Kyshiro wrote:

As requested in my queue I modded your map.

Wasn't much to mod here. Great map.

Normal
v______________________________________________v

-00:32:832 Add beat ok
-00:55:177 ^ no
^______________________________________________^

Hard
v______________________________________________v

-01:15:142 (3) - Not sure if this beat should be there. i think it's fine
(The following parts which have this have more logic)
-01:28:384 (3) - Same story naa
-01:34:901 (2) - [nazi] Might want this one to be put a bit more to the left ok
(like 01:31:177 (1,2,3) - )
^______________________________________________^

Lunatic
v______________________________________________v

-00:18:142 (6,7,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1) - Why so many new combo's? i'll leave it as it is until i get a MAT's opinion
-01:01:177 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - ^
^______________________________________________^

Any questions? Contact me in game :3

~Kyshiro

Nymph wrote:

Hi Nymph here and request from my queue.

General:
no letterbox is on purpose? yes, on purpose


Normal:
Issues
maybe consider AR-1? i'm not sure if AR4 or AR5 is easier really...


Hard:
really nothing I can nazi about.


Insane:
Beatmap design/suggestion
00:18:142 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1) - oops do these new combos really necessary...
01:01:177 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - ^ ok now I see your reply on the post before mine.


OK, I have to say I almost have nothing to mod. so here is a star and good luck!

[CSGA]Ar3sgice wrote:

Hi, from my queue


[General]

1. Overall good map and nice BG

[Normal]

1. fine

[Hard]

1. 00:52:073 (3,4,5) - this part is hard to read/play, maybe delete 5? no

[Lunatic]

1. 00:51:349 (1) - add a note and change this to a 1/2 slider? o.o no
2. 01:12:349 (6) - add clap no
3. 01:15:866 (8) - 094.jpg ??
4. 01:36:556 (1,2,3,4) - use rotate 90 degrees? o.o why?

Good luck~

kosiga wrote:

hi~ mochi

from my queue ~

here my mod ~

[Normal]

1. 00:18:349 (3) - add NC
2. 01:01:177 (2) - remove whistle.
3. 01:38:625 (1) - add finish to end of the slider
4. 01:39:763~01:41:315 - add spinner ? if you add please gradually lower volume

[Hard]

1. 00:32:418 (3) - add clap
2. 00:32:832 (4) - remove clap
3. 00:52:073 (3) - add NC
4. 01:01:177 (2) - remove whistle to start of the slider
5. 01:05:935 (1) - remove NC and 01:06:142 (2) - add NC
6. 01:19:177 (1) - remove NC and 01:19:384 (2) - add NC
7. 01:36:142 (4) - add NC
8. 01:38:625 (1) - add finish to end of the slider
9. 01:39:763~01:41:315 - same as Normal

[Lunatic] ⇒ change name Insane ( does not match the other )

1. 00:32:418 (3) - add clap to start of the slider and remove clap to end of the slider
2. 00:32:832 (4) - remove clap
3. 01:36:142 (10) - add NC
4. 01:38:625 (1) - add finish to end of the slider
5. 01:39:763~01:41:315 - same as Normal

very good map ~ Star ☆ ~

and sorry, poor mod. Please do not throw kudosu if worthless

Good luck ~

CDFA wrote:

Dammit my queue needs to stop having good maps, I'm losing all of my kudosu stars~

also @kosiga, Lunatic is the name for Insane in Touhou games >w<~.

Kenezz wrote:

Hello o/
from my queue~
Kenezz's Bakamod~

General

1. 01:29:521 - imo the kiai time should be end here or put another kiai fountain here~ (in all diffs) I feel the beginning of this section doesn't give enough impact to warrant a kiai fountain
2. I think in the section-fail/pass.png should be different, really I don't know if this a problem but consider this~ It's supposed to be the character talking
3. Considers put a spinner in the end~ I considered it with kosiga's mod

Normal

1. 00:26:211 (1) - Remove new combo here and put it in the next note.It doesn't make a difference because anything after a spinner is a new combo
2. 00:31:590 (4) - Add finish or clap in the start and end of this slider- no
3. 00:53:108 (1) - Add finish here FIXED
4. 01:13:384 (1) - Add clap here and remove from the next slider no
5. 01:13:590 (2) - This sounds a bit weird, maybe for the repeat, my solution: remove te repeat from this slider and 01:14:832 finally add a slider since 01:14:418 to 01:14:832, try it~ It will sound the same since it's the same rhythm ._. I prefer the repeat so I'm keeping it
6. 01:26:832 (2) - Same as before (^)

Hard

1. I can't found nothing wrong, good~

Insane

1. Nothing to remark, just I say something, some streams like this 01:01:177 (1) have too new combo and I would prefer that they like these 00:53:108 (1), just NC when necessary. Already mentioned before that I will wait for MAT/BAT's opinion on this

Ok, It's all~
I hope to helps you (:

Soul-less wrote:

As per request from mod queue....nothing much to suggest really, so I'll just leave some of my opinions here.

For [Normal], beats around 01:11:108 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) played not so well IMO. Try suggestion below? Feel free to ignore if you feel it's worse, since it's not quite placement friendly with your current distance setting.

I feel my rhythm follows the song better

I feel that some of the triplets in [Hard] aren't really necessary, they're kinda overmapped, but since the usage is kinda consistence so it's kinda fine. Kinda.(Stop abusing kinda, damnit XD) I don't know... I don't have any problem with the triplets but seems like a lot of people don't like it

For [Lunatic] I personally prefer 4 per new combo for those (1,2) parts , but yea since you said you're waiting for MAT/BAT's opinion so I'll just leave this here. I will consider adding NC every 4 notes if MAT/BAT tells me to change it

And oh there's two .osb files in your current song folder. Not a big deal but eh, probably consider cleaning it up? That file name too. =P
You downloaded the osz a long time ago, I already removed it

I knew it'll be kudosu star spree seeing my latest mod request batch. Oh well.

hoLysoup wrote:

[General]
Where the hell is your old name?! wtfbbq add qilliam to tags

[Insane]
00:26:211 (1) - remove clap
00:31:590 (1,2,3,4) - remove claps from these

[Hard]
Exact same claps suggestion as Insane.
Nothing else here except kiai could use more jumps. Right now they're all flowing with the same distance snap, which is good, but I feel it could use more jumps to be more fun.

How come you don't use silent slider body? I think the default slider sound is quite annoying especially for Normal since there are less beats. 00:24:970 (1) - especially this. But that's just my opinion though. ok, silenced sliderslide

That's all lol

KingsAL2 wrote:

Sorry for longlong reply~~~

--------------------------Lunatic
00:37:797 (6) - New combo?
00:41:108 (6) - ^?
00:44:418 (6) - ^?
01:09:246 (7) - ^? And remove new combo 01:09:659 (1)
01:15:866 (8) - ^? And remove new combo 01:16:280 (1)


----------------------------Hard
No Maybe >..<

-----------------Overall
Nice map at all but the wistle were put a bit noise
Good luck <3 STAR

no changes made

Jayel wrote:

Hey, glad to mod your map

Red - Must
Black - Optional.

[General]
Why is there a little gap between two kiai times?
Why not making those two as one kiai time?
And I think it would be better if you end kiai time on 01:29:521.


[Normal]
I think the grid level for this diff is too high.
Plz lower it. I bet it would be better if it's 3.

00:50:211(2,3,4,5) - A little bit hard for Normal, especially if it is the easiest diff.
01:01:177(2) - ^
01:39:659(2) - ^
01:01:177 ~ 01:03:039(x) - Putting break time would be better.

[Hard]
00:49:797(1,2) - Hard to recognize.
00:51:246(1,2,3,4,5) - Hard to recognize the circles and the beats.
01:02:004(4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - A little hard for this diff?

[Insane]
HP Drain Rate -1.
That's all.

Ewww... I don't like IOSYS, their songs are all difficult to play!!!!
Anyways, your map is well-made, here's star.
Be sure to give me kudosu~~

Thank you and good luck~!

-Gamu- wrote:

I'm sorry.

very late...orz

hi-

request from my queue

[General]

●BG lol

[Normal]

●AR-1or2 "EASY diff" no. So, must be lowered
●00:20:004 (5) - Add finish?
●00:46:487 (1) - ^
●01:29:521 (1) - ^ (start)
●01:32:832 (1) - ^

[Hard]

●00:19:590 (4) - Add finish? (end)
●01:26:625 (2,3) - try this

328,268,86625,1,8
288,200,86832,2,0,B|271:167|271:167|205:130|147:203,1,150

●01:29:521 (1) - Add finish?
●01:32:832 (1) - ^

[Lunatic]

●HP+1?
●00:18:142 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - Same combo color? I think so
●00:19:590 (1) - Add finish? (end)
●01:01:177 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - Same combo color? I think so
●01:29:521 (1) - Add finish? (start)
●01:32:832 (1) - ^


Good map!!!!!!

lovhin456 wrote:

hello ~ let's do do do this :3

song's info;
- tags: curious about why there's the word 'arm', add your previous username 'qilliam' arm is the group that arranged the song and i prefer not to add my old username

general;
- everything looks fine

skin;
- loving the section-pass and section-fail along with the sounds ~

normal;
- AR -1, current one works fine too but since makes everything seem a little faster and since this is the easiest diff in the set ar -1 wouldn't hurt ok, reduced AR by 1
- maybe turn up the volume a bit by adding +10~15% volume to all sections ? I can hear the hitsounds fine, i don't want to overpower the song's volume
- 00:20:004 >> add a soft finish to emphasize the one in the music
- 00:24:970 >> here too, you could add soft finishes at the start and end
- 00:27:452 >> remove that red slider point, the slider looks better without it ok
- 00:31:590 >> here you could also add the finishes at the start and end
- the only 'issue' i see with this (i don't know if it's an issue) is that there are no spinners so the scores won't be different like this not really an issuehttp://puu.sh/9EFr

hard;
- the same suggestion about the volume as normal
- 00:20:004 >> soft finish, same reasons mentioned in normal
- 00:24:970 (1,2,3) >> ^
- 00:31:590 (1,3) >> ^
- 00:43:590 (2,3) >> stack better ok
- 00:51:246 (1,2) >> sounds kinda bad, well actually not sure (maybe it's just me) anyways consider shorten (1) until 00:51:452 it's the same rhythm as the previous 2 sliders
- 00:52:073 (3,4,5) >> not sure about these, it sounds kinda akward to me, try removing a repeat from (3) and moving (4) to 00:52:487 it follows the song exactly
- 01:02:211 >> new combo ? no
- the same 'issue' as normal
- some streams might not follow the music nevertheless they are not 'terrible/annoying'

lunatic;
- same suggestion about the volume as normal
- 00:18:142 >> mmm, new combo spam ? i think is better if you don't do it although it doesn't hurt anyone, still they aren't 'necessary' reduced amount of NC
- 00:20:004 >> soft finish, reasons mentioned in normal
- 00:24:970 (1,2,3) >> ^
- 00:26:004 >> ahm, maybe add a note here and at the next blue tick, the stream follows the drums in the music The drums are barely audible, so i prefer not to add the stream
- 00:28:384 >> sounds better without this note no
- 01:01:177 >> same as 00:18:142 reduced amount of NC
- 01:15:142 >> sounds better without this note imo no
- 01:28;384 >> ^ no
- same 'issue' as normal

Added the soft-hitfinish to all difficulties

* nice, star

narakucrimson wrote:

Hello!

[General]

1. Skin:
   It feels very awkward to have the same section pass and section fail, you always get the same drawing even if you aren't doing so well, and that's weird and confusing.
   However, the images fit the .wav files you picked, so I'll leave this to you. If you wanna make your map "richer", you could try to find another image for the section-pass or the section-fail. I will keep it the way it is then
2. Timing:
   The Offset should be moved to 142 ms. It's only so that the pulses on the menu follow the music from the start. You don't need to resnap, but just in case check AIMod after doing this to see if there are unsnapped notes. ok, changed to 142
3. Kiais:
   01:03:038 - Unsnapped kiai (by 1 ms) please snap it correctly~ fixed
4. Other suggestions:
   01:39:659 (2) - You could use a normal finish on this object in every difficulty ^^ ok

[Normal]

1. 00:56:418 (2) - Well since you use a new combo spam for the next sliders you could as well add a new combo here! no
2. 01:01:176 (2) - I don't recommend stacking 1/2nds under slider ends on the easiest difficulty. It's not as easy for new players, you know.
   Even if it doesn't look so good, try this: ok
3. 01:39:659 (2) - (^) ok
4. Actually, as a comment, it's never such a bright idea to stack stuff under slider ends on the easiest difficulty of a mapset. It really gives new players a hard time. I'm actually not sure which is easier. One is easier to read maybe, and the other requires less movement of the mouse/tablet.

------------
To be honest, I think that the jump in difficulty between these two difficulties (mainly because of the 1/4ths in hard) is a little big. It's not enormous so I don't really mind but bear in mind that a good difficulty curve is always a good thing to see on a mapset!
------------

[Hard]

1. 00:29:521 (1) - Feels as if the new combo shouldn't be here, but on the next circle (00:30:142 (2) - ). Well, that is if you wanna follow the finishes and not the vocals (well, even then you could apply this suggestion...) Because it's a slider that ends at the start of a new stanza, I follow the vocals.

All right, that's all! Call me back later (forum PM is ok) and I can probably rank it.
probably
(also very good job!)