1. Easy (1.02 stars, 147 notes)
2. Hard (4.85 stars, 456 notes)
3. Normal (2.77 stars, 221 notes)

bbj0920 wrote:

근데 Insane은 어디갔나요..?
저번에 F9에서 봤는데 Insane 2도 만들고 계시던데..

yeahyeahyeahhh wrote:

Insane:
02:51:347 (5) - Purposely not stacked?

ykcarrot wrote:

yeahyeahyeahhh wrote:

Insane:
02:51:347 (5) - Purposely not stacked?

ya, it's intended due to stack leniency

[Dango] wrote:

아이유! 아이유! 아이아이아이유!
L!O!V!E! lovrlovr IU!

Tanmak wrote:

어느새 만드셨네...

MoonFragrance wrote:

빨리 랭크 시켜주세요. 현기증난단 말이에요.

Siesta- wrote:

이동 기념 별투척 ☆

TTTTTTTTTTTT wrote:

[*]Easy

I think that it would be better to switch tick rate to 1.

Prime issue:

Tick sounds non-stop because it has a exceedingly high frequency. // I don't see any point to change tick rate. Just because Easy diff doesn't mean the song is changed.

Minor issue:

It is not friendly enough for rookie.

Other seems fine to me.

[*]Normal

Fine.

[*]Hard

00:47:832 (x) - There is lacks a note.It is an accent which can lead the song to chorus so we should have add a note...Shorten this slider and make it end at 00:47:832. // This was a thing that I had in my mind. Alright fixed everything below.

02:04:824 (x) - Shorten this slider and add finish at the end of the slider.The reason as shown previous.

02:57:324 (x) - Although this note doesn't have a sheer power like previous,but i think it would be better to shorten the slider to follow the tempo.

Other seems fine to me.

[*]Pretty good map, good diff spread

Good luck!

1. 02:24:394 (2) - add whistle on the reverse and remove from the end
2. 02:33:300 (2) - whistle?

1. 01:14:082 (1) - don't sure in this heart coz there's no clear direction but you don't care about it
2. 03:10:097 - whistle?

1. 00:21:347 (8) - prolong it to 00:21:816
2. 00:28:847 (10) - ^
3. 00:47:597 (4) - nc?
4. 00:57:441 (10) - add whistle on the beginning and remove from the end
5. 01:19:003 (1,2,3) - too small spacing between objects
6. 01:34:238 (3) - sounds..actually it's confusing, may be you will remove it and add eeeh circle or 1/2 slider with reverse?
7. 01:38:222 (12) - it's your choice but i said "prolong it"
8. 01:45:722 (8) - ^
9. 02:34:003 (1,2,3) - spacing
10. 03:06:816 - whistle

Vass_Bass wrote:

Hi~

Want more whistles in choruses D: // Added few in kiai part.

Easy

1. 02:24:394 (2) - add whistle on the reverse and remove from the end // No
2. 02:33:300 (2) - whistle? // ^

Normal

1. 01:14:082 (1) - don't sure in this heart coz there's no clear direction but you don't care about it // Its pass is just fine
2. 03:10:097 - whistle? // OK

Hard

1. 00:21:347 (8) - prolong it to 00:21:816 // No
2. 00:28:847 (10) - ^
3. 00:47:597 (4) - nc? // No
4. 00:57:441 (10) - add whistle on the beginning and remove from the end // Whistle is focused on echo. So nope.
5. 01:19:003 (1,2,3) - too small spacing between objects // On purpose
6. 01:34:238 (3) - sounds..actually it's confusing, may be you will remove it and add eeeh circle or 1/2 slider with reverse? // Hmm. Left it as it was for now.
7. 01:38:222 (12) - it's your choice but i said "prolong it"
8. 01:45:722 (8) - ^
9. 02:34:003 (1,2,3) - spacing
10. 03:06:816 - whistle

Good luck

ykcarrot wrote:

From IU 3rd mini album 'Real'.

Real wrote:

ykcarrot wrote:

From IU 3rd mini album 'Real'.

D:

• General

1. Why does every difficulty have different combo colours?

• [Easy]

1. 01:14:082 (1) - Awesome slider.
2. 02:53:691 (5) - This is a Easy difficulty, and this slider would be confusing because it has 2 repeats, and your previous ones are sliders with only 1 repeat, so the player might think that this one has 1 repeat too. I suggest you to try something else here.

• [Normal]
  
  The slider velocity of this difficulty is very high for a Normal, aaaaaand this song only has 128BPM, so I don't see why it is so high.

1. 01:51:582 (3) - Why did you leave that whistle at the sliderbody? I think that it sounds better without it.
2. 01:53:457 (3) - ^
3. 01:59:082 (3) - ^

• [Hard]

1. 03:08:925 (6) - Perhaps add a new combo here to avoid that high combo number (12)?

Kei wrote:

• General

1. Why does every difficulty have different combo colours? // They have just different order of combo colors. It's for heart slider.

• [Easy]

1. 01:14:082 (1) - Awesome slider. // <3
2. 02:53:691 (5) - This is a Easy difficulty, and this slider would be confusing because it has 2 repeats, and your previous ones are sliders with only 1 repeat, so the player might think that this one has 1 repeat too. I suggest you to try something else here. // Fixed

• [Normal]
  
  The slider velocity of this difficulty is very high for a Normal, aaaaaand this song only has 128BPM, so I don't see why it is so high. // It's fine :3

1. 01:51:582 (3) - Why did you leave that whistle at the sliderbody? I think that it sounds better without it. // Removed whistle from body
2. 01:53:457 (3) - ^ // ^
3. 01:59:082 (3) - ^ // ^

• [Hard]

1. 03:08:925 (6) - Perhaps add a new combo here to avoid that high combo number (12)? // Nope

Nothing much else. I think that this map looks and plays fine as it is. Good luck!

Kawayi Rika wrote:

Hi ~ ykcarrot ~

Mod time for PM in game ~



Red : Must be fixed
Pink : Should be fixed
Purple : Just suggestions

[Hard]

1. 03:00:019 (7) - Add new combo,long combo imo and vocal here. // It's different to other streams, there is no reason to divide combo.
2. 03:07:050 - Remove clap and Add whistle,sound much better here. // Didn't fix. But This suggestion made me to add whistles to the other points.
   
   휘슬 더한 부분이 아래 네 군데입니다.
   00:56:269 (7) -
   00:58:144 (2) -
   02:13:144 (8) -
   02:15:019 (2) -
   
   노트 지우고 음악 들어보시면 메아리처럼 들리는 부분이 있어요.
   1, 2 절에는 모두 메아리가 있는데 키아이파트는 마지막 부분(03:07:050)에 메아리가 없습니다.
   그래서 마지막 부분에는 휘슬 안더하고 그냥 원래대로 클랩만 넣은거예요.

That's all ~ Very clean mapset and nice map ~

Call me back recheck ~ when you are ready ~