1. 00:39:974 (2,4,5,6) - Stack properly.
2. 00:44:374 (1) - NC, big white tick and it seems like a good place for a NC
3. 01:24:373 - Lower the hitsound volume here? I think it is a bit high.
4. 01:49:573 - Here you must mute it, since it lands on no beat.
5. 01:56:373 (1,2,3) - Try to make the spacing perfect here, and for some reason it looks weird, I am really not sure why.
6. Also, I think you should lower the hitsound from 01:49:973, since this part is slow and relaxed (I recommend lowering SV as well)
7. 01:51:173 (1) - This slider doesn't follow the vocals precisely, try to fix it because there's no beat there.
8. 02:05:706 (1) - It is too close to the previous slider, it looks a bit annoying and since the song gets a bit more intense here you should move it away from it.
9. 03:33:571 (5,6,7) - Spacing.
10. 03:55:171 (2,3,4) - I think both blankets can be improved a bit here.
11. You can also gradually lower the volume of hitsounds towards the end so it will be nicer.

Avishay wrote:

Heyo!

[Right Back]

1. 00:39:974 (2,4,5,6) - Stack properly. Done
2. 00:44:374 (1) - NC, big white tick and it seems like a good place for a NC done
3. 01:24:373 - Lower the hitsound volume here? I think it is a bit high. Its okay
4. 01:49:573 - Here you must mute it, since it lands on no beat. Ill change it if more people will point that out
5. 01:56:373 (1,2,3) - Try to make the spacing perfect here, and for some reason it looks weird, I am really not sure why. I think its okay
6. Also, I think you should lower the hitsound from 01:49:973, since this part is slow and relaxed (I recommend lowering SV as well) No need to
7. 01:51:173 (1) - This slider doesn't follow the vocals precisely, try to fix it because there's no beat there. fixed
8. 02:05:706 (1) - It is too close to the previous slider, it looks a bit annoying and since the song gets a bit more intense here you should move it away from it. I think its fine. Its not overlaping or anything like that.
9. 03:33:571 (5,6,7) - Spacing. fixed
10. 03:55:171 (2,3,4) - I think both blankets can be improved a bit here. done
11. You can also gradually lower the volume of hitsounds towards the end so it will be nicer.

The map is great, there weren't too many problems, I hope it is fine that I mod just one diff. Thank you very much :3 And it is okay

1. 02:09:774 (2) - Make it a better blanket. move 2nd dot to x:303 y:201 - 3rd dot to x:263 y:255
2. 02:11:974 (6) - Make it straight with 02:11:374 (5) - . Move 02:11:973 (6) - 1st dot to x:334 y:150 - 2nd dot to x:264 y:153
3. 03:32:372 (1) - reapir this blanket. move 2nd dot to x:370 y:62 - 3rd dot to x:308 y:115
4. 04:13:972 (1,2,3) - Uh... I don't like this triangle. move 04:14:772 (3) - to x:213 y:211
5. ^If Ok.... make 04:14:772 (3) - a better blanket. move 2nd dot to x:265 y:228 - 3rd dot to x:323 y:191
6. ^If Ok.... move 04:15:972 (5) - to x:143 y:200

1. 00:24:774 (9) - Just use 1/4...
2. 01:16:773 (4) - this note should be at 01:16:873. move it to stack with 01:16:973 (5) -

Fantastica wrote:

Hi~
a mod come from my queue :3
as requested I'm only mod 2 diffs

[Normal]

1. 02:09:774 (2) - Make it a better blanket. move 2nd dot to x:303 y:201 - 3rd dot to x:263 y:255 Done
2. 02:11:974 (6) - Make it straight with 02:11:374 (5) - . Move 02:11:973 (6) - 1st dot to x:334 y:150 - 2nd dot to x:264 y:153 done
3. 03:32:372 (1) - reapir this blanket. move 2nd dot to x:370 y:62 - 3rd dot to x:308 y:115 done
4. 04:13:972 (1,2,3) - Uh... I don't like this triangle. move 04:14:772 (3) - to x:213 y:211 done
5. ^If Ok.... make 04:14:772 (3) - a better blanket. move 2nd dot to x:265 y:228 - 3rd dot to x:323 y:191 ^
6. ^If Ok.... move 04:15:972 (5) - to x:143 y:200 ^

[Right Back]

1. 00:24:774 (9) - Just use 1/4... No, 1/6 fits perfectly
2. 01:16:773 (4) - this note should be at 01:16:873. move it to stack with 01:16:973 (5) - done

Okay that's all
sorry I can't mod all of your diffs
if that mod wasn't help you, don't give me a star :3 It was helpful, thank you very much

1. Not sure if it'll be applied at ranking, but I think an electronic, dance, AND/OR bass tag is appropriate.
2. Some combos are pretty long, I think most of them are doable and it looks(and sounds) intentional with good reason. Consider just tweaking a couple of these 8+ combos.
3. Star worthy. \o/

• 
  00:51:574 - I feel like a short repeater would go great here just to throw something in the gap and further hype up the next section.
  <- Just one of these. Under 00:50:775 (3) kinda works, but you may not want it there so wherever preferred. Sounds cool too.
  01:05:175 (1,3) - I like these, however they're vertically un-even. The top of 01:06:775 (3) has a difference of 8 in comparison to 01:05:175 (1) (y:19). Moving (1) fixes this easily to match (3) at y:27.
  ~This ALSO puts it perfectly symmetrical over the x-axis as well, since it wasn't. :p
  ~~Might help the next suggestion up a little better too
  01:07:975 (4,1) - This could be slightly improved, uneven space. Soo close.
  
  01:51:574 (1,1) - Being an [Easy] diff, miiiiight want to undo new combo for followpoint purposes. I'm unsure on this one, but its difficulty-based.
  02:01:973 - There's a soft note here that would go well with filling this gap, it's slow enough to keep the 'intended calm' of this part as well. Rhythm keeper circle, kinda.
  02:19:973 (1) - Doesn't look intentional, but un-NC suggested for this diff. Also keeps your 1-2-3-4 counts.
  02:58:373 (1) - Un-New combo, as well a new combo for 02:58:773 (2). 1-2-1-2-1-2-1-2
  03:09:973 (1) - This whole section gets me so hype, dear god. I love it. 03:22:772 (5) - unf.

• 
  00:54:775 (4,5) - I think (4) would look better if it matched the red point shape of 00:53:175 (2), and gave the curve to 00:55:375 (5) since the lyric being emphasized is strong here.
  02:12:473 (1) - I think common consensus says spinner should be 1/2 beat apart below Hard, not really a big matter though. If changed, place on 02:12:573 (red) and end on big white tick.
  02:22:373 (2,3) - Mismatched spacing/angle. 02:21:773 (1) - could be rotated a little (and moved) to replicate spacing between (2) and (3). Overall map appearance would benefit from this imo.
  04:09:372 (4) - Feels overmapped, repeater hit an empty spot. I recommend a pattern with this:
  . (4) and (5) under 3 gives a nice gap between 04:09:972 (6) to emphasize the slight pause. It's already a 1.13x gap after stacking the 2 singles, so bumping 04:09:972 (6) up to 1.2x DS isn't much of a pattern change at all.
  
  04:42:571 (1,2) - Could be spaced a tiny bit better. Cosmetic mod.

• 
  04:28:771 (5) - Sliding this over to x:395 y:200 would make this perfect.
  04:33:171 (1,3) - Could be improved slightly as well.
  

• 
  04:42:370 (11) - Potential new combo helps the lyric not join the already long combo. Brings it into the beat with the lyric starting halfway through the slider. 04:42:970 (1) - lands on the "is" after "This" in the lyric. Just a suggestion.

Kamidachi wrote:

Hi Hi, you modded my map so I'm gonna 'give it right back'~ I laughed T_T
(Yeah, I did do that)

From my mod queue in response to request:

[General Stuffs]

1. Not sure if it'll be applied at ranking, but I think an electronic, dance, AND/OR bass tag is appropriate. I never changed that.... It was like that suddenly
2. Some combos are pretty long, I think most of them are doable and it looks(and sounds) intentional with good reason. Consider just tweaking a couple of these 8+ combos.
3. Star worthy. \o/

[Easy]

• 
  00:51:574 - I feel like a short repeater would go great here just to throw something in the gap and further hype up the next section.
  <- Just one of these. Under 00:50:775 (3) kinda works, but you may not want it there so wherever preferred. Sounds cool too. done
  01:05:175 (1,3) - I like these, however they're vertically un-even. The top of 01:06:775 (3) has a difference of 8 in comparison to 01:05:175 (1) (y:19). Moving (1) fixes this easily to match (3) at y:27. fixed
  ~This ALSO puts it perfectly symmetrical over the x-axis as well, since it wasn't. :p
  ~~Might help the next suggestion up a little better too
  01:07:975 (4,1) - This could be slightly improved, uneven space. Soo close. done
  
  01:51:574 (1,1) - Being an [Easy] diff, miiiiight want to undo new combo for followpoint purposes. I'm unsure on this one, but its difficulty-based. done
  02:01:973 - There's a soft note here that would go well with filling this gap, it's slow enough to keep the 'intended calm' of this part as well. Rhythm keeper circle, kinda. I want a little break there
  02:19:973 (1) - Doesn't look intentional, but un-NC suggested for this diff. Also keeps your 1-2-3-4 counts.
  02:58:373 (1) - Un-New combo, as well a new combo for 02:58:773 (2). 1-2-1-2-1-2-1-2 done
  03:09:973 (1) - This whole section gets me so hype, dear god. I love it. 03:22:772 (5) - unf.

[Normal]

• 
  00:54:775 (4,5) - I think (4) would look better if it matched the red point shape of 00:53:175 (2), and gave the curve to 00:55:375 (5) since the lyric being emphasized is strong here. Copy paste is boring in a normal or higher diffs. Thats just my opinion though
  02:12:473 (1) - I think common consensus says spinner should be 1/2 beat apart below Hard, not really a big matter though. If changed, place on 02:12:573 (red) and end on big white tick. done
  02:22:373 (2,3) - Mismatched spacing/angle. 02:21:773 (1) - could be rotated a little (and moved) to replicate spacing between (2) and (3). Overall map appearance would benefit from this imo.
  04:09:372 (4) - Feels overmapped, repeater hit an empty spot. I recommend a pattern with this: Its fine how it is
  . (4) and (5) under 3 gives a nice gap between 04:09:972 (6) to emphasize the slight pause. It's already a 1.13x gap after stacking the 2 singles, so bumping 04:09:972 (6) up to 1.2x DS isn't much of a pattern change at all.
  
  04:42:571 (1,2) - Could be spaced a tiny bit better. Cosmetic mod. done

[Hard]
I really didn't see much in this diff to note on, pretty solid. Rethink some combos and new combos here and there is all I can really see in addition to below:

• 
  04:28:771 (5) - Sliding this over to x:395 y:200 would make this perfect. done
  04:33:171 (1,3) - Could be improved slightly as well. Looks fine to me 0.0
  

[Right Back]
Again, really solid. I apologize, I don't have much at all to offer here even after going over it few more times than usual. I really like the sequences you have to transition between rhythms and vocals. I didn't really find any overwhelming parts either, in terms of mapping/overmapping.

• 
  04:42:370 (11) - Potential new combo helps the lyric not join the already long combo. Brings it into the beat with the lyric starting halfway through the slider. done 04:42:970 (1) - lands on the "is" after "This" in the lyric. Just a suggestion.

I did state in my queue I'd only do 3 diffs with 4+mins(12minutes total song time), however I liked this song and mapset a lot. I also didn't find much with my eyes or ears after the Hard difficulty, so I went through all the diffs anyway. :3

Have a star or two, I'd love to see this in my friend rankings soon. Thank you very much *________________________*

Good luck, and keep it up~

CheezusCrust wrote:

The latest version for all difficulties: initial timing offset values are completely off.
For Right Back, I believe it should be 13275, not 13975 (I honestly cannot tell.), which is strange because this timing value does not fit any other difficulty o.o??
If anyone has an older version maybe check with them Everything is perfectly fine for me lol 0.0
Maybe you have to redownload it again due to mp3 change.

1. I found the timing being flawed, use this instead (ah, I use the wrong timing for modding, so only change it after applying mods below):
   

   13959,400,4,2,0,70,1,0

2. Adjust the size of background to 1366*768 to meet the 16:9 ratio.
3. You may want to use custom combo colors to fit with the colour pitchi and atmosphere of the background.
4. Snap the preview time after changing the timing.
5. Disable widescreen support as the map doesn't have a storyboard.
6. I guess metadata is correct: https://soundcloud.com/d3-structive-rec ... meters-per

1. 00:13:975 - finish
2. 00:24:774 (9) - this is definitely 1/4 snapped
3. 00:26:774 - starting from here, i am afraid it lacks claps matching with the snare (i mean the constant percussion (drum) sounds), you can try to use the normal-sampleset.
4. 00:36:374 (1,2,3,4) - this parallelogram is crapped
5. 00:39:174 (8) - 3/4 slider here is suitable for the wub sound or it is just too hollow for the halt, 04:39:170 (10) - goes similarly
6. 00:49:974 (3,5) - finishes like heads of 00:49:174 (1,2) -
7. 00:58:774 (1,2,3,4,5) - placing regular pentagon by CTRL+SHIFT+D
8. 01:17:973 (11) - finish is too strong for a note with no background cymbal, remove it
9. 01:49:973 (1) - finish, add some whistles on this stanza like 02:03:173 -
10. 01:53:573 (1,2,3,4,5) - it would be a lot greater if you follow the vocal strictly like this: http://puu.sh/e34nX.jpg as the background music is so weak and blurred
11. 02:20:372 (7) - NC here
12. 02:26:772 (7) - ^ same for 02:36:172 (7,7,3) -
13. 02:57:172 - Claps instead of that soft whistles for snares
14. 02:57:972 (1,1) - NCs here are unnecessary
15. 03:03:772 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - doublets go derailing with the music, also for the hitsounds, 03:03:972 - 03:04:772 - 03:05:572 - 03:06:372 - stresses are missing, redo the rhythm is necessary i guess
16. 03:11:572 - i personally didn't like the usage of 3/4 sliders in these kiais, the bang bang sounds are quite crispy and not prolonging, rhythm in the last kiai sounds much better
17. 03:32:371 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - you can increase the intensity near the end of the kiai by placing streams
18. 04:01:171 - finish, 04:13:971 (1) - too
19. 04:44:170 - place something here for the sake of vocals

1. Hard's rhythm is mostly fine, but some parts are too difficult. I will poke them all below:
   00:25:975 (1,2,3,4,5,6) -
   00:45:575 (9,10,11,12) - Triplet is the most difficult patterns which i can accept for such spread
   03:07:573 (5,6,7) - too difficult, replace it by reversed slider
   03:09:372 (3,4,5,6,7) - these also ^ jumps and triplets at the same time
   04:00:372 (3,4,5,6,7) -
   04:37:571 (3,4,5,6) -
   04:45:571 (7,8,9,10,11) -
   You either make them kick sliders or simplify the rhythms.
2. 00:36:975 (2) - CTRL+G this to make the flow more comfortable
3. 00:51:375 (5) - 1/6 snapped
4. 01:59:974 (1) - delete this to follow strictly the vocal
5. 02:05:773 (1,2,4,5,7,8) - these are wrongly snapped, they should be the same as Insane
6. 02:19:173 (1,2,1) - unnecessary NCs, NC at 02:20:373 (3) - instead
7. 02:57:573 (1,1) - ^
8. 03:11:572 - i have told u above about the usage of 3/4 sliders
9. 03:56:172 (5) - NC
10. About the hitsounds, just look at those in Insane session, i'm too lazy and busy to type them all out again.

1. 03:48:171 - redundant green line
2. 00:38:775 (1) - remove NC; please keep the NC pattern simple, i don't see any reasons on playing tricks on it, e.g. 00:45:175 (1) - 02:57:573 (1) -
3. 00:43:175 (2,3) - replace by a slider to reduce the density, the BPM isn't that low for consecutive 1/2 circles, same for 01:11:175 (6,7) - 02:08:774 (7,8) - ah, i stop mentioning them all here, explore them yourself C:
4. 00:54:775 (4,5,1,2,3,4) - density is too high, simplify the rhythm by putting pauses
5. 01:01:175 (6,1,2,3,4,5) - ^
6. 02:18:773 (1,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5) - ^
7. 02:26:773 (3,4,5,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,6) - ^
8. Basically, the problem of the normal is being too difficult, i am afraid you need to cut quite a number of objects.
9. 01:55:374 (6,7) - don't stack for such tricky rhythm in between, spread them apart

IamKwaN wrote:

hi, sorry for delay
[General]

1. I found the timing being flawed, use this instead (ah, I use the wrong timing for modding, so only change it after applying mods below):
   

   13959,400,4,2,0,70,1,0

2. Adjust the size of background to 1366*768 to meet the 16:9 ratio.
3. You may want to use custom combo colors to fit with the colour pitchi and atmosphere of the background.
4. Snap the preview time after changing the timing.
5. Disable widescreen support as the map doesn't have a storyboard.
6. I guess metadata is correct: https://soundcloud.com/d3-structive-rec ... meters-per

[Right Back]

1. 00:13:975 - finish done
2. 00:24:774 (9) - this is definitely 1/4 snapped [/color]
3. 00:26:774 - starting from here, i am afraid it lacks claps matching with the snare (i mean the constant percussion (drum) sounds), you can try to use the normal-sampleset. done
4. 00:36:374 (1,2,3,4) - this parallelogram is crapped fixed
5. 00:39:174 (8) - 3/4 slider here is suitable for the wub sound or it is just too hollow for the halt, 04:39:170 (10) - goes similarly I dont want to put a slider there
6. 00:49:974 (3,5) - finishes like heads of 00:49:174 (1,2) - done
7. 00:58:774 (1,2,3,4,5) - placing regular pentagon by CTRL+SHIFT+D I dont see the problem with this one
8. 01:17:973 (11) - finish is too strong for a note with no background cymbal, remove it done
9. 01:49:973 (1) - finish, add some whistles on this stanza like 02:03:173 - done
10. 01:53:573 (1,2,3,4,5) - it would be a lot greater if you follow the vocal strictly like this: http://puu.sh/e34nX.jpg as the background music is so weak and blurred done
11. 02:20:372 (7) - NC here done
12. 02:26:772 (7) - ^ same for 02:36:172 (7,7,3) - done
13. 02:57:172 - Claps instead of that soft whistles for snares Im wasnt following the snares there
14. 02:57:972 (1,1) - NCs here are unnecessary fixed
15. 03:03:772 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - doublets go derailing with the music, also for the hitsounds, 03:03:972 - 03:04:772 - 03:05:572 - 03:06:372 - stresses are missing, redo the rhythm is necessary i guess done
16. 03:11:572 - i personally didn't like the usage of 3/4 sliders in these kiais, the bang bang sounds are quite crispy and not prolonging, rhythm in the last kiai sounds much better It fits with the very soft melodics in the background
17. 03:32:371 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - you can increase the intensity near the end of the kiai by placing streams done
18. 04:01:171 - finish, 04:13:971 (1) - too
19. 04:44:170 - place something here for the sake of vocals done

[Hard]

1. Hard's rhythm is mostly fine, but some parts are too difficult. I will poke them all below:
   00:25:975 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - fixed
   00:45:575 (9,10,11,12) - Triplet is the most difficult patterns which i can accept for such spread There is a triplet now
   03:07:573 (5,6,7) - too difficult, replace it by reversed slider done
   03:09:372 (3,4,5,6,7) - these also ^ jumps and triplets at the same time fixed
   04:00:372 (3,4,5,6,7) - fixed
   04:37:571 (3,4,5,6) - fixed
   04:45:571 (7,8,9,10,11) - fixed
   You either make them kick sliders or simplify the rhythms.
2. 00:36:975 (2) - CTRL+G this to make the flow more comfortable done
3. 00:51:375 (5) - 1/6 snapped done
4. 01:59:974 (1) - delete this to follow strictly the vocal done
5. 02:05:773 (1,2,4,5,7,8) - these are wrongly snapped, they should be the same as Insane done
6. 02:19:173 (1,2,1) - unnecessary NCs, NC at 02:20:373 (3) - instead done
7. 02:57:573 (1,1) - ^ done
8. 03:11:572 - i have told u above about the usage of 3/4 sliders Same reason as in Insane
9. 03:56:172 (5) - NC done
10. About the hitsounds, just look at those in Insane session, i'm too lazy and busy to type them all out again.

[Normal]

1. 03:48:171 - redundant green line fixed
2. 00:38:775 (1) - remove NC; please keep the NC pattern simple, i don't see any reasons on playing tricks on it, e.g. 00:45:175 (1) - 02:57:573 (1) - fixed
3. 00:43:175 (2,3) - replace by a slider to reduce the density, the BPM isn't that low for consecutive 1/2 circles, same for 01:11:175 (6,7) - 02:08:774 (7,8) - ah, i stop mentioning them all here, explore them yourself C:
4. 00:54:775 (4,5,1,2,3,4) - density is too high, simplify the rhythm by putting pauses
5. 01:01:175 (6,1,2,3,4,5) - ^
6. 02:18:773 (1,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5) - ^
7. 02:26:773 (3,4,5,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,6) - ^
8. Basically, the problem of the normal is being too difficult, i am afraid you need to cut quite a number of objects.
9. 01:55:374 (6,7) - don't stack for such tricky rhythm in between, spread them apart done

Easy's rhythm is great, it's neither too easy nor too difficult, probably you can solely focus on hitsounds.
This mapset needs more work on spread and hitsounds, let me know if you have any inquiries. Good luck C: Thank you very much :3

Neil Leo wrote:

From NLOMQ

General
- Hitsounds are inconsistent. Put claps/whistles on 2 and 4.
- Put combo colors (maybe something related to the nature of the song)

Easy
02:19:973 (1) - Remove NC fixed

Normal
03:33:972 (4,1) - Avoid 1/4 space between a circle and a spinner. Beginners may take some time to recognize that there is already a spinner there. fixed
04:23:571 (6,1) - ^ fixed

KwaN's so fast!

1. Looks like you've forgotten to resnap all notes and kiai-times in all diffs after changing the offset. It happens with all diffs, so you should re-snap hitobjects in all diffs.
   Note: I'm sure you know how to do thet, but in case you forget: Timing > Resnap All Notes
2. Please go to Song Setup > Storyboarding and disable the Letterbox during reaks options.
3. Are you sure about the default como colours? The default ones vary from skin to skin, so it might look really bad depending from the skin.
4. If I got it right, the normal-hitclap.wav has a little delay. I tried to fix that, and this is what I've got.

1. 00:15:159 (2,3) - minor -personally, I would move (3) a little away to make the pattern look neater. example
2. 00:31:559 - since a new beat kicks in here, it feels weird to have a sliderend at this point. How about a rhythm like this, so the beat at 00:31:959 - will become more playable.
3. 00:47:559 (3,4,1) - this pattern is a little tricky., (1) is too close to (3) and it is placed in an awkward way, so newbies may not notice (4) and click (1). can we organize them more obviously? Example
4. 00:51:558 (1) - I strongly suggest you to move the slider away from the previous hitobject, so newbies won't hit it too early by mistake.
5. 01:54:558 (4) - a sudden change of the rhythm is really hard to feel and play. Can we move on with simple 1/1 rhythm or sliders? Example
6. 03:17:557 (2) - minor - to avoid stacking 3 circles in the same place we can move (2) down. example. New players will be able to read this pattern much better. Moreover, it also improves your flow a little.
   
   Well, I'm okay with this diff. It's a little challenging for an Easy, but the song is asking for it.

1. Well, your Slider Velocity here is relatively low, that is why I would use AR5,5. It will balance the diff settings, too.
2. 00:31:559 (4) - minor - placing tail of the slider so close to the previous circle is something a little confusing, can we adjust it a little to make things look neater? Example
   Note: same here. :c
3. 00:37:559 (4) - can't say that the downbeat (00:37:959 ) is mapped in a good way here. I would recommend to make it clickable for players. Here, have a look.
4. 01:08:959 (2,3) - on harder diffs, you're using 1/3 snap divisor for this part, on this diff you use 1/2, which sounds pretty much off. Take a good look at the rhythm and avoid the 1/2s at this part, please.
   Note: same happens with 02:05:959 - and I believe there're a few more patterns. Please, make sure to pay attention and fix the 1/3s everywhere in the diff.
5. 01:14:759 (6) - looks like you've missed a new combo here. It goes off your combo pattern and the chain gets too long, so a new combo is necessary here.
6. 01:51:158 (2) - I believe it should be snapped o the white tick. (tail). It sounds weird to me as it is.
7. 01:58:758 (6) - the slider feels off here as second half of the vocals sticks to the red ticks. So, it should be a repeated 1/2 slider.
8. 04:07:356 (8,1) - if I'm not mistaken, this is the only stack in the whole diff. For that reason I find it very questionable and suggest you to get rid of it since it looks really random.
   
   I would say that the rhythm needs a little more work, but overall that's a nice diff.

1. 00:37:759 (5) - remember the thing about downbeats I've mentioned earlier in other diffs? Same happens here. Take a look at this, maybe? As gor this pattern, an 1/4 slider and an 1/2 slider with a repeat would match here better. Example
2. 00:41:559 (6) - according to the rule, reverse-arrows must be clearly visible, while this one gets covered a little. We can move (6) around, so the overlap will disappear, right? Example.
3. 00:45:559 (9,10,11,1) - having 1/2 and 1/4s in the same stack feels really challenging for a Hard. Can we unstack (1) to make this pattern more playable? Example
4. 01:10:359 (6,7,1) - you have 1/3s and 1/2s in the same combo. Try moving NC from (1) to (7), as this would increase playability and make the rhythm change more clear.
5. 02:08:959 (8) - I think it would be better to remove this circle. The reason is similar with the suggestion above, but this time we can freely remove the circle as there is nothing but some quite vocals.
6. 03:07:957 (6) - it is hard to tell the exact number of repeats in the slider. Personally, I believe that a stream would fit in significantly better here.
   Note: 04:45:554 (7) - as for this one, breaking it into two sliders and a circle would be better, I believe. Example
   
   Looks pretty nice, I like it!

1. 00:54:758 (4,5) - more like a personal preference, but the jump seems to be really off here. The vocals are calm and a sudden spacing change does not match with it. In case if you want to stress the heavy beat, begin the slider at 00:55:559 -
2. 01:17:957 (11) - put a new combo on this circle. It has nothing to do with the previous combo and it will give some extra HP which also nice.
3. 03:06:756 (1,2) - can we use more sliders here? I believe sticking to the main beats would be better here, since this would make mmuch more sense with the music. Example
   
   Looks pretty nice to me.

-Bakari- wrote:

Yo!

[General]

1. Looks like you've forgotten to resnap all notes and kiai-times in all diffs after changing the offset. It happens with all diffs, so you should re-snap hitobjects in all diffs.fixed
   Note: I'm sure you know how to do thet, but in case you forget: Timing > Resnap All Notes
2. Please go to Song Setup > Storyboarding and disable the Letterbox during reaks options. fixed
3. Are you sure about the default como colours? The default ones vary from skin to skin, so it might look really bad depending from the skin. Most people are having other skins ignored anyway, thats why i think its fine
4. If I got it right, the normal-hitclap.wav has a little delay. I tried to fix that, and this is what I've got. Can't download it because puush is weird again. Ill try it later again

[Easy]

1. 00:15:159 (2,3) - minor -personally, I would move (3) a little away to make the pattern look neater. example done
2. 00:31:559 - since a new beat kicks in here, it feels weird to have a sliderend at this point. How about a rhythm like this, so the beat at 00:31:959 - will become more playable. fixed
3. 00:47:559 (3,4,1) - this pattern is a little tricky., (1) is too close to (3) and it is placed in an awkward way, so newbies may not notice (4) and click (1). can we organize them more obviously? Example fixed
4. 00:51:558 (1) - I strongly suggest you to move the slider away from the previous hitobject, so newbies won't hit it too early by mistake. fixed
5. 01:54:558 (4) - a sudden change of the rhythm is really hard to feel and play. Can we move on with simple 1/1 rhythm or sliders? Example fixed
6. 03:17:557 (2) - minor - to avoid stacking 3 circles in the same place we can move (2) down. example. New players will be able to read this pattern much better. Moreover, it also improves your flow a little. fixed
   
   Well, I'm okay with this diff. It's a little challenging for an Easy, but the song is asking for it.

[Normal]

1. Well, your Slider Velocity here is relatively low, that is why I would use AR5,5. It will balance the diff settings, too. done
2. 00:31:559 (4) - minor - placing tail of the slider so close to the previous circle is something a little confusing, can we adjust it a little to make things look neater? Example fixed
   Note: same here. :c
3. 00:37:559 (4) - can't say that the downbeat (00:37:959 ) is mapped in a good way here. I would recommend to make it clickable for players. Here, have a look. fixed
4. 01:08:959 (2,3) - on harder diffs, you're using 1/3 snap divisor for this part, on this diff you use 1/2, which sounds pretty much off. Take a good look at the rhythm and avoid the 1/2s at this part, please. fixed (I dont know if i did it right
   Note: same happens with 02:05:959 - and I believe there're a few more patterns. Please, make sure to pay attention and fix the 1/3s everywhere in the diff.
5. 01:14:759 (6) - looks like you've missed a new combo here. It goes off your combo pattern and the chain gets too long, so a new combo is necessary here. done
6. 01:51:158 (2) - I believe it should be snapped o the white tick. (tail). It sounds weird to me as it is. done
7. 01:58:758 (6) - the slider feels off here as second half of the vocals sticks to the red ticks. So, it should be a repeated 1/2 slider. done
8. 04:07:356 (8,1) - if I'm not mistaken, this is the only stack in the whole diff. For that reason I find it very questionable and suggest you to get rid of it since it looks really random. done
   
   I would say that the rhythm needs a little more work, but overall that's a nice diff.

[Hard]

1. 00:37:759 (5) - remember the thing about downbeats I've mentioned earlier in other diffs? Same happens here. Take a look at this, maybe? As gor this pattern, an 1/4 slider and an 1/2 slider with a repeat would match here better. Example done
2. 00:41:559 (6) - according to the rule, reverse-arrows must be clearly visible, while this one gets covered a little. We can move (6) around, so the overlap will disappear, right? Example. done
3. 00:45:559 (9,10,11,1) - having 1/2 and 1/4s in the same stack feels really challenging for a Hard. Can we unstack (1) to make this pattern more playable? Example done
4. 01:10:359 (6,7,1) - you have 1/3s and 1/2s in the same combo. Try moving NC from (1) to (7), as this would increase playability and make the rhythm change more clear. done
5. 02:08:959 (8) - I think it would be better to remove this circle. The reason is similar with the suggestion above, but this time we can freely remove the circle as there is nothing but some quite vocals. done
6. 03:07:957 (6) - it is hard to tell the exact number of repeats in the slider. Personally, I believe that a stream would fit in significantly better here. done
   Note: 04:45:554 (7) - as for this one, breaking it into two sliders and a circle would be better, I believe. Example done
   
   Looks pretty nice, I like it!

[Right Back]

1. 00:54:758 (4,5) - more like a personal preference, but the jump seems to be really off here. The vocals are calm and a sudden spacing change does not match with it. In case if you want to stress the heavy beat, begin the slider at 00:55:559 - I did ctrl + g on it. I hope thats okay
2. 01:17:957 (11) - put a new combo on this circle. It has nothing to do with the previous combo and it will give some extra HP which also nice. done
3. 03:06:756 (1,2) - can we use more sliders here? I believe sticking to the main beats would be better here, since this would make mmuch more sense with the music. Example I really dont want to put more sliders there. I had it before and somehow it felt wrong. I hope thats okay
   
   Looks pretty nice to me.

Thanks

I would say thatthe set is nice. It might need a little more work on rhythm, but overall it's nice. Get a little more (1-3) mods and feel free to call me back when you feel like we're ready!

FaiVillager wrote:

Hi~~~from your m4m queue~~

[right back]
generally: well orgnized but a little bit boring because of the simple sliders used(only my thought)
details:
00:17:959 (4) -
is it better?(of course move 5 for certain DS.) done
00:19:159 (7,8) - put them in a line No, because the vocals are getting a bit higher, thats why there is a jump
00:19:959 (9) - humm, place it at another space? maybe done
00:27:159 (3) - y208 or higher than before done
00:29:959 (1) - the two red dots better at 1/3 of the slider i moved it up a little bit
00:42:759 (1) - No, that'd ruin the blanket
01:00:759 (1,2) - 1 and the begin of 2 can be in a line There is no reason too
01:03:759 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,1) - when you use these arrangement think about stack should influence them in game I know that, but it is fine
01:11:959 (2,3) - first part of 3 can be in a line with 2 They are in a line, but not straight down
01:45:159 (1) - erasure No
02:16:759 (1) - same No
02:33:959 (5) - x180 y212 Its okay how it is
03:13:559 (2) - higher Why should it be higher?
04:37:159 (3,4,5,6,7) - remap the stream,not so beautiful? I think it is beautiful

[hard]
pretty good.but is it a easier ver of right back?
00:20:359 (1,2,3,4) - special response(?) What do you mean?
00:26:159 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - a little bit difficult for 3 star map Its a Hard, 3 stars doesnt mean anything. Its 3 stars because of the BPM
00:39:559 (1,2) - parallel fixed
00:41:559 (6) - not in shape fixed
01:12:759 (3,4,1,2,3,4,5) - well designed Thanks :3
01:43:559 (1) - erasure No
02:05:559 (9) - delete There is a hitsound on it which is needed
02:41:159 (1) - i suggest change a shape here. fixed
03:09:959 (1) - notes after here is too loud for me, maybe vol down? I think it is okay
03:23:559 (2) - x316 y216 done
04:21:159 (3,5) - pretty different shape,maybe use same curvature here? It has the shape to be blanket with (3)
04:36:359 (1,2) - fixed

[normal]
this diff's DS is about 1.2x so I suggest use CS 3 cs 3 would ruin the whole diff
00:45:959 (1,3) - better in same shape If more people will point that out. ill chgane it
01:51:159 (1) - a reentry slider is better? No
02:00:359 (2) - fixed
02:24:759 (6) - a straight one is better I dont think so
03:00:359 (1,2) - Its okay how it is

[easy]
SV is a little high, but pretty fine for me.

That's all:D

[Right Back]

SPOILER

http://puu.sh/ec7FR/ad9e22f1f9.jpg

01:51:159 (1) - I feel like the slider velocity is a bit too high on this slow part

02:05:692 (1) - This one is hard for sightreading (Just pointing it out.)

Can't find anything more.

[Hard]

00:23:159 (10) - Maybe turn this into a circle as it sounds better to me

[Normal]

02:05:559 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - This might be too hard for a normal diff

SPOILER

http://puu.sh/ec9VB/c3a152e837.jpg

This might work


[Easy]

Could not find anything in easy, I'm bad at modding Easy :^)

Lazer wrote:

This has been modded many times, I'll try my best ;-;

[Right Back]

SPOILER

http://puu.sh/ec7FR/ad9e22f1f9.jpg

01:51:159 (1) - I feel like the slider velocity is a bit too high on this slow part^But the vocals are pretty strong

02:05:692 (1) - This one is hard for sightreading (Just pointing it out.) Its an insane so it should be alright

Can't find anything more.

[Hard]

00:23:159 (10) - Maybe turn this into a circle as it sounds better to me Fixed

[Normal]

02:05:559 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - This might be too hard for a normal diff Fixed. Its 1/2 now

SPOILER

http://puu.sh/ec9VB/c3a152e837.jpg

This might work


[Easy]

Could not find anything in easy, I'm bad at modding Easy :^)

Sorry if the mod is unsatisfying, it's very hard for me to mod something that has +32SP :^(

Modem wrote:

Modem wrote:

Hi~! For the ticket (> w <)

General

Bg is so cool!!! (o w o)/
...... Wait, why did you use the same colour for combo colours?? (o w o) All of them are orange (o A o)
The player might confuse because of this. Umm.... This is just a suggestion. But, how about change them?
You can use blue, purple, yellow and orange
But, if you still wanna to use orange instead of the other colours then, make them different each other
For example, make one of them as a light orange, then the other is a darker orange, etc. Its not orange at all. Maybe thats your skin

Easy

Change AR to 3
Kiai time at 03:09:957 isn't snapped (AiMod) please fix it fixed
03:22:756 Here too..... Kiai's end isn't snapped. Please fix it
03:23:156 Same goes here. Kiai's end isn't snapped please fix it
03:35:556 Here too ^
04:01:156 Here as well ^
04:26:770 And here ^
There are DS problem at 01:53:559 , 01:54:559 , and 01:55:759 (AiMod) Fix it by :
Move 01:52:759 (2) to x:424 y:192
Then, move 01:53:959 (3) to x:240 y:76 There is no ds problem 0.0
So, the DS problem will gone
01:49:959 (1) Ummm..... Use finish + clap hitsound in drum additions at this spinner's end No need to
02:11:959 (4) Blanket this note with 02:11:559 (3) done
02:31:559 (1) Use clap + finish hitsound in drum additions at this slider's head done
02:40:759 (4) Instead of stacking it, how about make it into a blanket with 02:40:359 (3) ? The flow will also get better I didnt blanket it, but ive changed the position
02:44:359 (1) Add finish hitsound with 40% volume at this spinner's end. The music strongly suggest it There is no spinner
04:12:359 (1) I think the stack between this slider's tail with 04:13:959 (1) (at the reverse part) is a bit imperfect fixed
In my opinion, maybe the spinner is too much for an Easy diff. How about reduce it?? There is no need to

Normal

Same as Easy diff. There are some kiai issues at some parts (o A o)
Kiai time at 03:09:957 isn't snapped (AiMod) please fix it
03:22:756 Here too..... Kiai's end isn't snapped. Please fix it
03:23:156 Same goes here. Kiai's end isn't snapped please fix it
03:35:556 Here too ^
04:01:156 Here as well ^
04:26:770 And here ^
Change AR to 5
01:49:959 (1) Add finish hitsound with 40% volume at this spinner's end. The music strongly suggest it No need to
01:51:559 (1) Add whistle hitsound at this slider's end Ive added alot of whistles now
01:52:759 (1) Here too. Add whistle hitsound at this note
01:52:959 (2) Here as well. Add whistle hitsound at the head of this slider
01:53:759 (3) Add whistle at this slider's end
01:54:559 (5) Here as well. Add whistle hitsound at this slider's head
01:54:959 (5) Add whistle hitsound at this slider's end
01:55:359 (6) Add whistle hitsound for this note too
01:55:959 (7) ^
02:15:559 (1) Add finish hitsound with 40% volume at this spinner's end. The music strongly suggest it
02:21:759 (1) Remove clap hitsound at this slider's head. It's too loud to follow the vocal with clap I think. You can replace it with whistle while following the vocal No, ireally want the clap there since at that place there is a clap too in the kiai time
02:23:359 (4) Here too ^
02:28:959 (1) You can add whistle at this slider's reverse part instead of leaving it as a silent part done
02:30:259 (3) Here too. It will sounds much better if you add whistle at this part
02:31:059 (4) Here too ^
02:31:359 (4) Here as well ^
02:34:559 (1) Remove clap hitsound at this slider's head. It's too loud to follow the vocal with clap I think. You can replace it with whistle while following the vocal
02:36:159 (4) ^
02:41:759 (1) Add whistle at this slider's reverse part instead of leaving it as a silent part
02:44:359 (5) Remove clap hitsound from this note, then replace it with finish instead
03:51:359 (1) Add whistle at this slider's head instead of leaving it as a silent part
03:52:959 (4) ^
03:53:359 (4) ^
03:53:759 (4) ^
03:55:059 (1) ^
03:55:859 (2) ^
03:56:659 (3) ^
03:57:459 (4) ^
03:59:159 (1) Make this spinner longer so it will end at 03:59:559 then, add clap + finish in drum additions hitsound. It'll suits more with the music I guess Recovery time would be too short

Hard

Kiai time at 03:09:957 isn't snapped (AiMod) please fix it
03:22:756 Here too..... Kiai's end isn't snapped. Please fix it
03:23:156 Same goes here. Kiai's end isn't snapped please fix it
03:35:556 Here too ^
04:01:156 Here as well ^
04:26:770 And here ^
Change AR to 7
00:48:759 Add a note + clap (SC1) done
00:51:459 Add a note at this part too. The music suggest it done
01:49:959 (1) Add finish hitsound with 40% volume at this note. The music strongly suggest it
01:51:159 (2) I think this slider should end at 01:51:559 (big white tick). Not at the 01:51:459 (blue tick) fixed
Nothing more found by me! Nice!! (> w <)

Right Back

Kiai time at 03:09:957 isn't snapped (AiMod) please fix it
03:22:756 Here too..... Kiai's end isn't snapped. Please fix it
03:23:156 Same goes here. Kiai's end isn't snapped please fix it
03:35:556 Here too ^
04:01:156 Here as well ^
04:26:770 And here ^
Change AR to 8
(o w o) Nicely mapped!

That's all!! Good Luck for rank!! (> w <) Thank you very much *_*



In progress..... Please wait (= w =)/

Fortune wrote:

From your queue.

Easy

1. 00:20:359 (1) - why don't you make a clear z-slider like symmetric fixed
2. 00:37:959 (3) - bend a little for better flow like this?
   
   fixed
3. 00:51:559 (1,2) - better blanket fixed
4. 01:16:359 (3) - 260||208 fixed
5. 01:57:559 (2,1) -
   
   I dont want them curvy
6. 03:13:559 - why don't you use a slider tick here. Becaue i want the map easy, with long sliders so the players can relax
7. 03:19:959 - ^
8. 03:53:159 (3) - try this shape
   
   done
9. 04:21:959 (3) - why don't you tilt to right side

done

Normal

1. 00:38:759 (6) - bend a little I think its alright
2. 00:40:759 (2) - 245||229 done
3. 01:52:959 (2,3) - there's no sound at 01:53:559. try to change the rythm Ive tried to keep the flow.
4. 01:55:359 (5,6) - this rythm is too hard for newbies. how about this pattern?
   
   Its not too hard
5. 04:04:959 (3,4,5) - it seems better ->
   
   Its alright how it is
6. 04:08:359 (3,4) - balnket Seems alright to me

Hard

1. 00:16:559 (6) - better flow?
   
   done
2. 00:20:359 (1,2,3,4,5) - what happened to these shape o.o
   
   There is nothing wrong with it
3. 00:37:859 - need a note here There was a note before. But i had to delete it
4. 03:05:559 (3,5) - better blanket fixed
5. 03:08:159 (8) - ^ fixed

Insane

1. 00:21:159 (4) - bend a little? nvm :p
   
   No
2. 01:12:959 (5) - ^ ^
3. 04:06:359 (8,9) - current flow is awkward. ctrl + g and replace 9 to other place like 123||91 done
4. 04:27:159 (2,3) - blanket fixed
5. 04:45:559 (1,2,3,4,5) - why don't you unstack these as you did it at hard diff done

Good luck with you ranking! Thank you very much :3

1. 01:50:490 - during the calm/quite parts hitsounds feel too loud. Maybe you can make them less loud? minus 10 or 15% from your current volume would do great, I'd say. (That would mean a Soft section with ~60 or 55% volume)

1. 04:01:159 - Unsanepped kiai. Please, re-snap properly, kiais must be consistent and snapped.
2. 00:25:959 (2,3,1,2,3) - minor - sorta personal preference, but are you sure about the stacked triplet? Probably we could just replace it with a slider to improve playability.
3. 00:51:359 (5) - this should be snapped to 1/8, listen to the music, there are 5 clearly audble hits. You can ask anyone else if you are unsure.
4. 01:03:759 (1,2,3) - 01:04:559 (6,7,8) - as the sounds are quite minor here, we can use 1/4 sliders with repeats. Then, the beats at 01:04:959 (9,10) - will give a more impressive effect on players and will fit better. It's sorta hard to explain, just give it a try and you'll feel the difference, I believe.
5. 01:08:892 (2,4) - I've asked around and apparently these are not 1/3s, just the vocals going off music. The actual beats are on 1/4 beats, so I recommend you to double-check the rhythm yourself and probably remove the sliders.
   
   Note to myself: triplecheck this one more time. I am really in doubt about these ones as they sound really weird. I'll try to contact a QAT or a few more BATs about them to be sure.
6. 02:21:559 (5,1) - 02:22:359 (2,3,4,5,6) - the jumps feel really exaggerated/forced. The music goes relatively slow/clam here, and that is why those jumps feel really weird.
7. 03:13:159 (1) - more like a general suggestion, but I don't really like how those whistles sound on the blue ticks. They sound like they are abused and the music does not suggest adding so much of them.
8. 04:05:559 (6,7) - minor - after the jumpy part this stack sorta breaks the movement, I would say it feels a little awkward to play. Avoid it if it's possible, please.
9. 04:30:159 (2,3) - minor - whoops, feels a little exaggerated. Are ou sure you want the DS to be this huge?

1. 00:48:359 (7,8,1) - due to the way osu! unstacks hit-objects in-game, these ones get overlapped with 00:47:959 (6). So, please, unstack them manually or move them away a little.
2. 01:08:092 (1,3,5) - same as Insane. Please, make sure to doublecheck them.
   Note: 02:05:692 (1,3,5) - same.
   Note to myself: I really should get more people to check them.
3. 01:53:759 (5) - this one hardly follows the vcals and does not feel nice at this point. The problem is that it begins on the red tick, therefore, it makes the strong white tick unclickable. Replace the slider with a circle on the white tick? Really, try it, please!
4. 03:22:159 (4,1,1) - the unstack here feels too hard to read and new combo does not really help to make it better. Unstacking would be a better idea, if you do it, you can also remove NC from 03:22:759 (1) - since it won't be really necessary here.

1. 00:53:159 (2,4) - minor - you might want to make them symmetrical. Well, honestly, it looks like you wanted them to be symmetrical, so...
2. 00:58:759 (1) - minor - the reverse arrow is placed here in a misleading way. Mind naking it more obvious? Example
3. 01:04:959 - I don't think this heavy kick is intended to be ignored. Just listen to it, we can't let such a strong beat stay without a hitcircle on it!
4. 02:00:959 (3) - I would replace this one with a single circle at 02:01:159 - since this is a Normal diff I believe that players should have a very clean and loud enough track to follow instead of some rather unstable vocals.
5. 02:03:159 (1,2,3,4,5) - the way how they are stacked is a quitestionable one. Mind making the pattern a little more obvious by avoiding the stacks? (3) is really hard to read, atm.
6. 03:06:759 (1) - well, I would remove it and place a couple of sliders sice the spinner feels way too short at this point. But it's up to you. Rough example
7. 03:24:359 (4,5,6) - minor - the spacing inconsistency is noticeable here, I would strongly recommend you to fix it. Even though the difference is really smal.
8. 03:54:759 (1,2,3,4) - personally, I would map them with 1/1 objects as 3/4 sliders don't seem to fit well here. Well, I just can't hear how they're matching with the song and they feel pretty foced at this point.
9. 04:45:559 (6) - replace with an 1/2 slider and a circle, to stress the last beat of the song. I'm sure this matches in a really great way with the music. Example

1. AiMod detecs a few spacing mistakes. please check them.
2. 03:09:959 - Unsanepped kiai. Please, re-snap properly, kiais must be consistent and snapped.

-Bakari- wrote:

Re-checking.

[General]

1. 01:50:490 - during the calm/quite parts hitsounds feel too loud. Maybe you can make them less loud? minus 10 or 15% from your current volume would do great, I'd say. (That would mean a Soft section with ~60 or 55% volume)

Has 55% now


[Insane]

1. 04:01:159 - Unsanepped kiai. Please, re-snap properly, kiais must be consistent and snapped. fixed
2. 00:25:959 (2,3,1,2,3) - minor - sorta personal preference, but are you sure about the stacked triplet? Probably we could just replace it with a slider to improve playability. It plays perfectly fine, ive had many people testplaying it, now complaints at all
3. 00:51:359 (5) - this should be snapped to 1/8, listen to the music, there are 5 clearly audble hits. You can ask anyone else if you are unsure. done
4. 01:03:759 (1,2,3) - 01:04:559 (6,7,8) - as the sounds are quite minor here, we can use 1/4 sliders with repeats. Then, the beats at 01:04:959 (9,10) - will give a more impressive effect on players and will fit better. It's sorta hard to explain, just give it a try and you'll feel the difference, I believe. done
5. 01:08:892 (2,4) - I've asked around and apparently these are not 1/3s, just the vocals going off music. The actual beats are on 1/4 beats, so I recommend you to double-check the rhythm yourself and probably remove the sliders. Sliders are removed
   
   Note to myself: triplecheck this one more time. I am really in doubt about these ones as they sound really weird. I'll try to contact a QAT or a few more BATs about them to be sure.
6. 02:21:559 (5,1) - 02:22:359 (2,3,4,5,6) - the jumps feel really exaggerated/forced. The music goes relatively slow/clam here, and that is why those jumps feel really weird. fixed
7. 03:13:159 (1) - more like a general suggestion, but I don't really like how those whistles sound on the blue ticks. They sound like they are abused and the music does not suggest adding so much of them. I think that without them it sounds more boring. It feels like there is missing something.
8. 04:05:559 (6,7) - minor - after the jumpy part this stack sorta breaks the movement, I would say it feels a little awkward to play. Avoid it if it's possible, please. done
9. 04:30:159 (2,3) - minor - whoops, feels a little exaggerated. Are ou sure you want the DS to be this huge? fixed

[Hard]

1. 00:48:359 (7,8,1) - due to the way osu! unstacks hit-objects in-game, these ones get overlapped with 00:47:959 (6). So, please, unstack them manually or move them away a little. done
2. 01:08:092 (1,3,5) - same as Insane. Please, make sure to doublecheck them. I did. It really sounds like 1/3 to me.
   Note: 02:05:692 (1,3,5) - same. Fixed
   Note to myself: I really should get more people to check them.
3. 01:53:759 (5) - this one hardly follows the vcals and does not feel nice at this point. The problem is that it begins on the red tick, therefore, it makes the strong white tick unclickable. Replace the slider with a circle on the white tick? Really, try it, please! fixed
4. 03:22:159 (4,1,1) - the unstack here feels too hard to read and new combo does not really help to make it better. Unstacking would be a better idea, if you do it, you can also remove NC from 03:22:759 (1) - since it won't be really necessary here. done

[Normal]

1. 00:53:159 (2,4) - minor - you might want to make them symmetrical. Well, honestly, it looks like you wanted them to be symmetrical, so... I never wanted them to be symmetrical because i think thats boring. But ok, fixed.
2. 00:58:759 (1) - minor - the reverse arrow is placed here in a misleading way. Mind naking it more obvious? Example done
3. 01:04:959 - I don't think this heavy kick is intended to be ignored. Just listen to it, we can't let such a strong beat stay without a hitcircle on it! fixed
4. 02:00:959 (3) - I would replace this one with a single circle at 02:01:159 - since this is a Normal diff I believe that players should have a very clean and loud enough track to follow instead of some rather unstable vocals. done
5. 02:03:159 (1,2,3,4,5) - the way how they are stacked is a quitestionable one. Mind making the pattern a little more obvious by avoiding the stacks? (3) is really hard to read, atm. Fixed, (i guess)
6. 03:06:759 (1) - well, I would remove it and place a couple of sliders sice the spinner feels way too short at this point. But it's up to you. Rough example fixed
7. 03:24:359 (4,5,6) - minor - the spacing inconsistency is noticeable here, I would strongly recommend you to fix it. Even though the difference is really smal. Fixed. (I guess)
8. 03:54:759 (1,2,3,4) - personally, I would map them with 1/1 objects as 3/4 sliders don't seem to fit well here. Well, I just can't hear how they're matching with the song and they feel pretty foced at this point. fixed
9. 04:45:559 (6) - replace with an 1/2 slider and a circle, to stress the last beat of the song. I'm sure this matches in a really great way with the music. Example fixed

[Easy]

1. AiMod detecs a few spacing mistakes. please check them. Ive checked them more than once. There are no problems lol
2. 03:09:959 - Unsanepped kiai. Please, re-snap properly, kiais must be consistent and snapped. fixed

1. 03:22:159 (4,5,1) - the spacing is still the same. Let me make it more clear, it should be something like this. I believe that it makes the pattern much more understandable.
2. 01:08:359 (1,2,3,4,5) - 02:05:692 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - the vocals are 1/3 but it would be too complicated, considering that there're only two patterns mapped this way. So I suggest sticking to consistent 1/2 rhythm and following it.

1. 01:56:759 (3,4,5) - minor - the jump feels a little forced. Are you sure you want to keep it there?
2. 01:08:359 (1,2,3,4,5) - 02:05:692 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - the vocals are 1/3 but it would be too complicated, considering that there're only two patterns mapped this way. So I suggest sticking to consistent 1/2 rhythm and following it.

-Bakari- wrote:

Okay.

[Hard]

1. 03:22:159 (4,5,1) - the spacing is still the same. Let me make it more clear, it should be something like this. I believe that it makes the pattern much more understandable.
2. 01:08:359 (1,2,3,4,5) - 02:05:692 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - the vocals are 1/3 but it would be too complicated, considering that there're only two patterns mapped this way. So I suggest sticking to consistent 1/2 rhythm and following it.

[Insane]

1. 01:56:759 (3,4,5) - minor - the jump feels a little forced. Are you sure you want to keep it there?
2. 01:08:359 (1,2,3,4,5) - 02:05:692 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - the vocals are 1/3 but it would be too complicated, considering that there're only two patterns mapped this way. So I suggest sticking to consistent 1/2 rhythm and following it.

Fixed Everything

Call me back. This should be the lasst time, sorry about taking so long.

Desperate-kun wrote:

Imo it's a perfect spread since the density gap between Easy and Normal is equal to the one between Normal and Hard. (The Hard to Insane one is a bit smaller but that doesn't really matter)

Bubbled!

1. 00:32:359 (4) - I would change this slider to a note, leaving a pause here fits the music well, please try your best to do this one.
2. 00:43:959 (2) - You need to make this flipped somewhere else, it flows better and this note is kinda blocked by the notes before. Please do this : http://puu.sh/erj3D.jpg
3. 01:52:759 (2) - You still need to treat this as normal DS even if the DS is quite obvious, for beginners this can be a possible miss, don't worry you can still keep your symmetry if you move the previous note farther away.
4. Please fix all of the above!

1. 02:19:359 (2) - Remove this note.
2. 02:29:759 (2) - ^
3. 02:32:159 (2) - ^
4. 02:38:559 (2) - ^
5. 02:42:559 (2) - ^
6. 03:11:359 (3) - ^
7. 03:14:559 (3) - ^
8. 03:17:759 (3) - ^
9. 03:22:159 (4) - ^
10. 03:25:359 (5) - ^
11. 03:27:359 (3) - ^
12. 03:30:159 (2) - ^
13. 03:31:759 (5) - ^
14. 04:01:759 (2) - ^
15. 04:04:759 (2) - ^
16. 04:27:359 (2) - ^
17. 03:03:559 (1,2,1,2) - The reverses are mapped to nothing. end them at red or white ticks please

Tari wrote:

Checking! <3

[Easy]

1. 00:32:359 (4) - I would change this slider to a note, leaving a pause here fits the music well, please try your best to do this one.
2. 00:43:959 (2) - You need to make this flipped somewhere else, it flows better and this note is kinda blocked by the notes before. Please do this : http://puu.sh/erj3D.jpg
3. 01:52:759 (2) - You still need to treat this as normal DS even if the DS is quite obvious, for beginners this can be a possible miss, don't worry you can still keep your symmetry if you move the previous note farther away.
4. Please fix all of the above!

[Normal]

The diff spread is awful, rhythms used are almost same as Hard. and thats not good. but its a simple fix you remove some notes.

1. 02:19:359 (2) - Remove this note.
2. 02:29:759 (2) - ^
3. 02:32:159 (2) - ^
4. 02:38:559 (2) - ^
5. 02:42:559 (2) - ^
6. 03:11:359 (3) - ^
7. 03:14:559 (3) - ^
8. 03:17:759 (3) - ^
9. 03:22:159 (4) - ^
10. 03:25:359 (5) - ^
11. 03:27:359 (3) - ^
12. 03:30:159 (2) - ^
13. 03:31:759 (5) - ^
14. 04:01:759 (2) - ^
15. 04:04:759 (2) - ^
16. 04:27:359 (2) - ^
17. 03:03:559 (1,2,1,2) - The reverses are mapped to nothing. end them at red or white ticks please They are mapped to the soft Melodics in the background which fits perfectly. There is really no need to remove it. But ive fixed everything else

Oh well, going stop now. You need to remove a bunch of circles in Normal, mapping consecutive 1/2 is unacceptable especially since now your basically on-par with the rhythms in the hard. (mapping all red and white ticks) Removing some of the notes will definitely fix the issue.

Popping this for now.

1. A ton of placement issues
2. A ton of flow's issues have been fixed
3. Changed CS in Normal diff
4. Added some patterns
5. Added tags
6. Removed some overlaps!

19:21 Secretpipe: We're gonna IRC man
19:21 *Come[Back]Home is listening to [http://osu.ppy.sh/b/556472 Star Driver - 5 Centimeters Per Second]
19:21 Come[Back]Home: You seem to be in a good mod lol
19:21 Secretpipe: nah
19:21 Come[Back]Home: Never saw so many "XD"
19:21 Secretpipe: I'm always like this
19:21 Secretpipe: XD
19:21 Come[Back]Home: xD
19:21 Secretpipe: ohwait
19:21 Secretpipe: LOLOL
19:21 Come[Back]Home: lol
19:21 Come[Back]Home: ?
19:22 Secretpipe: u sais that I wrote too many "XD"
19:22 Secretpipe: And I just wrote one
19:22 Secretpipe: lol
19:22 Come[Back]Home: Well, there are a lot more 0.0
19:22 Secretpipe: yes
19:22 Secretpipe: anyay
19:22 Secretpipe: anyway
19:22 Secretpipe: oh shiet
19:22 Secretpipe: 4x5 min
19:22 Secretpipe: DAMNIT
19:23 Secretpipe: I'm damned
19:23 Secretpipe: also
19:23 Come[Back]Home: Why?
19:23 Secretpipe: Okoratu sent me a PM for adding tags
19:23 Secretpipe: it's long lol
19:23 Come[Back]Home: Hmm, i love to map long songs, i hate it when a song is just 1-2 Mins long
19:23 Secretpipe: really ?
19:23 Come[Back]Home: Yeah
19:24 Secretpipe: I hate do this when the song is boring
19:24 Secretpipe: but we've got hardsyle
19:24 Secretpipe: so it's cool xD
19:24 Come[Back]Home: Haha xD
19:24 *Secretpipe is editing [http://osu.ppy.sh/b/556472 Star Driver - 5 Centimeters Per Second [Easy]]
19:24 Secretpipe: so 
19:24 Secretpipe: okoratu sent me a pm for tags
19:24 Come[Back]Home: But mapping Hardstyle can be boring, every Hardstyle track has 150 bpm
19:24 Come[Back]Home: Ok, lets get started
19:24 Come[Back]Home: xD
19:25 Secretpipe: Add "Florian Billan" and "D3-Structive Records"
19:25 Secretpipe: in tags
19:25 Secretpipe: for every diff :p
19:26 Secretpipe: Also there's a markpage there LOL http://puu.sh/eEhIt.png
19:26 Secretpipe: unremovable
19:26 Come[Back]Home: Is that wrong?
19:27 Come[Back]Home: I mean, it isnt doing enything to the song
19:27 Secretpipe: the bookmark ? nah
19:27 Secretpipe: nah it's just funny
19:27 Secretpipe: not unrankable too
19:27 Come[Back]Home: xD
19:27 Secretpipe: cause it doesn't affect the timing
19:27 Come[Back]Home: Yeah, changed the mp3, thats how it got there
19:28 Secretpipe: okay~
19:28 Secretpipe: 00:43:959 (2) - If you follow 00:42:759 (1) - 's shape , you must move 00:43:959 (2) - to x:396 y:204 
19:29 Secretpipe: but I guess you're gonna deny this because you will need to change all pattern
19:29 Secretpipe: so maybe consider to reduce 00:42:759 (1) - 's shape
19:30 Come[Back]Home: Hmm, can you send me an example if possible?
19:31 Come[Back]Home: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/2548405
19:31 Come[Back]Home: Is this alright?
19:31 Secretpipe: yeah
19:32 Secretpipe: brb 3min , need to buy some flavour I guess xD
19:32 Secretpipe: I will be back soon !
19:32 Come[Back]Home: Alright :3
19:38 Secretpipe: back
19:39 Come[Back]Home: wb
19:39 Secretpipe: still checking~
19:39 Secretpipe: 00:52:759 (2) - NC should be here nah ?
19:39 Secretpipe: Well , massive beat start at 00:52:359 - 
19:40 Secretpipe: So just add a nc at 00:52:759 (2) - 
19:40 Come[Back]Home: Done
19:40 Secretpipe: nice!
19:41 Secretpipe: break time !
19:41 Secretpipe: xD
19:41 Come[Back]Home: Im bad at mapping easys btw
19:41 Secretpipe: nah
19:41 Secretpipe: it's good!
19:41 Come[Back]Home: Hmm
19:41 Come[Back]Home: K
19:41 Secretpipe: xD
19:41 Come[Back]Home: Whats wrong with the brealtime?
19:41 Come[Back]Home: break*
19:41 Secretpipe: bah
19:41 Secretpipe: nah
19:41 Secretpipe: nothing wrong XD
19:42 Secretpipe: just said break time
19:42 Come[Back]Home: Oh
19:42 Secretpipe: cause
19:42 Secretpipe: I was at 
19:42 Secretpipe: breaktime
19:42 Secretpipe: xD
19:42 Come[Back]Home: Ah xD
19:42 Secretpipe: Flow could be better between theese notes →02:25:159 (1,2) - 
19:43 Secretpipe: you have to make the slider's tail toward 02:26:359 (2) - 
19:44 Come[Back]Home: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/2548491
19:44 Come[Back]Home: Like this?
19:44 Secretpipe: 03:06:359 (4) - Well, I think you can move the note in another place for avoiding stacks and adding some originality! Maybe move it to x:192 y:304 ?
19:44 Secretpipe: yeah like this
19:45 Come[Back]Home: Done
19:45 Secretpipe: yay \o/
19:45 Secretpipe: hope my suggestions are useful 
19:45 Secretpipe: 03:15:959 (4,1,2) - the triangle's shape can be better! 
19:45 Come[Back]Home: They are haha
19:45 Secretpipe: thanks <3
19:46 Secretpipe: 03:20:759 (2,3,4,5) - same
19:46 Secretpipe: 03:25:959 (1,2) - Flow issue here too !
19:46 Secretpipe: 03:30:359 (2,3,4) - triangle too
19:47 Come[Back]Home: fixed all, except that flow issue
19:47 Secretpipe: okay
19:47 Secretpipe: 03:53:159 (3) - A blanket would better fits here
19:48 Secretpipe: for the flow
19:48 Secretpipe: 03:56:359 (3) - here too , you can try to blanket it with 03:57:559 (4) - 
19:48 Secretpipe: don't move 03:57:559 (4) - but adjust the slider for make a blanket! 
19:49 Come[Back]Home: 03:54:759 (1,3)
19:49 Come[Back]Home: Those two are already blanket
19:49 Secretpipe:   oh yeah
19:49 Secretpipe: didn't notice
19:49 Secretpipe: but well
19:50 Secretpipe: keep it xD
19:50 Secretpipe: 04:05:959 (3) - Try to make it toward 04:07:159 (4) - 
19:50 Come[Back]Home: xD
19:50 Secretpipe: 04:07:559 (1) - is already doing it
19:51 Secretpipe: and it's okay for Easy !
19:52 Come[Back]Home: Phew, youre pretty fast xD
19:52 Secretpipe: rly ?
19:52 Come[Back]Home: Yeah
19:52 Secretpipe: MAN
19:53 Secretpipe: THE CS IN NORMAL
19:53 Secretpipe: Is too low omg
19:53 Secretpipe: 3.8 is for hard lol
19:53 Secretpipe: put 3.5 for being consistent and make the spread better
19:53 Secretpipe: it's really better
19:54 Come[Back]Home: Done, i hope there wont be any ugly overlaps now
19:54 Secretpipe: It doesn't change all pattern
19:54 Secretpipe: also sry for caps xD
19:54 Come[Back]Home: Its okay haha
19:54 Come[Back]Home: But is cs 3,8 really too low?
19:55 Come[Back]Home: In 2011/12 there were enough maps with cs 4
19:55 Secretpipe: for normal ?
19:55 Secretpipe: well
19:55 Secretpipe: it was a really bad idea
19:55 Come[Back]Home: Yeah
19:55 Secretpipe: and it's horrible for normal
19:55 Come[Back]Home: Hmm
19:55 Secretpipe: it's really awesome when playing
19:55 Secretpipe: I love playing normal
19:55 Secretpipe: And normal are the diff I most enjoy play/mapping
19:55 Secretpipe: trust me
19:55 Secretpipe: xD
19:56 Come[Back]Home: xD
19:56 Come[Back]Home: Okay
19:57 Secretpipe: u did it ?
19:58 Come[Back]Home: Yeah
20:01 Secretpipe: 00:37:959 (5,6) - 
20:02 Secretpipe: maybe do sth like this?
20:02 Secretpipe: http://puu.sh/eEnf1.jpg
20:03 Secretpipe: 00:48:759 (4) - Is overlaping with 00:49:559 (2,3) - 
20:03 Secretpipe: move it anywhere ?
20:03 Come[Back]Home: You wont notice the overlap when you play
20:03 Secretpipe: with the AR yes
20:04 Come[Back]Home: K
20:04 Come[Back]Home: Hmm
20:04 Come[Back]Home: Fixed
20:04 Secretpipe: did u even tried ? ;;
20:04 Secretpipe: it's seen so fa
20:04 Secretpipe: far
20:05 Come[Back]Home: osu.ppy.sh/ss/2548647
20:05 Come[Back]Home: Hmm
20:05 Come[Back]Home: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/2548647
20:05 Secretpipe: nice
20:05 Secretpipe: I'd need ur skin later
20:05 Secretpipe: XD
20:05 Come[Back]Home: Okay xD
20:06 Secretpipe: xD
20:07 Secretpipe: 02:01:159 (3,4,5) - improve da triangle sir
20:07 Secretpipe: xD
20:07 Secretpipe: 02:08:959 (6) - NC
20:08 Come[Back]Home: Both fixed
20:08 Secretpipe: cool !
20:09 Secretpipe: 02:32:359 (2) - Flow issue here
20:09 Secretpipe: you HAVE to agree with me XD
20:10 Come[Back]Home: Fixed
20:10 Secretpipe: TRIANGLE 
20:10 Secretpipe: 02:42:759 (2,3,4) - 
20:11 Come[Back]Home: Fixed
20:11 Secretpipe: yay
20:12 Secretpipe: 03:14:759 (3) - this too
20:12 Come[Back]Home: Whats there?
20:12 Secretpipe: a flow issue too
20:12 Secretpipe: 03:17:359 (2) - Well , I think,you can remove the red anchor
20:13 Secretpipe: the slider would have a neater aspect!
20:13 Come[Back]Home: Done
20:13 Come[Back]Home: But i dont get the flow issue haha
20:13 Secretpipe: it doesn't go toward the next note
20:14 Secretpipe: 03:57:959 (1) - Are you sure there's enough time for spin ?
20:14 Come[Back]Home: Yeah
20:14 Come[Back]Home: But, i can remove it ofc
20:15 Secretpipe: yeah
20:15 Secretpipe: you should do it
20:15 Secretpipe: it's really shor
20:15 Come[Back]Home: Ok, its longer now
20:15 Secretpipe: short
20:15 Come[Back]Home: 03:59:559
20:15 Secretpipe: 03:59:959 (1) - you removed 03:59:959 (1) -  ?
20:15 Come[Back]Home: Removed the circle here
20:15 Secretpipe: I'M SO PRO
20:15 Secretpipe: I GUESSED IT
20:15 Secretpipe: xD
20:15 Come[Back]Home: Haha xD
20:16 Secretpipe: 04:02:959 (3,4,1) - nice pattern !
20:16 Come[Back]Home: Thanks
20:17 Secretpipe: 04:27:559 (2,3,4) - triangleeeeee
20:17 Secretpipe: 04:30:359 (2) - you can curve it like your cool pattern at 04:02:959 (3,4,1) - 
20:17 Secretpipe: and it's enough for normal
20:19 Come[Back]Home: Done
20:20 Secretpipe: !!!
20:21 Come[Back]Home: ? D:
20:21 Secretpipe: WE DID THE HALF
20:21 Secretpipe: xD
20:21 *Secretpipe is editing [http://osu.ppy.sh/b/556326 Star Driver - 5 Centimeters Per Second [Hard]]
20:21 Secretpipe: 04:02:959 (3,4,1) - 
20:21 Secretpipe: oops
20:21 Secretpipe: 00:25:959 -  and 00:26:059 - 
20:21 Secretpipe: you need to add some circle there
20:22 Come[Back]Home: I first had Circles there, but some1 requested to delete it, i think it fits much better now
20:22 Secretpipe: nah
20:23 Secretpipe: ppl will miss
20:23 Secretpipe: because the rhythm is weird after you spin
20:23 Come[Back]Home: Hmmmm
20:23 Come[Back]Home: Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm
20:23 Come[Back]Home: Okay
20:23 Secretpipe: well
20:23 Secretpipe: iit's up to you
20:23 Secretpipe: try to add them
20:23 Secretpipe: and play it
20:23 Secretpipe: and tell me what you think
20:23 Come[Back]Home: There are Circles now
20:24 Secretpipe: 00:52:359 (1,2,3) - NICE
20:24 Secretpipe: I mean triangle ;~;
20:24 Come[Back]Home: No, i really dont want to make that a triangle
20:24 Secretpipe: Okay ;;
20:24 Secretpipe: also , just for remonding , you added the two names in tags ?
20:25 Come[Back]Home: I did
20:25 Secretpipe: nice!
20:29 Secretpipe: and 
20:29 Secretpipe: that's all
20:29 Secretpipe: :p
20:29 Come[Back]Home: Yay :3
20:29 Secretpipe: 00:27:059 (2,3) - 
20:29 *Secretpipe is editing [http://osu.ppy.sh/b/554363 Star Driver - 5 Centimeters Per Second [Right Back]]
20:29 Secretpipe: I thik you should stack them under slider
20:30 Secretpipe: it's really confusing otherwise
20:30 Come[Back]Home: Okay
20:33 Secretpipe: 03:05:459 (2,3) - Same !
20:33 Come[Back]Home: Fixed
20:33 Secretpipe: 03:11:959 (2) - I think you should remove overlap
20:33 Secretpipe: by moving 2 at
20:34 Secretpipe: x372 y360
20:34 Secretpipe: for example
20:34 Secretpipe: 03:13:559 (2) - this too
20:34 Secretpipe: 03:15:159 (2) - ^
20:34 Come[Back]Home: Hmm, i really dont think thats necessary
20:34 Secretpipe: I think so
20:34 Come[Back]Home: Hmm
20:34 Secretpipe: I respect your style though
20:34 Come[Back]Home: Main time is full of that
20:34 Secretpipe: 03:18:359 (2) - 
20:34 Secretpipe: yeah
20:35 Secretpipe: but see this pattern for example
20:35 Secretpipe: 03:22:559 (6,1,1) - Here , this is really weird,  there's random spacing here , this must be fixed!
20:35 Come[Back]Home: I like those overlaps, it looks kinda ugly when they don't, and its the normal DS after all
20:36 Secretpipe: yeah keep your overlaps
20:36 Come[Back]Home: Fixed the last one
20:37 Secretpipe: about random spacing ?
20:37 Secretpipe: AND
20:37 Secretpipe: we just finished
20:37 Secretpipe: :d/
20:38 Come[Back]Home: Yeah, about the random spacing
20:38 Come[Back]Home: Yay
20:38 Come[Back]Home: xD
20:38 Come[Back]Home: Should i update it (Ill loose my bubble though)
20:38 Secretpipe: you should know sth
20:38 Secretpipe: the bubble will
20:38 Secretpipe: pop
20:39 Secretpipe: but I'm gonna rank
20:39 Secretpipe: baka

Squirrel wrote:

omg I've been waiting for this!! Congratz for first ranked! :3
osu definitely needs more Hardstyle ~ >w<

btw, magst du rausnehmen woher du's mp3 file hast, ich steh nich gerne in iwelchen Beschreibungen.. pretty please. <3 '__'

Aka wrote:

okoratuh ;_;