Hi! From my forum NM/M4M taiko queue.
I am pretty thorough, so don't feel bad if I point out a lot of issues. A lot of times they are just my opinions, so feel free to object to them. :3
After looking through my mod, would you mind taking the time to check out
my taiko set? <3
Btw, I don't know how to make bpm/offset/scroll speed changes, so don't ask me those pls. XD
d = don
k = katsu
D = big don
K = big katsu
[General]
Your music file cuts off at the end, is that intentional?
Good difficulty curve, but Kantan could be easier, and Oni harder.
Below 1.5: Easy/Kantan
Below 2.25: Normal/Futsuu
Below 3.75: Hard/Muzukashii
Below 5.25: Insane/Oni
Above 5.25: Expert/Inner Oni
Your song has a lot of offbeat patterns in the vocals... It would be hard for beginners to follow the note patterns in Kantan and Futsuu. They're ok for Muzukashii and Oni only.
Adding some timing changes could make the map more interesting to play, just a suggestion ^_~
[Kantan]
Consider reducing the HP drain rate and overall difficulty, and reducing overall number of notes placed on the offbeat.
00:11:704 (9,10,11,12) - offbeat pattern is too harsh for kantan difficulty. Suggest recomposing.
00:24:153 (10,11) - change to dk, maintain previous pattern
00:27:214 (14) - move to 00:27:418, offbeat pattern is too harsh for kantan difficulty.
00:32:928 (22) - change to k
00:54:969 (46) - move to 00:55:173, offbeat pattern is too harsh for kantan difficulty.
00:58:234 (51) - move to 00:58:438, ^
01:01:500 (54) - move to 01:01:704, ^
01:11:500 (68) - change to K, follow pattern
01:13:744 (71,72,73) - offbeat pattern is too harsh for kantan difficulty. Suggest recomposing.
01:24:562 (87) - change to K, follow pattern
01:26:806 (90,91,92,93) - offbeat pattern is too harsh for kantan difficulty. Suggest recomposing.
[Futsuu]
00:09:459 (21) - change to D, follow previous pattern
00:28:642 (27) - change to K, highlight piano glissando
00:32:928 (39) - change to D, accentuate beat
00:40:887 - add d
00:51:908 (83) - change to d, onbeat
01:01:908 (107,108) - change to DD, follow previous D
01:11:500 (131) - change to d, follow previous pattern
01:24:562 (164) - change to d, ^
[Muzukashii]
Good muzukashii! Could be harder, 3 stars would be ideal.
00:11:091 (33,34,35,36) - change to kdkk, vocals are pretty high pitched, should be k instead of d
00:21:295 (19) - move to 00:21:193 , follow vocals
00:23:949 (28) - change to k
00:49:255 (110) - change to K, follow previous pattern
00:50:275 (112) - change to d, this is the start of a rising sequence of 3, onbeat should not be accentuated
01:01:908 (150,151) - change to DD, same as Futsuu
01:19:255 (211) - change to d
01:26:193 (242,243,244,245) - change to kdkk, vocals are pretty high pitched, should be k instead of d
[Oni]
Oni is overall pretty easy, 4 stars would be ideal for your curve.
00:11:091 (45,48,49) - change to k, vocals are pretty high pitched, should be k instead of d
00:15:989 (1) - remove this note, does not follow anything in the music
00:28:234 - you can add a 1/4 note run here
00:36:500 (90) - change to d, accentuate previous note
00:36:704 (91,92) - change to kd, vocals are k according to your pattern.
00:40:683 (114,115,116) - change to kdk, ^
00:49:255 (164) - change to K, follow previous pattern
01:01:500 (228) - change to k, high pitched strings
01:08:234 (264) - change to k, high pitched vocals
01:17:622 (311) - change to d
01:26:193 (363,366,367) - change to k, vocals are pretty high pitched, should be k instead of d
There you go! Nice beatmap overall. Hope you find this mod helpful, and good luck beatmapping! :3