like what? can you point out what argument has no basis instead of just saying it has no basis?Drace wrote:
None of you are presenting anything that could even be considered a fragment of a decent argument. Throwing stuff around like it's "absurd", "unfair" and saying we should all "perish the thought" with no basis whatsoever, thinking that it's enough to prove a point.
ok. i'll type out my thoughts.Drace wrote:
And the slight points raised that could probably make a clueless person nod to the cause are completely overwhelmed and showed to be irrelevant in my previous post. It makes me wounder if anyone bothered reading it. Was it too long? Too hard to understand? Or maybe is it purposely being ignored because there's nothing to be said against it?
to me, that comes off as "don't rank auto-convert songs because high-level players don't like them." auto-converting standard maps is a major, attractive feature of osu!mania. they don't need to go through the ranking process because they are an inherent feature of osu!mania. whether you like the quality of the maps or not is completely irrelevant. and whether those maps hold up at a high level is also completely irrelevant.Drace wrote:
First of all, those autoconverts wouldn't pass the ranking process if they were submitted like mania maps. Many maps gots notes mapped to stuff that mania maps normally wouldn't. The long note's release are not correctly timed. And no matter the map, you'll never have something layering multiple tracks which is pretty much the essence of multi key games like this. These maps were converted from a 1k source and the patterns processed by a semi-controlled randomization.
you need to recognize that difficulty is relative. speed is extremely difficult for new players. the patterns found in auto-converted maps, while easy to you, are also extremely difficult for new players. instead of seeing this from your current skill level, you need to see it from the perspective of a new player. osu!mania features gameplay requiring skills that are not typically used or trained. having a way for new players to practice the mode using familiar and enjoyable songs while at the same time allowing them a way to participate in ladder play is a great thing.Drace wrote:
With autoconverts, speed is the ONLY difficulty factor. You will never find difficult patterns. "Difficult patterns" are patterns that would still be difficult when slowed down because of how the notes are placed. I would agree to a certain extent with the people that mentioned that the people that play autoconverts exclusively aren't true mania players. The whole difficulty ladder in all similar rhythm games is learning and recognizing different patterns after extended play, even the standard mode. But the maps converted from there are stripped from the clever patterns they once had and become a useless junk with single-dimension difficulty.
you also address this point later in your post.
this is the value of auto-convert maps and there is nothing wrong with that. lower difficulties help acclimate a new player to the controls, higher difficulties introduce simple beginner patterns, and the hardest difficulties get the new player used to playing at higher speeds. having them ranked allows a player to track their progress. and when their rank gains start to slow, they should be confident enough to do the easy mania-specific maps.Drace wrote:
To everyone who doesn't understand what I'm saying look at this. t/146615 and scroll down to the pattern repository. Now try and find autos that feature anything but beginner patterns. All those "omg so hard" autos are just fast beginner and maybe novice level patterns. Keep in mind that this is a just a fraction of "common" patterns. Harder maps all feature unique stuff to make them memorable.
from what i've been seeing, you are making arguments only from the perspective of a high-level player. you need to also think about the low-level players. the osu!mania ladder should not be some exclusive club open only to the skilled and experienced.