfortable to play? he doesn't need anyone's input to remap this. He has way more than enough experience to remap this to his original style.Fezu wrote:
News flash: Telling a person to map it better without providing any mods won't make a map better.
Arusamour wrote:
idk the problems with this map because im truthful; not ignorant. btw i have long shlong lma0
- old mapping not bad; learn fundamental mapping from them.
- ugly sliders are opinions, not apart of fundamental(ever-so changing factor in mapping history). If i'm a shit slider artist, you can't tell me to make "prettier" sliders.
- aesthetics has nothing to do with rank criteria, nor quality of the map. it's purposely there, and it's consistnet. use your brain power; THINK!
- speed ranking. nothing wrong with it.
- if you no like-y, like-y don't complain to monstrata, complain to some guy who created the system. he will call you a dumbass though.
Kiyohime wrote:
The unfortunate thing is that it's literally just a matter of time. Even if a lot of people dislike the map for what it is or what it does, it's Monstrata and the circlejerk is real; it will eventually reach rank.
Thanks for the mod!!Yunomi wrote:
hey monstroti,
02:51:908 (1,1) - maybe the sv increase could increase by smaller increments cuz its really uncomfortable to play repeats on such high sv when you have to move as well. It plays fine for me idk. You have to click and move the sliders independently, it'll feel like the slider-ball is following your cursor instead of you following the cursor ball. I think if you do that you shouldn't have trouble playing it.
try to remove or decrease the spacing of the jumpstreams as well since this is 280bpm I don't really want to nerf it, but I improved the structure a bit. I think the spacing between 1>3>5>7 could have thrown people off.
try nerfing the fullscreen jumps, i don't mean the large jumps, but i mean the actual full screen jumps like 01:01:580 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - even if its just a little nerf i think it would help a lot. Nerfed a bit. Oh, this was supposed to be for the jumpstreams, flip the replies^
i don't think the sliders are ugly since it fits your theme of the map, some patterns are arguable but the slider shapes themselves are fine since you are consistent with them throughout the map.
already seen some maps go down the toilet in quality this year so i don't understand why people are freaking out over this map being "ugly". it's not that bad overall.
Thanks for the mod!! (Sorry i accidentally denied your kds cuz im bad at aiming)MCB wrote:
Hi noob here, I'll probably be eaten alive but I might as well have a go at this.SPOILERI can't play the map obviously, I'll just have to use whatever intuition I have to try and be of use :/
The part between 01:41:487 and 01:59:463 shows irregular sliders. Of course, you've done this before during the chaotic parts, but you've shown before in the map that you want to map the orderly parts in an orderly fashion, so why are the sliders here so oddly shaped? I'd say this part sounds quite neat and orderly and the slider shapes could better reflect that. Kinda cheeky, but If you notice, the first two sliders look pretty, and then it devolves back into chaos. This part "sounds" like it will be orderly when you first hear it, but then as you listen on, you realize the rhythm and timing is completely erratic and the Chaotic sliders come back. I ended up changing 01:47:183 (1,2) - though to become uglier to fit my original idea above^
02:21:689 (1,2) - 02:23:624 (1,2) - etc. There are some of these sliders which represent the exact same sound in the song but have a completely different shape, I'm assuming it's intentional? I feel like you could create more order within the chaos to better represent the song It's intentional.
02:55:471 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1) For a part that's quite neat in its rhythm and sound, the shape's good, but why is the spacing so high? Your spacing approached this during the extremely chaotic parts but it seems weird to make the jumps this huge for a reasonably orderly and calm part. This is the one of the heights of the map imo. It's where the song finally transitions from chaotic 280 bpm mapping to 120 bpm mapping so here I wanted a blend of both the craziness of the first half of the map, and the structural integrity of the second half. It's why the arrangement here (along with the sliders before it) are noticeably normal, while still being really over the top.
Just some opinion: You probably noticed most of my suggestions (woah there were so many) were about the randomness factor of the map. I do know that there are a lot of parts where you decided to just let the randomness do its thing, because the song's that way. But I feel like you show in certain parts that you do care for the order of the map by doing things more neatly, but you're not doing it all the time, which isn't because the song's just that way (it certainly isn't in some parts) but because you're straying away from how the song is and approaching this randomness feature that you've created around the map and turning it into a gimmick. I'm not saying the randomness is bad, I think there should be structure within it. So I feel like you should actually be more consistent with this behaviour and make the neater parts of the song neater in the map and such. I think of the map in this way because there's definitely structure and order within the song and you definitely do interpret it, but sometimes you don't seem to show it which is a waste if you ask me :c
All in all, I really like the randomness effect but I think you can improve on it
Good luck with the map!
Thanks for your feedback!!Reddit wrote:
SPOILER00:40:066 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5) - possibly change the pattern here to something smoother or at least lower spacing No, I want to show the jumps spiraling out of control. You can see how the pentagon/star jump pattern just dissipates into chaos.
01:01:580 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - the spacing here could be a bit lower come on lmao Explained with Yumoni's post
02:55:471 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,1,1) - extremely over mapped imo, this isnt a Rabbit Jumping Style map lol Explained with MCB's post.
ok there is my first ever mod in osu, i even had to watch ztrots osu accademy video to do it. kudosu pls
Remapping the guitar to 1/3 tho!Sieg wrote:
hello apparition wannabe
confirming from my part that guitar in intro 1/3 yea
also, don't you feel like those patterns overextended? No, but I made some minor changes see above for changes/reasonings
01:01:151 (3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) -
02:55:471 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1) -
also, while 1/4 sliders can be justified(?), I don't see much support for placing just streams there: The 1/4's exist, and in both cases I've been prepping the player with those 1/4 patterns, whether kicksliders or 1/4 repeats so they should expect some sort of 1/4 rhythm going into both of then.
01:41:058 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) -
02:32:742 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) -
Thanks for your concerns!!BOUYAAA wrote:
Should be 1/3 as said above yea
there are still alot of questionable things in the map imo though
rythm is kinda fucked in some places like here 01:38:058 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - etc i'm guessing you're doing that kickslider stuff because vocals go crazy or something but you're not following the vocals so yea feels super weird I disagree...
some pretty ugly overmaps too like 01:37:362 (2,3,4,5) - idk it's probably not 1/4 it's probably there, but it might not be. Either ways though I would want to keep, i don't think the overmap is inherently wrong, and I don't think you'll even be able to complain about a lack of a note there when actually playing (listening at 100%). The vocals support it imo.
01:41:058 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1) - this one is pretty lol with the streamjumps and all Well, i nerfed spacing a bit~
don't have time to look at the rest but yea
idk