LunaticMara wrote:
Hey guys what's going on this mafia thr-
OH SNAP
bmin11 wrote:
The way I recommand you to play
bmin11 wrote:
recommand
Really now bminbmin11 wrote:
recommand
This is exactly what makes your claim so hard to believe. The only pro-town vibe you're supplying is your roleclaim, which you have very blatantly acknowledged to be a power-role. Obviously WIFOM, but if you were mafia on the verge of being lynched, you'd roleclaim a power role.Salvage wrote:
realize that a lynch on me it's not a good option (also to point out that Wojjan suggested that) since i roleclaimed an important pro-town role ..
Rolled wrote:
I've considered letting Salvage live until D2 but honestly, how credible will his information be? I'm confident that the information we get from his death will be more credible and useful than anything he can supply D2.
Not to mention like half the posts in this thread have been from Salvage, and 1/8th of Salvage's posts have been informative.
Pretty much. I've already stated that I think both pieguy and Salvage are potentially scum (Alongside DxS for doing nothing but correcting the votecount after NoHItter posted it), but I'm not the type to lynch a claimed power role on D1, and I have certain suspicions about DxS's role.akrolsmir wrote:
Or you really can't think of anything, which no doubt you will claim.
I'm sorry, do you mind pointing out the part where I'm actually voting Salvage? Because I'm pretty sure I'm not.pieguy1372 wrote:
However, FoS adam2046, Wojjan
Wanting to lynch Salvage even though it's not the right move (and with adam, he specifically said it). I have a gut feeling Wojjan is town, not so much on adam2046 though. adam2046 has also been rather inactive (compared to others), which fits what I said before.
I want Wojjan lynched, more than you do, but you're making it extremely hard for me to not vote you instead entirely out of distaste.Voting someone out of distaste doesn't make sense IMO
(Not a serious HoS btwalong with an obviously invalid reason isn't enough to make it completely disregardable...)
did he just decide to keep playing or something?NoHItter wrote:
Jaqennn has asked for a replacement.
Again.pieguy1372 wrote:
Voting someone out of distaste doesn't make sense IMO
I won't include your joke HoS (though arguably it is distracting)pieguy1372 wrote:
mod: votecount please?
I only changed suspicions once, from LunaticMara to DxS. (I still think DxS is the most suspicious.) I haven't changed my mind since then, so I'm not sure exactly what you mean. >.>
I'm still waiting for a reply from rust45.foulcoon wrote:
did he just decide to keep playing or something?
You said you wanted to, though... I know you didn't actually, but it's still not a good idea.adam2046 wrote:
I didn't vote for him.
(And wow, did you even pay attention to my post? I even said you didn't vote for him)...>.> It would only be suspicion hopping if I suddenly wasn't suspicious of DxS. Although I didn't explicitly state it, I still find DxS to be the most suspicious. This should have been implied by not unvoting him. I just became suspicious of more people. (And the very first one was a RV) Thus, the only time my suspicion really changed was from the first non-RV to the second one.Rantai wrote:
RVS (yeah, I know, RVS) --> First --> Second --> Third
Before you say you didn't vote them (third), you are still suspicious of them, hence suspicion hopping.
One of the goals of the mafia is to mislead people, not to come up with possible leads. The latter one is more a towntell~pieguy1372 wrote:
Maybe I just wasn't clear enough and you all are doing this because it's D1 and you want any possible lead you can get, but that's exactly one of the goals of the mafia.
Why didn't you just say that when you first voted DxS?pieguy1372 wrote:
I gave my reasoning for DxS (second one) here.
Why make the vote in the first place (Mara's one), it had the same weight as an RVS you might as well not have done anything in that regard.pieguy1372 wrote:
My LunaticMara vote (first one) had little reasoning (compared to future votes) because there wasn't much information, and was entirely a gut feeling. Then, I changed it because my gut feeling on DxS was stronger and more reliable due to additional information. Did you really think I would want to keep a vote with far less reason? ><
Of course, I am not associating that RVS to my disagreement with you.pieguy1372 wrote:
When I removed my previous vote after making my LunaticMara (first) vote, there was nothing to the previous vote at all since it was a RV, so there should be no problem with removing it. Listing that as a reason doesn't make much sense IMO.
pieguy1372 wrote:
oh wait, I remember the time I had a gut feeling on you ever since D1 and you were mafia, perhaps you and DxS are both mafia this time?
Actually, this sounds pretty bad and needs to be fixed.akrolsmir wrote:
Vote: DxS for saying absolutely nothing.
Did you read my post? The most important part is that you wanted to vote for him, regardless of the fact that you didn't. (OT: Do you actually know what my signature says?adam2046 wrote:
Pieguy, the most important part is that I'm not voting him. The one who doesn't understand is you.
)At the time I wasn't exactly sure why DxS seemed suspicious to me, but after some time I figured it out.Rantai wrote:
Why didn't you just say that when you first voted DxS?pieguy1372 wrote:
I gave my reasoning for DxS (second one) here.
Or did you need time to think of a way to justify your vote. (Really only you know, so much WIFOM)
I made that vote because at that point in time, I thought LunaticMara was the most suspicious. Thus, it has more weight than an RV.Why make the vote in the first place (Mara's one), it had the same weight as an RVS you might as well not have done anything in that regard.pieguy1372 wrote:
My LunaticMara vote (first one) had little reasoning (compared to future votes) because there wasn't much information, and was entirely a gut feeling. Then, I changed it because my gut feeling on DxS was stronger and more reliable due to additional information. Did you really think I would want to keep a vote with far less reason? ><
That one comes off as you were forcing a vote to look like you're doing *something*.
pieguy1372 wrote:
oh wait, I remember the time I had a gut feeling on you ever since D1 and you were mafia, perhaps you and DxS are both mafia this time?Oh wait, I remember that game where you gut voted a lot and I had my self doubts and you were mafia, maybe you and Salvage are mafia this time?
<3
K, unvoteWojjan wrote:
no. ask for a replacement.
Er... yes?Swiftwolf Yellowtail wrote:
FoS akrilsmir
Are you implying to lynch the lurkers?
Yep!akrolsmir wrote:
Trying to get by without doing any work?
Oh my gooood scum harder! HOw can you seriously scumpaint two people and VOTE SOMEONE ELSE and get away with it?!Salvage wrote:
okay i'm back, even tho i already said like thousands of times that i know 2 mafia members and nobody listens to me i find a Mashley lynch better than anyone else cause he's pretty suspicious so fair enough.
vote: Mashley
Wojjan wrote:
Oh my gooood scum harder! HOw can you seriously scumpaint two people and VOTE SOMEONE ELSE and get away with it?!Salvage wrote:
okay i'm back, even tho i already said like thousands of times that i know 2 mafia members and nobody listens to me i find a Mashley lynch better than anyone else cause he's pretty suspicious so fair enough.
vote: Mashley
Huh?Salvage wrote:
and adam it's playing to deffend people time after another and that's pretty scum imo.
I do that, too. It's called analyzing.Salvage wrote:
That's not the case and i never mentioned foulcoon in the post, in fact i said i forgot to put you there .. that group of people it's the people i just expected to come with good plans, not the people i 'listen' i read everything and pay attention to everything, and that's why i'm asking you to trust me in this one ..
since i'm leaning towards trusting you're town here, for the rest of the people who reads this, realize that a lynch on me it's not a good option (also to point out that Wojjan suggested that) since i roleclaimed an important pro-town role ..I'm gonna pull a similar tactic that was pulled on me last game: "I CLAIMED TOWN THAT MEANS IM CONFIRMED TOWN!!!!!!!!!1111111111" This is totally not true.
it could be a lie? sure, but what if it's not and you end up lynching a good role?You didn't even think about the complete opposite.
i can be prooven telling te truth in no time anyways,Given the roles you've been getting in the previous games, that's highly unlikely. Plus the fact that this is PyP.
plus i'm almost 100% sure adam/wojjan or even both of them are mafia,"Almost 100%" is just the same as saying you're 95%, or even less. It's a bit contradicting.
i already stated why i think that and wojjan just came here to solidify my toughts about it, so since i already told everything about it i'd love if you guys really want to win to trust me.So far, we're not believing you, and you actually haven't stated why. All you did was babble on and on about why you're right and why we shouldn't lynch you.
Wojjan reacted like if he'd know adam would flip mafia so he would be nextCare to explain?
.. so now i'm pretty sure they both are mafia,.. so now i'm pretty sure you are still trying to hide something.
there you have my good reasoning i'd higly appreciate you take my post seriously and follow me now, since that's a way to proove myself also if there is a smart doctor to save me n1.Asking to be followed and taken seriously. That's funny.
Swiftwolf Yellowtail wrote:
Hmm... after doing some research, I came across this.
There's nothing about infiltrators.
New post:Salvage wrote:
I actually really want to start fighting with you right now, but i know all the roles and i still think that's not a good conclusion.
Salvage wrote:
I actually really don't want to start discusing you about little things, but i know all the roles and i still think that's not a good conclusion.
...I just noticed something from this post.Swiftwolf Yellowtail wrote:
Also, nice edit.
Original post:New post:Salvage wrote:
I actually really want to start fighting with you right now, but i know all the roles and i still think that's not a good conclusion.Salvage wrote:
I actually really don't want to start discusing you about little things, but i know all the roles and i still think that's not a good conclusion.
You know all the roles? It's day one! How the hell do you know this? We haven't even made it to night yet!Salvage wrote:
but i know all the roles and i still think that's not a good conclusion.
Makes sense. He could've at least said that.bmin11 wrote:
He means by Roles listed on mafiascum
Swiftwolf Yellowtail wrote:
Also, nice edit.
bmin11 wrote:
Can you explain Wojjan being afraid Adam flipping mafia? I want you to write in a format of...
Theory: Wojjan is mafia if Adam flips to be mafia
Reason: You write down why Wojjan would be mafia if adam flips to be mafia. DO NOT CONCLUDE on this stage, but just carefully explain.
Evidence: You post Wojjan's or Adam's posts that backs up your reasoning. This is important, so please do so.
adam2046 wrote:
Unvote
Vote: Wojjan
he's not willing to lynch he's mafia partner cause "he thinks he's town" with no reason to believe it,"I'm not lynching adam, that makes me scum."
so you just want town to trust you on this one? Salvage you got all the scumtells and the kitchen sink so I don't think you're in any position to lead a lynch on anyone if you can't even get your point across.Salvage wrote:
i'm actually trying really hard to show my point since i see i fail pretty often at it, so i'll be glad if we lynch any of them today to show my point even clearer.
Wojjan wrote:
so you just want town to trust you on this one? Salvage you got all the scumtells and the kitchen sink so I don't think you're in any position to lead a lynch on anyone if you can't even get your point across.
Misspelled =/= wrote the sentence wrong. You already misspelled "misspelled".Salvage wrote:
yea i misspeled it D:
I didn't say anything when you voted me. Does that mean we're both scum?Salvage wrote:
evidene:adam2046 wrote:
Unvote
Vote: Wojjan
and wojjan didn't say anything at all about it even with RV already done .. then it comes up to the rest of the story that you already know, not feeling like quoting old posts right now.
Good luck with trying to fix your logic.Salvage wrote:
Wojjan wrote:
so you just want town to trust you on this one? Salvage you got all the scumtells and the kitchen sink so I don't think you're in any position to lead a lynch on anyone if you can't even get your point across.
yes i do.
Swiftwolf Yellowtail wrote:
I didn't say anything when you voted me. Does that mean we're both scum?
this, combined with your bashing of salvage with completely useless info makes me find you suspicious. people always scumpaint people by saying shit like "are you just trying to get by unnoticed"? you're a classic exampleSwiftwolf Yellowtail wrote:
Plus, I never vote D1.
..I've mentioned EBWOP/EBWODP before in this thread. Apparently, you didn't see that.Salvage wrote:
i etided the post above me cause i didn't quote what i wanted to on Swift post. >.<
Why are you voting me?akrolsmir wrote:
Ah well, the idiocy of the accuser does not indicate the innocence of the accusee. Mashley, I'd like to get you lynched, but for now unvote, vote: adam
And so you voted for me. Instead of, you know, 100% DEFINITELY MAFIA WOJJAN.Salvage wrote:
yea i'm not sure about you adam, but you're tied to wojjan so that's what makes me think you're mafia mostly .. and i'm sure about him.
In this post Salvage says adam distanced from me by voting me.Salvage wrote:
or when you want to play distant with your mafia partners.
and that "you voted for me thing" was to get Wojjan say stuff that would solidfy my toughts about you and him, wich was exactly what happened so .. yeah.
In this postSalvage says I distanced from adam by not voting him.Salvage wrote:
Swiftwolf Yellowtail wrote:
Also, nice edit.
yea i misspeled it D:bmin11 wrote:
Can you explain Wojjan being afraid Adam flipping mafia? I want you to write in a format of...
Theory: Wojjan is mafia if Adam flips to be mafia
Reason: You write down why Wojjan would be mafia if adam flips to be mafia. DO NOT CONCLUDE on this stage, but just carefully explain.
Evidence: You post Wojjan's or Adam's posts that backs up your reasoning. This is important, so please do so.
oh god is this even nessesary? :
theory: wojjan is mafia if adam flips mafia (not nessesary cause wojjan is mafia anyways that's why i suggest a wojjan lynch instead of adam right now but let's just analyze this situation)
reason: wojjan really trying hard to paly distant with adam and him doing the same (a tell of him playing the same way as mafia on another gmaes) .. and him NOT WANTING us to lynch adam since he knows they're linked and that'll lead to us lynching him after if i was right about adam.
evidene:adam2046 wrote:
Unvote
Vote: Wojjan
and wojjan didn't say anything at all about it even with RV already done .. then it comes up to the rest of the story that you already know, not feeling like quoting old posts right now.
You're acting as if mine was a random vote? It was pretty clear what that vote was for so I didn't leave a reason in my post.Salvage wrote:
RV was already done there and adam's vote was totally out of place, mine was cause something you did, plus i don't expect you to, i do with wojjan.
hang on a sec, let me be you for a second:Salvage wrote:
or when you want to play distant with your mafia partners.
I'm pretty sure that Wojjan has just been trying to get on my good side this whole time by saying nice things about me after I pointed out how mafia Wojjan is right at the start.Salvage wrote:
and that "you voted for me thing" was to get Wojjan say stuff that would solidfy my toughts about you and him, wich was exactly what happened so .. yeah.
Yes, because you're inevitably correct about your statement!adam2046 wrote:
hang on a sec, let me be you for a second:Salvage wrote:
or when you want to play distant with your mafia partners.
"OTHER POSSIBILITIES DON'T EXIST I AM RIGHT."
As you can clearly see from how I stated that I am clearly right, I am clearly right.
Yeah basically so no one will suspect me when I NK youadam2046 wrote:
I'm pretty sure that Wojjan has just been trying to get on my good side this whole time by saying nice things about me after I pointed out how mafia Wojjan is right at the start.
might be because it's 2 AM but you have no idea how much that made me laugh.akrolsmir wrote:
Anyways, new theory: Salvage is attacking adam and Wojjan because he's trying to distance himself because they're all mafia together.