JEEZ, THANKS. xDIrreversible wrote:
Take another star, I really like that song *-*
forum
Pendulum - The Island
posted
Total Posts
127
Topic Starter
hey just dropping by~
General
- Your mp3 bitrate is0?? or apparently 123kbps VBR xD Either way, these rates aren't rankable. It should be between 128-192kbps. You should reencode this to be safe. After replacing the mp3, the offset may have to be adjusted a little.
Edit: here's the soundcloud page https://soundcloud.com/schavezpalma/the-island-pendulum
Therefore, you can also add "Sebastian Cháve" to tags since he's the arranger
- Delete "pendulum the island" from tags. They're already in your title and artist
Absolution
General
- Your mp3 bitrate is
Edit: here's the soundcloud page https://soundcloud.com/schavezpalma/the-island-pendulum
Therefore, you can also add "Sebastian Cháve" to tags since he's the arranger
- Delete "pendulum the island" from tags. They're already in your title and artist
Absolution
- 00:02:167 (1) - seemed a bit like you were making your own rhythm here, which can be misleading in a rather quieter section. Try something like this to match the bgm more: http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1074605
00:05:977 (1) - ^
00:09:786 (1) - ^
00:13:596 (5) - ^, also NC to follow NC pattern like before
There are a couple more of these ahead so i'll stop mentioning them =v=
00:27:882 (3) - hmm how about letting the previous note create a nice blanket~ http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1074619
01:06:453 (3) - Clap for hitsound consistency
01:06:929 (5) - Clap on tail for same reason as above
01:31:691 (3) - For this section, try using Soft sample set for every red tick http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1074627 highlighting the specific spot and selecting "Soft" from the upper-left dropdown, as shown in the screenshot. I think that'd be really appropriate for this part, since I feel that it's a bit noisy atm
01:45:977 (1,2,3,4) - What's this following? either way, the bgm for (2,4) is really subtle/silent. I suggest you change up the rhythm a bit here to fit the constant beat going here
01:49:786 (7,8) - ^
again, there are more spots like these~
01:56:453 (5) - NC?
03:18:358 (1) - NC
03:22:881 (2,3) - again, rhythm is off imo
06:14:865 (4,5,6) - I'd at least halve the spacing of this stream. Being in the same combo with 06:14:429 (2) - (1/4 rhythm as opposed to 1/8) with similar spacing would cause confusion in rhythm reading here
06:37:722 (6,7,8) - again, consider moving these closer together
06:53:595 (1) - probably not a good idea to stack this because the cursor movement comes to a disturbing halt imo. The combo really gets moving in all these directions and suddenly this =v=!
06:55:976 (1) - Not sure about the necessity of this spinner, seemed more like a filler
07:06:929 (13) - Finish would sound nice
07:25:976 (4) - NC, to give players some drain leniency here
07:43:119 (3) - ^same here maybe
Andy Chen_old
LunarSakuya wrote:
hey just dropping by~
General
- Your mp3 bitrate is0??or apparently 123kbps VBR xD Either way, these rates aren't rankable. It should be between 128-192kbps. You should reencode this to be safe. After replacing the mp3, the offset may have to be adjusted a little.
- Delete "pendulum the island" from tags. They're already in your title and artist
Absolutionthis is pretty awesome. Hope this gets approved eventually xD feel free to ask me any questions! Good luck
- 00:02:167 (1) - seemed a bit like you were making your own rhythm here, which can be misleading in a rather quieter section. Try something like this to match the bgm more: http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1074605
00:05:977 (1) - ^
00:09:786 (1) - ^
00:13:596 (5) - ^, also NC to follow NC pattern like before
There are a couple more of these ahead so i'll stop mentioning them =v=
00:27:882 (3) - hmm how about letting the previous note create a nice blanket~ http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1074619
01:06:453 (3) - Clap for hitsound consistency
01:06:929 (5) - Clap on tail for same reason as above
01:31:691 (3) - For this section, try using Soft sample set for every red tick http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1074627 highlighting the specific spot and selecting "Soft" from the upper-left dropdown, as shown in the screenshot. I think that'd be really appropriate for this part, since I feel that it's a bit noisy atm
01:45:977 (1,2,3,4) - What's this following? either way, the bgm for (2,4) is really subtle/silent. I suggest you change up the rhythm a bit here to fit the constant beat going here
01:49:786 (7,8) - ^
again, there are more spots like these~
01:56:453 (5) - NC?
03:18:358 (1) - NC
03:22:881 (2,3) - again, rhythm is off imo
06:14:865 (4,5,6) - I'd at least halve the spacing of this stream. Being in the same combo with 06:14:429 (2) - (1/4 rhythm as opposed to 1/8) with similar spacing would cause confusion in rhythm reading here
06:37:722 (6,7,8) - again, consider moving these closer together
06:53:595 (1) - probably not a good idea to stack this because the cursor movement comes to a disturbing halt imo. The combo really gets moving in all these directions and suddenly this =v=!
06:55:976 (1) - Not sure about the necessity of this spinner, seemed more like a filler
07:06:929 (13) - Finish would sound nice
07:25:976 (4) - NC, to give players some drain leniency here
07:43:119 (3) - ^same here maybe
Hi Sala- got my friend BAT for you~
sorry im late D':
lets go~
Absolution
00:05:977 (1) - I think you can put it on top of 00:06:929 (2) - 00:37:405 (3) - 00:56:453 (9) - NC
00:58:358 (1,2,3,4) - 01:02:167 (3) - I suggest you can put this slider more far away from 01:01:691 (2) - \:D/ 01:08:358 (1) - stack with 01:07:643 (6) - head
01:11:453 (3,4) - how about this rhythm \:D/ 01:15:739 (3,4,5,6,7) - not so suitable for the rhythm
01:19:310 (6,7,1) - spacing these notes with ds1.8 seems more better
01:40:262 (5,6) - keep doing the jump just like 01:39:310 (1,2,3,4) - 01:43:596 (2) - 02:05:977 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - 03:03:119 - why dont stop kiai here :p
03:30:858 (6) - delete this note
03:41:215 (1) - why you make speed up here D:
04:22:643 (3) - put it on about x:312 y:344
04:36:453 (5,6,7) - use slider to replace all these circle
06:10:262 (2,3,1,2,1,2,3) - a bit hard to read
06:52:881 (4) - NC
I LOVE THE PART IN THE END
sorry for my poor English+poor mod ;w;
awesome map and good luck\:D/
jizzzzzz~
lets go~
Absolution
00:05:977 (1) - I think you can put it on top of 00:06:929 (2) - 00:37:405 (3) - 00:56:453 (9) - NC
00:58:358 (1,2,3,4) - 01:02:167 (3) - I suggest you can put this slider more far away from 01:01:691 (2) - \:D/ 01:08:358 (1) - stack with 01:07:643 (6) - head
01:11:453 (3,4) - how about this rhythm \:D/ 01:15:739 (3,4,5,6,7) - not so suitable for the rhythm
01:19:310 (6,7,1) - spacing these notes with ds1.8 seems more better
01:40:262 (5,6) - keep doing the jump just like 01:39:310 (1,2,3,4) - 01:43:596 (2) - 02:05:977 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - 03:03:119 - why dont stop kiai here :p
03:30:858 (6) - delete this note
03:41:215 (1) - why you make speed up here D:
04:22:643 (3) - put it on about x:312 y:344
04:36:453 (5,6,7) - use slider to replace all these circle
06:10:262 (2,3,1,2,1,2,3) - a bit hard to read
06:52:881 (4) - NC
I LOVE THE PART IN THE END
sorry for my poor English+poor mod ;w;
awesome map and good luck\:D/
jizzzzzz~
Topic Starter
Thanks all of you, Chen for getting Sakuya, Sakuya for the Mod and also Foreverends for the mod. Tried to change as much as possible.
This map need way too many mods to get rarnked, the last 3 minutes are completly unreadable!
Topic Starter
Is this statement supported by anybody else?PrivatHansi1 wrote:
This map need way too many mods to get rarnked, the last 3 minutes are completly unreadable!
00:02:524 (2) - i think this is placed 1/4 beat too late
00:06:334 (2) - ^
00:10:143 (2) - ^
00:13:953 (2) - ^
00:17:762 (2) - ^
00:21:572 (2) - ^
04:40:262 (1,2,3) - i can't really feel the rhythm at these 3 circles
05:53:953 (6,7) - the space between these 2 shouldn't be there
06:10:857 (1,2,1,2,3) - these are a little bit confusing, if you ask me
06:15:262 (7) - i don't really like the position of this one, how about placing it a bit further away?
07:53:119 (1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,4) - i don't know what i should think about this part, it's weird and hard to read
i hope i could help you a little bit
I love Pendulum, so do your best!
00:06:334 (2) - ^
00:10:143 (2) - ^
00:13:953 (2) - ^
00:17:762 (2) - ^
00:21:572 (2) - ^
04:40:262 (1,2,3) - i can't really feel the rhythm at these 3 circles
05:53:953 (6,7) - the space between these 2 shouldn't be there
06:10:857 (1,2,1,2,3) - these are a little bit confusing, if you ask me
06:15:262 (7) - i don't really like the position of this one, how about placing it a bit further away?
07:53:119 (1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,4) - i don't know what i should think about this part, it's weird and hard to read
i hope i could help you a little bit
I love Pendulum, so do your best!
hi again, i can't mod insanes but.. as i know, 04:53:596 - map is unrankable if you have a break time in the kiai time
Try something to fill this break
maybe some notes, but this break shouldn't be in the kiai time
Try something to fill this break
maybe some notes, but this break shouldn't be in the kiai time
Topic Starter
Marco wrote:
00:02:524 (2) - i think this is placed 1/4 beat too late
00:06:334 (2) - ^
00:10:143 (2) - ^
00:13:953 (2) - ^
00:17:762 (2) - ^
00:21:572 (2) - ^
04:40:262 (1,2,3) - i can't really feel the rhythm at these 3 circles
05:53:953 (6,7) - the space between these 2 shouldn't be there
06:10:857 (1,2,1,2,3) - these are a little bit confusing, if you ask me
06:15:262 (7) - i don't really like the position of this one, how about placing it a bit further away?
07:53:119 (1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,4) - i don't know what i should think about this part, it's weird and hard to read
i hope i could help you a little bit
I love Pendulum, so do your best!
Tried to fix everything.
Topic Starter
Fixed, thanks.AlexaBM wrote:
hi again, i can't mod insanes but.. as i know, 04:53:596 - map is unrankable if you have a break time in the kiai time
Try something to fill this break
maybe some notes, but this break shouldn't be in the kiai time
Re-encoded your mp3 file to 192kbps, which is a rankable bitrate: DOWNLOAD
The new offset should be ~290 (I hope it's accurate enough).
Also remove from Tags "Pendulum the island" since they're already the Artist and the Title. "Immersion" is the name of the album where The Island appear, but normally mappers don't include the album in the Source. Add it in Tags instead.
Good luck!
The new offset should be ~290 (I hope it's accurate enough).
Also remove from Tags "Pendulum the island" since they're already the Artist and the Title. "Immersion" is the name of the album where The Island appear, but normally mappers don't include the album in the Source. Add it in Tags instead.
Good luck!
Topic Starter
Deif wrote:
Re-encoded your mp3 file to 192kbps, which is a rankable bitrate: DOWNLOAD
The new offset should be ~290 (I hope it's accurate enough).
Also remove from Tags "Pendulum the island" since they're already the Artist and the Title. "Immersion" is the name of the album where The Island appear, but normally mappers don't include the album in the Source. Add it in Tags instead.
Good luck!
Substituted audio and changed Offset, thanks!
Can't really support that statement, except for a few pattern:Sala- wrote:
Is this statement supported by anybody else?PrivatHansi1 wrote:
This map need way too many mods to get rarnked, the last 3 minutes are completly unreadable!
Somewhat awkward to read
06:10:274 (2,3,1,2,1,2,3,4) - Can't really put it into words, but I just couldn't sightread it.
06:16:465 (1,1,2) - (2) is hidden under a slider, thus awkward to see and hidden by a hitburst
06:25:512 (1,2,1) - Those sliders overlap in weird way to me
Also:
06:10:289 (2,3,1,2) - You may want to turn this one into a consecutive stream, like this because otherwise the stream would start on a blue tick, which isn't too nice, and would be nicer to play.
06:16:465 (1,1,2) - (2) is hidden under a slider, thus awkward to see and hidden by a hitburst
06:25:512 (1,2,1) - Those sliders overlap in weird way to me
Also:
06:10:289 (2,3,1,2) - You may want to turn this one into a consecutive stream, like this because otherwise the stream would start on a blue tick, which isn't too nice, and would be nicer to play.
Just wanted to drop my opinion here.
Topic Starter
I will try to put the next update together and fix problems and add hitsounds at once, thuis it will need some time. Maybe this weekend.
Noob Modding incoming D: :
06:53:607 (1) - Seems kinda unreadable, not sure if it's me though..
06:58:846 (6) - ^
07:39:337 (1) - This slider ends too early in my opinion/ears.
Can't really find more what bothers me, so yea, hope I could help a bit and good luck with getting it approved! :3
06:53:607 (1) - Seems kinda unreadable, not sure if it's me though..
06:58:846 (6) - ^
07:39:337 (1) - This slider ends too early in my opinion/ears.
Can't really find more what bothers me, so yea, hope I could help a bit and good luck with getting it approved! :3
Topic Starter
Tried to fix things. The slider was too short because of the new Offset. Is fixed with the next update.Ririi wrote:
Noob Modding incoming D: :
06:53:607 (1) - Seems kinda unreadable, not sure if it's me though..
06:58:846 (6) - ^
07:39:337 (1) - This slider ends too early in my opinion/ears.
Can't really find more what bothers me, so yea, hope I could help a bit and good luck with getting it approved! :3
o_O new offset? can you please sent me the new .mp3 then?
btw i have done 1 min today and hopefully will do tomorrow ~2 min and over the week maybe +3 min? i would send you the new .osz the current objects. please do not change anything or else i would be fucked O:
FINISHED
btw i have done 1 min today and hopefully will do tomorrow ~2 min and over the week maybe +3 min? i would send you the new .osz the current objects. please do not change anything or else i would be fucked O:
FINISHED
Topic Starter
http://puu.sh/5kpkV.mp3 Here you go.
I will do no further changes to the beatmap. I hope you are done in time.
Edit: As soon as the hitsounds are all set and the custom sounds are uploaded, the map will be ready for modding again.
I will do no further changes to the beatmap. I hope you are done in time.
Edit: As soon as the hitsounds are all set and the custom sounds are uploaded, the map will be ready for modding again.
Topic Starter
Hitsounds are completed, mods can be added again.
Hi , I'm from #modreq and also from PM :3
Pls , be gentle with my mod >w<
01:23:145 (1,2,3,4) - Make a symmetrical order (/ make a better pattern !)
01:32:668 (5,6,7,8) - ^
01:39:335 (1,2,3,4,5) - ^
02:06:954 (5) - Move it a little bit in right ?
02:08:859 (2) - Make a straight line ?
05:14:930 (1) - Stack it ! ( like 05:42:906 (8) - )
I haven't find any mistakes after !
That's all I think !
Good luck for bubble ! :3
Pls , be gentle with my mod >w<
01:23:145 (1,2,3,4) - Make a symmetrical order (/ make a better pattern !)
01:32:668 (5,6,7,8) - ^
01:39:335 (1,2,3,4,5) - ^
02:06:954 (5) - Move it a little bit in right ?
02:08:859 (2) - Make a straight line ?
05:14:930 (1) - Stack it ! ( like 05:42:906 (8) - )
I haven't find any mistakes after !
That's all I think !
Good luck for bubble ! :3
Topic Starter
Thank you.Secretpipe wrote:
Hi , I'm from #modreq and also from PM :3
Pls , be gentle with my mod >w<
01:23:145 (1,2,3,4) - Make a symmetrical order (/ make a better pattern !)
01:32:668 (5,6,7,8) - ^
01:39:335 (1,2,3,4,5) - ^
02:06:954 (5) - Move it a little bit in right ?
02:08:859 (2) - Make a straight line ?
05:14:930 (1) - Stack it ! ( like 05:42:906 (8) - )
I haven't find any mistakes after !
That's all I think !
Good luck for bubble ! :3
I just played through this until a bit into the dusk bit before failing. It definitely gets harder in dusk, so you might want to consider making the Dusk section easier, or the dawn section harder for a more uniform difficulty
Just a couple of personal things I'd like to point out
0:27:907 (3) goes off time and might throw people off track.
Also, the subsequent notes (4, 1, 1, 1, 1) shouldn't overlay like that in my opinion. Not sure about others, but I didn't notice that another slider appeared underneath. Consider either spacing them or repositioning them completely.
0:44:097 is a bit difficult and also quite hard to see what is going on - mainly because the fades on the notes you've already clicked.
Generally it was quite simple to follow apart from repetitions of what i've already linked.
Good map though, keep it up
I look forward to seeing updates
Just a couple of personal things I'd like to point out
0:27:907 (3) goes off time and might throw people off track.
Also, the subsequent notes (4, 1, 1, 1, 1) shouldn't overlay like that in my opinion. Not sure about others, but I didn't notice that another slider appeared underneath. Consider either spacing them or repositioning them completely.
0:44:097 is a bit difficult and also quite hard to see what is going on - mainly because the fades on the notes you've already clicked.
Generally it was quite simple to follow apart from repetitions of what i've already linked.
Good map though, keep it up
I look forward to seeing updates
Topic Starter
It was my intention to make the second part harder than the first, it can be compared to the music, at first it is rather decent and then you have the dubstep.SkinnyBill wrote:
I just played through this until a bit into the dusk bit before failing. It definitely gets harder in dusk, so you might want to consider making the Dusk section easier, or the dawn section harder for a more uniform difficulty
Just a couple of personal things I'd like to point out
0:27:907 (3) goes off time and might throw people off track.
Also, the subsequent notes (4, 1, 1, 1, 1) shouldn't overlay like that in my opinion. Not sure about others, but I didn't notice that another slider appeared underneath. Consider either spacing them or repositioning them completely.
0:44:097 is a bit difficult and also quite hard to see what is going on - mainly because the fades on the notes you've already clicked.
Generally it was quite simple to follow apart from repetitions of what i've already linked.
Good map though, keep it up
I look forward to seeing updates
But basically, all other things were fixed, my overlays were once or twice mentioned before, but I did not see any problems with them. Now I realize that they are not too good.
Thus I tried to fix all parts with those (at least where they were not well-made or well-fitting.
Thank you!
02:07:192 (6,7) - maybe 2note and 1 slider better than now
than all
really nice map;w;
than all
really nice map;w;
Red for important
Green for my important *opinion*
Blue small little details
so... lets get started..
perhaps add "instrumental", "electronic", and "house music" to the tags?
00:44:097 (1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,2) - This is actually nice, but I think the spacing is a bit untidy and it is too well... unreachable. Just my opinion, I recemended using a short slider stream with a few reverse arrow, and arrange them properly like yeah rotate them some degrees. (you can use the copy paste method.)
00:55:049 (4,1) - Beetween them, don't you think it's to far and too fast to reach? Make them closer a little. and beside after that slider is a stream so it will exhaust the player hand if it gets too far xD.
00:55:526 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16) - add some new combo? well, your opinion where to put it. perhaps after 4 hit circle or at the 8th hit circle would be nice ^_^>
01:01:716 (2,3) - Spacing, would be nice if you make them closer a little somehow.
01:08:026 (7,8) - Feels unneccessary and strange to me... how about change it into a slider?
.
01:11:240 (2) - ^, i think just delete it or something....
01:27:906 (1,2,3) - I recomended using hitcircle on consistent rhytm. for this one, beside sounds unsual, it is unfamiliar. Recomned using sliders, 1 long or 2 short up to you.
01:31:240 (5) - move it to x:184 y:260???
02:13:383 (1,1) - Just My opinion, since this is a long, streamful and insane map, if there's spinner I think you should give break to player, some break space...you know not to break their hand.
02:17:906 (1) - Remove new combo
02:26:359 (2) - Strange??? maybe you can add hitsound to make this rhytm more clear.
03:01:716 (2) - to make it consistent and make player feel familiar, change it into 4 hitcirlce like before.
03:02:192 (3,4) - Now I'm pretty sure u need to add some hitsound here, I recomended something outloud and can be heared clearly, like clap, or sth. like that
03:25:049 (2,3,4) - Same....dont use hit circle on non-consistent rhytm. change it into sliders, perhaps 3 short will do.
03:36:002 (2,3) - Spacing....to far
03:45:049 (1,1,2,3,4,5) - Same.... spinner and stream will break player's hand, try make it easier a little somehow, like using slider.
04:42:906 (3,1) - too close right??
08:53:620 (1) - Add spinner after this one to make it more "dramatic"
THAT's ALL
1. NEWBIE MODDER SORRY FOR MISTAKE/UMIMPORTANT MOD.
2 GOOD LUCK, GET RANKED SOON!!
EXTRA's:
things I like from this map:
1.NICE SONG.
2. CREATIVE N' BEAUTIFUL SLIDER PATTERN NOT BORING AND MONOTHON> XDDD
Green for my important *opinion*
Blue small little details
so... lets get started..
perhaps add "instrumental", "electronic", and "house music" to the tags?
00:44:097 (1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,2) - This is actually nice, but I think the spacing is a bit untidy and it is too well... unreachable. Just my opinion, I recemended using a short slider stream with a few reverse arrow, and arrange them properly like yeah rotate them some degrees. (you can use the copy paste method.)
00:55:049 (4,1) - Beetween them, don't you think it's to far and too fast to reach? Make them closer a little. and beside after that slider is a stream so it will exhaust the player hand if it gets too far xD.
00:55:526 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16) - add some new combo? well, your opinion where to put it. perhaps after 4 hit circle or at the 8th hit circle would be nice ^_^>
01:01:716 (2,3) - Spacing, would be nice if you make them closer a little somehow.
01:08:026 (7,8) - Feels unneccessary and strange to me... how about change it into a slider?
.
01:11:240 (2) - ^, i think just delete it or something....
01:27:906 (1,2,3) - I recomended using hitcircle on consistent rhytm. for this one, beside sounds unsual, it is unfamiliar. Recomned using sliders, 1 long or 2 short up to you.
01:31:240 (5) - move it to x:184 y:260???
02:13:383 (1,1) - Just My opinion, since this is a long, streamful and insane map, if there's spinner I think you should give break to player, some break space...you know not to break their hand.
02:17:906 (1) - Remove new combo
02:26:359 (2) - Strange??? maybe you can add hitsound to make this rhytm more clear.
03:01:716 (2) - to make it consistent and make player feel familiar, change it into 4 hitcirlce like before.
03:02:192 (3,4) - Now I'm pretty sure u need to add some hitsound here, I recomended something outloud and can be heared clearly, like clap, or sth. like that
03:25:049 (2,3,4) - Same....dont use hit circle on non-consistent rhytm. change it into sliders, perhaps 3 short will do.
03:36:002 (2,3) - Spacing....to far
03:45:049 (1,1,2,3,4,5) - Same.... spinner and stream will break player's hand, try make it easier a little somehow, like using slider.
04:42:906 (3,1) - too close right??
08:53:620 (1) - Add spinner after this one to make it more "dramatic"
THAT's ALL
1. NEWBIE MODDER SORRY FOR MISTAKE/UMIMPORTANT MOD.
2 GOOD LUCK, GET RANKED SOON!!
EXTRA's:
things I like from this map:
1.NICE SONG.
2. CREATIVE N' BEAUTIFUL SLIDER PATTERN NOT BORING AND MONOTHON>
XDDDJust get this idea all of sudden, why don't you make those blue line, and yellow circle on your background glow following the BPM during kiai time? I think with mostly black background, the glow of those blue line and yellow circle will make your map more contrast and beautiful! try asking SB other/or in chat to find out how. And just 1 more Idea.....
COLLAB WITH OTHER MAPPER? and make a collab map^_^ people should appreciate it a lot. I recommend collab with BAT or famous ranked mapper!
try asking SB other/or in chat to find out how. And just 1 more Idea.....COLLAB WITH OTHER MAPPER? and make a collab map^_^ people should appreciate it a lot. I recommend collab with BAT or famous ranked mapper!
Topic Starter
I will take a look at this tomorrow. Thanks in advance!
Your Mod was partially implemented. about 5/6 are in now.
I somehow did not get any Kudosu-Star for that, so I can't add it to your map. :c
If I will get it, I will give that one to you.
Your Mod was partially implemented. about 5/6 are in now.
I somehow did not get any Kudosu-Star for that, so I can't add it to your map. :c
If I will get it, I will give that one to you.
Uuhhh sure, Thanks a lot
My attempt to mod this map.
SPOILER
1. 02:17:430 (1,2) - I don't like the slider velocity change in this one because I have no idea why it should become slower...
You could try to make those the same length as 02:19:335 (2,1) -
2. 03:02:549 (6) - Higher spacing on this one suggested, because i thought that was an 1/4 slider as i was playing it (the reason for that are sliders like this 03:53:144 (5,6) - )
3. 04:13:025 (7) - See 2. (lol)
4. 05:31:716 (1) - The green lines here look kind of unneccessary o.o
5. 05:53:501 (4) - A bit less spacing of this one to the next slider
6. 06:06:557 (3) - I think there's no sound which this slider snaps to, you could try to replace 06:06:478 (2,3,4) - with a single slider
7. 06:11:597 - You were mapping those sounds and I expected there to be some kind of circle correspondingly
8. 06:12:073 - see 7.
9.0 07:59:930 (5) - Can't hear the thing this snaps to ._.
9.1 08:00:049 (6,7) - Those sound like 1/6, dunno
10. Suggestion: 08:16:001 (1) - You could try to give those sliders increasing volocities to make this part funnier, but that's up to you ;D
11. 08:45:525 (5) - This one is a bit overmapped but it's not a thing i would remove
12. 08:52:668 (5,6,7,8,9,10,11) - might try to use some sliders for the 1/6 stream because it's a bit hard to read but nothing crucial.
You could try to make those the same length as 02:19:335 (2,1) -
2. 03:02:549 (6) - Higher spacing on this one suggested, because i thought that was an 1/4 slider as i was playing it (the reason for that are sliders like this 03:53:144 (5,6) - )
3. 04:13:025 (7) - See 2. (lol)
4. 05:31:716 (1) - The green lines here look kind of unneccessary o.o
5. 05:53:501 (4) - A bit less spacing of this one to the next slider
6. 06:06:557 (3) - I think there's no sound which this slider snaps to, you could try to replace 06:06:478 (2,3,4) - with a single slider
7. 06:11:597 - You were mapping those sounds and I expected there to be some kind of circle correspondingly
8. 06:12:073 - see 7.
9.0 07:59:930 (5) - Can't hear the thing this snaps to ._.
9.1 08:00:049 (6,7) - Those sound like 1/6, dunno
10. Suggestion: 08:16:001 (1) - You could try to give those sliders increasing volocities to make this part funnier, but that's up to you ;D
11. 08:45:525 (5) - This one is a bit overmapped but it's not a thing i would remove
12. 08:52:668 (5,6,7,8,9,10,11) - might try to use some sliders for the 1/6 stream because it's a bit hard to read but nothing crucial.
Topic Starter
Changed half of this mod.
About green lines: Those were used for the hitsounding, thus I have no idea whether they are used or not. Will check this.
9.: Normal 1/4s. They could also form a triple, but I felt like filling this up to the slider.
About green lines: Those were used for the hitsounding, thus I have no idea whether they are used or not. Will check this.
9.: Normal 1/4s. They could also form a triple, but I felt like filling this up to the slider.
I'm sorry, you will need to change the difficulty name to Marathon
gl
- BG Size is 1280x720, find one that is size 1366x768 or resize it
[Absolution]
- 00:13:621 (1,2) - This would be nicer as a blanket
- 00:15:526 (1) - The whistle on the slider body sounds bad, remove it
- 00:16:716 (3,2) - For a short time these overlap, try to avoid it
- 00:17:430 (1,2) - Blanket is off, use the approach circle to fix!
- 00:23:145 (1) - Same whistle suggestion
- 00:27:430 (2,3) - Have (2) blankets (3)'s slider end
- 00:32:668 (7,1) - (Nazi) Blanket is off
- 00:44:097 (1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1) - Try and not have too much new combo spam, its detrimental to the HP drain
- 01:08:859 (2) - This isn't stacked perfectly with 01:08:383 (1) - . Move it to 45:340
- 01:10:287 (5,1) - Avoid the overlap
- 01:18:383 (5,7) - Stack is also not perfect, move 01:19:811 (7) - to 286:175
- 02:15:764 (1,2,3,4,5) - The slowdown isn't really needed
- 03:49:573 (2,4) - (Nazi) Fix stack
- 03:50:287 (4,1) - (Nazi) Avoid the overlap (very small, almost unoticeable)
- 04:02:192 (1,1,1,1) - Just have these all one combo
- 04:45:049 (5,6,1) - Avoid the overlap
gl
Topic Starter
Thanks for your mod, will change things in some hours or tomorrow or sth.Lust wrote:
I'm sorry, you will need to change the difficulty name to Marathon
- BG Size is 1280x720, find one that is size 1366x768 or resize it
[Absolution]
- 00:13:621 (1,2) - This would be nicer as a blanket
- 00:15:526 (1) - The whistle on the slider body sounds bad, remove it
- 00:16:716 (3,2) - For a short time these overlap, try to avoid it
- 00:17:430 (1,2) - Blanket is off, use the approach circle to fix!
- 00:23:145 (1) - Same whistle suggestion
- 00:27:430 (2,3) - Have (2) blankets (3)'s slider end
- 00:32:668 (7,1) - (Nazi) Blanket is off
- 00:44:097 (1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1) - Try and not have too much new combo spam, its detrimental to the HP drain
- 01:08:859 (2) - This isn't stacked perfectly with 01:08:383 (1) - . Move it to 45:340
- 01:10:287 (5,1) - Avoid the overlap
- 01:18:383 (5,7) - Stack is also not perfect, move 01:19:811 (7) - to 286:175
- 02:15:764 (1,2,3,4,5) - The slowdown isn't really needed
- 03:49:573 (2,4) - (Nazi) Fix stack
- 03:50:287 (4,1) - (Nazi) Avoid the overlap (very small, almost unoticeable)
- 04:02:192 (1,1,1,1) - Just have these all one combo
- 04:45:049 (5,6,1) - Avoid the overlap
gl
Edit: Changed. About the slowdown, I am not sure whether to change it or not, look one mod before, it was done to compensate the slow slider afterwards.
I asked some BAT-Member, I don't have to change the diffname, I guess you said this because of the problem with the BSS, BATs do of course know this and can move this to pending without changing the name.
Unfortunately, as soon as I want to update the map after modding it, the same problem appears again and thus it is still in"WIP".
If I will really need to change it to marathon becuase of other reasons than the one just described, I will of course change it.
Did some IRC modding, mainly perfected patterns since I couldn't do a hitsounding mod considering -Sala isn't the one who did them.
woofwoof
16:56 Priti: First of all
16:56 Priti: increase all sections of 10~20 to atleast 30 (not counting stuff like silenced slider ends
16:56 Priti: )
16:57 Priti: inaudible sections are unrankable so.
16:57 Sala-: All of them?
16:58 Priti: except for the ones that are for like, slider ends which are meant to be silent
16:58 Priti: 00:23:621 (2) - the soft claps in this section don't really fit, just go for blank softs.
16:58 Sala-: Seems like I have to ask the one eho made the hitsounds to do that.
16:58 Priti: huh, who did it?
16:59 Priti: anywhos.
16:59 Sala-: phaZ.
16:59 Sala-: xD
16:59 Priti: 00:26:002 (7) - put the second point a bit higher? looks nicer to me
16:59 Sala-: At least not me.
16:59 Sala-: Is this for hitsounds only?
16:59 Priti: no
16:59 Sala-: Oh, you mean the whole slider, k.
16:59 Priti: I mean like, the second point of the slider
17:00 Priti: to change the angle
17:00 Priti: 00:36:478 (1) - control + H and then place it back where it was?
17:01 Sala-: Okay, done.
17:02 Priti: also, in general, the NCing is inconsistent, try to find a certain pattern for each sectino and use it
17:02 Priti: 02:31:716 (1) - tweak this a bit so it completely overlaps 02:30:525 (4) -
17:02 Priti: you can do it by moving it back a bit so you can see both at the same time
17:05 Priti: 02:53:621 (3) - make this a straight line and then rotate by 17 degrees from Selection Centre? makes it look nicer with 02:52:668 (1,2) -
17:09 Sala-: Sec. My dad was here.
17:09 Sala-: xD
17:09 Priti: okie
17:11 Sala-: Okay, done.
17:14 Priti: 04:37:430 (1,2) - delete 2, copy pasta 1 and control + g it
17:14 Priti: they are not indentical which makes the angle look awkward
17:15 Sala-: Okay.
17:15 Sala-: I thought they were.
17:15 Sala-: xD
17:15 Priti: 05:10:763 (5) - make it a straight slider and then rotate by 25 degrees
17:15 Priti: so it's the same angle as 3 and 4
17:16 Priti: 05:15:525 (3) - same thing but -3 degrees
17:16 Sala-: So, 5 should be parallel to 3 and 4?
17:17 Priti: 05:43:620 (2,4) - make 2 a copy pasta rotate of 4 (not the opposite since 4 looks better tbh)
17:17 Priti: uuhh no, it should be identical
17:17 Priti: but just be a better angle than what you currently have.
17:17 Priti: by straight slider I mean a perfect straight line that isn't in a diagnol
17:17 Sala-: So it is basically the same, but longer i guess.
17:18 Priti: not longer
17:18 Sala-: Oh-
17:18 Priti: just, perfected
17:18 Sala-: Should it overlap the beginnings of 3 and 4?
17:18 Sala-: Like that?
17:19 Sala-: Oh, got it now..
17:19 Sala-: xD
17:19 Priti: 06:08:382 (1,2,3) - again, these aren't copy pasted so the angles look horrible
17:23 Sala-: Copied 1 twice and copied these 3 for the following 3 sliders.
17:24 Priti: 06:40:287 (1,2) - again
17:25 Priti: 07:06:239 (8,9,10,11) - make this a perfect straight stream?
17:25 Priti: I mean like, perfect line, it can be in a diagnol
17:27 Sala-: I thought this is a fine transition to the next 2 circles.
17:27 Priti: nah
17:27 Priti: it's better when it's straight
17:28 Sala-: Alright.
17:28 Priti: 08:49:811 (1,1,1,1) - make them all straight sliders at first and then rotate them all by around 15 degrees
17:28 Priti: these are so uneven, it's awkward.
17:29 Priti: also, check AI mod (control + shift + a), there are some unsnapped notes
17:30 Priti: I am pretty much done, tell Phaz to poke me for a hitsounding mod
17:30 Sala-: Oh, okay.
17:30 Priti: saving the chatlog now
16:56 Priti: increase all sections of 10~20 to atleast 30 (not counting stuff like silenced slider ends
16:56 Priti: )
16:57 Priti: inaudible sections are unrankable so.
16:57 Sala-: All of them?
16:58 Priti: except for the ones that are for like, slider ends which are meant to be silent
16:58 Priti: 00:23:621 (2) - the soft claps in this section don't really fit, just go for blank softs.
16:58 Sala-: Seems like I have to ask the one eho made the hitsounds to do that.
16:58 Priti: huh, who did it?
16:59 Priti: anywhos.
16:59 Sala-: phaZ.
16:59 Sala-: xD
16:59 Priti: 00:26:002 (7) - put the second point a bit higher? looks nicer to me
16:59 Sala-: At least not me.
16:59 Sala-: Is this for hitsounds only?
16:59 Priti: no
16:59 Sala-: Oh, you mean the whole slider, k.
16:59 Priti: I mean like, the second point of the slider
17:00 Priti: to change the angle
17:00 Priti: 00:36:478 (1) - control + H and then place it back where it was?
17:01 Sala-: Okay, done.
17:02 Priti: also, in general, the NCing is inconsistent, try to find a certain pattern for each sectino and use it
17:02 Priti: 02:31:716 (1) - tweak this a bit so it completely overlaps 02:30:525 (4) -
17:02 Priti: you can do it by moving it back a bit so you can see both at the same time
17:05 Priti: 02:53:621 (3) - make this a straight line and then rotate by 17 degrees from Selection Centre? makes it look nicer with 02:52:668 (1,2) -
17:09 Sala-: Sec. My dad was here.
17:09 Sala-: xD
17:09 Priti: okie
17:11 Sala-: Okay, done.
17:14 Priti: 04:37:430 (1,2) - delete 2, copy pasta 1 and control + g it
17:14 Priti: they are not indentical which makes the angle look awkward
17:15 Sala-: Okay.
17:15 Sala-: I thought they were.
17:15 Sala-: xD
17:15 Priti: 05:10:763 (5) - make it a straight slider and then rotate by 25 degrees
17:15 Priti: so it's the same angle as 3 and 4
17:16 Priti: 05:15:525 (3) - same thing but -3 degrees
17:16 Sala-: So, 5 should be parallel to 3 and 4?
17:17 Priti: 05:43:620 (2,4) - make 2 a copy pasta rotate of 4 (not the opposite since 4 looks better tbh)
17:17 Priti: uuhh no, it should be identical
17:17 Priti: but just be a better angle than what you currently have.
17:17 Priti: by straight slider I mean a perfect straight line that isn't in a diagnol
17:17 Sala-: So it is basically the same, but longer i guess.
17:18 Priti: not longer
17:18 Sala-: Oh-
17:18 Priti: just, perfected
17:18 Sala-: Should it overlap the beginnings of 3 and 4?
17:18 Sala-: Like that?
17:19 Sala-: Oh, got it now..
17:19 Sala-: xD
17:19 Priti: 06:08:382 (1,2,3) - again, these aren't copy pasted so the angles look horrible
17:23 Sala-: Copied 1 twice and copied these 3 for the following 3 sliders.
17:24 Priti: 06:40:287 (1,2) - again
17:25 Priti: 07:06:239 (8,9,10,11) - make this a perfect straight stream?
17:25 Priti: I mean like, perfect line, it can be in a diagnol
17:27 Sala-: I thought this is a fine transition to the next 2 circles.
17:27 Priti: nah
17:27 Priti: it's better when it's straight
17:28 Sala-: Alright.
17:28 Priti: 08:49:811 (1,1,1,1) - make them all straight sliders at first and then rotate them all by around 15 degrees
17:28 Priti: these are so uneven, it's awkward.
17:29 Priti: also, check AI mod (control + shift + a), there are some unsnapped notes
17:30 Priti: I am pretty much done, tell Phaz to poke me for a hitsounding mod
17:30 Sala-: Oh, okay.
17:30 Priti: saving the chatlog now
Topic Starter
Thank you for your mod.
SPOILER
braucht noch polishing. frag einfach mal charles445 nach einer normalen mod/testplaymap hat guten flow, kein lames mainstream-mapping.
ich werd wenig übers polishen reden, ich seh ja ständig, dass du was verbesserst (im aussehen/flow/..). meine wird sich eher auf logik und rhythmus konzentrieren.
[]
fehelende Hitounds:
- 08:50:287 (1) - additions = normal, sliderhead (2faches selektieren des kopfes)
- 04:41:716 (3) - auf den sliderhead ein clap
- 05:10:763 (5) - ach da mal ein clap auf den tail
- 05:12:192 (7) - hier eine soft whistle auf dem head (sampleset=soft, whistle)
wird sich noch füllen wenn ich wieder kopfhörer habe
[]
Rhythmus:
- 00:04:097 (1,2) - ergibt rhythmisch keinen sinn. der rhythmus der melodie verläuft immer so wie bei 00:02:192 - 00:03:859. du halts es zwar konsistent aber ich würde es wenn dann schon eher so wie 00:11:716 (1) machen.
- 00:19:335 (1,2) - ^
- 00:24:097 (3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4) - ist ein ganz einfacher rhythmus. bei einem langsameren song ist es zwar nicht so dramatisch wenn man solche repeatslider drin hat, aber die passen rhythmisch doch gar nicht! da sollten/würde ich nur 1/2-slider immer auf dem weißen beat und circles benutzen http://puu.sh/6K6wA.png o.ä
- 00:58:383 (1,2,3,4) - die parrallel (180°) zur vorherigen combo (und nicht 90° gedreht) + größeres spacing würde vllt cooler aussehen?
- 01:01:240 (1,2,3,4,5) - melodie verlauf: töne beim 1., "2und", 3., 4. beat sind töne. also sollte bei "2und" (der auftakt quasi) nochmal ein circle sein (weil man das verlangen zu tappen an der stelle hat, weil es betont ist). stattdessen macht der circle bei 01:02:906 (5) - nicht so viel sinn, und fühlt sich eher wie overmapping an, weil da halt nichts ist. -> (4,5) zu nem slider machen. (2) zu zwei circle machen(oder (1) um 1/4 verlängern und halt nur einen circle setzten)
- 01:03:145 (1,2,3,4) - so muss der rhythmus sein ^-^ es ist eigentlich kein problem wenn man anstatt einen slider 2 circle setzt, umgedreht fühlt es sich aber häufig komischer an. oder noch schlimmer ist es, wenn die betonung auf dem tail des sliders liegt. dann sollte man mal dringend überlegen etwas zu ändern
- 01:06:716 (4,5) - ist zwar nicht so falsch, aber iich versteh nicht, warum der slider nicht bei der (4) startet? explain! (wehe du sagt, weil dann nichts auf dem großen weißen beat ist <.<)
- 01:08:383 (1,2) - es ist relativ unüblich, combos nach der paarung der objekte (nach dem aussehen) zu setzten. man setzt sie eigentlich nach abschnitten, standardmäßig, jeden neuen takt. also NC von (1) auf (2) verlegen.
wenn du die combo nicht einfach nur bei jeden neuen takt starten willst, dann würde ich von 01:03:859 bis 01:05:526 - und dann wieder bei 01:05:764 combos setzten.
- 01:11:478 (2,3,4,5,6) - ich bin zwar meisten gegen solche streams auf dem nichts aber wenn, dann würde ich die (5) entfernen. man setzt in der regel triplets so, dass der beat mehr betont wird ( in dem fall evtl bei 01:11:716).
- 01:33:621 (1,2) - ich würde hier eher den vocals folgen (vom rhythmus her) und den "lanweilgen beat" absetzten.
- 01:37:430 (1,2,3) - macht rhythmisch jetzt gar keinen sinn
- 02:03:621 (6,1) - hier liegen die vocals doch auf den red-ticks!
- 02:16:002 - wie schonmal erwähnt, weiß ich jetzt nicht warum die hier langsamer sind
- 02:31:716 (1) - sollte so sein, wie bei 04:18:382 (1,1) auch wenn hier beim zweiten mal in der melodie mehr hervorgehoben wurde. es sollte zumindest rhythmis identisch sein.
- 00:28:859 bis 00:30:526 - sollte definitiv größeres spacing haben, dorthin wird doch aufgebaut
- 00:30:526 bis 00:38:145 - ^ sollte genau so sein
- 01:43:145 (1,2) - rhythmisch strange. die vocals sind bei 01:43:383 dort könnte dann dann ein slider+circle oder einrepeat-slider langer slider (find ich am besten) hin
- 01:48:859 (4,5,6,7,8,9,1) - meine rhythmus idee: http://puu.sh/6KKEp.png ((3) und (4) könnten in der zeitlichen reihenfolge vertauscht werden und der letzte slider könnte auch ein repeat-slider sein)) oder: http://puu.sh/6KKMT.png (gefällt mir persönlich mehr)
- 01:58:383 (1,2,3) - macht wegen den vocals mehr sinn, wenn man ein repeat-slider bei (1) und einen langen slider bei (3) macht
- 03:20:287 (1,2,3,1) - stragner rhythmus
- 03:49:811 (3,4,1) - das gleiche "problem" wie bei 02:03:145 (5,6,1)
- 04:12:668 (6,7) - sollte eher http://puu.sh/6KKZs.png, http://puu.sh/6KL0T.png oder http://puu.sh/6KL2O.png bzw. http://puu.sh/6KL4P.png (hier beim letzten könnten es natürlich auch 1/4-slider anstatt der doublets sein)
- 04:26:954 (1) - wo ist da dieser rhythmus vom slider
- 05:36:478 (1) - wieso ist heir NC? 05:44:097 (4) hast du auch keine NC. wenn dann auch bei 05:36:954 (4). du könntest aber 05:36:001 (2) vllt eine NC setzen und die die hier halt wegnehmen
- 05:51:240 (6) - hier fängt das thema wieder an -> NC muss hier hin
- (05:51:954 (1,1) - NCs machen nicht so viel sinn und sind eher nach dem optischen gesetzt)
- 06:06:478 (2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4) - warum sind das 1/8-streams? das ist erstens rhythmisch falsch und 2. schwer zu lesen weil vorher schonmal mit genau diesem spacing 1/6-streams waren
- 06:10:882 (1,2,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - die stelle im song ist zwar ein bisschen merkwürdig, aber du hast das vollkommen overmapped, zumindest vomspacing her. auf jeden fall normaleres distance spacing
- 06:16:478 (1,1) - NCs weg?
- 06:36:954 (3) - NC, wenn du 05:36:001 (2) auch NC gesetzt hast. 06:44:573 (1) - hier hast du es ja so gemacht
- 06:45:049 (1) - NC weg
06:45:049 (1,2,3,4) - sieht ja ganz nice aus, aber ich bin mir nicht ganz so sicher ob es so bleiben kann. das hat so mehr den anschein als wäre der zeitliche abstand ziwschen (1,2) größer (nämlich 1/4) als bei (2,3,4) (sieht dann aus wie 1/8)
- 07:57:906 (6,7,8,1) - ^
- 06:52:906 (1) - NC weg
- 08:23:144 (5) - aucheine NC nach dem selben prinzip wie bei 06:44:573 (1)
- 08:24:097 (1,1) - NC weg
- 08:31:894 (1,1) - ^. auch merkwürdig, dass hier eine andere sv ist als bei 08:24:097 (1,1) obwohl das genau das gleiche ist
- 08:33:144 (3) - NC
- 08:52:906 (7,8,9,10,11) - sollte vllt das gleiche sein wie bei 07:06:239 (8,9,10,11) (also entweder beides 1/6 oder beides 1/8-streams)
- 08:53:739 (1) - weg damit
[]
Kiai:
der Kiai-usage im zweiten teil ist etwas verwirrend
- 08:38:382 (1) - die kiai ist bei dem tiefen beat, der direkt vor dem 1/4-thema ist
- 07:53:144 - die kiai ist nach dem tiefen beat, und auf dem 1/3-thema
-> beides unterschiedlich gesetzt, hat keine struktur
meine idee:
- 05:50:763 - kiai on, 05:58:382 - kiai off
- 06:21:240 - kiai on, 06:28:859 - kiai off
- 06:51:716 - kiai on, 06:59:335 - kiai off
- 07:52:668 - kiai on, 08:00:287 - kiai off
- 08:04:097 - on, 08:07:906 - off
- 08:08:382 - on, 08:15:525 - off
- 08:26:954 - on, 08:26:954 - off
- 08:34:573 - on, 08:36:477 - off (!)
- 08:38:858 - on, 08:46:001 - off
[]
Combo-colors:
combofarben sind blöd, würd color2 etwas rötlicher oder dunkler machen (das sieht so lachsfarben aus)
combo2 = 233,105,12
combo3 = 70,135,240
combo4+5 = 145,135,190 (nur leicht verändert)
http://puu.sh/6KNX7.png
ich werd wenig übers polishen reden, ich seh ja ständig, dass du was verbesserst (im aussehen/flow/..). meine wird sich eher auf logik und rhythmus konzentrieren.
[]
fehelende Hitounds:
- 08:50:287 (1) - additions = normal, sliderhead (2faches selektieren des kopfes)
- 04:41:716 (3) - auf den sliderhead ein clap
- 05:10:763 (5) - ach da mal ein clap auf den tail
- 05:12:192 (7) - hier eine soft whistle auf dem head (sampleset=soft, whistle)
wird sich noch füllen wenn ich wieder kopfhörer habe
[]
Rhythmus:
- 00:04:097 (1,2) - ergibt rhythmisch keinen sinn. der rhythmus der melodie verläuft immer so wie bei 00:02:192 - 00:03:859. du halts es zwar konsistent aber ich würde es wenn dann schon eher so wie 00:11:716 (1) machen.
- 00:19:335 (1,2) - ^
- 00:24:097 (3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4) - ist ein ganz einfacher rhythmus. bei einem langsameren song ist es zwar nicht so dramatisch wenn man solche repeatslider drin hat, aber die passen rhythmisch doch gar nicht! da sollten/würde ich nur 1/2-slider immer auf dem weißen beat und circles benutzen http://puu.sh/6K6wA.png o.ä
- 00:58:383 (1,2,3,4) - die parrallel (180°) zur vorherigen combo (und nicht 90° gedreht) + größeres spacing würde vllt cooler aussehen?
- 01:01:240 (1,2,3,4,5) - melodie verlauf: töne beim 1., "2und", 3., 4. beat sind töne. also sollte bei "2und" (der auftakt quasi) nochmal ein circle sein (weil man das verlangen zu tappen an der stelle hat, weil es betont ist). stattdessen macht der circle bei 01:02:906 (5) - nicht so viel sinn, und fühlt sich eher wie overmapping an, weil da halt nichts ist. -> (4,5) zu nem slider machen. (2) zu zwei circle machen
- 01:03:145 (1,2,3,4) - so muss der rhythmus sein ^-^ es ist eigentlich kein problem wenn man anstatt einen slider 2 circle setzt, umgedreht fühlt es sich aber häufig komischer an. oder noch schlimmer ist es, wenn die betonung auf dem tail des sliders liegt. dann sollte man mal dringend überlegen etwas zu ändern
- 01:06:716 (4,5) - ist zwar nicht so falsch, aber iich versteh nicht, warum der slider nicht bei der (4) startet? explain! (wehe du sagt, weil dann nichts auf dem großen weißen beat ist <.<)
- 01:08:383 (1,2) - es ist relativ unüblich, combos nach der paarung der objekte (nach dem aussehen) zu setzten. man setzt sie eigentlich nach abschnitten, standardmäßig, jeden neuen takt. also NC von (1) auf (2) verlegen.
wenn du die combo nicht einfach nur bei jeden neuen takt starten willst, dann würde ich von 01:03:859 bis 01:05:526 - und dann wieder bei 01:05:764 combos setzten.
- 01:11:478 (2,3,4,5,6) - ich bin zwar meisten gegen solche streams auf dem nichts aber wenn, dann würde ich die (5) entfernen. man setzt in der regel triplets so, dass der beat mehr betont wird ( in dem fall evtl bei 01:11:716).
- 01:33:621 (1,2) - ich würde hier eher den vocals folgen (vom rhythmus her) und den "lanweilgen beat" absetzten.
- 01:37:430 (1,2,3) - macht rhythmisch jetzt gar keinen sinn
- 02:03:621 (6,1) - hier liegen die vocals doch auf den red-ticks!
- 02:16:002 - wie schonmal erwähnt, weiß ich jetzt nicht warum die hier langsamer sind
- 02:31:716 (1) - sollte so sein, wie bei 04:18:382 (1,1) auch wenn hier beim zweiten mal in der melodie mehr hervorgehoben wurde. es sollte zumindest rhythmis identisch sein.
- 00:28:859 bis 00:30:526 - sollte definitiv größeres spacing haben, dorthin wird doch aufgebaut
- 00:30:526 bis 00:38:145 - ^ sollte genau so sein
- 01:43:145 (1,2) - rhythmisch strange. die vocals sind bei 01:43:383 dort könnte dann dann ein slider+circle oder ein
- 01:48:859 (4,5,6,7,8,9,1) - meine rhythmus idee: http://puu.sh/6KKEp.png ((3) und (4) könnten in der zeitlichen reihenfolge vertauscht werden und der letzte slider könnte auch ein repeat-slider sein)) oder: http://puu.sh/6KKMT.png (gefällt mir persönlich mehr)
- 01:58:383 (1,2,3) - macht wegen den vocals mehr sinn, wenn man ein repeat-slider bei (1) und einen langen slider bei (3) macht
- 03:20:287 (1,2,3,1) - stragner rhythmus
- 03:49:811 (3,4,1) - das gleiche "problem" wie bei 02:03:145 (5,6,1)
- 04:12:668 (6,7) - sollte eher http://puu.sh/6KKZs.png, http://puu.sh/6KL0T.png oder http://puu.sh/6KL2O.png bzw. http://puu.sh/6KL4P.png (hier beim letzten könnten es natürlich auch 1/4-slider anstatt der doublets sein)
- 04:26:954 (1) - wo ist da dieser rhythmus vom slider
- 05:36:478 (1) - wieso ist heir NC? 05:44:097 (4) hast du auch keine NC. wenn dann auch bei 05:36:954 (4). du könntest aber 05:36:001 (2) vllt eine NC setzen und die die hier halt wegnehmen
- 05:51:240 (6) - hier fängt das thema wieder an -> NC muss hier hin
- (05:51:954 (1,1) - NCs machen nicht so viel sinn und sind eher nach dem optischen gesetzt)
- 06:06:478 (2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4) - warum sind das 1/8-streams? das ist erstens rhythmisch falsch und 2. schwer zu lesen weil vorher schonmal mit genau diesem spacing 1/6-streams waren
- 06:10:882 (1,2,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - die stelle im song ist zwar ein bisschen merkwürdig, aber du hast das vollkommen overmapped, zumindest vomspacing her. auf jeden fall normaleres distance spacing
- 06:16:478 (1,1) - NCs weg?
- 06:36:954 (3) - NC, wenn du 05:36:001 (2) auch NC gesetzt hast. 06:44:573 (1) - hier hast du es ja so gemacht
- 06:45:049 (1) - NC weg
06:45:049 (1,2,3,4) - sieht ja ganz nice aus, aber ich bin mir nicht ganz so sicher ob es so bleiben kann. das hat so mehr den anschein als wäre der zeitliche abstand ziwschen (1,2) größer (nämlich 1/4) als bei (2,3,4) (sieht dann aus wie 1/8)
- 07:57:906 (6,7,8,1) - ^
- 06:52:906 (1) - NC weg
- 08:23:144 (5) - aucheine NC nach dem selben prinzip wie bei 06:44:573 (1)
- 08:24:097 (1,1) - NC weg
- 08:31:894 (1,1) - ^. auch merkwürdig, dass hier eine andere sv ist als bei 08:24:097 (1,1) obwohl das genau das gleiche ist
- 08:33:144 (3) - NC
- 08:52:906 (7,8,9,10,11) - sollte vllt das gleiche sein wie bei 07:06:239 (8,9,10,11) (also entweder beides 1/6 oder beides 1/8-streams)
- 08:53:739 (1) - weg damit
[]
Kiai:
der Kiai-usage im zweiten teil ist etwas verwirrend
- 08:38:382 (1) - die kiai ist bei dem tiefen beat, der direkt vor dem 1/4-thema ist
- 07:53:144 - die kiai ist nach dem tiefen beat, und auf dem 1/3-thema
-> beides unterschiedlich gesetzt, hat keine struktur
meine idee:
- 05:50:763 - kiai on, 05:58:382 - kiai off
- 06:21:240 - kiai on, 06:28:859 - kiai off
- 06:51:716 - kiai on, 06:59:335 - kiai off
- 07:52:668 - kiai on, 08:00:287 - kiai off
- 08:04:097 - on, 08:07:906 - off
- 08:08:382 - on, 08:15:525 - off
- 08:26:954 - on, 08:26:954 - off
- 08:34:573 - on, 08:36:477 - off (!)
- 08:38:858 - on, 08:46:001 - off
[]
Combo-colors:
combofarben sind blöd, würd color2 etwas rötlicher oder dunkler machen (das sieht so lachsfarben aus)
http://puu.sh/6KNX7.png
kannst mich natürlich jederzeit in-game fragen, was ich meine
Topic Starter
phaZ wrote:
SPOILERbraucht noch polishing. frag einfach mal charles445 nach einer normalen mod/testplaymap hat guten flow, kein lames mainstream-mapping.
ich werd wenig übers polishen reden, ich seh ja ständig, dass du was verbesserst (im aussehen/flow/..). meine wird sich eher auf logik und rhythmus konzentrieren.
[]
fehelende Hitounds:
- 08:50:287 (1) - additions = normal, sliderhead (2faches selektieren des kopfes)
- 04:41:716 (3) - auf den sliderhead ein clap
- 05:10:763 (5) - ach da mal ein clap auf den tail
- 05:12:192 (7) - hier eine soft whistle auf dem head (sampleset=soft, whistle)
wird sich noch füllen wenn ich wieder kopfhörer habe
[]
Rhythmus:
- 00:04:097 (1,2) - ergibt rhythmisch keinen sinn. der rhythmus der melodie verläuft immer so wie bei 00:02:192 - 00:03:859. du halts es zwar konsistent aber ich würde es wenn dann schon eher so wie 00:11:716 (1) machen.
- 00:19:335 (1,2) - ^
- 00:24:097 (3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4) - ist ein ganz einfacher rhythmus. bei einem langsameren song ist es zwar nicht so dramatisch wenn man solche repeatslider drin hat, aber die passen rhythmisch doch gar nicht! da sollten/würde ich nur 1/2-slider immer auf dem weißen beat und circles benutzen http://puu.sh/6K6wA.png o.ä Nach Rhythmus gemappt, nicht nach Vocals. Hab das Vocalmapping gelassen, weil es sich komisch angefühlt hat.
- 00:58:383 (1,2,3,4) - die parrallel (180°) zur vorherigen combo (und nicht 90° gedreht) + größeres spacing würde vllt cooler aussehen?
- 01:01:240 (1,2,3,4,5) - melodie verlauf: töne beim 1., "2und", 3., 4. beat sind töne. also sollte bei "2und" (der auftakt quasi) nochmal ein circle sein (weil man das verlangen zu tappen an der stelle hat, weil es betont ist). stattdessen macht der circle bei 01:02:906 (5) - nicht so viel sinn, und fühlt sich eher wie overmapping an, weil da halt nichts ist. -> (4,5) zu nem slider machen. (2) zu zwei circle machen(oder (1) um 1/4 verlängern und halt nur einen circle setzten)Fühlt sich zwar geändert um einiges übermappter an, hab die Änderung aber übernommen.
- 01:03:145 (1,2,3,4) - so muss der rhythmus sein ^-^ es ist eigentlich kein problem wenn man anstatt einen slider 2 circle setzt, umgedreht fühlt es sich aber häufig komischer an. oder noch schlimmer ist es, wenn die betonung auf dem tail des sliders liegt. dann sollte man mal dringend überlegen etwas zu ändern
- 01:06:716 (4,5) - ist zwar nicht so falsch, aber iich versteh nicht, warum der slider nicht bei der (4) startet? explain! (wehe du sagt, weil dann nichts auf dem großen weißen beat ist <.<) Weil ich so durchgehend einen gleichen Rhythmus habe.
- 01:08:383 (1,2) - es ist relativ unüblich, combos nach der paarung der objekte (nach dem aussehen) zu setzten. man setzt sie eigentlich nach abschnitten, standardmäßig, jeden neuen takt. also NC von (1) auf (2) verlegen.
wenn du die combo nicht einfach nur bei jeden neuen takt starten willst, dann würde ich von 01:03:859 bis 01:05:526 - und dann wieder bei 01:05:764 combos setzten.
- 01:11:478 (2,3,4,5,6) - ich bin zwar meisten gegen solche streams auf dem nichts aber wenn, dann würde ich die (5) entfernen. man setzt in der regel triplets so, dass der beat mehr betont wird ( in dem fall evtl bei 01:11:716).
- 01:33:621 (1,2) - ich würde hier eher den vocals folgen (vom rhythmus her) und den "lanweilgen beat" absetzten.
- 01:37:430 (1,2,3) - macht rhythmisch jetzt gar keinen sinn
- 02:03:621 (6,1) - hier liegen die vocals doch auf den red-ticks!
- 02:16:002 - wie schonmal erwähnt, weiß ich jetzt nicht warum die hier langsamer sind
- 02:31:716 (1) - sollte so sein, wie bei 04:18:382 (1,1) auch wenn hier beim zweiten mal in der melodie mehr hervorgehoben wurde. es sollte zumindest rhythmis identisch sein.
- 00:28:859 bis 00:30:526 - sollte definitiv größeres spacing haben, dorthin wird doch aufgebaut
- 00:30:526 bis 00:38:145 - ^ sollte genau so sein
- 01:43:145 (1,2) - rhythmisch strange. die vocals sind bei 01:43:383 dort könnte dann dann ein slider+circle oder einrepeat-sliderlanger slider (find ich am besten) hin
- 01:48:859 (4,5,6,7,8,9,1) - meine rhythmus idee: http://puu.sh/6KKEp.png ((3) und (4) könnten in der zeitlichen reihenfolge vertauscht werden und der letzte slider könnte auch ein repeat-slider sein)) oder: http://puu.sh/6KKMT.png (gefällt mir persönlich mehr)
- 01:58:383 (1,2,3) - macht wegen den vocals mehr sinn, wenn man ein repeat-slider bei (1) und einen langen slider bei (3) macht
- 03:20:287 (1,2,3,1) - stragner rhythmus
- 03:49:811 (3,4,1) - das gleiche "problem" wie bei 02:03:145 (5,6,1)
- 04:12:668 (6,7) - sollte eher http://puu.sh/6KKZs.png, http://puu.sh/6KL0T.png oder http://puu.sh/6KL2O.png bzw. http://puu.sh/6KL4P.png (hier beim letzten könnten es natürlich auch 1/4-slider anstatt der doublets sein)
- 04:26:954 (1) - wo ist da dieser rhythmus vom slider
- 05:36:478 (1) - wieso ist heir NC? 05:44:097 (4) hast du auch keine NC. wenn dann auch bei 05:36:954 (4). du könntest aber 05:36:001 (2) vllt eine NC setzen und die die hier halt wegnehmen
- 05:51:240 (6) - hier fängt das thema wieder an -> NC muss hier hin
- (05:51:954 (1,1) - NCs machen nicht so viel sinn und sind eher nach dem optischen gesetzt)
- 06:06:478 (2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4) - warum sind das 1/8-streams? das ist erstens rhythmisch falsch und 2. schwer zu lesen weil vorher schonmal mit genau diesem spacing 1/6-streams waren
- 06:10:882 (1,2,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - die stelle im song ist zwar ein bisschen merkwürdig, aber du hast das vollkommen overmapped, zumindest vomspacing her. auf jeden fall normaleres distance spacing
- 06:16:478 (1,1) - NCs weg?
- 06:36:954 (3) - NC, wenn du 05:36:001 (2) auch NC gesetzt hast. 06:44:573 (1) - hier hast du es ja so gemacht
- 06:45:049 (1) - NC weg
06:45:049 (1,2,3,4) - sieht ja ganz nice aus, aber ich bin mir nicht ganz so sicher ob es so bleiben kann. das hat so mehr den anschein als wäre der zeitliche abstand ziwschen (1,2) größer (nämlich 1/4) als bei (2,3,4) (sieht dann aus wie 1/8)
- 07:57:906 (6,7,8,1) - ^
- 06:52:906 (1) - NC weg
- 08:23:144 (5) - aucheine NC nach dem selben prinzip wie bei 06:44:573 (1)
- 08:24:097 (1,1) - NC weg
- 08:31:894 (1,1) - ^. auch merkwürdig, dass hier eine andere sv ist als bei 08:24:097 (1,1) obwohl das genau das gleiche ist
- 08:33:144 (3) - NC
- 08:52:906 (7,8,9,10,11) - sollte vllt das gleiche sein wie bei 07:06:239 (8,9,10,11) (also entweder beides 1/6 oder beides 1/8-streams)
- 08:53:739 (1) - weg damit
[]
Kiai:
der Kiai-usage im zweiten teil ist etwas verwirrend
- 08:38:382 (1) - die kiai ist bei dem tiefen beat, der direkt vor dem 1/4-thema ist
- 07:53:144 - die kiai ist nach dem tiefen beat, und auf dem 1/3-thema
-> beides unterschiedlich gesetzt, hat keine struktur
meine idee:
- 05:50:763 - kiai on, 05:58:382 - kiai off
- 06:21:240 - kiai on, 06:28:859 - kiai off
- 06:51:716 - kiai on, 06:59:335 - kiai off
- 07:52:668 - kiai on, 08:00:287 - kiai off
- 08:04:097 - on, 08:07:906 - off
- 08:08:382 - on, 08:15:525 - off
- 08:26:954 - on, 08:26:954 - off
- 08:34:573 - on, 08:36:477 - off (!)
- 08:38:858 - on, 08:46:001 - off
[]
Combo-colors:
combofarben sind blöd, würd color2 etwas rötlicher oder dunkler machen (das sieht so lachsfarben aus)
http://puu.sh/6KNX7.png
kannst mich natürlich jederzeit in-game fragen, was ich meine
Thanks.
What I did: Change Colours, inserted hitsounds and changed most of the other things.
Very nice map, good music and easy to play, perfect for relax
Hello.
General
- Regarding the diff name, as Lust brought it up, considering it's only one diff on the mapset, it should be okay to leave it as it is. Also the matter isn't because of BSS, but because there's a new rule, that does not allow custom diff names anymore. Do check it *here* for more information. And about the BSS, that is not supposed to happen when you just simply change the name of the diff. You should probably get someone to check it if that happens again.
- A lot of SV changes here. Keep in mind using only three is the recommended. It's not an unrankable issue, as long as it makes sense with the type/part of the song and difficulty you are doing. You might want to get more feedback on this though.
Absolution
- There are unsnapped inheriting sections at 00:30:758 and 00:38:378. Snap them to 00:30:764 and 00:38:383, respectively.
- 00:18:383 (3,4,1) - Spacing here looks a bit unpolished. I think you can keep up with the same spacing at least here. Basically you'll just need to move the circle to fix this up, keeping them at 1,6x should be nice (Example: x:178 y:228). Also, I think the flow can be improved here by moving the same circle to the right, so it gives some variation on the section:
- 01:08:859 (1) - A bit nazi but, have you considered making this unstacked? I mean, I haven't seen much of stuff like this on the diff, so you should probably do the same here (like in 01:13:145 (4) - for reference):
- 01:14:573 (1) - You can move this down a bit, so the overlap with 01:14:097 (6) - is improved. Just check that the slider at 01:14:097 (6) - ends in the middle of the next slider; overlaps looks much better like that:
- 01:15:764 (3) - Pretty much the same thing I said on 00:18:383 (3,4,1) -, I think this section can have a bit more of variation to improve flow. Moving either a bit up or down can give that feeling, but I'd suggest moving it down a bit (x:168 y:148), as it gives a better direction to the next slider:
- 01:16:478 (1) - Hmm, you should consider moving just a bit up. The flow is good here, but considering the shape of the slider it looks like it should be placed above the previous slider, not aligned to it, so basically you can improve the visuals:
- 01:17:430 (3) - You can give a bigger spacing between this and 01:16:954 (2) -, so it doesn't look like an unnecessary overlap, even if it's not actually overlapping.
- 01:25:049 (3) - The placement of it is a bit random to me. I mean, you could've placed it at where 01:24:097 (1) - ends or begins, so it gives a more solid gameplay. Give it a try, place the slider at x:297 y:153 (deactive grid snap for this), and see if you agree with me:
- 01:33:383 (8) - You can give this a bit more of spacing. I felt like this was supposed to be in a diamond shape (considering 01:32:668 (5,6,7,8) -), but it's a bit unpolished:
- 01:35:526 (1,2,3,4) - I'm very nazi when it comes to blankets, so I could't let this pass. You can work a bit more on the shape of them, to exactly improve the blankets. Also you might want to move 01:35:526 (1,2) - just a bit to the left (careful to not overlap with 01:34:573 (3) - ) so you can have a better space of the grid when making changes on the sliders:
- 01:45:049 (5,6) - Two things here, one is about pattern and the other about placement. The slider at (5) should be just a 1/2, it doesn't really match with the song on the blue tick. Also, reducing the length of the slider will allow you to move the slider at (6) to a better place, the current overlap it's going it's not good, visually speaking. Instead, try stacking it with the previous slider, it'll give a nice flow and will improve the visuals:
- 01:47:906 (3) - Hmm, it should flow better if this goes upwards instead of downwards. Check it out:
- 01:52:073 (4) - Very nazi, but you might want to move just a grid right (x:212 y:196), so the triplets are aligned better.
- 01:53:383 (2) - Also the thing about variations here. Try doing a ctrl+g here and see if it flows better for you.
- 02:03:621 (6,1) - Overlap can be improve here, just like what I said on 01:14:573 (1) -. Make the (1) a bit more wider and place it so that (6) ends in the middle of it:
- 02:15:764 - I also agree with Lust, this slowdown isn't necessary here as it does not match with the song. I think you should have it only at 04:57:430 - , as it makes more sens with the song.
- 02:28:383 (6) - Consider making it going upwards? It flows better to me, give it a check:
- 02:32:668 (1) - Change the colour of the NC? I mean, the previous combo is already purple, and to emphasize better the kiai you shouldn't make it the same color of the previous combo. If you don't know how to choose a specific combo colour between the combos, just go on the New Combo tab on the upper-right and click only on the small arrow, that way you can choose what colour to add on the new combo:
- 02:43:144 (1) - I feel you could've made this a 1/2, since the next slider is already on the blue tick. It's just me though, but I do like the combination of them.
- 02:44:097 (3) - Place at x:194 y:326 as it's the place where 02:43:144 (1) - begins, will make the placement less random.
- 02:48:859 (2) - Same thing as above, you could place this at where 02:47:906 (1) - ends though (x:168 y:64) so it also makes it less random, and also to fix the overlap. Plus, I'm sure it'll flow a lot better:
- 02:51:716 (4) - Make its shape a little less wider, so you can improve the blanket here:
- 03:25:049 (2) - You can make the "S" shape a lot better here by moving some nodes:
- 03:33:383 (1) - Think you can move this down a bit? Or change its shape so that it goes down? It's kinda off the grid, and since it's below the HP-bar, you might want to move it.
- 03:40:049 (2) - Hmm, the circle can go to x:156 y:216, so there will not be an overlap with 03:39:335 (1) -, plus, it'll match up with 03:41:240 (1) -:
- 03:51:478 (2,3,4) - Feels more consistent if they were all on the same y-axis, since they are aligned in a straight way:
- 04:06:954 (1,2) - This kinda ruins the flow. You could've made a jump here to keep the flow going. For reference, something like 04:18:382 (1,1) - would be nice.
- 04:17:192 (2) - Also nazi again, but just move this to x:176 y:205 so it's better "stacked" with 04:16:240 (6) - (deactivate grid snap for a bit to do this as well).
- 04:23:144 (4) - Looks a bit unpolished as well. Try using less nodes so the shape doesn't goes rusty:
- 04:43:621 (3,4) - Nice overlap! But I still think it can be improved. If you make both beginning and end more visible, it'll certainly be a bonus:
- 04:49:811 (1) - Can you also change the colour here? Just like I said on 02:32:668 (1) -. Even though there's no kiai, I still think this should be of another color.
- 04:57:906 (2) - Give a bigger spacing to improve blanket?
- 05:12:668 (1) - You should decrease the length of it to the white tick (05:13:144 - ), as the beat is quite strong there. Will make it better emphasized.
- 05:46:001 (1,2) - Overlap can be improved. Just move (2) a bit more to the left:
- 05:51:240 (1) - Make it more visible?
- 06:52:311 - Following the song, I think you should add a circle here, so it doesn't sound empty.
- 06:55:763 - Same as above, I think you can add an object so it doesn't sound empty with the song. You can make it a stack with 06:55:525 (7) -.
- 07:52:668 (2) - NC because kiai.
- 08:13:025 (3,5) - Think you can also make these more visible?
- 08:31:418 (1) - Looks like the end of it is unsnapped. Got this on AiBat: http://puu.sh/6XpFk.png
- 08:33:501 (2,4,6) - Same as above.
