1. Futsuu (2,37 stars, 215 notes)
2. Kantan (1,4 stars, 118 notes)
3. Muzukashii (2,69 stars, 300 notes)
4. Rew's Inner Oni (4,01 stars, 514 notes)
5. Skylish's Oni (3,64 stars, 414 notes)

Kasha wrote:

Sorry for the late mod, I got sick and wasn't able to get on osu orz do not worry


[Kantan]

00:15:985 (24) - kat ok

00:36:370 (5) - ^

00:39:446 (10) - ^ keep

01:01:754 (2) - ^

01:04:062 (6) - hitfinish ok

[Futsuu]

00:20:600 (9) - don ok

00:27:139 (18) - kat keep

00:59:062 (28) - ^

01:04:446 (11) - ^

01:07:139 (18) - ^

01:19:447 (13) - ^

[Muzukashii]

00:07:523 (12) - from here to the slider, this is too long for a muzukashii, maybe remove a few notes? you're right I'll fix this

00:31:946 (44) - remove ok

00:34:639 (6) - ^

00:40:792 (33) - kat ok

00:43:869 (42) - ^

00:44:062 (43) - hitfinish ok

01:05:408 (20) - kat ok

01:16:754 (14) - remove ok


[Oni]

00:12:619 (56) - kat ok

00:15:600 (72) - ^

00:35:216 (10) - ^

00:45:600 (59) - You can either remove it or change the combo to ddK (K = hitfinish kat), because this is unrankable. change ddK

01:07:331 (37) - kat ok

Etsu wrote:

Mania for now only 4k

Cipse wrote:

Well, this was meant to be a M4M but then I saw this:

Etsu wrote:

Mania for now only 4k

Oh well, free mod
0 1 2 3

• General
  
  Tags: should be the same as mine " dagashi kashi anime ending "
  
  
  Wide screen support should be disabled unless you are doing a story board.

• Kantan
  
  00:15:216 (23) - move to 00:15:600 - ? This pattern puts an emphaise on the last 2 notes
  
  
  00:16:369 (1) - change to a note?
  
  
  00:27:139 (10) - d the pitch sounds lower here
  
  
  00:27:908 (11) - move to 00:27:712 - change to k I think the vocals here are strong enough to move to red tic
  
  
  00:28:292 (12) - move to 00:28:677 - vocals
  
  
  00:29:831 (14) - move to 00:29:446 -
  
  
  00:19:446 - -->00:44:062 - This part might be too boring and I would remap it to strong vocals and other strong points but not to much where the star rating goes to high.

• Futsuu
  
  00:07:139 (10,11,12,13,14,15,16) - these long 1 / 1 patterns are too long try breaking it down by removing 00:08:292 (13) - or 00:09:062 (15) - removed
  this could be applied through the rest of this section.
  
  
  00:10:023 (16) - move to 00:10:408 - I'm mapping to the strong guitar here
  
  00:19:446 - - - ->01:27:139 - ^ this was mentioned above here are some examples of parts that could broken down 00:39:062 (16,17,18,19,20,21) - 00:57:908 (23,24,25,26,27,28,29,30,1) -

• Muzukahii
  Same issue with Futsuu but with 1/2 beats. Also i will point out some things you cant do 00:39:254 (26,27,28) - these are very rare in muzu would avoid
  Also the pattern structer feels a bit over mapped and unnecessary at some points like at 01:07:139 (26,27,28,29,30,31,32) - 01:10:216 (36,37,38,39,40,41,42,43,44,45,46,47,48,49,50,1) -

• Oni
  
  I would prefer not to map the Oni too because I would make it into something like mine but you cannot use finishers after streams like at 00:07:139 (23) -
  
  Also I think kai time is missing a few notes like at 00:07:139 (23) -

Cipse wrote:

EZ

00:00:985 (985|3) - the sound dies out at 00:02:139 -, not 00:01:658 -. Move the slider end ok

Change 00:04:639 (4639|0) - to an LN that ends at 00:05:023 -. In this section you were mapping the trumpets so keep it consistent
00:05:216 - there's a second trumpet sound here, so add another LN ok

00:06:369 (6369|2,6562|3,6754|1,6946|3) - There's nothing that suggests a random placements of SNs. Make the SN pattern step-wise, {0,1,2,3,0...} or {3,2,1,0,3...} It thinks you're right but the sound is almost similar... He applied the second option

This isn't really a problem but I think that it would be better if 00:18:292 (18292|0,18292|2) - were turned into LNs, to match the music slightly better you are right but I moved some notes

To keep it consistent with what you did between 00:17:908 - and 00:18:677 - and to make the map match the music better, I would move 00:30:216 (30216|2) - to {1}. You'll have to move the notes before to remove any newly created jacks yep also changes notes

If you changed 00:18:292 (18292|0,18292|2) - into LNs, also change 00:30:600 (30600|2,30600|0) -, for consistency

Make 00:43:485 (43485|1,43677|3,43869|2) - go into a step-wise pattern, for the same reasons as with 00:06:369 (6369|2,6562|3,6754|1,6946|3) - nice

00:44:062 - add a note here to keep it consistent with 00:47:139 -

It felt off to me when you dropped the percussion at 00:48:677 - and 00:49:062 -. Add in an SN at each of those points remove Ln

00:50:023 - add a note here. It feels weird leaving out the vocals here nop a bit difficult for new players (with more suggestions apply)
00:50:792 - as with above

There are three vocal notes being sung between 00:52:331 - and 00:52:523 -. Either add an LN at 00:52:331 -, that ends at 00:52:523 -, to map out the missing SN or put three SNs there. I'd go with the LN option fix some notes

00:54:254 - you're missing an SN here. If you're mapping the bass, instead of the vocals, there you're dropping a layer better I leave well (if someone tells me the same thing as change)
00:54:639 - as with above

00:56:369 - I'd add a second SN here, as the music is kinda strong. Place it in {1}
00:56:658 - as with above
00:56:946 - as with above, except place the SN in {2}
00:57:139 - add an SN in {2}

It won't make much of a different, but I'd like it if 01:04:254 (64254|1) - was mapped by a LN ok

01:05:600 (65600|0,65985|1,66369|3,66754|2) - if these are mapping the bass, you're dropping the vocal layer before it has reached the end of the section. To fix this, delete 01:06:369 (66369|3,66754|2) - and then add an SN to 01:06:177 - and 01:06:562 - nice

01:16:177 - add an SN here, for the vocals ok

NM

You're mapping the vocals in the beginning of this difficulty. So add in notes at 00:00:600 - and 00:00:792 - so you're not leaving some of them out ok
If 00:00:985 (985|2) - I'd change this into a LN that ends at 00:01:562 - combined with the drum imo

00:04:639 - the trumpets play here, so add another LN to map this (ends at 00:05:023 -) ok
00:04:831 (4831|2) - remove this SN, as it's not mapping anything ok
00:05:216 - the trumpets play here as well. Add an LN that ends at 00:06:369 - ok

Between 00:07:139 - and 00:16:369 -, you've placed doubled on 1st/3rd beat of every bar. For consistency, add an SN at 00:17:139 -

00:10:792 (10792|1,10985|1) - I don't know why this has a jack fix

00:18:292 (18292|2,18292|0) - potentially change these into LNs to match the music better ok

00:19:062 (19062|2) - I'm not sure what this is mapping, delete it. If it's the drums, it also feels weird to map one instance and ignore the rest nice

00:20:985 (20985|2) - this might be better as an LN? ok

00:21:754 - there are no vocals here, delete an SN for consistency here I made some changes that I like to leave it

00:22:139 (22139|0) - delete this, as you've been accenting the 1st/3rd beats throughout the difficulty, not the 2nd/4th

00:22:523 (22523|2,22716|2) - I don't see why this is a jack, remove it ok

00:24:062 (24062|2) - maybe change this into an LN? nice

00:24:831 - there are no vocals here, so delete an SN
00:26:369 - as with above

00:27:716 - you're missing a LN here, for the vocals

00:27:908 - no vocals here, delete an SN ok

00:28:292 (28292|1) - for consistency delete this, as you haven't been accenting the 2nd/4th beats previously

00:28:677 (28677|2,29062|1,29446|0,29831|1) - maybe change these into LNs, to match the vocals. Also, I'd move 00:29:831 (29831|1) - to {3}, because the pitch is consistently going down - it doesn't go up there
00:30:600 (30600|1,30600|3) - also, consider making these LNs we use it in the other diff

00:31:754 (31754|2,31946|2) - I don't see why there is a jack here, remove it

00:33:292 (33292|2) - maybe turn this into an LN?

00:34:062 - there are no vocals here - delete an SN here I keep the pace
00:34:446 - as with above. And you haven't been accenting the 2nd/4th beats

00:36:369 (36369|2,36754|2) - there's no reason for these to be in the same column, as the pitch changes. Also, consider making 00:36:369 (36369|2) - a LN

00:37:139 - no vocals; remove an SN ok
00:38:677 - as with above
00:40:216 - as with above

00:38:292 (38292|1) - it's on the 2nd beat and no vocals; delete this
00:39:831 (39831|3) - as with above nice

00:40:408 - you're missing a note here for the vocals. I'd suggest that this note is a LN, that ends at 00:40:600 -
00:40:792 - also missing a note for the vocals

00:44:831 - you're missing an SN, as it's the 3rd beat

00:47:523 (47523|3) - there are no vocals here, delete this note ok

00:47:716 - I'd make this an LN that ends at 00:48:100 -

00:49:831 (49831|2) - also no vocals, delete

00:53:100 - you're missing a note here, for the vocals ok
00:54:254 - as with above
00:54:639 - as with above

The trumpets between 00:54:831 - and 00:56:177 - sound similar to the ones between 00:56:369 - and 00:57:139 -. Map them in a similar way ok

00:58:677 - you're missing an SN here, for the 3rd beat accent ok
01:00:216 - as with above
01:01:754 - as with above
01:04:831 - as with above

01:05:985 (65985|1,66369|3,66754|2) - if these notes are mapping the bass, you've just dropped the vocal line. To fix, delete 01:06:754 (66754|2) -, move 01:06:369 (66369|3) - to {0} so it doesn't look like part of the vocal line and add an SN at 01:06:177 - and 01:06:562 -

01:07:908 - missing a 3rd beat accent here ok
01:08:677 - missing 1st beat accent
01:09:446 - missing 3rd beat accent

01:09:639 (69639|1,69831|2) - I'm not sure why these are here, delete them ok

01:10:985 - missing 3rd beat accent ok
01:12:523 - as with above
01:14:062 - as with above

01:16:177 - missing an SN for the vocals

01:17:139 - missing an accent on the 3rd beat

01:17:908 (77908|2,78292|2) - why is this a jack? fix

01:18:677 - this is on the third beat ok
01:20:985 - on the first beat
01:21:754 - on the third beat
01:23:292 - missing another third beat accent
01:24:831 - as with above

01:26:946 (86946|1) - I would change this into an LN, that ends at 01:28:677 - and move it to {0}. 01:27:139 (87139|0) - feels off, mainly because the instruments only play at 01:26:754 - and 01:26:946 -. Potentially move 01:26:754 (86754|2) - to {1} nice

__

Good luck

IControl wrote:

• General
  
  Tags: should be the same as mine " dagashi kashi anime ending " ok
  
  
  Wide screen support should be disabled unless you are doing a story board.

• Kantan
  
  00:15:216 (23) - move to 00:15:600 - ? This pattern puts an emphaise on the last 2 notes nice
  
  
  00:16:369 (1) - change to a note? It is well to accustom notes ...even if someone else says the same thing as change
  
  
  00:27:139 (10) - d the pitch sounds lower here ok
  
  
  00:27:908 (11) - move to 00:27:712 - change to k I think the vocals here are strong enough to move to red tic this feels confused... keep
  
  
  00:28:292 (12) - move to 00:28:677 - vocals
  
  
  00:29:831 (14) - move to 00:29:446 - voice fix
  
  
  00:19:446 - -->00:44:062 - This part might be too boring and I would remap it to strong vocals and other strong points but not to much where the star rating goes to high. you remove some notes
  

• Futsuu
  
  00:07:139 (10,11,12,13,14,15,16) - these long 1 / 1 patterns are too long try breaking it down by removing 00:08:292 (13) - or 00:09:062 (15) - removed
  this could be applied through the rest of this section. nice
  
  
  00:10:023 (16) - move to 00:10:408 - I'm mapping to the strong guitar here ok
  
  00:19:446 - - - ->01:27:139 - ^ this was mentioned above here are some examples of parts that could broken down 00:39:062 (16,17,18,19,20,21) - 00:57:908 (23,24,25,26,27,28,29,30,1) - I moved some note and delete

• Muzukahii
  Same issue with Futsuu but with 1/2 beats. Also i will point out some things you cant do 00:39:254 (26,27,28) - these are very rare in muzu would avoid
  Also the pattern structer feels a bit over mapped and unnecessary at some points like at 01:07:139 (26,27,28,29,30,31,32) - 01:10:216 (36,37,38,39,40,41,42,43,44,45,46,47,48,49,50,1) - fix

• Oni
  
  I would prefer not to map the Oni too because I would make it into something like mine but you cannot use finishers after streams like at 00:07:139 (23) -
  
  Also I think kai time is missing a few notes like at 00:07:139 (23) -
  
  I did not understand that part but I will check your map oni once more

Good Luck

Yoratama wrote:

Hi, NM from my queue
Sorry My English is Bad

General

- FIX OD and HP setting
this is usually ranked do about HP/OD
Kantan HP 8 - OD 3
Futsuu HP 7 - OD 4
Muzukashii HP 6 - OD 5
Oni HP 5 - OD 6 fix

This is Kantan, 20 Spin :3 the spin should be 20?I do not know how to increase the number ;-;


- Uncheck Widecreen Support fix
- maybe expand kiai till 01:28:677 - ? I not seem right ... although it is a bad idea kiai with spin
Kantan

00:21:369 - don? pitch lower ok
00:24:062 (4,5) - Ctrl + G? reverse from ^ nice
00:50:600 - why not filled? it's nice sound for finisher, and that will fun to play. I think many notes but you're right sound are stronger
00:51:369 - ^^
01:03:292 - kat? if you following vocal. pitch higher ok
01:14:831 (21,22) - Stcl+G if you applied ^ nice

Futsuu

00:10:216 (16,17,18) - same sound with 00:07:139 (10,11,12) - , make it same? ok
00:29:831 - remove, avoid short slider in low diff. ok
00:50:600 - same as kantan
00:51:369 - ^
01:15:600 - move to 01:15:408 - if you follow vocal different with 01:03:292 - that have 2 word (ni wa) yes
01:29:062 - remove, useless and no sound there. how it got there :d

Muzukashii

00:07:523 (12,13,14,15,16) - move to 00:07:331 - ? i think that's too late if you placed there. ok
00:08:292 - kat if you aplly ^ yes
00:50:600 - sam as kantan/futsuu
00:51:369 - ^
00:53:677 (32,33,34,35,36,37) - make this kdkkdk to fit with vocal.? mmm.. change dkkddD
00:38:869 (24,25,26,27,28) - make reverse of this pattern? 00:37:330 (18,19,20,21) - because lyric support that. I listen well and so I did not modify

Oni

I think oni pattern is random, just fixed some to make it not too random :3
00:07:331 - kat like 00:10:600 - ok
00:12:331 - kat like 00:09:254 - or make 36 don ok
00:25:216 - kat, follow drum snare and vocall too ok
00:38:869 (28,29,30,31,32) - do reverse like Muzukashii
00:50:600 - Big kat, same as 00:51:369 - nice
00:55:600 - avoid finisher in stream ok

Hope it help
Good Luck!

IControl wrote:

Oh yeah I forgot to mention the file size can't be greater than 192kbps try using audio converter than rename to the orginal audio file name. No kudos

KcHecKa wrote:

osu!mania Difficulties mod

Overall:
the BPM and offset seems good.. something about this mapping needing a normal/easy difficulty
in AI Mod, idk might just be an error on my part. anyways.. is a small warning to the osu! standard is normal when you map another mode so it is not so important
--------------------
HD:
The things said about Queen! can be applied to this difficulty as well. done
--------------------
Queen!:
At 00:10:216 do this
00:10:216 (10216|1,10216|3,10216|0,10408|2,10600|0,10600|1) - ok
At 00:16:292 do this
00:13:292 (13292|3,13292|2,13292|0,13485|1,13677|3,13677|0) - ok
At 00:21:754 do this
00:21:754 (21754|1,21754|0,21946|3,22139|2,22139|0) - ok
YOU SEE WHAT IM DOING?? KEEP UP WITH THE DAMN CONSISTENCY PLSS
---many instances of overlapping occurs, its not "bad" but its recommended to keep the map
somewhat consistent, AKA its-up-to-you I have no idea what you're saying but it seems I have to fix quite sorry
--------------------
Notes:
LOL im not checking the easier two difficulties. Boi

KcHecKa wrote:

osu!mania Difficulties mod

Cow's Calories:
--warning: very harsh--
Only 1 second in the song, and I'm already utterly disgusted by the mapper's choice of style here.
Please explain to me why you think its okay to end the Long-Notes like this?
00:00:985 (985|3,985|1,985|0) -
I understand that its because of the vocals and what not, but honestly, you should have done it like
00:00:985 (985|3,985|1,985|0,1946|2,2139|1,2331|0) -
Multiple parts in the map, you map the vocals to the end of the Long notes. This isn't exactly a "bad"
thing, but me personal, this is completely disrespectful.
In fact, this whole section of 00:07:331 - 00:16:369 the inclusion of short, Long-Notes, was NOT
needed.
Stuff like this really pisses me off 00:27:139 (27139|3,27139|2,27331|1,27523|0,27716|1,27908|0,28100|2,28292|3) -
Why?? whyyy Whhieee do yu du dis? ? ? ?
You have weird end timing for these Long-Notes
00:50:600 (50600|2,50600|1,50600|3,50985|1,50985|0,51177|2,51177|0,51369|0,51369|1,51369|3) -
I recommend doing it like this
00:50:600 (50600|2,50600|3,50600|1,50985|1,50985|0,51177|2,51177|0,51369|1,51369|0,51369|3) -
The same can be said for the next occurring Long-Note.
This looks well
01:00:985 (60985|0,60985|1,61081|2,61177|3,61273|2,61369|3,61369|1,61466|2,61562|0,61658|3,61754|2,61754|0,61850|3,61946|1,62042|0,62139|1,62139|3,62235|2,62331|1,62427|0,62523|2,62523|1) -
My main concern for this difficulty is the Long-Note usage, its not necessarily "bad", its just not my taste
Its up to you on how you go about this.
--------------------

xtrem3x wrote:

Removing my laziness ...


General:

don = d
kat = k
Big Don = D
Big Kat = K

Baja el volumen de los hitsounds a 70 u 80% ok
Quita la peruana (digo, paloma XD) de Widescreen Support ... Si tienes un Storyboard quedará activado. ya la habia quitado xD... solo video

Kantan

• 
  00:28:677 - en esta zona el ritmo se corta bien raro, asi que para compensarlo sería de meter una nota aca, posiblemente una k. ya estaba
  00:41:754 - Lo mismo acá ... nice... queda mejor con el ritmo de la voz
  
  00:49:062 - Aquí no se corta el ritmo como tal, pero siento que es necesario meterle una nota, posiblemente una d. verdad por lo cual de 00:44:831 (16,17,18)
  01:24:831 - Lo mismo ... ya estaba XD
  
  Que el spinner comience en 01:26:946- y en 01:26:754- agrega una nota. ok

Futsuu

• 
  00:39:831 (18,19) - Será repetitivo pero mejor cambia estas notas a d...
  
  00:59:254 - Aquí falta una nota ... facil una d nope se siente raro agregar esa nota ahi... mejor en 00:59:446 (28) - la voz termnia ahi (queen)
  01:00:792 - Lo mismo ...
  
  01:02:523 - Cambiala a k, tiene sonido alto ... nice
  
  01:03:100 - Veo mas factible que esta la muevas a 01:03:485- por que combina el sonido de trompeta para el triple. mmm... no aqui sigo la voz ya que es confuso con las trompetas
  
  01:11:562 - Agrega una d aqui tambien ... por lo mismo de 00:59:254- no
  01:13:100 - Lo mismo ...
  01:17:716 - Lo mismo ...
  01:20:023 - Lo mismo ...
  01:23:869 - Lo mismo ...

Muzukashii

• 
  desde 00:07:523- hasta 00:16:177- obviamente son secuencias largas, tal vez estén en 1/2 pero igual deben reducirse un poco, asi que pondré los numeros de cuales borrar:
  00:08:100- , 00:08:869- , 00:11:177- , 00:11:946- , 00:14:254- , 00:15:023- Muy bueno
  
  00:31:946 - A borrar esta tambien para reducir los patrones largos. ok
  00:35:023 - Lo mismo ok
  
  00:39:254 - usualmente en Muzukashii están casi prohibidos los triples en 1/4 de diferente color pero ya ni estoy seguro que dice el criteria al respecto, asi que pasaré por alto esto. eso ya lo arregle hace tiempo XD
  
  01:17:139 - Borrar ... para reducir patrones largos de nuevo. ok

Oni

• 
  Hay como 5 o 6 partes donde tienes triples o streams 1/4 con nota grande al final, lo cual es bastante inusual de ver, asi que sería mejor arreglar esas partes sea dejando las notas grandes solas o en su defecto quitandolas... tienes razon creo que se utiliza mas en inner
  
  00:29:831 - Veo mas conveniente que esta parte sea ddddk ... hasta la 1ra nota suena igual que el resto de notas rojas. yo lo siento muy bien dejando triple en el centro (kdddk)
  
  00:42:331 - Siento que aqui falta una nota, posiblemente una d verdad
  
  00:43:100 - Cambia esta nota a K ... para combinarla con la anterior (00:42:533- ) nice
  
  00:43:677 - Lo mismo que en 00:29:831- bueno si alguien mas dice eso lo cambiare
  
  01:03:869 - Aquí también hace falta una nota, ese hueco suena extraño.
  01:10:023 - Lo mismo ^ aqui quiero dejar un pequeño descanso... suena bien por lo que terminando k en 01:09:831 (51)
  01:22:331 - Lo mismo ^

si algun punto aca ya fue mencionado ps sorry ... no tengo internet para nada y modeo offline .-. fue util

AikawaSora wrote:

Hi !

From my Modding queue. Super sorry for the delay. I couldn't open since I was tired recently from work.

For the NM request:

Focus:

* Patterns
* Checking for needed note removal or additional to maps.
* Simplicity of the map to make it playable for most players.

Don't hesitate to say anything if my mods aren't good as i'm also a total beginner at modding right now.
Feel free to reject any suggestions I have for this^^
Alright let's start this.

le mods~

Columns: 0|1|2|3

EZ

01:26:369 (86369|3) - Remove. For simplicity of EZ difficulty. you are right because it would be too much for easy

Nothing else needed to be modded here.

NM

01:09:062 - 01:09:831 - Just a suggestion. You can add notes here. Unless if you are really just following the vocals you can disregard that. ok

HD

00:22:331 - Add note to |0| for bass, unless you intend to keep it as single note but it wouldn't make sense since there are also double notes for bass as well. ok

00:25:408 - ^

00:28:485 - ^

00:34:254 - ^

00:34:639 - ^

00:37:331 - ^

00:40:408 - ^

00:40:792 - ^

00:42:331 - 2 notes here if you like. ok here if there rate so I modified some sections in that part

Sorry if HD dif looks like a redundant mod.

Calories

00:22:331 - Same as in HD. For Bass. better a note ok

00:25:408 - ^

00:28:485 - ^

00:34:254 - ^

00:34:639 - ^ but can also leave as is. ok

00:37:716 - ^

00:40:408 - ^

00:40:792 - ^

00:42:331 - ^

01:14:254 (74254|2) - move to |3| to make is more fun. nice

Queen

I find this map great already. Been testing it so many times and I thought it was fun to play. awesome patterns.

The hitsounds is simple and good. Layed out pretty nice so good job on that >w<)b

Here is the mods.
Hope this was helpful for you and sorry if most of it was redundant but I think you need to look at it more that way
Think twice about giving me kudos if this helped you or not. Good luck with ranking the map! Aikawa out do not worry was helpful

Ayyri wrote:

Hello~

M4M.

Keep in mind, these are my suggestions, don't change something I mentioned unless it seems good to you!

If I didn't make a box for something, that doesn't mean I didn't look at it. It just means I didn't find anything wrong with it.

Kantan

Change HP to 7. Seems odd to have it as 8 when the bpm is very slow. done
00:37:908 (7) - Change to K. There's a finish sound in the background here, and the vocal is more emphasized. mmm.. but the sound does not sound so loud so I will not change
00:50:600 (8) - ^
00:51:369 (9) - Change to D. There's a loud trumpet here. (If you apply both of these finishers, consider removing 00:50:985 (9) - ) sounds good

Futsuu

00:34:447 (2,3) - Delete. They sound weird without the vocals with them. Also the pattern they are a part of is kind of long. Seems best to simplify it a bit. nice
00:37:908 (8) - Change to K. Same reason as in Kantan. It doesn't make sense of 00:39:446 (10) - the voice sounds better imo

Muzukashii

00:27:908 (30) - Change to d. Fits the rhythm here better. ok
00:53:869 (32) - Delete. The pattern here is a bit long, this would help to simplify it. nice
01:09:446 - Could add a d here to start where the trumpet starts, rather than midway through it at 01:09:639 - ok

Oni

00:50:216 (20,21) - Change both to k's. They have a different pitch than 00:49:831 (18,19) - and make a good set up for the upcoming D. (Also matches the pattern after them.) nice

NM

01:20:985 (80985|2) - This note doesn't really sound needed. (Also kind of annoying to play since it's not mapped to a rather important sound.) in that part i hear a sound of dishes so i did not eliminate

I actually really like these mania difficulties. They're fun. :3 I'm glad you like ^^

Draftnell wrote:

oke M4M with https://osu.ppy.sh/s/460324

ok here my mod o/
[HD]
00:04:831 (4831|2) - delete ? i thinks here ghost note ok
00:05:023 - add this is missing ok
00:19:254 - add
00:45:985 - add
here 00:57:331 - until 00:57:908 - stream 1/4 lol but the sound is not as high... if someone else says the same thing I'm going to change

[Calories]
00:04:831 - here and 00:05:023 - same problem with HD fix
00:45:985 - umm add LN is better I modify some parts with Ln's
here 00:57:331 - until 00:57:716 - stream 1/4 lol

hmm that's all

Raediaufar wrote:

M4M (see your queue)

Take a note that my mod here is mostly for pitch and better playability. Won't add much reasons to every point of mod since I have said the reason here

[Oni]

click

00:10:601 (43,44,45) - I think it's not suit for alternate here, suggest to delete 00:10:696 (44) - ok

00:12:139 (53,54) - ctrl + G

00:12:524 (55,56,57) - kkk ? better kkd

00:13:677 (61,62,63) - ddk

00:22:139 - suggestion for this part https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/5321060 more fit to the rhythm nice

00:26:369 (26,27) - make alternate here, so add 00:26:466 - d here and change 00:26:562 (27) - to k so it's ddk

00:37:715 (23,24,25) - kkk

00:39:254 (30,31,32) - ddd

00:49:254 (15,16,17) - ddk

00:54:062 (41) - change to k

00:59:254 (68) - d

00:59:446 (69) - k

01:00:023 (71,72,73) - ddd

01:00:792 (76,1) - ctrl + G

01:01:946 (5,6,7) - kkk

01:01:946 (5,6,7) - ddk

01:02:523 (9) - k

01:07:331 (38,39,40) - kkk

01:08:677 (45) - delete, weird rhythm if this added

01:09:254 (47,48,49) - ddd

01:16:081 - add d, alternate is good here

01:17:235 (17) - delete, not sync if you alternate here

01:17:427 - add d here, I want to focus the alternate on "waku waku" sound, alternating just there is great

01:20:023 (28) - k

all accepted

[Muzukashii]

click

00:12:524 (32) - k

00:26:754 (24) - k, plays better ok

00:29:831 (36) - short slider? I think this is just useless. You can add d here 00:29:831 - and k here 00:30:216 - just ignore that drummy thing there, there's a vocal that you can map ok

00:34:254 (4,5) - ctrl + G mm... doesn't sound right

00:34:639 - add k, this feels really empty. If you apply this then delete 00:33:870 (2) - to make it more fit to the rhythm

00:59:062 (51) - k

01:03:196 (9) - move to 01:03:004 - I think better to start alternate there no... here i follow the trumpet

01:16:562 (13) - delete, seems offbeat here ok

01:16:754 - add d if you apply above ok

[Futsuu]

click

00:06:369 (9) - delete slider and add d here 00:06:369 - try to make a break for futsuu player, slider is annoying if it short and just after there's a note ok

00:49:062 - add d here I am doing rest for the following notes in 00:50:216 (7,8,9,10,11) and is well following the voice

00:52:042 (13) - delete, the snapping is just hard and better to make a break here nice

00:54:831 (17,18,19,20) - are you sure this on futsuu? you can make the don without finisher since imo this is too hard for futsuu diff you are right but I have seen that loud sounds if necessary but this map is much

00:56:946 (23,24) - and this d is without finisher as well keep

01:07:139 (13,14) - what with this awkward beat of sliders. I suggest http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/5321270 nice

01:26:177 (22,23,24,25) - I'm not sure about this on futsuu diff but I can't recommend anything :/ better delete a note

[Kantan]

click

00:16:369 (1) - delete this and add d here 00:16:369 - try to make a break here as the previous mod says the same thing as take away and add d as the previous mod says it will remove

00:41:369 (10) - delete, 5 series of notes here is not good for kantan ok

00:53:677 (13) - delete ok

Ochasan wrote:

hi~

here your request mod

MANIA MOD

MOD

Kiai
00:07:139 kiai too short, remove here feels well kiai shouts in 00:07:139 - so I'll keep

EZ and NM is clear for me~

HD
00:20:889 and other, just make this 1 part for 1/4 snap because is weight for advance player
00:25:216 - 00:37:523 - 00:40:600 - bass here?

Calories
00:07:331 to 00:19:446 just make little jack. for me the part should to be harder ok add some Ln's
01:09:927 ghost hitpoints (hear the song) snap 1/4
01:10:023 bass

Queen
00:36:706 too harder for read, just make it easy to read

METADATA
EZ : HP : 6
OD : 7
AR : 5

NM : HP : 7
OD : 8
AR : 6

HD : HP : 7,5
OD : 8
AR : 6

Calories : HP : 8
OD : 8
AR : 6

Queen : HP : 8,5
OD : 8
AR : 6

for metadata is checked, and that not change AiMod/not errorly fixed

thanks

Arkano036 wrote:

Oni
00:45:600 (60) -
En esta parte está ubicada una nota grande (finish), el cual no es usual en un mapa de oni que al final o inicio de un triple, tener un finish, no sería bueno para la vista y podría confundir. Buena observación no se porque puse triple ahí... lo dejo como d K lo escucho mejor así

Lo demás, excelente. Ty :3

[Shi-Ra] wrote:

Hello, there are mods for your mania chart ^w^ Hi !

Queen!

Inside :3

00:04:062 (4062|1,4062|2) - incorrect ending, these LNs should ends here 00:04:446 - according to the sound Fixed

00:06:273 (6273|3,6321|2) - there are no sound which you can clearly accent here so I recommend you to remove them (background sounds aren't a thing that you can accent in this way) I hear drum sounds here, but i'll consider

00:15:816 (15816|1) - misplaced note? I think you wanted to place it here 00:15:889 Fixed

00:49:254 (49254|2) - move to 1st column and then move this note 00:49:639 (49639|0) - to 3rd column, it'll be more suitable transition here without doublenoting, there are no sounds for jacks Nice, applied

00:57:716 - I suggest you to add note to 1st column accorging to the beat, i'll be comfortable to play too Added

01:06:754 - you can add a note here to 1st column too according to the beat like you did it in previous part Nice catch here, added

01:26:754 (86754|1,86946|2) - if you want to accent beat sounds here, there's no need to make LNs for them, I suggest you to replace them with single notes, it'll be more suitable here Ok, good point. Fixed

That's all here~ Thanks a lot for mod, it was really helpful! ^^
Good luck :3/

[Shi-Ra] wrote:

Hello, there are mods for your mania chart ^w^

Shi-Ra's Pattern Review:
(notice that columns are following like 0 1 2 3 for 4K diffs)

First of all I must say that you need to rename all of your mania diffs with custom diff names. They should look like EZ NM HD HD+ (for example). That's an important thing if you are going to qualify this mapset. Ok

EZ

Inside :3

00:05:216 (5216|3) - this long note is a bit hard for EZ diff with next going two simple notes here, I recommend you to replace it with single note too, it won't affect bad on the diff quality but will be easy enough for this diff You're right in that part is too much for a EZ

00:17:908 (17908|2) - I recommend you to move this note to 1st column, You can make a nice transition filling the 1st column (it was empty for last two tacts as I can see) Sure

00:18:677 (18677|2) - three notes ending for EZ diff is too much, I suggest you to remove this note due to easiest diff in this mapset Right

00:25:408 (25408|2) - move to 1st column, it'll be a bit harder to play jack note here but you can accent the beat correctly Nice

00:28:677 - I suggest you to end this part like you did it with notes here 00:25:600 - it fits the song very good Sure

00:30:985 (30985|2) - same thing with three notes, I recommend you to remove it Ok

00:49:254 (49254|2) - move to 00:49:062 - there's no beat here (if you're trying to follow vocal road then I must say that it's not a good idea for EZ diff, for HD it'll be ok) Correct

00:57:139 (57139|1) - I suggest you to move this note to 2nd column, previous note has another sound and you can't use jack here Fix

That's all for EZ diff~

NM

Inside :3

00:04:062 (4062|1) - move to 3rd column to make your pattern more hand balanced here Ok

00:10:408 - you can add a note here to 0 column according to the song, it looks like this note is missed Ok

00:13:485 - same situation here like above and same recommendation ^ Ok

00:19:062 - add note to 2nd column according to the beat Here it is for a short break but I will consider

00:21:754 - same recommendation as above, 2nd column please Ok

00:42:139 (42139|3) - I suggest you to move this note to 2nd column, it'll be more suitable with your previous and next going patterns here Ok

00:50:600 (50600|2) - move this LN to 0 column, then you can add a note here 00:51:177 - to 3rd column to follow the beat, it sounds clearly here, there's no need to ignore it not feeling well... I'll move to another column. Next so LN in 00:51:369 (51369|0) - and it can be a little difficult

Calories

Inside :3

00:03:677 (3677|2) - I suggest you to move this note to 3rd column to keep this pattern balanced, don't leave 3rd column empty here Nice

00:07:331 (7331|3) - move this note to 2nd column, it fits more with your next going note here according to the sound Ok

00:10:600 (10600|1) - move this one to 2nd column too, same reason as above Ok

00:18:966 (18966|0,19062|3) - there's no need to accent soft snare sound with two notes, it's not that loud, I recommend you to remove this notes to avoid overmapping Ok

00:20:889 (20889|3,20985|0) - same thing as above, keep an eye on such notes and please, fix the overmapped parts like this (where notes aren't loud enough to accent them with more than one note), overmapping isn't a good thing Fix

00:30:985 (30985|2) - you can remove this note to perform more comfortable transition with next going triplet, it's enough to use two notes+LN to accent all sounds here Ok

00:50:216 (50216|3,50408|3,50985|0,51177|0) - remove, there are only one bass kick sound, there's nothing to accent with two notes (especially if you're making them jacking) Ok and add more notes in the next section

01:27:139 (87139|1,87331|2) - I'm not sure about these LNs, especially where are they begin...there are no any clear sound which player cound hear so I recommend you to remove them or place at the same time with this LN 01:26:946 (86946|0) Fix

That's all here~
Good luck :3/ Thanks ^^

blackcow30 wrote:

[Shi-Ra] wrote:

Hello, there are mods for your mania chart ^w^ Hi !

Queen!

Inside :3

00:04:062 (4062|1,4062|2) - incorrect ending, these LNs should ends here 00:04:446 - according to the sound Fixed

00:06:273 (6273|3,6321|2) - there are no sound which you can clearly accent here so I recommend you to remove them (background sounds aren't a thing that you can accent in this way) I hear drum sounds here, but i'll consider

00:15:816 (15816|1) - misplaced note? I think you wanted to place it here 00:15:889 Fixed

00:49:254 (49254|2) - move to 1st column and then move this note 00:49:639 (49639|0) - to 3rd column, it'll be more suitable transition here without doublenoting, there are no sounds for jacks Nice, applied

00:57:716 - I suggest you to add note to 1st column accorging to the beat, i'll be comfortable to play too Added

01:06:754 - you can add a note here to 1st column too according to the beat like you did it in previous part Nice catch here, added

01:26:754 (86754|1,86946|2) - if you want to accent beat sounds here, there's no need to make LNs for them, I suggest you to replace them with single notes, it'll be more suitable here Ok, good point. Fixed

That's all here~ Thanks a lot for mod, it was really helpful! ^^
Good luck :3/

UPDATE

http://puu.sh/pw4Ak/7a2ee10090.osu

blackcow30 wrote:

Hola Etsu!
Hice una modificación muy pequeña al mapa, de un error que tenía. Aquí te dejo la update:

UPDATE

http://puu.sh/pzLHu/910ba79abd.osu

Soul Evans wrote:

Here is mod as requested from my queue
Will do HD+ sometime later on so for second post don't give me kodosu this one is plenty enough:

HD

00:06:754 move that note to 2~
00:06:850 that note to 1~
I think it plays out a little more smoothly like this /*the drums sound a bit random and almost similar... for now keep
00:13:292 move Note 3 to 4 /*Ok
00:18:966 move to 1 /*No
00:19:062 move to 2 /*Ok
00:19:254 move to 3/*Ok
00:20:600 move note 1 to 2
00:20:600 move not 3 to 4
00:20:792 move to note 3
00:20:889 move to note 2
00:20:985 move to note 1 for better drum transaction /*Yes
00:24:062 move that to 4
00:24:254 move that to 1
00:27:139 move that to 1
00:33:196 move to 3
00:33:292 move to 2
00:33:485 move that to 4
00:36:369 move to 4 /*Ok
00:45:600 Try rearranging patterns like this: /*It sounds good but i changed some notes column
00:56:369 same thing here : /*Same

jukkaduei wrote:

JUKKADUEI

From NM request

Column |0|1|2|3|

EZ

00:22:139 (22139|0,22523|1) - Ctrl + G /*Yes it sounds fine
00:34:446 (34446|3) - Move to column 0 /*Ok
00:37:523 (37523|0,37716|1,37908|2,37908|3) - Ctrl + H /*No
00:38:292 (38292|0) - Move to column 3 /*Ok

00:38:677 (38677|2) - Move to column 1
00:56:658 (56658|0) - Move to column 3
01:26:369 (86369|0) - Move to column 3 /*Ok

NM

00:10:600 (10600|0) - Move to column 1 /*Mmmm... The trumpets sound similar with00:10:408 (10408|0) -
00:13:677 (13677|3) - Move to column 2
00:16:369 (16369|1) - Move to column 2
00:16:754 - Add note in column 3
00:17:139 - Add note in column 1 /*I would be more but I will consider
00:38:292 - Add note in column 3 /*Ok
00:47:523 - Add note in column 2
00:49:831 - ^ /*Ok

HD

01:06:369 (66369|3) - Move to column 0 /*Ok
01:08:869 (68869|1,69062|0,69254|1,69446|0) - Ctrl + G /*Ok and remove a note

Good luck with your beatmap

Shinzo- wrote:

★ ★ ★ Mod for Mod ★ ★ ★

[Oni]

00:02:908 (6) - change this to k and 00:03:292 (7) - to D will be better imo //Ok
00:04:639 (10) - well i think the finisher should be here ? //Ok, and removed and delete the Finish K in next notes
00:09:831 (40,41) - Ctrl G for pitch ? //Nice
00:11:947 (52) - Ctrl G this and change 00:12:331 (54) - into k for flow (00:08:677 (33,34,35,36) - ) //No for control g but i changed some notes i did not like
00:15:216 (70) - change to d for pitch //Yes
00:16:369 (77) - you can change this to d or maybe make 00:15:985 (75,76,77) - into kdd for the pitch //Ok
00:17:235 - you must be missing a note here, seriously you better add, 00:16:754 (78,79,80,81,82) - feels too awkward imo also 00:17:042 (80) - i don't know what sound that you layer, and i suggest to move that to 00:16:658 - and 00:17:331 (81) - move to 00:17:139 - and then add note on 00:17:427 - well i think it's good xD but i think you gonna reject this so... idk //I'm leaving here 1/1 space to have more attention in the next note and combines well with bass in 00:16:754 (78,79,80) - (apply a note but some do not)
00:20:889 (98) - change to k? //No
00:43:773 (49) - change to k? since 00:43:869 (50,51) - has a drum so it think better make it diffrent //Better remove not sound rhythm and combines well with voice and instruments
00:49:350 (16,17) - welp better to Ctrl G ? for pitch.. also for flow 00:46:946 (4,5,6) - //Ok
00:55:408 (47,48,49) - kkd? i think it's better for pitch and prevent boringness //Ok
01:07:139 (37) - add finisher ? //Ok
01:08:004 - no more something like 01:02:812 (10) - ? //Yes
01:08:869 - maybe you should a dd a note here ? there's a finisher .. and the trumpet //Yes
01:13:677 (2,3) - Ctrl G ? //Ok
01:19:446 (26) - add finisher ? same like 01:19:446 (26) - //Ok

[Muzukashii]

00:04:639 (5) - i think the finish is here lol, but hey you do it too on Oni, i think you gonna reject this one //I do not know what happened there xd
00:09:254 (19) - change to d? for pitch //Ok
00:15:985 (46,47) - Ctrl G ? //Ok
00:32:716 (48,49) - Ctrl G and 00:33:100 (50,51,52) - kkk? well just a suggestion but if you accept this, then maybe 00:35:793 (10,11,12,13,14) - this one tho... actually this sugestion just for make the pattern didn't monotone //Nice
00:40:600 (31) - this or 00:40:792 (32) - this change to d ? //Ok
00:41:754 (35,36) - Ctrl G ? //Ok
00:50:985 (20) - change this to k or 00:51:369 (21) - to K for consistency pattern //I like the second option
01:10:793 (39) - move to 01:10:985 - better since 01:10:600 (38) - likea finish sound, i think it's more consistent tho //Ok

[Futsuu]

00:04:831 (5) - srsly feels like a wrong snap xD //Ok better move in 00:04:639 - xD
00:12:139 (20) - change to k? for flow 00:08:677 (13,14,15) - //Yes
00:37:523 (7) - change to d? //Ok
00:44:446 (18,19) - ctrl G since the sound is diffrent in 00:44:446 - and i think it will be a nice flow with 00:47:139 (2,3,4) - //Ok
00:56:369 (20,21,22,23) - isn't it too hard ? o.o //Lol I did not know what it was Futsuu notes as the pace is very high xd
01:27:139 (1) - delete and 01:26:946 (24) - change into spinner.... maybe //It does not sit well with the pace but i will consider

[Kantan]

00:13:292 (19,21) - what about Ctrl G ? //Ok
00:17:908 (26,27,28) - KDK is really better for pitch imo, also 00:15:600 (23,24,25) - //Mmm... no, It sounds good for the trumpet in 00:18:292 (27) -
00:22:523 (2) - k for flow ? //No

ok sorry if it not really help xD im still not good at modding taiko hehe xD //It is not so bad for me xD
Good Luck >w< //Thanks ^^

AlisceaSparku wrote:

[Cow's HD+]

00:05:216 - I suggest another pair of sliders here. Uhm, i'm mapping drum sounds in that part, but i'll consider it

I don't really find anything else, but if you mind things like 00:59:062 (59062|0,59254|0,59446|0,59639|0) - , you may want to rearrange those because too much jacks can make other columns vacant. If you do mind, there are several of these so you may want to mind that. Also consider this as a general mod :p Nice catch. Rearranged

That's it!
I hope my mod helps >w<
Good luck with your map!

Soul Evans wrote:

HD+

00:09:639 (9639|3) - This needs to be at 3 I'm following pitch relevance, so no
and 00:09:831 (9831|1) - Needs to be at 4 ^
It feels like it would go smoother that way for the LN's
00:13:292 (13292|2) - move to 3 (for flow) Ok
00:16:562 (16562|1,16658|3,16754|1,16754|0,16850|3,16946|0) - Maybe make patterns like this for consistency?
Ok, rearranged
00:19:014 (19014|2,19062|3) - reverse this pattern Nope, I think it can be uncomfortable to play
00:28:869 (28869|3) - move that note to 4 Ok
00:28:966 (28966|1,29014|0) - reverse that No (same reason as before)
00:29:831 - number 4 move to 1 I think this part is good already, i'll consider it
00:29:927 (29927|3) - move to 4 ^
00:30:119 (30119|0) - move to 1 ^
00:30:216 (30216|0,30216|2) - move 1 and 3 to 2 and 4 ^
00:33:485 (33485|3) - move to 4 Ok
00:34:062 (34062|3) - move to 4 Uhm... No. That notes are placed according to pitch relevance
00:34:062 (34062|0) - move to 1 ^
00:34:446 (34446|3) - move to 4 ^

AlisceaSparku wrote:

Hello, Etsu~
Aliscea here, from TechNoir's Neo-Plaza Mania Modding Queue!
NM Mod as requested!

*Please note that the mod inside this spoilerbox are only my suggestions and you are free to reject them. Just explain the reason why you rejected them so that I can learn more about your mapping style

*I also tend to give wrong screenshots, so kindly inform me if I did send a wrong screenshot xD

*If I suggested something like ctrl+g, please remember to take care of the hitsounds :p

Columns: 1/2/3/4

[NM]

00:00:600 (600|0,792|1,985|2) - I suggest to do ctrl+h so 00:00:985 - will have a [1][4] pattern that could put emphasis for the cymbal sound. //Done

00:04:062 (4062|0,4639|1) - move to the right by one column, so 00:04:062 (4062|0) - will not jack with 00:03:677 (3677|0) - . //Applied

00:04:639 - add a note for the cymbal. It's to be consistent with 00:04:062 - in terms of note counts. Also apply this mod at 00:05:216 - . //Yes

00:05:023 - very audible sound here. I suggest adding a note. //Ok

00:17:523 - http://puu.sh/pEiPD/eb1ffcfe76.jpg
> In this suggestion, the first highlighted note from the bottom is just for balance for the notes after it.
> The [2][3] pattern could really fit well with the drum sound, because it sounds "compact".
> The [1][4] slider pattern could put emphasis on the cymbal and pitch higher than 00:17:908 - .
> The final [2][3] pattern is repeated, to clearly show that the same sound will play again. //Applied it sounds nice

00:22:331 - I suggest adding a note here also. Really, really audible sound. ( unless you focus too much on the vocals then this suggestion and the few below this are optional. ). Note that there are also other very audible sounds played in the song, so you may want to look out for that. //You're right it and it feels a nice beat

00:24:831 - I assume the drum sound here is supposed to be mapped? ( it's the same consistency with 00:21:754 (21754|2,22139|1) - ). //Correct

00:27:716 (27716|2) - move to 2 for balance and to avoid the jacked note above it. //Ok

00:57:139 (57139|2) - to 1 please. For balance and comfortability. Also, you could make a 1/2 jack at 00:57:331 - and 00:57:523 - for that repeated sound ( idk what it is called ;w; ) //It is somewhat confusing but i will consider

00:57:908 - for the kiai time, you could focus more to the vocals, since the whole kiai is about 99% for the vocals. What I mean is, put sliders like in 00:58:292 - , etc. //You're right but i think it is a bit difficult to follow the background vocals too ... if someone says the same thing i will change

01:26:946 - add a note at 2, to be consistent with 01:26:369 - in terms of note counts. //Ok

01:14:062 (74062|2) - to 4, for balance and comfortability. //Yes

//*General Mod
//+- Vocal Mapping://+I think I am starting to be fond of vocal mapping because the sliders for the vocals in this difficulty is well built. //- however, vocal mapping can let you miss very, very important sounds and may cause inconsistencies. I mentioned some above so you might want to take a look. //Yes This map leads with voice although it is difficult to map voices combined with the instrument but I'm slowly learning to improve

//+ Patterns: There are many variations in this difficult in terms of patterns. Good job!:D //Thanks

[HD]

00:27:331 (27331|1) - move to 3 for balance. //Ok

00:30:600 (30600|1) - move to 4 to avoid 4 jacks ( specifically 00:29:927 (29927|1,30216|1,30600|1,30985|1) - ). BUT then fourth column will have 4 jacks so ctrl+g 00:30:985 (30985|3,31177|2) - so the last 2 columns in that short stream will put more emphasis on the drum sound. //Correct

00:34:254 - add a note, to be consistent with 00:34:639 - in terms of note counts. ( if the doubles are meant for the kick ) //Nice

00:50:600 - add a note at 1 to emphasize that trumpet //Done

00:51:369 - ^, but to 4. //^

00:57:908 - for the kiai, all I can say is that there are inconsistencies in terms of note counts. I'm not sure if you are following the bell sound only or the vocals, because it feels so random. An example is 01:10:985 - has two notes but at 00:58:677 - only has one. I don't think it happened in the other places, but take this as a general mod :p. //Ahah good point not know why but i think he was excited by putting more notes ... but I'll fix sections of kiai xD

That's it!
I hope my mod helps >w<
Good luck with your map! Thanks ^^

blackcow30 wrote:

AlisceaSparku wrote:

[Cow's HD+]

00:05:216 - I suggest another pair of sliders here. Uhm, i'm mapping drum sounds in that part, but i'll consider it

I don't really find anything else, but if you mind things like 00:59:062 (59062|0,59254|0,59446|0,59639|0) - , you may want to rearrange those because too much jacks can make other columns vacant. If you do mind, there are several of these so you may want to mind that. Also consider this as a general mod :p Nice catch. Rearranged

That's it!
I hope my mod helps >w<
Good luck with your map!

Thanks for modding, Aliscea!

Soul Evans wrote:

HD+

00:09:639 (9639|3) - This needs to be at 3 I'm following pitch relevance, so no
and 00:09:831 (9831|1) - Needs to be at 4 ^
It feels like it would go smoother that way for the LN's
00:13:292 (13292|2) - move to 3 (for flow) Ok
00:16:562 (16562|1,16658|3,16754|1,16754|0,16850|3,16946|0) - Maybe make patterns like this for consistency?
Ok, rearranged
00:19:014 (19014|2,19062|3) - reverse this pattern Nope, I think it can be uncomfortable to play
00:28:869 (28869|3) - move that note to 4 Ok
00:28:966 (28966|1,29014|0) - reverse that No (same reason as before)
00:29:831 - number 4 move to 1 I think this part is good already, i'll consider it
00:29:927 (29927|3) - move to 4 ^
00:30:119 (30119|0) - move to 1 ^
00:30:216 (30216|0,30216|2) - move 1 and 3 to 2 and 4 ^
00:33:485 (33485|3) - move to 4 Ok
00:34:062 (34062|3) - move to 4 Uhm... No. That notes are placed according to pitch relevance
00:34:062 (34062|0) - move to 1 ^
00:34:446 (34446|3) - move to 4 ^

Thanks for modding, Soul!

UPDATE

http://puu.sh/pEZD8/16325bda1e.osu

Nyan wrote:

[Kantan]

is fine ty

[Futsuu]

01:03:100 - add a kat /*Better 1/1 and add note in 01:03:677 - (Little uncomfortable the instrument and voice imo)

[Muzukashii]

00:04:062 (4,5,6,7) - D__Dk_D /*Yes kat is not as strong

[Oni]

00:43:773 - add a don /*Better kat (Little little loud sound)
00:58:196 - add a kat /*Ok he heard a tap guitar
01:10:504 - add a kat /*^
01:21:273 - add a kat /*Ok

cikra wrote:

harro~
Columns: 1|2|3|4

EZ

00:40:985 - Add a note for consistency with pattern /*Double you mean? can be

NM

00:24:831 - Add a note for consistency with pattern
00:37:139 - ^
00:38:677 - ^
00:40:216 - ^ /*All was arranged xd

HD

All's good! /*Ty

Fun map to play~ /*Yes :3
Good luck on your map! /*Thanks

- R e b a - wrote:

Hello there, came from Team Symphony Mania Modding Queue

Columns : | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 |

[HD]
00:05:600 (5600|3,5985|3) - el numero de notas en estos dos tiempos deberian de ser iguales, te recomiendo a agregar una nota en la colmna 2 00:05:600 y 00:05:985 (5985|0) - mover esto a la columna dos /*Se siente bien y mejor balance pero mejor como yo lo tengo, ya que al apretar teclas 1|4 combina bien con el vocal... pero voy a considerar
00:26:946 (26946|3) - mueve esto a 2 /*No se siente muy dificil xd
00:27:042 (27042|1) - esto a 4
00:29:831 (29831|0,29927|1,30023|3) - cambialo asi : http://puu.sh/pNs2B/45e4cdbea5.jpg /*Buena sugerencia por los golpes de los tambores que te hace seguir en la misma columna... pero mejor en todas las columna para poco dificil (poco aleatorio) asi que por ahora lo dejo asi pero voy a tomar en cuenta
00:31:369 (31369|0) - mueve esto a la columna 4 /*No
00:31:562 (31562|1) - esto a 1
00:36:273 (36273|2,36369|3) - que tal esto http://puu.sh/pNs6s/0f69752fba.jpg /*Yes
00:47:139 (47139|1) - hay un finish sound, deberia de tener 3 notas, y que tal si cambias estos LNs 00:46:177 (46177|2,46177|0,46177|1) - asi : http://puu.sh/pNsbt/c6a79061f5.jpg /*Aplique el hitsound pero los Ln lo dejo asi por que sigo el "heyhey" hace que el mapa sea divertido imo
01:00:600 (60600|3) - falto una nota aqui, agrega una nota en la columna 1 /*Ya estaba agregado xd


mi mod termina aqui :v suerte /*ty

cikra wrote:

Cow's HD

00:19:014 (19014|2,19062|3) - move to 2 3? feels more natural Ok, good point
00:46:754 - to 00:47:139 - maybe 14 23 pattern would be better for playability Nice. Rearranged
01:03:389 (63389|3,63485|2) - Ctrl+J for hand balance/playability Nope, I'm following trumpet melody with those jacks

Fun map to play~
Good luck on your map!

blackcow30 wrote:

cikra wrote:

UPDATE

http://puu.sh/pO4El/ff8b534fa1.osu

Protastic101 wrote:

Here from my queue or whatever.

Column 1|2|3|4

*drops mod and leaves*

[General]- + in difficulty names is unrankable, so change Cow's HD+ to MX /*Sure? I've seen ranked maps that add "+" by the GD... i would not change it for now
- HP of EZ is probably too low for the note to LN ratio, so increase it to ~7?
- OD of NM is too high for the low density of notes, so reduce it to ~7.
- I'd consider HP and OD ~7.5 for HD for close to the same reasons as above. /*Fixed all

[EZ]
00:02:523 (2523|2) - This ends at 00:03:292 /*Yes
00:03:292 (3292|3) - and this ends at 00:03:869 /*^
00:05:216 (5216|3) - Make this an LN because it's the same brass sound as 00:04:639 (4639|1) End at 00:05:600 /*Correct
00:16:754 - 00:17:139 - I feel like not having notes here for the drum kicks breaks the flow and steady 1/1 rhythm you had here because it goes from 1/1 notes to a sudden 3/1 break when the music hasn't changed much except for the addition of a louder brass. /*But if added notes would be difficult for the LN... i will consider
00:19:062 - 00:19:062 - Also, consider adding notes here for the drums to lead into the first verse of the song. /*Ok
00:22:523 (22523|0,22523|2) - Remove a note because there's no crash here. /*Keep, It mixes well also the sound of an instrument
00:28:485 - Add a note in 3 for the kick? /*Yes it feels good
00:30:600 - add a note here for the crash. /*Ok
00:34:831 (34831|2,34831|1) - Remove note because there's no emphasis in the music here. /*Yes
00:38:292 (38292|3) - I don't really see a reason for this to be jacked with 00:37:908 (37908|3) and also because you don't use any jacks elsewhere in the measure, so move this to 3? /*Sure

[NM]
00:25:408 - Add a note here in 1 because you mapped the same sound as a double at 00:22:331 /*Yes
00:50:216 (50216|2,50408|3) - Why not try jacking these two notes together because they're the same kicks? /*You're right
00:50:985 (50985|3,51177|2) - ^^
00:52:331 (52331|0,52427|1,52523|2) - I understand you're mapping to vocals here, but I think it'd be better to ignore the vocal here and use this roll to represent the drumroll at 00:52:716 because that's more what the player would expect, as opposed to vocal mapping. /*Ok, would mini staircase...
00:55:119 (55119|3,55119|2,55889|2,55889|3) - I'd consider turning one of these notes into an LN ending at 00:55:408 - 00:56:177 - respectively for the trumpet. /*Yes

[HD]00:10:216 (10216|3,10216|0,10216|2) - No need for a triple here if there's no emphasis in the music like a crash. I'll shut up about these now since I've been nagging you about it since the EZ diff XD /*I think it would be essential for the secondary rate imo xd
00:15:985 - Why isn't there a double here for the kick or whatever? /*Fixed

[General Comments and feedback]Alright, the only thing I'd really look out for is your difficulty gap between HD and HD+. I'm not saying that in terms of SR, but more about the rhythm and structure of each diff. In HD, 1/4 is scattered and only used a little, whereas HD+ has full 2 measure long bursts of 1/4 and even includes 1/8 rolls, which are completely fine, but if a player were to try and go from HD to HD+, they would find themselves very ill prepared. My suggestion is to up the amount of 1/4 used in HD at places like 00:43:966 and 00:45:889 and 00:47:619 to name a few examples. This way, players are already somewhat familiar with how the 1/4 notes are used in this mapset, and be better able to play HD+. /*I had not thought of that :d. Start analyze the structure and familiarize yourself with the following diff... I thank you for taking note of this

Most of the stuff I generally write down here, I wrote in the box, so end of mod I guess. Good luck. /*Ty very good your suggestion ^^

Loctav wrote:

what is an Easy+ please? We nuked the existence of these kind of diff names for ages. Is it an Easy? or a Normal? Please decide. Then I can give you an evaluation on that.

Protastic101 wrote:

Yes, I apologize for having to be "that" person, but + difficulty names are unrankable. To quote Loctav here

Loctav wrote:

what is an Easy+ please? We nuked the existence of these kind of diff names for ages. Is it an Easy? or a Normal? Please decide. Then I can give you an evaluation on that.

taken from his post at Underjoy's Kakuzetsu Thanatos p/4841822/

_kumakichi wrote:

hi

it's a short mod since there's pretty much nothing to change after so many mods

timing

try offset 1005? /* Tried but at the last second comes forward a little... will try again to capture the rhythm

futsuu

00:29:831 (17) - d->k, maybe it fits better to vocal /*Ok
01:26:946 (25) - replace with 1 spinner as in kantan. more suitable for a futsuu imo /*Yes, I think the same as it was uncomfortable for futsuu

muzu

00:50:216 (18,19,20,21,22,23,24,25,26,27) - i like this part~ /*
00:30:119 (38) - delete. 5-lets (sorry for this coined term) are too difficult for a muzu map, especially when not monochromatic (i forgot the actual term....i mean sth like ddddd)... ddd k is enough imo /*Fixed
01:05:985 (22) - d->k. as i observed you were following the vocal, so you might want to stick with vocal here (a higher pitch) too. Another idea is to make it a kkk triplet, but it might deviate too much from the map style. /*Yes
01:07:716 (29) - d->k. imo kdd ddd has too many d. since you did not follow the drums strictly in the first place (if i did not mis-read), adding a k would sound better /*Ok

oni

i feel that oni works perfectly fine, just two suggestions to add more variation (please feel free to ignore them)
00:10:408 (41,42,43,44,45,46,47,48,49,50) - kdd can be replaced by kkd in this part as it sounds more natural and echoes with 00:07:139 (23,24,25,26,27,28,29,30,31,32,33) - (ddk d k ddk d <-> kkd k d kkd k) /*Fixed, it is a good suggestion
01:08:004 (40,41,42,43) - xdk d k -> dk dd k /*keep, since no sound in 01:08:409 - ... although it could follow the rhythm mapping so i will consider

good luck~

Protastic101 wrote:

Here from my queue or whatever.


[HD+]00:36:754 (36754|1,37139|0) - I suggest control H and shifting to the left so the LN is in 4 and the note in 3. Then, move 00:36:658 (36658|0) to 2 Reason is because this kind of note placement for 1/8 is a little uncomfortable to hit because 00:36:369 (36369|3,36706|2,36754|3) the release of the LN, plus the note in 3 and then note in 4 makes it kind of like a one handed 1/8 minitrill. Uhm... Applied from another perspective
00:53:773 (53773|1) - This is a ghost note, so remove? That isn't a ghost note. There's a bass sound
00:53:485 (53485|0,53485|3,53869|0,53869|3) - Also, why are these doubles when the only sound they have are hihat clicks? Fixed
01:07:331 (67331|2,67331|3) - ^^ Fixed

blackcow30 wrote:

HD+

Protastic101 wrote:

[+ difficulty names are unrankable.

I don't think so. There are some ranked maps with "HD+"
http://osu.ppy.sh/b/736929
http://osu.ppy.sh/b/800539
http://osu.ppy.sh/b/408082
http://osu.ppy.sh/b/525200
http://osu.ppy.sh/b/391595
I will not give more examples, but "HD+" is completely rankable.I don't see a rule that says " '+' is unrankable " :p

blackcow30 wrote:

UPDATE

http://puu.sh/pTSOk/8718ddc5e7.osu

[Baim] wrote:

hi etsu mod here , sorry for long delay ._.

General

Artist: Right
Title: Right
Source: Right
Tags: Right
AiMod: Right
Background: Right
BPM/Offset: Right
mp3/Hitsounds: /*It is still in process :s
Other: -

NM

00:02:523 (2523|2,2908|3,3677|0,4062|1,4639|0) - this , how about follow the vocal anf change thme into LN , since you following the vocal pattern /*It was combined with the trumpets... I will consider (column changes)
00:07:139 (7139|1,7523|1,7908|1,8292|1,8677|1) - hei ._. , re-arrange please /*Fixed
00:40:985 (40985|1,41369|2,41754|1,42139|0) - change into LN since the vocal is so long /*Ok, but in some
01:00:985 (60985|2,61369|1,61754|2,62139|3,62523|1) - ^ /*Yes, it feels nice
01:13:292 (73292|1,73677|2,74062|0,74446|1,74831|2) - ^
01:26:754 (86754|0) - move to 3 (col 1 2 3 4) , avoid jack with this 01:26:946 (86946|0) - /*Ok

Ok Good luck x3 !! /*ty ^^

Baim wrote:

MX

00:09:639 (9639|3,9831|1,10023|0) - i think the LN end here 00:10:216 - Fixed
00:13:292 (13292|1,13292|3) - how about add note for finish? since this the hardest diff Uhm... nope.
00:09:446 (9446|2,9446|3,9446|0) - 2 notes is enough, there not have finish sound Ok
00:44:062 (44062|3,44062|2) - add one for finish Ok
00:47:139 (47139|3,47139|0) - ^ ^
00:50:600 (50600|1,50600|3,51369|2,51369|0) - ^ ^
00:57:139 (57139|1,57139|2) - add note , the sound same as 00:56:658 (56658|0,56658|1,56658|2,56946|2,56946|3,56946|1) - Ok
01:11:754 (71754|3,71754|2,71754|1) - 2 notes is enough Ok
01:17:908 (77908|0,77908|3,77908|2) - 2 notes is enoughNo. There's a strong beat, and a trumpet (LN) sound

blackcow30 wrote:

UPDATE

http://puu.sh/pYJk4/5d47447d43.osu

Lenfried- wrote:

will mod once baim's mod is applied, wont ninja

Lenfried- wrote:

hi hi ^^ Hi!

mx

00:14:831 (14831|2) - move to 2 because of long stack at column 3 Ok
00:53:100 - feels empty not adding a note here, preferably at 3 Added
01:02:716 (62716|1,62812|2) - ctrl h to avoid long stack Ok
01:03:389 (63389|3) - if this jack is not PR-ed move this to 2 for equal distribution of stress to the left and right hand Good point, i'll consider it
01:13:581 (73581|2,73677|3,73773|2) - swap columns because yeah, stacks Ok

Good luck!

Lenfried- wrote:

hi hi ^^

sorry for late mod D: /*do not worry no trouble :p

hd

00:10:023 (10023|2,10216|2) - with this being jacked, you should jack this too 00:13:100 (13100|2,13292|3,13292|0,13292|1) -
00:16:177 (16177|3,16369|1,16369|2,16369|0) - likewise, if not, then don't jack
01:25:408 (85408|3) - move to 3, more balanced and has a better flow /*Fixed all

Good luck! /*ty ^^

blackcow30 wrote:

UPDATE

http://puu.sh/q1KMU/8d99bc284c.osu

1. 00:58:292 (19) - and 01:10:600 (17) - use k to be consistent with 00:59:446 (21,22,23) -

1. 00:58:292 (24) - and 01:10:600 (19) - same as Kantan's suggestion

1. 00:33:100 (51,52,53) - ddd (similar to 00:20:792 (66,67,68) - ); I also want to limit kkk in this part since this section is realtively quiet
2. 00:46:562 (2,3,4,5) - kkdd or kddk (mapping more to vocals in these parts)
3. 00:50:216 (18,19,20,21) - dKdK and delete 00:51:562 (22) - (you're possibly mapping to vocals here, but I feel this fits so much better) Alternatively you can go with your Futsuu's kKdD.
4. 00:57:908 (46,47,48,49,50,51,52,53,54) - should be the same as 01:10:216 (37,38,39,40,41,42,43) - or at least the same beat, since the song sounds the same in these parts. If you took the suggestions from Kantan/Futsuu, then I would also suggest somehow putting a kat note at 00:58:292 - and 01:10:600 - .

1. AIMod lists an unsnapped object - please check that.
2. 00:16:850 (77) - move back 1/4 tick, to 00:16:754 - . I was going to question why the notes were a bit "uneven" here but then realized you were following that trumpet at 00:16:658 - . This adjustment seems to match better.
3. 00:57:908 (57,58,59,60,61,62,63,64,65,66) - similar advice from Muzukashii (make same/similar to 01:10:216 (51,52,53,54,55,56,57,58,59,60,61) - )

1. 00:34:831 - two-key note?
2. 01:19:446 (79446|3) - end of this note is too close to 01:20:023 (80023|1) - ; I suggest truncating the end by 1/4 beat

1. 00:04:639 - add another key to be consistent with 00:04:062 - which has two keys.
2. 00:07:331 (7331|1) - move from col 1 to col 3; that way there would be two notes in same column, which would be consistent with 00:10:408 (10408|0,10600|0) - and 00:13:485 (13485|3,13677|3) - .

1. Overall pretty good, though I do question why 00:59:639 (59639|3) - is not 1/4 tick forward to be consistent with the spacing at 00:58:196 (58196|2,58292|0,58292|1) - (also similar remark for 01:11:946 (71946|1) - ), since the instrumentals/vocals sound about the same here.

1. Add a note at 01:09:735 - in col 1 for a trumpet sound, then move 01:09:831 (69831|1) - to col 0.

Narwhal Prime wrote:

Hi Etsu and blackcow30, here's a mod from my GIVE ME ANYTHING queue!

| 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 |

[Kantan]

1. 00:58:292 (19) - and 01:10:600 (17) - use k to be consistent with 00:59:446 (21,22,23) - /*here I am following the rhythm and sounds good when begins the kiai for this diff ... and I'm trying to assign don, because much kat will be difficult for the novice and also affects the SR for Kantan

[Futsuu]

1. 00:58:292 (24) - and 01:10:600 (19) - same as Kantan's suggestion /*yes sounds good, here if i can

[Muzukashii]

1. 00:33:100 (51,52,53) - ddd (similar to 00:20:792 (66,67,68) - ); I also want to limit kkk in this part since this section is realtively quiet /*yes
2. 00:46:562 (2,3,4,5) - kkdd or kddk (mapping more to vocals in these parts) /*better kkdd
3. 00:50:216 (18,19,20,21) - dKdK and delete 00:51:562 (22) - (you're possibly mapping to vocals here, but I feel this fits so much better) Alternatively you can go with your Futsuu's kKdD. /*I made some change in that part because it was not as some colors but keep note in 00:51:754 (24) - as it feels empty imo
4. 00:57:908 (46,47,48,49,50,51,52,53,54) - should be the same as 01:10:216 (37,38,39,40,41,42,43) - or at least the same beat, since the song sounds the same in these parts. If you took the suggestions from Kantan/Futsuu, then I would also suggest somehow putting a kat note at 00:58:292 - and 01:10:600 - . /*yes

[Oni]

1. AIMod lists an unsnapped object - please check that. /*Fixed
2. 00:16:850 (77) - move back 1/4 tick, to 00:16:754 - . I was going to question why the notes were a bit "uneven" here but then realized you were following that trumpet at 00:16:658 - . This adjustment seems to match better. /*correct
3. 00:57:908 (57,58,59,60,61,62,63,64,65,66) - similar advice from Muzukashii (make same/similar to 01:10:216 (51,52,53,54,55,56,57,58,59,60,61) - ) /*yes

[EZ]

1. 00:34:831 - two-key note? /*yes he heard a knock
2. 01:19:446 (79446|3) - end of this note is too close to 01:20:023 (80023|1) - ; I suggest truncating the end by 1/4 beat /*I'm following the voice but i'll delete this note 01:19:937 -

[NM]

1. 00:04:639 - add another key to be consistent with 00:04:062 - which has two keys. /*ok
2. 00:07:331 (7331|1) - move from col 1 to col 3; that way there would be two notes in same column, which would be consistent with 00:10:408 (10408|0,10600|0) - and 00:13:485 (13485|3,13677|3) - . /*fixed

[HD]

1. Overall pretty good, though I do question why 00:59:639 (59639|3) - is not 1/4 tick forward to be consistent with the spacing at 00:58:196 (58196|2,58292|0,58292|1) - (also similar remark for 01:11:946 (71946|1) - ), since the instrumentals/vocals sound about the same here. /*I hear loud chords but it seems you're right so it also confuses, but for now i do not change

Solid work overall! Now I have "calorie queen" stuck in my head. Good luck with ranking! /*ty ^^

Regards,
NP

Narwhal Prime wrote:

Hi Etsu and blackcow30, here's a mod from my GIVE ME ANYTHING queue! Hi Narwhal!

| 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 |


[Cow's MX]

1. Add a note at 01:09:735 - in col 1 for a trumpet sound, then move 01:09:831 (69831|1) - to col 0. There's a LN for that trumpet sound.

Regards,
NP

blackcow30 wrote:

Btw, Etsu, I can't see the BG in mania diffs. D: