mapped by Skidooskei
submitted
ranked
This beatmap was ranked on 4 October 2023!
nominated by meiqth, Metzo, fieryrage, and rosario wknd
New Discussion
Please sign in to post or reply
Discussions
Sort by

00:04:406 (4,5) - kind of weird to only do a 1/1 stack here and nowhere else in the map outside of one area (more on that below), shouldn't this just be spaced out like everything else?

permalink

02:02:263 (3,4) - same for this, stack just seems out of place since these are the only two times they're used

permalink

yeah made them not stack

permalink
Marked as resolved by Skidooskei

was also used at 01:06:906 (2,3) - but changed that as well

permalink

00:05:786 (1,2) - nitpick but try not to make the bodies near each other when mapping easy diffs in the future

it may cause confusion to newer players since it looks ' close '

permalink

Changed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Skidooskei

Wouldn't hurt to include a circle on 00:11:192, just feels like a missed opportunity to map the decreasing synth sounds 00:10:120 (4) but ignore 00:11:192 entirely

permalink

Changed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Skidooskei

00:20:071 (1,2) - same here as issue #1471836

permalink

Fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Skidooskei

00:27:972 (4,1,2) - Should probably even out the visual spacing between these so it's a bit more readable for an easy diff

Stuff like 00:27:972 (4,1) could be misread as the tail of 00:28:686 (1) coming before the head etc.

permalink

00:30:114 (2,3,1) - Pretty ambigiuos as to which of 00:31:186 (3) 00:31:543 (1) comes first

permalink

00:59:400 (4,1) - This one is super fucked

permalink
permalink

01:06:900 (2,1) - This whole thing is a mess

permalink
permalink

02:11:631 (1,2,3,4,1) - This is all really cluttered too

permalink

fixed, 01:55:829 (3,1) - might still be bad but idk

permalink
Marked as resolved by Skidooskei

00:35:786 (2,3,1) - blanket properly pls ty

permalink

Not properly blanketed but if you highlight 00:36:857 (3,1) - it should make more sense. Also blanket mod >:(

permalink
Marked as resolved by Skidooskei

00:52:929 (2,3,1) - avoid overlapping it like this especially for the reverse slider, iirc a slider needs to disappear first before putting any sliders on it. it causes visual disruption and affects readability.

try changing the shapes for 2 and 1

permalink

I just moved it I didn't want ruin anything aes wise. But fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Skidooskei

00:54:406 (1) - This should be a S:C1 instead of just S. (for green line)

permalink

I'm confused, I'm pretty sure it is S:C1 and it sounds fine. Also I only have one sample set on this I'm pretty sure

permalink
Marked as resolved by Skidooskei

01:02:978 (1) - as cool as this slider is, i'm pretty sure this is too complex for beginners to read properly since the loop is negligibly visible -- to some players this can just look like a normal red node curve i.e. https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18520907/8a35 like this

since this is an easy difficulty, it's better to simplify this to something more understandable for new players to follow, with little confusion

permalink

I really really wanna keep this and so I went halfway and kept the loop but made it significantly more vertical, hopefully that should fix it?

permalink
Marked as resolved by Skidooskei

unfortunately no, the curves still noticeably bulge outwards which will confuse players

https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18715976/90c9 this is pretty much the only way it really can work :s

permalink
Reopened by fieryrage

okay :(

permalink
Marked as resolved by Skidooskei
permalink
Reopened by fieryrage

yeah

permalink
Marked as resolved by Skidooskei

01:07:257 (1) - smth like https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18737968/0c4e this works a lot better imo, the overlap between circle and slider here makes this kinda difficult to read for newer players

permalink

think I fixed this before but my big brain reset it

permalink
Marked as resolved by Skidooskei

01:07:353 (1) - would just use a slider starting 01:07:263 (3) - here instead for this -- the spinner barely is 4 beats long as specified by guidelines and is pretty out of place

permalink

adding a cool slider

permalink
Marked as resolved by Skidooskei

I also did this for normal diff so I could add a spinner

permalink

01:25:786 (1) - i suggest you can end the spinner on here 01:27:214 - because here is a Guidelines on Easy diff: Spinner recovery time should be at least 4 beats. This is to ensure adequate time to click a hit object following a spinner.

permalink

I'm pretty sure 3 beats is ok but just to be safe I'll move it back one beat.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Skidooskei

01:25:834 (1) - #2449539 doesn't seem like this was applied here; you need to get rid of the spinner here since it breaks guidelines (specifically: "There should be at least 4 beats between a spinner's end and the next object. This is to ensure adequate time to click a hit object following a spinner.")

permalink

sure ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by Skidooskei

01:25:835 (1) - I'd honestly just gut this spinner entirely

Such a short spinner at this bpm is a bit harsh on an easy diff like this + it just feels a bit strange to end it on 01:27:263 when the wacky synth persists until around 01:27:799

permalink

Aight

permalink
Marked as resolved by Skidooskei

01:50:834 - rhythm break here feels super forced with what the song is doing, just add a circle here instead honestly

permalink

okie

permalink
Marked as resolved by Skidooskei

01:51:543 (1) - do something like https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18715978/d0e7 this instead, maybe? flows a lot better that way

permalink

alright

permalink
Marked as resolved by Skidooskei
permalink
Reopened by fieryrage

ya

permalink
Marked as resolved by Skidooskei

02:11:637 (1,2,3,4,1) - think it'd be better to simplify the rhythm here as the song speeds up immensely during this section which can catch players off-guard, something like https://i.imgur.com/jczmoXN.png this would work better

permalink

Would really like to keep those last 2 circles so I'm not sure if there's anything I can do, and anyway I think it's readable. There are 2 1/1 sliders just before as well and they are only 10bpm slower?

permalink
Marked as resolved by Skidooskei

02:12:831 (3,4,1) - Would maybe look a bit nicer if this were straight

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Skidooskei

02:13:437 (1) - shouldn't this slider end on 02:13:972 - this red tick? it feels kinda weird having it end before all the sounds are finished.

permalink

Alright good idea

permalink
Marked as resolved by Skidooskei
/