pishifat wrote:
if this is about proposing more types of vague genre markers for maps, let's avoid that. it's already hard to manage the difference between nightcore and sped up ver as seen by this thread
Uhh I had already added a list of genres where Nightcore applies, that's the deciding factor so it's necessary to define it that way.
pishifat wrote:
could someone who's kept up with this thread post what the proposed change is here now that some discussion was had? i struggle to follow cuz i am a dumbo
The reasons why more discussion was necessary were these:
1. Your previous wording didn't distinguish between the two markers which seemed a bit odd to me so I asked people who are familiar with these music genres for advice
2. Nevo wants to use "Sped" and there was some discussion about that
After that I updated my initial post with a possible wording, but it can probably be improved. I'll post it here again for better visibility:
If a song has been edited to have a higher tempo, use a (Speed Up Ver.) marker at the end of the current title string. If there is an existing 'Speed Up Ver' marker in the title, the (Speed Up Ver.) marker would replace it. For songs of the genres Techno, Trance, Dance, Eurodance, Hands Up, Jumpstyle and Hardstyle, use (Nightcore Mix) instead.
I was basically just waiting for you to confirm this/say what needs to be fixed.
pishifat wrote:
re: speed vs sped, i'll poll the bns about what they prefer
I'm not sure if that's the best solution but I also don't know how else to decide it since the discussion died out so go ahead I guess? It would be nice if some people could add reasoning though and not only say "option1/option2".