mapped by Hollow Wings
submitted
ranked
This beatmap was ranked on 28 December 2023!
nominated by enneya and zekk
New Discussion
Please sign in to post or reply
Discussions
Sort by

checked & discussed together with zekk in voice chat. https://enneya.s-ul.eu/9OqCPbPo.png

permalink

metadata for original song https://maoujo-anime.com/music/
short discussion about artist here #3086659

permalink

Hi, you probably missed anime tags as you have it set in website genre, also this is a cover from an anime theme song, so i think it would be benefical to add.

permalink

changed site was genre to pop already, since it's minor i'll resolve to let the map get ranked

permalink
Marked as resolved by enneya

Why does this have a TV Size marker? This cover wasn't featured in the anime so it shouldn't be in the title. RC only states the source needs to be reused, not markers

Here's a recent example of a cover omitting TV Size marker: https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/2001413#taiko/4161705

permalink

The marker can be used. The cover is a cover of the TV size version of the song. I disagree that it has to be omitted.

permalink

TV Size is an artifical osu marker though, not an official marker

permalink

that doesn't matter at all, I think it's more than appropriate stating that this cover is a cover of the TV Sized version of the song

permalink

not a huge deal so I'll close this, but #4090615 still needs addressed

permalink
Marked as resolved by Molybdenum

osu idol

permalink

moecho vocal 好啊

permalink

could add cover 歌ってみた utaite to tags

permalink

ok, added those tags.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Hollow Wings

Too high or low audio bitrate.
Average audio bitrate for "audio.ogg", 443 kbps, is too high.

The audio file of a beatmap must...

...use the .mp3 or .ogg file format.
...have an average bit rate no greater than 192 kbps for .mp3 files, or 208 kbps for .ogg files.

permalink

sry for the late reply... changed the audio.ogg into a 204kbpms one (still ogg file thou).

permalink
Marked as resolved by Hollow Wings

shouldn't the artist be:

Artist: りりこ feat. スヤリス姫 (CV: 水瀬いのり)
Romanised Artist: ririco feat. Syalis-hime (CV: Inori Minase)

I can clearly hear Inori Minase's voice in the background.

permalink

cover artist has the right to decide it @moecho

permalink

i sang all parts in the song (including overlapped vocals)

u can hear inorin’s voice because she is faintly in the background as i couldn’t get good off-vocal version of the song ;u;

i wanna keep as is

permalink

"u can hear inorin’s voice because she is faintly in the background as i couldn’t get good off-vocal version of the song ;u;"

that's why i said "feat" since she's still singing in the background. adding only your name would mean that you're the only one singing which is not the case here.

I don't think your reasoning for not adding it is reasonable enough tbh.

permalink

i don't think her vocal in the background is significant enough to state this in the artist
it would be different and more reasonable to add if i had let her be dominant in any part of the song, but it is not the case

as @Present stated, cover artist has the right to decide it, and it is not against the RC either
wouldn't it seem more unreasonable to force the artist to change this? (with respect to the already stated reasonings from my reply before)

also this should not be a problem stamp, if anything it's a suggestion

permalink

kept the current meta with reasons above.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Hollow Wings

moecho uwu owo

permalink

o

permalink

nice

permalink

hao ye

permalink

moe chu punch

permalink

uwu..zzz

permalink

Suya

permalink

nice

permalink

 

permalink

osu!idol lol (wha)

permalink

osu!idol

permalink

osu!idol

permalink

osu!idol project

permalink

osu!idol

permalink

osu!idol

permalink
/