mapped by sxy62146214
submitted
last updated
This beatmap wasn't updated since 2 December 2023 so it was graveyarded...
New Discussion
Please sign in to post or reply
Discussions
Sort by

00:00:111 (1,2,1,2,1,2) - it will be better if you put the higher distance (1.20x/1.30x) between (2) to (1) instead of (1) to (2), since it's the downbeats and will makes more sense

permalink

applied owo

permalink
Marked as resolved by sxy62146214

I prefer higher distance because 00:00:106 (1,2) - feel stacked, can move the pattern a bit to the left and give it 1,4x ds to have it clean

permalink
Reopened by -Joni-

Moved 00:01:706 (1,2) a little left

permalink
Marked as resolved by sxy62146214

00:01:006 (2,1) - should not be antiflow this whole intro is pretty smooth so doesnt seem like fit, you should keep same rhythm but just adjust gameplay and remove antiflow

permalink

Fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by sxy62146214

00:01:706 (1,2) - don't feel antiflow is needed here, sound is pretty the same as 00:00:106 (1,2) - so no need to emphasize imo

permalink

mirrored 00:01:706 (1)

permalink
Marked as resolved by sxy62146214

00:03:306 (1) - consider making this slider shape different than 00:00:106 (1) - or 00:01:706 (1) - as it maps different instrument/noise

permalink

Changed to a stright sharp twist.

permalink
Marked as resolved by sxy62146214

00:03:311 (1,2) - walk from 1 -> 2 seems off. Make sure to tilt the 2 more down (can be like 00:02:611 (2) ) to achieve a cleaner walk.

permalink

adjust 00:04:911 (1,2,3,4) afterwards :3c

permalink

Applied :3
Also I ctrl+h 00:04:911 (1,2,3,4) this is what I want to do personally

permalink
Marked as resolved by sxy62146214

00:04:211 (2) - I'd personally make this one flow to the left instead of anti-flow (basically CTRL+H it and fix the distance to 1.2x as your the patterns before)

permalink

Yep applied

permalink
Marked as resolved by sxy62146214

00:04:911 (1,2,3,4) - these sounds are of the same intensity, why is the distance suddenly increasing? i'd keep it 1.00x

permalink

Yes they should be same. turned into 1.05x since they are final four strong tunes.

permalink
Marked as resolved by sxy62146214

00:05:506 - you can map the 1/2 here its 150 bpm and theres buildup, there will also be rhythm progression just fine with salad so it should be fine.

(make sure to make it a comfortable walk and adjust 00:06:106 (5) - for a comfortable flow)

permalink

Added

permalink
Marked as resolved by sxy62146214

00:06:506 (1) - Only as a suggestion but for the spread i sugges to map the spinner, feels so empty compared to the other diff and you can map the rythm like this to regard the spread

permalink

I prefer the spinner rn, since I want to express these 1/8 drums in Cups I decide to use a spinner. Mapping 1/1 like suggestion feels same with the beginning part and that's not I wanted

permalink
Marked as resolved by sxy62146214

00:08:106 (1,2,1) - Can move to the left and make 00:09:106 (2,1) - more horizontal for a better and clean walk

permalink

idk what 'move to the left' mean but I make every slider like 00:08:106 (1) pure horizontal

permalink
Marked as resolved by sxy62146214

00:08:106 (1,2) - Don't you think the density in that section is a bit low? I feel like this section has a similar density to the preceding section, 00:00:106 (1,2) - , but I don't feel like the intensity of the music is quite the same.

I suggest adding more notes to give some contrast to the density of the previous section. ex-considering piano sounds on 00:09:306 - 00:09:506 -

00:11:306 (1,2) - 00:14:506 (1,2) - same.

permalink

added

permalink
Marked as resolved by sxy62146214

00:09:706 (1,2) - u can make this 1.0x spacing if u want since u stick with that spacing for non-emphasis needed notes for this diff

permalink

yep

permalink
Marked as resolved by sxy62146214

00:10:606 (2,3,1) - I don't like the movement here, is a bit weird for the style of the map, suggest to do something like this https://i.imgur.com/t9Icz0P.png or something like this https://i.imgur.com/cmK4L6v.png to give more emphasis to 00:11:306 (1) -

permalink

hmm I kinda like this sudden vertical stand stop, it combines well with following patterns and hitsounds. Player's surprised feeling here is intended and imo moving at 1/2 like 00:10:906 (3) is a little too tense for players in music's beginning part. Tend to keep.

permalink
Marked as resolved by sxy62146214

00:10:906 (3,1) - can buff spacing between this to be around or over 1.0x to emphasize movement onto white tick

permalink

applied

permalink
Marked as resolved by sxy62146214

00:12:306 (2,1,2) - The movement here feels a bit boring and static, suggest to make something with more variety like this > https://i.imgur.com/Ld5d4Cf.png to have a better movement and clean walks between 1 and 2

permalink

Did some antiflow/vertical move change. Not very satisfied but I think it's okay.

permalink
Marked as resolved by sxy62146214

00:12:306 (2) - slight slant here feels unnecessary considering map aesthetic is pretty clean. also feels weird how this triplet has almost no movement when 00:09:106 (2) - has alot of movement. i guess u can try to use something similar to https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18617396/61e3

permalink

It was a compromise ‘cause pattern hits screen edge. Now rearranged it into middle so that pattern has better movement.
Also introduce ![](image link magic)

permalink
Marked as resolved by sxy62146214

00:20:106 (2) - Prefer to make it full horizontal to have a better walk with 00:20:906 (1) -

permalink

did

permalink
Marked as resolved by sxy62146214

00:20:911 (1) - Making it flow wouldn't be a bad idea here so CTRL+H then move accordingly if you do decide to take this mod.

permalink

Applied.
(Tend to think SadEgg's suggestion of Mirror here is a timestamp typo)

permalink
Marked as resolved by sxy62146214

ye, timestamp of mine was a typo, whoops

permalink

00:25:706 (1) - why long slider here then u do apart on 00:28:906, i suggest change 00:25:706 (1) to 2 sliders

permalink

Reasonable, did this

permalink
Marked as resolved by sxy62146214

00:26:506 (2,1) - spacing between these can be nerfed to maybe 1.3x or 1.4x like 00:22:506 (1,1) - , its a bit big for something that id argue only needs normal amount of emphasis

permalink

Nerfed to 1.35x: little weaker than 00:22:506 (1,1).

permalink
Marked as resolved by sxy62146214

00:26:506 (2) - Considering that the pitch of 00:25:706 (1,2) - is ascending, I'd like to see 00:26:506 (2) - 's notes be more active like 00:12:906 (1,2) - .

The current vertical slider isn't providing any movement in play, so it's not a good representation of the pitch ascending.

00:28:906 (1,2) - As as similar reason, 0.08x ds between notes feels a bit static. So Can be give more spacing between them.

permalink

00:26:506 (2) - C-shaped
00:28:906 (1,2) - Changed to 1.1x walk

permalink
Marked as resolved by sxy62146214

00:28:706 (3,1,2) - standstill makes flow kinda weird to me, maybe try something like https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/18619724/e303

permalink

Horizoned 00:28:906 (1) and did related rearrangement. also introduce ![](image link magic)

permalink
Marked as resolved by sxy62146214

👍

permalink

00:28:711 - map this instrument since you mapped it in the other parts [00:22:111 (2,3) - and 00:25:311 (2,3) - ]

the difference would be too noticeable if you skipped this one but mapped the other parts

permalink

Applied

permalink
Marked as resolved by sxy62146214

00:28:911 (1) - imo adding a 1/1 wiggle here would be too unexpected for cup players, i'd use this pattern and then move 00:30:511 (1) - a little to the left so there's more space between sliders

permalink

Applied as suggestion.

permalink
Marked as resolved by sxy62146214

00:30:506 (1) - Can put in x:138 to have a better distance with 00:29:706 (2) -

permalink

oki

permalink
Marked as resolved by sxy62146214

00:30:506 (1) - can change to 2 1/1 sliders at 00:30:506 - and 00:31:306 - , prefer to have 00:31:306 - to 00:31:706 - mapped since there is continuous instrument sound

permalink

Prefer to keep since here is a drum->flute mapping main structure switch on all diffs.

permalink
Marked as resolved by sxy62146214

00:32:511 , 00:32:911 , 00:33:311 why you dont add the notes on here ? you can applied slider too if you wanted since this is cup

permalink

Rejected due to music simplify reason. A long stright slider is already very tense for cup.

permalink
Marked as resolved by sxy62146214

00:32:111 (2) - this sliders plays too wrong to me, specially cuz it finishes on the start of the kiai. I'd suggest doing a spinner that ends on 00:33:311 then adding a note on 00:31:711 (2) - for that snare on the back.
This enables you to put a note, or even a slider, at the start of the kiai and it won't feel akward to finish the slider into a kiai

permalink
Reopened by Aryssiel

whoops this did feels much better! Applied.

permalink
Marked as resolved by sxy62146214

00:33:706 (1,1) - Here you can make 00:34:706 (1) - horizontal and move a bit to the left like this > https://i.imgur.com/hVRsdQz.png and made 00:33:706 (1) - a bit vertical for better flow

permalink

yep

permalink
Marked as resolved by sxy62146214

00:33:706 (1) - would extend this to 00:34:306 - if u want since i think ending pattern on that noise is much more fitting but up to u

permalink

having 3/2 timing gap is kinda meh since u use alot of 1/1 rhythm

permalink

u can consider extending 00:46:506 (1) - as well and remove 00:47:306 (2) - if u want for consistency but up to u

permalink

I don't want change for these following reasons:

  1. First kiai mainly following flutes, almost no drums were mapped. For 00:33:706 (1) the flute did end at 00:33:706 (1).
  2. The 3/2 meh feeling in my opinion is pretty good for telling players "now ready for first kiai, preview time part!"

Changed 00:33:706 (1) shape and position btw since spinner changed due to former mods.

permalink
Marked as resolved by sxy62146214

did end at 00:34:106* timestamp typo

permalink

00:38:311 (1) - cancel New Combo because you don't put NC on 00:41:511 (3) -

permalink

opps

permalink
Marked as resolved by sxy62146214

00:39:311 (2,1) - These are pretty tight to hit so I would reduced their distances.

permalink

Reduced to 1.25x

permalink
Marked as resolved by sxy62146214

00:40:106 (1,2,3) - This is only a esthetic change, can change 00:41:306 (2) - to x:211 and the end of the slider 00:40:106 (1) - to x:273 > https://i.imgur.com/GDf5Vmf.png and visual it looks better

permalink

yep

permalink
Marked as resolved by sxy62146214

00:42:511 (4,1) - higher up the distancing? you put 1.4x for 00:36:111 (3,1) - although it has a similar type of downbeat

permalink

Moved both to 1.3x

permalink
Marked as resolved by sxy62146214

00:43:306 (1,2,3) - Compared to not having a strong sound, I think it's a pretty active movement. I think you could adjust the angle of the slider to consider a less active slider movement. ex

permalink

did a little

permalink
Marked as resolved by sxy62146214

00:44:906 (1,1) - Give this a bit distance, 00:46:506 (1) - in x:290 works fine

permalink

Moved next all part (00:46:506 (1,2,3,1,2,3,4)) owo

permalink
Marked as resolved by sxy62146214

00:44:906 (1) - Can remove NC here, is unncesary

permalink

oki

permalink
Marked as resolved by sxy62146214

00:44:906 (2,1) - for transition of new kiai section, this has kinda low emphasis compared to some other patterns. u can buff spacing to 1.3x - 1.4x

permalink

buffed to 1.3x

permalink
Marked as resolved by sxy62146214

00:48:106 (1,2,3,4) - i don't really love how the notes slightly slant to the screen edge rather than just like this? idk how to explain it lol
same goes for 00:51:306 (1,2,3,4) -

permalink

I get what you meant but I like the tendence of direction =w=

permalink
Marked as resolved by sxy62146214
/