mapped by Ayucchi
submitted
last updated
This beatmap wasn't updated since 14 September 2019 so it was graveyarded...
New Discussion
Please sign in to post or reply
Discussions
Sort by

00:07:470 (1) - remove nc

permalink

understandable

permalink

d

permalink
Marked as resolved by achyoo

00:09:601 (1,1,1,1) - if you read my mod on general, like for example here , tbh here its doesnt necessarily need to nc all of that cuz there is nothing happend here , if the sv of every slider are changing and yeah better nc all of those to help player read properly but here it just the same sv , the only difference is the slider patern , just need one nc only here 00:09:601 (1) -

permalink

made it 00:09:601 (1,2,1,2) instead

permalink

d

permalink
Marked as resolved by achyoo

00:18:125 (1) - emphasis here imo is lacking due to how it's such a loud piano sound while its previous object is close to (1). since you do a lot of high spacing emphasis like 00:12:880 (1) - i think it'll be better for that in this case as well.

i suggest just moving 00:17:961 (3) - below 3 or something similar. https://i.imgur.com/I8VM3Vt.jpg

permalink

seems reasonable, fixed

permalink

d

permalink
Marked as resolved by achyoo

00:24:971 (1,2,3) - I don't really see why this is a part of parts like 00:25:626 (1,2,3) - because the first one is very different from the second one I posted because the first one still has a guitar and the second doesn't for example

permalink

I'm mapping to the vocals here, so i don't see a reason to change this

permalink

d

permalink
Marked as resolved by achyoo

i would NC 00:25:339 (3)

permalink
permalink

I un-nced 00:26:650 (3) - for a more consistent representation of vocals

permalink

d

permalink
Marked as resolved by achyoo

00:44:355 (1,2) - maybe increase the spacing here to give emphasis on the vocal here 00:44:519 (2) -

permalink

reversed 2

permalink

d

permalink
Marked as resolved by achyoo

00:47:921 (4) - this stands out a lot in terms of spacing but the music doesn't stand out very much so you could make the same spacing as 00:48:249 (1,2) -

permalink

fair point, i rearranged the objects in the timeline for better spacing

permalink

d

permalink
Marked as resolved by achyoo

00:48:289 (1) - 1-2 nc here isnt necessary imo, it's in the same musical phrase with the notes before it and i dont think it's nc'd through the vocals or for patterning/readability either since the two notes previous it 00:47:634 (3,4) - are the same sound as 00:48:289 (1) - is not nc'd and it'd be quite inconsistent with 00:53:535 (3,4) - where it also has the same sound

permalink
permalink

understandable, changed combos

permalink

d

permalink
Marked as resolved by achyoo

00:51:568 (1,2,1) - if you gonna follow vocal just continue until the end of this section , you suddenly change it to drum here make it inconsistent with what you did here 00:48:945 (1) -

permalink

i'd say this is a buildup from the last 2 phrases, unchanged

permalink

d

permalink
Marked as resolved by achyoo

I would highly agree, I would make it a long slider to be consistent, but if you are insistent it's a buildup then I would at least make 00:54:191 (1,2,1,2,1) more rhythmically dense, as 00:51:568 (1,2,1,1,2) is denser than that part.

but I very much recommend making it a long slider, as the buildup wasn't that effective and it was a very jarring change

permalink
Reopened by Confusianism

changed to a 1/2 repeating slider instead

permalink

d

permalink
Marked as resolved by achyoo

00:54:191 (1,2,1,2,1) - this is kinda ruin the intensity of this part , i recommend to make it 1/1 slider or somthing

permalink

i don't think there's a problem here

permalink

d

permalink
Marked as resolved by achyoo

00:56:158 (1) - the repeat slider is wrongly snapped, as it is rn it's not currently following anything and is snapped in the 1/3 divisor, but since it looks like it's trying to follow the drums it should be a 3/4 repeat instead.

https://i.imgur.com/KyhC4Yc.png

permalink

additionally, you could put some drum hitsounds there on the repeat and the tail to properly represent the actual drums playing, drum-hitfinish sounds perfect here imo

permalink

woops, fixed and hitsounded

permalink

d

permalink
Marked as resolved by achyoo

00:57:142 (1) - section here can be spaced up more imo, currently, the section is a more intense part of the song where it's building up to the pre-chorus, but the spacing is much less spaced, this is very underwhelming to play.

the section before this is, however 00:46:322 -, is quite a calm part of the song where the objects are much more spaced and this is quite contrary to the timestamped section mentioned.

you could just increase the spacing on the hexgrid that you are using and increase the sv to match the sliders to the increased sv,

permalink

understandable, increased spacing a bit

permalink

d

permalink
Marked as resolved by achyoo

hate to be that kinda mod but 00:58:945 (4,2,2) - isn't overlapped perfectly

permalink

f

permalink

d

permalink
Marked as resolved by achyoo

01:00:053 (1,2,1,2,1) - why are those 1-2s all of a sudden? the music doesn't even support those 1-2s

permalink

i see no problem with this, unchanged for now

permalink

d

permalink
Marked as resolved by achyoo

would move 01:00:748 (1,2) down a couple of pixels so 01:00:748 (1) would overlap 01:00:093 (1)

permalink

understandable

permalink

d

permalink
Marked as resolved by achyoo

would remove NC from 01:01:240 (1) bc 1) it doesn't really make sense to NC there and 2) It more effectively shows the player that you rotated the slider 60 degrees from 01:00:912 (2)

permalink

understandable

permalink

d

permalink
Marked as resolved by achyoo

01:01:978 (1) - you should have the nc on the downbeat instead imo -> 01:02:060 (2) -

feels wrong to have an nc on a blue tick since it's making it look like it's completely ignoring the emphasis on the downbeat by having that nc there, saying it's a more important note than the downbeat

permalink

fair point, changed

permalink

d

permalink
Marked as resolved by achyoo

01:07:716 - sound here , should start stream a bit earlier here 01:07:634 - xd

permalink

understandable, changed

permalink

d

permalink
Marked as resolved by achyoo

i would remove the NC's at 01:07:961 01:07:961 (1,1,1)

permalink

fair point

permalink

d

permalink
Marked as resolved by achyoo

01:08:741 - why would you skip this? the drums are very noticeable here and not mapping them just feels empty put 2 circles on here 01:08:905 - and it should be fine

permalink

understandable, changed

permalink

d

permalink
Marked as resolved by achyoo

01:12:060 (4,1,2) - bad flow here , dont force player to make a turn spike , its very uncomfortable to play , just 01:12:224 (1,2) - ctrl+g this , should fix the flow :)

permalink

understandable, changed

permalink

d

permalink
Marked as resolved by achyoo

01:15:175 (1) - and 01:16:486 (2) - could use more spacing like how previous objects like 01:09:929 (1) - are spaced due to how they're downbeats and louder vocals.

i'm seeing that there's a pattern going on these timestamps, having small back and forth jumps however the fact that it's still the same loud vocal as 01:09:929 (1) - and etc, they should still have the same emphasis to be consistent

you could do something like https://i.imgur.com/FmB0SjR.png it would still have the same back and forth movement

permalink

01:17:798 (1) - this one is different but still same issue, needs more spacing since vocals are different now and more stronger than how it is previously 01:12:552 (1) - on the first half of the chorus

permalink

understandable, changed slightly

permalink

d

permalink
Marked as resolved by achyoo

unnecessary NC 01:17:470 (1,1)

permalink

yes

permalink

d

permalink
Marked as resolved by achyoo

i wouldn't put the slider tail at 01:21:732 (1) under 01:21:568 (3), players can't really tell if there is a reverse or not

permalink
permalink
permalink

fair, unoverlapped the slidertails

permalink

d

permalink
Marked as resolved by achyoo

01:35:175 (2,3,1,2,1,2) the jumps should increase in spacing instead of decreasing, the drum hits are getting loud

permalink

fair point

permalink

d

permalink
Marked as resolved by achyoo

01:35:502 (1,2,1,2) - #1120376 (the volume part, ignore everything else)

permalink
permalink
Marked as resolved by achyoo

01:42:716 (1) kinda an awkward place to start the spinner, since you continued mapping you should continue until 01:43:699 so it could be consistent

permalink

understandable

permalink

d

permalink
Marked as resolved by achyoo
/