forum

scop - Keppekishou

posted
Total Posts
50
Topic Starter
tutuhaha
This beatmap was submitted using in-game submission on 星期一, 15 四月, 2013 at AM 7:27:30

Artist: scop
Title: Keppekishou
Tags: Megpoid GUMI Vocaloid
BPM: 190
Filesize: 22445kb
Play Time: 03:39
Difficulties Available:
  1. Dance (4.9 stars, 751 notes)
  2. Easy (2.06 stars, 196 notes)
  3. Hard (4.89 stars, 473 notes)
  4. Insane (5 stars, 614 notes)
  5. Normal (3.98 stars, 262 notes)
Download: scop - Keppekishou
Download: scop - Keppekishou (no video)
Information: Scores/Beatmap Listing
---------------
:D
I love this song
finish~
---------------------
Dance:100%
Hard+:100%
Hard:100%
Normal:100%
Easy:100%
mintong89
wa
No_Gu
http://puu.sh/1DJcv
video provide
mintong89
Ruslya_old
good :3
Cloudchaser
From my modding queue~ :3
only 2 diffs.. im a little tired
i'd like a m4m
Hard
00:34:512 (1) - remove new combo
00:51:723 - add note?
01:36:723 (4,1) - increase distance ><
01:56:933 (2) - x:452 y:184

Normal
00:04:039 (1) - decrease distance
00:18:091 - add circle
00:21:249 - ^ x:160 y:136
00:21:565 (4) - add circle

nothing else i can say >w<
GL!
Cloudchaser
EDIT:
D: double post, srry
787B
Hi again ♬
Sorry for the waiting.

General
Seems good.

Easy
01:20:933 (3) - NC to emphasize?
01:38:618 (4) - NC?
02:06:408 (1) - Could've been made symmetric.
02:21:565 (3) - Same as 01:20:933 (3)
03:39:565 (4) - NC?

Normal
00:15:249 - Why no note/slider here?
02:27:881 (2) - Move to x:132 y:196 to match with previous slider curvature.

Hard
Nothing much I can add here.
00:12:328 (1) - Extend to 00:14:618 - ?

Dance
Couldn't find anything.

Hard+
Same here.

Good job again.
Sun Rainbow
你好我是来MOD的~其实来蹭KD啥的我会说吗
[Easy]
00:26:618 (2,3,1) - 可能受到hello how are you的影响吧,我不是很赞成高BPM的图弄这种紧密的节奏。
00:30:407 (1,2,1) - ^
00:34:197 (3,4) - ^
00:43:039 (1,2,1) - ^
00:46:828 (3,1) - ^
其他地方不举例=A=
01:39:881 (5) - WHISTLE?
01:59:776 (2) - D了这个然后中间白线放一个NOTE
02:09:881 (4) - 中间的白点、 、有CLAP声音
02:21:565 (3) - 不提高声音吗
03:05:144 (2,3) - 加 finish
03:07:039 (1,2,3) - soft
每一段的结尾的FINISH太小声了,改一下吧。

[Normal]
还是同easy结尾那句话。

[Hard]
其实有些地方可以放NORMAL WHISTLE的
02:12:565 (1,2,3) - 类似这里。、
03:39:249 (1,2) - 这里也是。

其他不能pass的diff就不MOD了sorry=A=
祝早日rank~
[CSGA]Ar3sgice
mod for play, 233


Dance

  1. 00:21:565 (1) - 3/4 连续两个这样有点不好o.o
  2. 00:23:618 (6) - 这里用个1/4的滑条o.o
  3. 00:35:460 (8) - http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/565465
  4. 01:47:776 (3) - 把3放右下角.. http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/565474 打着舒服点感觉
  5. 02:05:776 (3) - 干嘛不放这里o.o http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/565475
  6. 02:20:776 - addnote
  7. 03:23:539 - 这中间加个note 或者这里改成3/4 o.o
  8. 03:25:670 (5) - http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/565477
  9. 03:37:986 (1,2,1,2) - put streams here!!
Hard+

  1. 还叫啥hard+直接insane就行了难道你对自己的鬼畜没信心!
  2. 01:38:539 (6,7) - http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/565482
  3. 02:28:197 (3,4) - http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/565485
  4. 03:39:565 (3) - http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/565486 ...这里用直的比较符合整体的style吧
Hard

  1. 00:29:618 (2) - 对称
  2. 00:35:618 - 不spin?
  3. 这个没什么好mod的/.\
Normal

  1. 00:32:933 (1) - move to 68:248
  2. 02:26:618 (1) - http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/565500 48:152|60:228|136:264
  3. 02:32:618 (2) - up ~4grids
that's all

Good luck~
cmn_891127
~~

[Dance]
00:20:302 (3) -
204,84,20302,2,0,P|268:144|268:144|288:180|272:216,1,157.5,4|0,0:0|0:0,0:0:0
00:50:302 (6) - 这个不是1/3呀,应该是o_ooo
00:52:828 (6) - ^
00:52:197 (4) - ^,也是红线结尾啊
00:55:355 (6,7,8) - ^
01:50:933 (5) - 这段同上

[Hard+]
1/3问题同上
02:10:749 (3) - remove,因为后面那串鼓声已经用slider代替了,这个1/4note就感觉多余了

[Hard]
这个是tick rate 2?
01:40:512 (5) - 这个前面再加一个note,正好slider的结尾又卡在一个字符上

[Normal]
[Easy]
木有啦~
BounceBabe
Hi from the Queue!

General

Right Timing:
1. Offset: 1.347ms BPM: 190,00
Move the timing points after and resnap!


Easy


02:08:934 (3) - NC

Normal

00:04:039 (1) - Remove NC
00:09:091 (1) - ^

Hard

01:20:933 (2) - I dont suggest putting this circle there, make the slider longer instead
01:32:144 (1) - Remove NC
01:34:670 (1) - ^
02:21:249 (1,2) - I dont suggest putting this circle there, make the slider longer instead
02:27:723 (3) - Move this circle a half beat back to 02:27:565 - flows better and goes to the rythm

Dance

Sorry I refuse this to mod, since there are parts which are totally unrankable unless its for approval

Hard +


General
Name it Insane, its more Insane than Hard +

00:04:039 (1) - Remove NC
00:04:670 (2) - NC remove nxt
01:16:828 (1) - Remove NC
01:19:355 (1) - ^
02:20:144 (1) - ^
02:46:197 (1) - ^
03:28:354 (1) - ^
03:34:512 (6) - NC
03:36:091 (1) - Remove NC

Good luck
Topic Starter
tutuhaha

BounceBabe wrote:

Hi from the Queue!

Dance

Sorry I refuse this to mod, since there are parts which are totally unrankable unless its for approval
[b]
well I dont think so ^_^
I find many test player come to test this diff, they think it is fun and someone can play with HR and HD
it is rankable
and Thank you for your mod
Autumn
Mod from 寒假冻死人星球 _(:3 」∠ )_

[Easy]
从00:15:244 到 00:25:034 背景声有点大..考虑下把音量调到80%

[Normal]
00:07:665 到 00:12:402 :能听见背景里的鼓音和你下的节拍错开了一个二分拍..考虑把00:07:823 (1) 往前提一点

[Hard]
00:26:613 (4) - 这里Voacl貌似是从00:26:455 开始的..
00:42:876 - 貌似可以Add
00:47:928 - ^
01:44:613 (4) -换成单点更符合Vocal一点
03:04:507 (1) - 向下弯漂亮一点:

[Insane]
00:48:086 (1,2) - 有点挡..
02:08:928 (1) - 同上
01:08:613 (2) - 对齐强迫症..
02:06:086 (5) - 这里的节奏..略鬼畜
其实可以把它换成一个单点,再接个三连:
03:28:823 (2) - 滑条尾稍微向下移一点..

[Dance]
01:50:928 (5) - 折返滑条结束后flow是朝下的..然后马上变成01:51:244 (1) 朝右,容易断尾..如果flow是平行的话会舒服一点,例如01:57:560 (1,2) - 这个衔接就好打得多..
想来想去直接换成2-3个单点 if you like:
01:53:455 (6) - ^
03:28:192 - Add?

差不多就这些了..
好歌~Good Luck!
Roddie
IRC modding for every difficulty and the map in general. Its going to include two parts of the chatlogs because I started yesterday but couldn't finish that day. So, I continued on the day later and finished.



Chatlog Part 1
10:11 Roddie: okay, let's get to modding in-game!
10:11 tutuhaha: :O!
10:11 Roddie: worry for the hold up
10:12 tutuhaha: really D:.......can you just type it in game, I need go to buy some eat and then take bathe............
10:13 Roddie: very well
10:13 tutuhaha: I will reply all things when I come back :D
10:13 tutuhaha: Thank you then
10:16 Roddie: on easy:
10:16 Roddie: 00:25:350 (1)-I think you forgot to add a finish on the beginning.
10:16 Roddie: 03:19:665 (1)-^ same thing
10:18 Roddie: on normal:
10:21 Roddie: 00:07:823 (1)-this is in my opinion but this rhythm you put in doesn't seem to fit well. what I can suggest is to delete that slider and create a new rhythm pattern.
10:23 Roddie: you can add a slider on 00:07:507 and end it on 00:07:823. then, add a slider on 00:08:139 and create a repeat for like. its something like this. http://puu.sh/1R6oo
10:28 Roddie: 01:41:139 (1)-Forgot to add a finish here?
10:31 Roddie: 03:14:613 (1)-^Same thing here

Chatlog Part 2
08:35 Roddie: hi
08:35 Roddie: shall we continue?
08:35 tutuhaha: :O!
08:35 tutuhaha: hi~
08:35 tutuhaha: sure
08:36 tutuhaha: Easy and normal finish and update
08:37 Roddie: fantastic
08:37 tutuhaha: wwwww
08:37 Roddie: now, lets take a look at hard then
08:38 tutuhaha: sure~
08:41 Roddie: sorry, had to do something
08:42 Roddie: now i'm ready
08:42 tutuhaha: is ok wwww
08:43 Roddie: 00:30:402 (2)-forgot to add a finish on the beginning here as well huh?
08:45 tutuhaha: fix~
08:59 Roddie: *pokes*
08:59 tutuhaha: :D
09:00 Roddie: 02:30:402- you should consider removing this new combo. the reason I ask is that it doesn't seem to fit. just remove it and let the combo extend, you know?
09:00 Roddie: 02:30:402(1)-
09:00 Roddie: oh, not this again....
09:00 tutuhaha: :O
09:00 Roddie: 02:30:402 (1)-
09:01 tutuhaha: get it
09:01 tutuhaha: fix~
09:05 Roddie: now to insane
09:06 tutuhaha: ok~
09:06 Roddie: 00:07:507 (1)-I can see potential of having a new combo there
09:06 Roddie: imo
09:07 Roddie: don't you agree?
09:07 tutuhaha: well this is ok, I think Nc begin to 00:07:823 (1)- is ok............
09:10 Roddie: very well
09:11 tutuhaha: www
09:20 Roddie: hm...
09:20 Roddie: mind if I ask a question?
09:20 tutuhaha: O.Osure
09:21 Roddie: 00:52:823 (4)- Do you think a 1/3 slider sounds right there?
09:21 Roddie: 1/3 repeat slider I mean
09:21 tutuhaha: yes i think is right :D
09:22 tutuhaha: I do 1/3 rhythm in dance diff, when people test it, they can know it is 1/3 :D
09:23 Roddie: okay, i believe ya
09:23 tutuhaha: wwww
09:31 Roddie: 03:14:534 (x)-You're missing a good opportunity of adding a note here.
09:32 tutuhaha: :O!
09:32 tutuhaha: yes
09:32 Roddie: doing that will combine with the other notes between it to be a noe triple you know?
09:32 tutuhaha: add~
09:32 Roddie: note*
09:32 Roddie: good
09:32 Roddie: :D
09:32 tutuhaha: wwww yes
09:32 tutuhaha: :D
09:33 Roddie: now to dance
09:33 tutuhaha: ok~
09:46 Roddie: 02:20:771 (x)- it doesn't hurt to add a note here
09:46 Roddie: you can make this be part of that jumping formation
09:46 tutuhaha: :O
09:47 Roddie: 02:21:560 (3)-honestly, a finish sounds better than a clap
09:48 Roddie: would be a good idea to switch 'em
09:48 tutuhaha: change~
09:49 Roddie: 02:46:823 (3)-forgot to add a finish here?
09:50 tutuhaha: yes :O
09:50 tutuhaha: wow why I can forgot this one
09:50 Roddie: its happens
09:50 Roddie: even for me
09:51 tutuhaha: Orz yes
09:51 Roddie: we thought we put stuff for sure but nope
09:51 Roddie: this game sometimes lol
09:52 tutuhaha: lo
09:52 tutuhaha: lol
09:56 Roddie: 03:07:034 (2, 4)-even for the hardest diff, placing objects on blue ticks while one part of the song sounds like there isn't much rhythm, really isn't needed
09:57 Roddie: those doesn't suit well honestly ):
09:57 tutuhaha: ok let me see
09:58 tutuhaha: 03:07:034 (2)- change for white line end and add note on 03:07:507 (X)-
09:58 tutuhaha: wwwww
09:58 Roddie: yes, that can work!
09:59 Roddie: 03:08:771 (3, 4, 5)-This is okay to have i suppose
09:59 Roddie: just wanted to tell you that
10:00 tutuhaha: :D this is ok~~~~XDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD
10:01 Roddie: 03:29:060 (1)-I think a new combo here really isn't need
10:01 tutuhaha: ok delete~
10:01 Roddie: just doesn't seem right. its just too soon. would be best to remove it and keep the combo going
10:01 Roddie: good
10:02 Roddie: almost done. just need to check the maps contents
10:02 tutuhaha: ok~
10:09 Roddie: you have at least one diff that has a slider tick rate of 2
10:09 Roddie: i strongly suggest you keep the slider ticks consistent for every diff
10:10 tutuhaha: yes already change it Orz
10:10 tutuhaha: all are 1 tick now
10:11 Roddie: very good
10:11 tutuhaha: wwwww
10:11 tutuhaha: update now
10:12 Roddie: one thing I got point out. I was meaning to save this until now
10:12 tutuhaha: wwwww ok
10:16 tutuhaha: I cant update D:............................
10:16 tutuhaha: reopen osu...........
10:16 Roddie: better now?
10:17 tutuhaha: well try it now D:....
10:17 tutuhaha: :O
10:17 tutuhaha: ok now
10:18 tutuhaha: update finish~
10:19 Roddie: okay here's what i'm gonna say
10:19 Roddie: 03:01:981 (1)-I do believe that other diffs don't have a finish there
10:19 Roddie: like dance for example
10:20 Roddie: would be best to have it
10:20 Roddie: check the other diffs to make sure
10:20 tutuhaha: Thank you so much :D
10:20 tutuhaha: let me see
10:21 tutuhaha: ok make sure all diff have that finish now
10:21 tutuhaha: updat now~
10:23 Roddie: you're all set now
10:23 Roddie: but
10:23 tutuhaha: :O?
10:23 Roddie: I'm not so sure about the slider speed changes in Dance
10:23 tutuhaha: slider speed?
10:24 Roddie: the beginning is okay
10:24 tutuhaha: this is ok when the first time I update and I find some XAT test it
10:24 Roddie: but i'm not sure about this
10:24 tutuhaha: like wcx :O
10:24 tutuhaha: or Lks
10:24 Roddie: 01:10:192 (x)-
10:24 Roddie: oh
10:24 tutuhaha: :O
10:24 Roddie: and what did they say?
10:24 Roddie: about that part?
10:24 tutuhaha: just litter bit hard but is ok :o
10:24 Roddie: hm...
10:24 Roddie: okay, i'll take their word for it
10:24 tutuhaha: but well I want to change this part now............
10:25 Roddie: if you want
10:25 tutuhaha: wait min.................
10:25 Roddie: okay
10:25 Roddie: :o
10:25 tutuhaha: yes I want.......wait.......
10:27 tutuhaha: fix
10:27 Roddie: okay
10:27 tutuhaha: use same 1.10
10:27 Roddie: not a problem then
10:27 tutuhaha: wwww
10:27 Roddie: and we're done

Good luck to ya, tutu. :)
Lally
Hi from Andrea's and Lally's Mod4Mod Queue ♥

must fix
suggestions
♥ normal things

[General]
  1. what about tick rate 2 ?
  2. why don't you try in all diff to put a spinner from 00:35:455 - to 00:36:718 - because the vocal continues.or make it like in the Insane diff
  3. 01:38:928 - to 01:39:560 - why don't you map this part i can hear vocal here :U is not nice to stop the rhythm random
  4. in some diff the breaks are unsnapped try to make they all similar
[Easy]
  1. what about CS -1 i think it would pass better to a easy diff
  2. 00:12:718 - i think is better to beginn this spinner here
  3. 01:39:244 - add a circle
  4. 02:01:034 - remove this line is useless
  5. 02:29:139 (1,2) - please don't stack subjeks in a easy try to find a other way to place they
[Normal]
  1. 00:02:455 - this line is useless just add the volume % to the offset
  2. 00:23:455 (2,3) - do a better blanket
  3. 00:35:455 - unsnapped break
  4. 01:00:402 - useless line
  5. 01:20:928 - unsnapped break
  6. 01:52:823 - add a circle
  7. 01:55:350 - add a circle
  8. 01:57:876 - add a circle
  9. 02:01:034 - useless green line
  10. 02:21:560 - unsnapped break
  11. 02:46:823 - unsnapped break
  12. 03:06:718 - add a circle here since the vocal don't stop
  13. 03:09:244 - useless green line
  14. 03:37:350 - useless last white point on slider
[Hard]
  1. 03:01:665 - why not something like ↓ i think it will flow better
    03:09:560 (1) - try something like ↓
[Dance]
  1. o3o nothing to say about
[Insane]
  1. 00:12:402 - start spinner here
  2. 00:35:455 - unsnapped break
  3. 01:20:928 - unsnapped break
  4. 01:41:297 (2,3) - u no blanket?
  5. 02:01:034 - useless green line
  6. 02:21:560 - unsnapped break
  7. 02:46:823 - unsnapped break
Topic Starter
tutuhaha

Lally wrote:

Hi from Andrea's and Lally's Mod4Mod Queue ♥

must fix
suggestions
♥ normal things

[General]
  1. what about tick rate 2 ? too noies for me Orz..sorry
  2. why don't you try in all diff to put a spinner from 00:35:455 - to 00:36:718 - because the vocal continues.or make it like in the Insane diff hmmm...I dont really like to use spinner in that part. From my point there need nothing O_O.......
  3. 01:38:928 - to 01:39:560 - why don't you map this part i can hear vocal here :U is not nice to stop the rhythm randomhmmm..From my point there need nothing will be more fun O_O, too.......
  4. in some diff the breaks are unsnapped try to make they all similar
Orz I dont know why this happen...try to fix all

[Easy]
  1. what about CS -1 i think it would pass better to a easy diff
    hmmm...I like play HR and DT in Easy diff, it will be more hard if I do CS-1 QAQ..........
  2. 00:12:718 - i think is better to beginn this spinner here sure
  3. 01:39:244 - add a circle this is the part which you said about so....nope sorry Q_Q....
  4. 02:01:034 - remove this line is useless sure
  5. 02:29:139 (1,2) - please don't stack subjeks in a easy try to find a other way to place they
sure~

[Normal]
  1. 00:02:455 - this line is useless just add the volume % to the offset FIX
  2. 00:23:455 (2,3) - do a better blanket sure
  3. 00:35:455 - unsnapped break FIX
  4. 01:00:402 - useless line FIX
  5. 01:20:928 - unsnapped break FIX
  6. 01:52:823 - add a circle FIX
  7. 01:55:350 - add a circle FIX
  8. 01:57:876 - add a circle FIX
  9. 02:01:034 - useless green line FIX
  10. 02:21:560 - unsnapped break FIX
  11. 02:46:823 - unsnapped break FIX
  12. 03:06:718 - add a circle here since the vocal don't stop FIX
  13. 03:09:244 - useless green line FIX
  14. 03:37:350 - useless last white point on slider FIX
[Hard]
  1. 03:01:665 - why not something like ↓ i think it will flow better FIX
    03:09:560 (1) - try something like ↓ FIX
[Dance]
  1. o3o nothing to say about
[Insane]
  1. 00:12:402 - start spinner here FIX
  2. 00:35:455 - unsnapped break FIX
  3. 01:20:928 - unsnapped break FIX
  4. 01:41:297 (2,3) - u no blanket?If I do that there will be more cluster =_=
  5. 02:01:034 - useless green line FIX
  6. 02:21:560 - unsnapped break FIX
  7. 02:46:823 - unsnapped break FIX
Thank you
Andrea
Pretty good map :3 Nothing wrong I can see.

Bubbled~
Lally
:3/ woohoo~
NatsumeRin
Popped for unsnapped slider's end in hard diff:
01:00:718 (1) -
02:01:350 (1) -

[General]
First offset, 2455
Second offset, 15244

[Easy]
00:50:613 (1,2) - parts like this coold really be done better.
00:59:297 (2) - start 1/2 later.
01:31:981 (2) - remove, this seems the only one 1/1 used in this pattern.
01:51:244 (1) - same problem in the copy&pasted part.
01:59:771 (2) - ^
02:36:718 (1,2,3,4,1,2) - if you noticed the sound change, why not do something in the placement too..? other diffs are the same.

[Normal]
00:52:507 (4) - For such notes, i think clap-normal is better than normal-clap
00:59:139 (2) - same with easy.
01:19:350 (2) - http://puu.sh/1Xg7t some kind of curve may fit better with the previous slider
01:59:771 (2) - sigh
02:19:981 (2) -

[Hard]
01:19:507 (2,3) - a slider may fit better here.
02:20:139 (2,3) -

这样的话自己剪下来搞short ver不就好了。。。。真是服气
Topic Starter
tutuhaha

NatsumeRin wrote:

Popped for unsnapped slider's end in hard diff:
01:00:718 (1) -
02:01:350 (1) -

[General]
First offset, 2455
Second offset, 15244

[Easy]
00:50:613 (1,2) - parts like this coold really be done better.
00:59:297 (2) - start 1/2 later.
01:31:981 (2) - remove, this seems the only one 1/1 used in this pattern.
01:51:244 (1) - same problem in the copy&pasted part.
01:59:771 (2) - ^
02:36:718 (1,2,3,4,1,2) - if you noticed the sound change, why not do something in the placement too..? other diffs are the same. now is ok I think, other diffs are the same

[Normal]
00:52:507 (4) - For such notes, i think clap-normal is better than normal-clap
00:59:139 (2) - same with easy.
01:19:350 (2) - http://puu.sh/1Xg7t some kind of curve may fit better with the previous slider
01:59:771 (2) - sigh
02:19:981 (2) -

[Hard]
01:19:507 (2,3) - a slider may fit better here.
02:20:139 (2,3) -

这样的话自己剪下来搞short ver不就好了。。。。真是服气
Then fix all
不是很失败么亲,太服气了好么
NatsumeRin
[Dance]
02:30:638 (2,3) - snapped to the wrong place.

高难可以,低难惨不忍睹
Topic Starter
tutuhaha

NatsumeRin wrote:

[Dance]
02:30:638 (2,3) - snapped to the wrong place.

高难可以,低难惨不忍睹
FIX
Thankyou
有求于人时不可以爆粗,所以我闭嘴,这是礼貌
NatsumeRin
Rebubbled.
No_Gu
Title:Keppeki Show

实在不想戳的话等BAT来了再改吧。。
Topic Starter
tutuhaha
youtube什么乱七八糟的英文网站都是这个check N多遍了
没打算改
gurodoll_old
~❤ delicious
Frostmourne
hi

General
fine

Easy
this setting is quite too hard , I suggest you lower OD by 1 , it will be much easier for the easiest diff
00:27:559 (3) - missing clap here
00:35:138 (4) - maybe clap head ?
02:45:559 (2) - this slider shouldn't start here as it doesn't follow anything.
I suggest you start this 1/2 beat later and end at 02:46:507 like this picture
03:19:665 (1) - I think the finish on the last point isn't needed (03:20:928) as you didn't add them in the rest of the map

Normal
02:20:927 (3) - unsnapped
02:45:559 (2) - same as the Easy diff
03:18:086 (2) - finish tail ? it would work imo

Hard
fine

Dance
02:20:454 (1,2,3,4) - personal feeling , this jump is really hard and uncomfortable to play. I would fix this
02:45:086 (3) - this should be NC to improve readability , it's similar to 02:19:033 (1,2,3,1,2) -
beware of combo colorhax for this too
03:39:086 (1) - on (03:39:244) finish as in the Easy diff

Insane
03:39:086 (1) - on (03:39:244) finish as in the Easy diff

Popped for unrankable issue
Topic Starter
tutuhaha

Frostmourne wrote:

hi

General
fine

Easy
this setting is quite too hard , I suggest you lower OD by 1 , it will be much easier for the easiest diff
00:27:559 (3) - missing clap here
00:35:138 (4) - maybe clap head ?
02:45:559 (2) - this slider shouldn't start here as it doesn't follow anything.
I suggest you start this 1/2 beat later and end at 02:46:507 like this picture
03:19:665 (1) - I think the finish on the last point isn't needed (03:20:928) as you didn't add them in the rest of the map

Normal
02:20:927 (3) - unsnapped
02:45:559 (2) - same as the Easy diff
03:18:086 (2) - finish tail ? it would work imo

Hard
fine

Dance
02:20:454 (1,2,3,4) - personal feeling , this jump is really hard and uncomfortable to play. I would fix this
02:45:086 (3) - this should be NC to improve readability , it's similar to 02:19:033 (1,2,3,1,2) -
beware of combo colorhax for this too
03:39:086 (1) - on (03:39:244) finish as in the Easy diff

Insane
03:39:086 (1) - on (03:39:244) finish as in the Easy diff

Popped for unrankable issue
all fix
Pokie
Don't forget moving Vocaloid to tags.
Topic Starter
tutuhaha

Pokie wrote:

Don't forget moving Vocaloid to tags.
Orz fix
Frostmourne
checked

rebubbled
Garven
[General]
Consider using darker combo colors. Right now they all really blend in with the video, and the white one is really bad against the background as well.
02:26:296 - A kiai fountain here would be pretty awesome.

[Easy]
00:07:823 (1,2) - I'm not really understanding why you chose this rhythm. It finally lines up with something easy to follow at the end of 2, but the rest of the offbeats are perplexing.
00:12:718 (1) - I found this to have a cooler effect if you just deleted the spinner. This way you can start a new beat at 00:15:244 - or even at 00:14:928 - instead of leaving that area empty.
00:59:296 (2,3) - This is already rather complex... maybe extend the end of 2 to where 3 is at to make it a little easier.
01:59:928 (2) - Same thing here

[Normal]
00:12:402 (1) - This might benefit like the Easy by just deleting the spinner and adding notes at 00:14:928 - and 00:15:244 -
Nice Normal though.

[Hard]
00:59:770 (5) - Just remove one repeat. There's not point in having the return when there's nothing in the song.
02:00:401 (5) - ^
03:03:875 (3,4) - This jump was kind of unexpected since you don't use jumps much at all in this map except at 02:43:033 -
03:08:612 (6) - Remove one repeat
03:39:243 (1,2) - This would have more impact as three circles with larger spacing rather than just the one larger spaced final circle.

[Insane]
00:58:112 - Add a beat here. Right now it makes 00:58:191 (2,3) - play awkwardly without that buffer rhythm
01:50:296 (2,3,4) - The 4 being misaligned from the 2 and 3 looks awful. Can you arrange these a bit better?
03:08:928 (5) - Just set as a circle

[Dance]
...you know, you had a nice smooth difficulty progression. All the maps had fairly similar themes going on. General flow was consistent. Then we get to this difficulty. I think this is going to be the same situation as a very hurtful pain was. I honestly don't like it. The flow is plain counter-intuitive when you try to fit in a lot of 1/4 rhythms, and you start mapping patterns instead of trying to fit the song better just so you have a harder difficulty. It doesn't really fit the music nor the set. As a bonus, the really light combo colors render this pretty much impossible to play if you have the BG or video displayed. Some of the map is good though, so I'll try and look through this more thoroughly later. I'll edit in the rest tomorrow, time permitting.

Edit:

Well, it seems a lot of the issues are during that intro part. A lot of the rest of the map is okay, once you fix the bad combo colors (I just set to default for readability).

00:03:402 (5,1,2) - Why such huge spacing? This is a very calm and slow part of the song. There's other parts during this intro as well.
00:09:718 (3,4,5,6,1) - Not really hearing any musical justification behind this spacing either.
00:19:980 (1,2,3) - An example of the really unfitting 1/4 spacing with pretty poor flow to boot.
00:56:296 (4,5) - Please snap these to 1/3. Suddenly following the drums after all the 1/3 rhythms is really disorienting.
01:00:086 (4) - Just make it a circle
01:52:191 (5) - Please snap this to 1/3. Suddenly following the drums after all the 1/3 rhythms is really disorienting (this one isn't that bad, but would be more consistent with the previous fix).
02:00:717 (4) - Just make it a circle
02:21:401 (1,2) - Just delete them. You overmap all over the place, but these ones just sound horrid.

I'll finish this off hopefully tomorrow.

Edit:

Tomorrow sure is far away, isn't it?

02:46:191 (1,2) - Please no. Use closer spacing. This reads and plays poorly.
03:08:928 (5) - Just make it a circle. As in not a slider.
03:30:401 (3) - After so much overmapping all over the map, this slider felt rather bland.
03:34:507 (1,2) - As said earlier, please no

I'll put in the recheck in a separate post.
Topic Starter
tutuhaha

Garven wrote:

[General]
Consider using darker combo colors. Right now they all really blend in with the video, and the white one is really bad against the background as well.try to make more darker on white one
02:26:296 - A kiai fountain here would be pretty awesome. dont plan to add kiai here =_=.......

[Easy]
00:07:823 (1,2) - I'm not really understanding why you chose this rhythm. It finally lines up with something easy to follow at the end of 2, but the rest of the offbeats are perplexing. FIX
00:12:718 (1) - I found this to have a cooler effect if you just deleted the spinner. This way you can start a new beat at 00:15:244 - or even at 00:14:928 - instead of leaving that area empty. FIX
00:59:296 (2,3) - This is already rather complex... maybe extend the end of 2 to where 3 is at to make it a little easier. FIX
01:59:928 (2) - Same thing here FIX

[Normal]
00:12:402 (1) - This might benefit like the Easy by just deleting the spinner and adding notes at 00:14:928 - and 00:15:244 - FIX
Nice Normal though. Thanks~

[Hard]
00:59:770 (5) - Just remove one repeat. There's not point in having the return when there's nothing in the song. fix
02:00:401 (5) - ^ fix
03:03:875 (3,4) - This jump was kind of unexpected since you don't use jumps much at all in this map except at 02:43:033 - fix
03:08:612 (6) - Remove one repeat fix
03:39:243 (1,2) - This would have more impact as three circles with larger spacing rather than just the one larger spaced final circle. fix

[Insane]
00:58:112 - Add a beat here. Right now it makes 00:58:191 (2,3) - play awkwardly without that buffer rhythm fix
01:50:296 (2,3,4) - The 4 being misaligned from the 2 and 3 looks awful. Can you arrange these a bit better? fix
03:08:928 (5) - Just set as a circle fix

[Dance]
...you know, you had a nice smooth difficulty progression. All the maps had fairly similar themes going on. General flow was consistent. Then we get to this difficulty. I think this is going to be the same situation as a very hurtful pain was. I honestly don't like it. The flow is plain counter-intuitive when you try to fit in a lot of 1/4 rhythms, and you start mapping patterns instead of trying to fit the song better just so you have a harder difficulty. It doesn't really fit the music nor the set. As a bonus, the really light combo colors render this pretty much impossible to play if you have the BG or video displayed. Some of the map is good though, so I'll try and look through this more thoroughly later. I'll edit in the rest tomorrow, time permitting.
Just need said, now I have 39 ranked maps, At least 30 maps I use the same way and same rhythm handle to mapping it. That is the way I choose on my map style,but now add more 1/4 is overmap╮(╯_╰)╭......
I will delete some 1/4 but not all of them, some part I like to use more 1/4 note to make smooth on playing, listening and reading.
Oh and about light color, ppy give us more choose about background,why we dont use it >vO
sorry has some complain =w=||||...

Edit:

Well, it seems a lot of the issues are during that intro part. A lot of the rest of the map is okay, once you fix the bad combo colors (I just set to default for readability).

00:03:402 (5,1,2) - Why such huge spacing? This is a very calm and slow part of the song. There's other parts during this intro as well. fix
00:09:718 (3,4,5,6,1) - Not really hearing any musical justification behind this spacing either.I hear it,,,,,
00:19:980 (1,2,3) - An example of the really unfitting 1/4 spacing with pretty poor flow to boot.fix
00:56:296 (4,5) - Please snap these to 1/3. Suddenly following the drums after all the 1/3 rhythms is really disorienting.fix
01:00:086 (4) - Just make it a circlethis is which the best can make Orz
01:52:191 (5) - Please snap this to 1/3. Suddenly following the drums after all the 1/3 rhythms is really disorienting (this one isn't that bad, but would be more consistent with the previous fix).
02:00:717 (4) - Just make it a circlethis is which the best can make Orz
02:21:401 (1,2) - Just delete them. You overmap all over the place, but these ones just sound horrid.nope, this part I try to underline it, if I delete it I will feel petty wried....

I'll finish this off hopefully tomorrow.
Garven
[Hard]
03:39:243 (1,2) - I still think this would be better as 3 circles with larger spacing than a slider into a circle, but oh well.

[Dance]
00:24:401 (5,6) - You forgot these ones
01:00:086 (4) - I meant this to be a hitcircle, not a slider. q:
02:00:717 (4) - ^
02:21:401 (1,2,3) - I'd almost suggestion you delete all three and extend the break, but the flow kind of dies if you do that. I still find having only one circle instead of the 3 fits better rhythmically and musically. You're mapping to nothing there.

And this is pasted from the previous post.

02:46:191 (1,2) - Please no. Use closer spacing. This reads and plays poorly.
03:08:928 (5) - Just make it a circle. As in not a slider.
03:30:401 (3) - After so much overmapping all over the map, this slider felt rather bland.
03:34:507 (1,2) - As said earlier, please no

As for your comments before, having all those 1/4 has always been overmap. It's just that we're bothering to look down upon it more and more, as it takes away from the music when applied poorly. You're better at it than most that I come across, but there are still areas where it could be improved.

I guess I'll apply the pop icon here so you get the priority.
Topic Starter
tutuhaha

Garven wrote:

[Hard]
03:39:243 (1,2) - I still think this would be better as 3 circles with larger spacing than a slider into a circle, but oh well. well...

[Dance]
00:24:401 (5,6) - You forgot these ones fix
01:00:086 (4) - I meant this to be a hitcircle, not a slider. q: no plan to change those, I think play is petty good
02:00:717 (4) - ^ ^
02:21:401 (1,2,3) - I'd almost suggestion you delete all three and extend the break, but the flow kind of dies if you do that. I still find having only one circle instead of the 3 fits better rhythmically and musically. You're mapping to nothing there. fix

And this is pasted from the previous post.

02:46:191 (1,2) - Please no. Use closer spacing. This reads and plays poorly. fix
03:08:928 (5) - Just make it a circle. As in not a slider. ^
03:30:401 (3) - After so much overmapping all over the map, this slider felt rather bland. I use the same way to design the same rhythm in this diff, so no change
03:34:507 (1,2) - As said earlier, please no fix

As for your comments before, having all those 1/4 has always been overmap. It's just that we're bothering to look down upon it more and more, as it takes away from the music when applied poorly. You're better at it than most that I come across, but there are still areas where it could be improved.
I still not agree more 1/4 rhythm means overmap, because I want to make my map more rich and interesting so I use more 1/4 rhythm try to make a new rhythm that can use more way to design in the map. I use normal rhythm on Insane diff, and Dance diff can not just has same rhythm with Insane because Dance diff is ex. diff. In vocal song many rhythm you cannot clear to hear that but it still there, vocal song has more way to mapping because it not just music, people change they voice or breathe or stress some word, there will has more rhythm.
like this map, soft map but mapper still add many 1/4 to stress it.
https://osu.ppy.sh/b/211306

I guess I'll apply the pop icon here so you get the priority.
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply