It seems like you're using that gut-feeling of yours a lot recently Rantai
ARE YOU BECOMING LAZY
ARE YOU BECOMING LAZY
forum
Newbie Mafia - 2of4 [Town Win!]
posted
Total Posts
267
I wouldn't say lazy more than a what I perceive to be my only lead right now.
NoHitter - I'm lazy because they gave me vanilla. ;_;
this is the main reason I am voting bmin over and over again. I was so dang sure when I read this one of the newbies is his scum partner, but I expected it to be Darkari rather than Ekaru. I was alright with a lynch on either of them but Ekaru being PR screwing up was just as likely which is why I was as apprehensive. If I had been around or if the lynch on Ekaru was not gonna go through for some reason I probably would've voted from him too but as it stood there were quite enough votes on him I'm sure you dodn't need me in spirit.bmin11 wrote:
Confirm
inb4 drakari & ekaru mafia pair
I wouldn't say that "Not voting Ekaru" is enough of a reason to lynch someone right now, but I will say that I doubt the other mafia would have voted for his ally in that situation.
So Wojjan, Backfire, JInxyjem are the current possibilities. I'm leaning toward Backfire for trying to roleclaim vanilla townie.
So Wojjan, Backfire, JInxyjem are the current possibilities. I'm leaning toward Backfire for trying to roleclaim vanilla townie.
Trying to roleclaim
No I did
But go ahead, one more game I dont have to worry about.
No I did
But go ahead, one more game I dont have to worry about.
nah it'd be too easy for scum
plus role-claiming vanilla townie day 2 of a 2of4 game isn't scummy
plus role-claiming vanilla townie day 2 of a 2of4 game isn't scummy
Actually I think that claiming Vanilla Townie like that is a town tell.
In a game like this, Mafia should technically claim a power role to avoid getting lynched.
The very fact that Backfire claimed a role that we wouldn't think twice of lynching makes him look town.
In a game like this, Mafia should technically claim a power role to avoid getting lynched.
The very fact that Backfire claimed a role that we wouldn't think twice of lynching makes him look town.
that and he doesn't really seem to give a fuck about this game
Eh, it was just a feeling. In the past I've explicitly claimed generic townie more when I'm not one then when I am, but it could go either way.
I give no fucks about this or jesterfest right now.Sync wrote:
that and he doesn't really seem to give a fuck about this game
Just waiting for touhou and my game.
Vote: Wojjan
It's not Hitter or Sync for sure in my opinion. bmin seemed a bit out of it but Wojjan's odd hesitation last day sticks out a hair in front (on top of gut).
Backfire, I have a null tell on due to his apathy and Drakari is actually up there in the suspicion list, but I need to see more before forming a full opinion.
It's not Hitter or Sync for sure in my opinion. bmin seemed a bit out of it but Wojjan's odd hesitation last day sticks out a hair in front (on top of gut).
Backfire, I have a null tell on due to his apathy and Drakari is actually up there in the suspicion list, but I need to see more before forming a full opinion.
Topic Starter
Vote Count
JInxyjem (1) - Wojjan
Wojjan (1) - Rantai
Not Voting - Sync, Backfire, JInxyjem, NoHItter, Drakari
2 days + 18 hours remaining.
JInxyjem (1) - Wojjan
Wojjan (1) - Rantai
Not Voting - Sync, Backfire, JInxyjem, NoHItter, Drakari
2 days + 18 hours remaining.
Rantai how can you admit to bmin acting scummmy and then vote me because I think they're scummy
not gonna get into the gut feeling because that is a can of wifom I won't open up
not gonna get into the gut feeling because that is a can of wifom I won't open up
hi Wojjan can you explain the meta lane thing (i'm curious)
Jinxy is being careful with his posts (FoSing instead of voting, targeting wojjan in most of his posts. probably making up for bmin's mistake. also, confirmed Drakari as "not scum" in the same post he FoS'd Ekaru, which seems very odd to me. Town doesn't know who is and isn't scum.)
NoHItter is town in my eyes for voting mafia and having reason to do so
Drakari is ????
Backfire is ???? (leaning town due to meta)
vote: Jinxy
Jinxy is being careful with his posts (FoSing instead of voting, targeting wojjan in most of his posts. probably making up for bmin's mistake. also, confirmed Drakari as "not scum" in the same post he FoS'd Ekaru, which seems very odd to me. Town doesn't know who is and isn't scum.)
NoHItter is town in my eyes for voting mafia and having reason to do so
Drakari is ????
Backfire is ???? (leaning town due to meta)
vote: Jinxy
Ekaru flipping his shit was what he did as town in uh, the only other game he was ever in, was it salvage's?
I just thought people were picking on the new guy too much at first and just him posting like a madman was just panic attack but eventually I also reconsidered.
I just thought people were picking on the new guy too much at first and just him posting like a madman was just panic attack but eventually I also reconsidered.
oh ok thx
if you reconsidered why didn't you vote
if you reconsidered why didn't you vote
My reasons have all been posred beforehand. I FoS'd Ekaru because I didn't want to leave someome at L-1 when there were still 3 days, and I never confirmed Drakari as town, I just said his posts were bad and unhelpful.Sync wrote:
Jinxy is being careful with his posts (FoSing instead of voting, targeting wojjan in most of his posts. probably making up for bmin's mistake. also, confirmed Drakari as "not scum" in the same post he FoS'd Ekaru, which seems very odd to me. Town doesn't know who is and isn't scum.)
Wojjan has been voting for bmin/me since Day 1. When Day 2 came, it was the only.odd thing so of course I would ask for ghs reason for voting me.
ghs = his
both of you are pretty suspicious in my eyes, but answers to questions was all I was looking for
Waiting for other people to help me out on this
this is really itching at meWojjan wrote:
Ekaru flipping his shit was what he did as town in uh, the only other game he was ever in, was it salvage's?
I just thought people were picking on the new guy too much at first and just him posting like a madman was just panic attack but eventually I also reconsidered.
Waiting for other people to help me out on this
did you really need five votes instead of four on ekaru? I was just as strong on my jinxy read, from the point of my last post even stronger than ekaru because, you know, four votes on a day one lynch. Something could be up with that. I didn't feel like going out of my way from my vote on bmin to a bandwagon I was less sure of that was going to go through anyway
Topic Starter
I'm actually ok with editing posts, so feel free to do so.JInxyjem wrote:
ghs = his
Topic Starter
Well as far as I'm concerned, if you make a spelling error then fixing it isn't a big deal. If it's a bigger issue, then by editing you take the risk that no one catches you and calls you out on it.
The only thing I would have a problem with editing out is votes. Though if you want to discuss this further we should probably take it to the General Discussion thread. There isn't anything in the rules about it atm, so it probably IS something we should come to a consensus on.
The only thing I would have a problem with editing out is votes. Though if you want to discuss this further we should probably take it to the General Discussion thread. There isn't anything in the rules about it atm, so it probably IS something we should come to a consensus on.
I believe bmin was acting weirdly but not overly scummy per se.Wojjan wrote:
Rantai how can you admit to bmin acting scummmy and then vote me because I think they're scummy
What sticks out the most (outside gut) is your line;
... but I almost wanna vote him just to see if he's scum so I can make a case when this happens againIt was like a really awkward "I think he's scummy but not going to vote him" kind of flick off (to appear to agree while not voting for their partner). Yeah you were tunneled on bmin, but that could also add to the flick off. I could be over reading it but that's all I have.
almost. still on bmin
You can see it that way, but you can also see it as fence sitting. Not voting for someone when he/she's going to get lynched offers many excuses as to why you didn't vote him/her depending on the situation.Wojjan wrote:
did you really need five votes instead of four on ekaru? I was just as strong on my jinxy read, from the point of my last post even stronger than ekaru because, you know, four votes on a day one lynch. Something could be up with that. I didn't feel like going out of my way from my vote on bmin to a bandwagon I was less sure of that was going to go through anyway
For example, if the person lynched was town, the excuse could be: "I was suspicious, but my gut told me otherwise. That's why I didn't vote."
Whereas if the person lynched was scum, the excuse could be: "Oh he/she was going to get lynched anyway, but I did point out that he/she was suspicious."
So your excuse as to why you didn't vote Ekaru seems scummy.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
But that doesn't discount JInxyjem though.
JInxy only said that he wasn't going to vote for Ekaru in the meantime since there was still time and it would mean placing Ekaru at L-1.
I understand JInxy's reason to not place Ekaru at L-1 with three days left.
Placing someone at L-1 without being 100% sure is generally dangerous.
(If Ekaru had been a town power role, mafia could have quickhammered thus making us lose an important role.
Now that we know Ekaru was scum, he could have self-hammered too - ending the discussion prematurely.)
But, JInxyjem, were you/when were you planning to actually vote for Ekaru.
You said that only reason why you didn't vote for him was because there was three days left.
Now why didn't you vote for him when we had only one day left before the deadline?
Well on the other hand he was mafia rolecop don't you think that if I were his partner I would've done a lot more than "This is how townekaru's meta is too but meh" to get him off the hook
or you could have distanced yourself from him for this very reason
no man persian or greek lets town lynch their rolecop like that
I mean especially with Ekaru's townplay in themeless and the fact that the only sound argument I heard against ekaru was that he was digging his own hole in his replies. The only actual scummy thing people were building off was a misplaced randavote
you're fucked man oh shit you're going to get lynched oh shit you're going to lose it for mafia what are you going to do now
seriously though based off every single game I've ever played it always seems like the people who I don't think are mafia are mafia
** POINTING AT DRAKARI/BACKFIRE **
WHAT DO YOU TWO HAVE TO SAY FOR YOURSELF
edit: totally thought I was going to die N1
seriously though based off every single game I've ever played it always seems like the people who I don't think are mafia are mafia
** POINTING AT DRAKARI/BACKFIRE **
WHAT DO YOU TWO HAVE TO SAY FOR YOURSELF
edit: totally thought I was going to die N1
also if they don't respond or only respond with an "i'm here" and don't give thoughts on the game replace them
Mostly because I had work piled on after my post on the not-voting and stuff got busier, and Ekaru and Sync's long argument didn't quite help either when I only have little time between lessons to read and I had to skim quite a lot.NoHItter wrote:
But, JInxyjem, were you/when were you planning to actually vote for Ekaru.
You said that only reason why you didn't vote for him was because there was three days left.
Now why didn't you vote for him when we had only one day left before the deadline?
Wojjan wrote:
Well on the other hand he was mafia rolecop don't you think that if I were his partner I would've done a lot more than "This is how townekaru's meta is too but meh" to get him off the hook
This argument to me is kind of weak, mostly because no one else, persian nor greek, stood against Ekaru's lynch. Most wanted his lynch, I was still hesitant during my last D1 post for the previously said reason to avoid a quickhammer, and BF wasn't even there for most of Day 1. The vaguest objection to the lynch would probably be you, actually.Wojjan wrote:
no man persian or greek lets town lynch their rolecop like that
It's all I got. I didn't vote him because I voted for you who I am more sure of.
Requesting replace.
Well, if that's the case, then I don't really have much to say. To me it's either you or Backfire who's the last mafia, and your focus on me and explanations on not voting for Ekaru D1 just don't sit right with me and make me suspect you more than Backfire.Wojjan wrote:
It's all I got. I didn't vote him because I voted for you who I am more sure of.
Vote: Wojjan
Topic Starter
Drakari has been prodded, finding a replacement for Backfire.