IS NOT WHERE YOU COME FROM!!!
forum
Kari Kimmel - Where You Belong
posted
Total Posts
28
hi
[General]
[General]
- Show me from where you got your metadata
- I know there are lesbians in the show, but putting lesbians as a tag is not fine. If the song was specifically talking about lesbians or was an lgbt dedicated song then it would make sense, so it would be nice if you remove that tag.
- 00:32:582 - the green lines in the spinner, starting here, are unsnapped, pls snap them (all diffs)
- 00:01:073 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,1,2,3,4) - this part is as dense as the hard diff rhythm-wise, pls use a couple of 1/1 sliders in this section and more 1/2 with a repeat so there's more contrast in the spread
- 00:22:448 (2) - you should move it a bit up so the alignment with (3) is more similar as when you did it at 00:10:448 (2,3) - . Perhaps you could work on both patterns and make the 1/4 slider be centered in the middle rather than being closer to a start/end of the 1/2 slider for a neater design.
- 00:28:073 (1,3) - improve this blanket plsss
- 00:02:573 (1,2) - uhh this is the only antijump you make, the diff should be better without it
Topic Starter
Ok but tags are fine, they dont need to be related to the song at all. I even put the series actors in the tags too.
metadata shouldn't be wrong, it is pretty easy to know this was sung by Kari Kimmel and the name is pretty much it too. I dont think we will have problems with it and I cant find good sources.
metadata shouldn't be wrong, it is pretty easy to know this was sung by Kari Kimmel and the name is pretty much it too. I dont think we will have problems with it and I cant find good sources.
Tags have to be relevant to the song or the source of the song, the actors are fine I guess, but this specific tag is not imo because, as I said earlier, the show's main focus isn't about that. Anyway, I'll let you have your tag cuz I don't wanna fight over something like that.MkGuh wrote:
Ok but tags are fine, they dont need to be related to the song at all. I even put the series actors in the tags too.
metadata shouldn't be wrong, it is pretty easy to know this was sung by Kari Kimmel and the name is pretty much it too. I dont think we will have problems with it and I cant find good sources.
Now, about metadata, even if you think the artist and title of the song are correct, you still have to show some proof of it because it's a requirement and the smallest mistake can cause a disqualification. If you have trouble finding metadata, just ask for help; you're in the discord metadata server..
I couldn't find this specific song there, but she linked her youtube channel there. I found this video in her channel https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xTCNY6a5W1U
boom https://soundcloud.com/karikimmel/where-you-belong
It seems you don't have to make any metadata changes, but we have something to show now~
Call me back when you're done with the mod~
netflix and lesbians in tags? Put America in tags too since that's where this song was made; oh and daytime since it's daytime both in the bg and during the times where they shot the tv show. I think one of the actor's favourite food was chicken so make sure to add that too
Topic Starter
I don't like your tone, you don't need to use irony like that, I thought tags were used to make the beatmap easier to find. I admit I am wrong though, as ezek said, the show is not specifically about gay people, and I don't think anyone will use this word to look for the song. I do think netflix is fine though, this show is pretty much known for appearing in netflix, and to those who watches netflix a lot and would like to search for series opening beatmaps, should be ok.
@ezek: I am already done with the mod, everything was applied. xD
@ezek: I am already done with the mod, everything was applied. xD
Sorry, I thought you would have taken it lightheartedly; I didn't meant to patronise you.
Top
I don't understand the variable combo lengths. 00:13:073 (1,2,3,4,1,2) - You use 2 NCs in 1 measure here and 1 NC for measure with 00:16:073 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) . And this happens frequently throughout the map. It doesn't really seem pattern dependant as many of your big patterns could have been split up into smaller combos since they have gaps 1/1 gaps in rhythms too. The normal uses consistent combo lengths
00:28:823 (1) - This slider just looks random. If it were an adaption from the style of the map then fair enough but it's not so yh..
Hard
00:28:823 (3) - Could be a nice idea to NC this so the player would get more hp before the final spinner which is a bit longer than usual
[]
OD 6.5 and 7.5 are too high for the Hard and Top diff. You can say that it's mapped at like a hard and insane (which would also make your OD for hard too high anyways) but it doesn't match the bpm and rhythm density/complexity.
I would also state that the ARs are too high too since they only allow for about 2-3 objects on at a time (depending on if there is a triplet). These diffs are still low SR and far below 3* so there is no real need to make it such a struggle for beginners.
[]~
Top
I don't understand the variable combo lengths. 00:13:073 (1,2,3,4,1,2) - You use 2 NCs in 1 measure here and 1 NC for measure with 00:16:073 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) . And this happens frequently throughout the map. It doesn't really seem pattern dependant as many of your big patterns could have been split up into smaller combos since they have gaps 1/1 gaps in rhythms too. The normal uses consistent combo lengths
00:28:823 (1) - This slider just looks random. If it were an adaption from the style of the map then fair enough but it's not so yh..
Hard
00:28:823 (3) - Could be a nice idea to NC this so the player would get more hp before the final spinner which is a bit longer than usual
[]
OD 6.5 and 7.5 are too high for the Hard and Top diff. You can say that it's mapped at like a hard and insane (which would also make your OD for hard too high anyways) but it doesn't match the bpm and rhythm density/complexity.
I would also state that the ARs are too high too since they only allow for about 2-3 objects on at a time (depending on if there is a triplet). These diffs are still low SR and far below 3* so there is no real need to make it such a struggle for beginners.
[]~
Topic Starter
AR may be too high, and SR too low, but the top diffs requires lot of aims, beginners can't play it properly so it is not really meant to beginners. But I lowered the AR and the OD to make it fit more with the song.
Applied the combo and the NC at the slider in hard. I'd like to keep my slider art at the end on the top diff, song was asking for a long slider so why not making an slider art there.
Updated.
Applied the combo and the NC at the slider in hard. I'd like to keep my slider art at the end on the top diff, song was asking for a long slider so why not making an slider art there.
Updated.
pls adopt this bubble 
We need more tv series openings tbh :3
Oi Guh, parabéns pela bubble, me ensina <3
Oi Guh, parabéns pela bubble, me ensina <3
Hey!
General
Metadata:
https://soundcloud.com/karikimmel/where-you-belong <- She linked this SoundCloud from her official site.
http://karikimmel.com
https://itunes.apple.com/us/album/where ... =663069947 <- Taken from her official Youtube account.
Video uploaded by herself where it shows the title and artist.
General
- I'd highly recommend you to cut the last part of the mp3/video that is unnecesary because there's nothing important from them, remember that it's not an excuse to use "It seems fine, it is part of the video series, so is no problem at all" It's the same thing as I did for "Pretty Little Liars" set, I mean, there are basically 4 seconds of empty sounds, which could reduce the weight of the mp3 itself, the same goes for the video. (There you go), I've edited them, as you requested it.
- 00:04:073 (1,2,3) - I wonder why you didn't keep the same kind of distance regarding this objects while 00:01:073 (1,2,3,4) - that here, which is basically the same rhythm you went with x2.0, I'd like to be consistent with both sections.
- 00:05:198 (1,2,3,4,5) - Come on, you could do this better than the current pattern. I mean the flow, and jump is pretty neat. But I'm pretty sure that this circle could be inside of (2) (3) and (1) just like this, and then when the drums plays the spacing could be increased like this.
- 00:14:573 (5,6,1,3) - This would make sense if it were a Hard or even an Advanced, but since this is basically like a Hard + ignoring the vocals which you have been following up until this point, but being ignored so suddenly makes an inconsistency which isn't alright at all. You could do either this, or this, up to you. (00:22:073 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - Take in mind that you should be consistent with this as well, due that is the same part of the song).
- 00:16:635 (2,3) - Same goes to this.
- 00:24:510 - Vocals.
Metadata:
https://soundcloud.com/karikimmel/where-you-belong <- She linked this SoundCloud from her official site.
http://karikimmel.com
https://itunes.apple.com/us/album/where ... =663069947 <- Taken from her official Youtube account.
Video uploaded by herself where it shows the title and artist.
Topic Starter
Please adopt this Gero
Topic Starter
Please adopt this GeroGero wrote:
Hey!
GeneralFosters
- I'd highly recommend you to cut the last part of the mp3/video that is unnecesary because there's nothing important from them, remember that it's not an excuse to use "It seems fine, it is part of the video series, so is no problem at all" It's the same thing as I did for "Pretty Little Liars" set, I mean, there are basically 4 seconds of empty sounds, which could reduce the weight of the mp3 itself, the same goes for the video. (There you go), I've edited them, as you requested it.
Call me back, so I can give your bubble back. Such a shame that ezek is not around anymore.
- 00:04:073 (1,2,3) - I wonder why you didn't keep the same kind of distance regarding this objects while 00:01:073 (1,2,3,4) - that here, which is basically the same rhythm you went with x2.0, I'd like to be consistent with both sections. I am emphasizing only the harder sounds of the piano as u can see, and when the vocals/drums starts to show out I change the focus to the drums and the vocal entonation.
- 00:05:198 (1,2,3,4,5) - Come on, you could do this better than the current pattern. I mean the flow, and jump is pretty neat. But I'm pretty sure that this circle could be inside of (2) (3) and (1) just like this, and then when the drums plays the spacing could be increased like this. I like it like that, as you said, everything is neat, and I think visual look neat also. (Which doesn't even matter since players don't know anything about aesthetics so who will care while playing?)
Fixed all the vocals stuff.
Metadata:
https://soundcloud.com/karikimmel/where-you-belong <- She linked this SoundCloud from her official site.
http://karikimmel.com
https://itunes.apple.com/us/album/where ... =663069947 <- Taken from her official Youtube account.
Video uploaded by herself where it shows the title and artist.
Yes what a shame
Topic Starter
fixed
Topic Starter
What is 24 hours more when you've waited 2 months already, huh?! xD
^^MkGuh wrote:
What is 24 hours more when you've waited 2 months already, huh?! xD
go