Charles445 wrote:

dkun didn't point out specifics so I'll start with some issues brought up.

Please note, it wasn't a single member that pointed out all of these, this was a large discussion.

Quiet notes - Some objects are as low as 5%. BATs reported having trouble hearing these sounds at all. all fixed
Slider that changes speed - This slider in particular undergoes a radical speed change due to its scrunched nature http://puu.sh/3yN3l.jpg fixed
Streams where they don't fit - Often a stream is placed when the music doesn't fit with it. remove a lot of streams already
Playability - The feasibility of passing the map was questioned even by very experienced players. A good example of the difficulty being an issue 04:30:530 i confirm with some players again this part could be fc so don't worry please ~

These were not all the issues but this should cover the large problems.

Loctav wrote:

Confirming the silence hitsound thing, playability issues, slider speed issues, general design issues mentioned by others. This is just a quick glance to confirm what has already been mentioned (not as detailed as it should):

01:56:435 (1) - this is unrankable. Sliders are not supposed to speed down and speed up in themselves. It is not unrankable. You can see similar slider in thousands of ranked maps :>
04:17:675 (1) - unrankable. This is totally offtimed (too early) time checked by LKs and NatsumeRin already
04:18:942 (1) - silent note, silent sliderside, silent everything. Also using bpm changes to manipulate slider speed is invalid. silence notes are changed
04:52:280 (1) - see other slider see other comment
06:07:511 (1) - ^

Stuff I consider overmapped:

01:00:935 (8,9) - why is there a triplet? because of music
01:16:627 (9,10) - ^ ^
01:31:397 (4) - I dont get this repeat slider i like it
02:05:435 (8,9) - this jump is unjustified and totally sudden i can play it, and i also ask for some top players to confirm it already so no change
02:07:051 (6,9,10) - wow, what is that for a hitobject timing. how unintuitive it follows the music sense and i believe it is fine to play
02:55:166 (7,8,9,1) - I wonder if this jump is just placed for the intention to make it even more difficult no, just because i think jump is more suitable
03:02:781 (1,2) - whats with this triplets everywhere. why are they existant? because of music
03:06:474 (1,2) - this follows nothing, not even anything you attempt to "remix upon the song". i think it make sense due to the guitar around here
03:38:897 (4,5,6,7) - ^ (the guitars do something else, the 2nd slider is redundant, since the tone you follow still should belong to the first one) follows music tune
04:58:165 (4,5) - *gasp*



Other stuff that I noticed while taking a glance on it:

00:39:590 (4) - why is that a slider and not two circles? because it's more suitable
00:39:590 (4,1,2,3) - this sounds off, the sliderends make this entire attempt to make the player alternate to the choral sound like poop. Making the first two sliders end on red ticks works waaaay better (soundwise) change a bit
01:37:051 (1,2) - what an ass move it's fine to play don't worry even me could pass it :>
01:41:897 (2,3,4) - ^ ^
01:48:935 (1,2) - inconsistent with previous mapping the music is inconsistent so i choose to make some different/color]
03:37:974 (1,2) - just another ass move to make people break
03:49:197 - suddenly, slow piano, suddenly, boring 1/2 sliders. There are so many syncopes you could make a use of, yet you simply copypasted 1/2 sliders everywhere. Pretty disappointing. Also this part lacks circles. it's not boring but welcomed
.

JappyBabes wrote:

this must be some sort of joke, the chinese bat connections are too strong for approval system

JappyBabes wrote:

this must be some sort of joke, the chinese bat connections are too strong for approval system

Shiro wrote:

No. Just no.
This is beyond overmapped. There are silenced beats as well, and this went from popped bubble to approved in under an hour. What kind of attitude is this ?

Unranking. This is going into internal discussion as to what to do with this map.

Silynn wrote:

this should not have been unranked

<3 map forever

Shiro wrote:

No. Just no.
This is beyond overmapped. There are silenced beats as well, and this went from popped bubble to approved in under an hour. What kind of attitude is this ?

Unranking. This is going into internal discussion as to what to do with this map.

No. Just no.

Silynn wrote:

this should not have been unranked

<3 map forever

JappyBabes wrote:

this must be some sort of joke, the chinese bat connections are too strong for approval system

Shiro wrote:

No. Just no.
This is beyond overmapped. There are silenced beats as well, and this went from popped bubble to approved in under an hour. What kind of attitude is this ?

Unranking. This is going into internal discussion as to what to do with this map.

SPOILER